Separating gas-giant and ice-giant planets by halting pebble accretion

Abstract

In the Solar System giant planets come in two flavours: 'gas giants' (Jupiter and Saturn) with massive gas envelopes and 'ice giants' (Uranus and Neptune) with much thinner envelopes around their cores. It is poorly understood how these two classes of planets formed. High solid accretion rates, necessary to form the cores of giant planets within the life-time of protoplanetary discs, heat the envelope and prevent rapid gas contraction onto the core, unless accretion is halted. We find that, in fact, accretion of pebbles (~ cm-sized particles) is self-limiting: when a core becomes massive enough it carves a gap in the pebble disc. This halt in pebble accretion subsequently triggers the rapid collapse of the super-critical gas envelope. As opposed to gas giants, ice giants do not reach this threshold mass and can only bind low-mass envelopes that are highly enriched by water vapour from sublimated icy pebbles. This offers an explanation for the compositional difference between gas giants and ice giants in the Solar System. Furthermore, as opposed to planetesimal-driven accretion scenarios, our model allows core formation and envelope attraction within disc life-times, provided that solids in protoplanetary discs are predominantly in pebbles. Our results imply that the outer regions of planetary systems, where the mass required to halt pebble accretion is large, are dominated by ice giants and that gas-giant exoplanets in wide orbits are enriched by more than 50 Earth masses of solids.

Accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics

References in corpus (8)

• Coagulation, fragmentation and radial motion of solid particles in protoplanetary disks
• Particle Stirring in Turbulent Gas Disks: Including Orbital Oscillations
• The Gemini Deep Planet Survey -- GDPS
• Variations on Debris Disks: Icy Planet Formation at 30-150 AU for 1-3 Solar Mass Main Sequence Stars
• Dust flow in gas disks in the presence of embedded planets
• Layered convection as the origin of Saturn's luminosity anomaly
• Embryos grown in the dead zone: Assembling the first protoplanetary cores in low mass self-gravitating circumstellar disks of gas and solids
• Infall of planetesimals onto growing giant planets: onset of runaway gas accretion and metallicity of their gas envelopes

Cited by in corpus (197)

• The Gemini Planet Imager Exoplanet Survey: Giant Planet and Brown Dwarf Demographics From 10-100 AU
• The structure of protoplanetary discs around evolving young stars
• Origin of water in the inner Solar System: Planetesimals scattered inward during Jupiter and Saturn's rapid gas accretion
• Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: How the radial pebble flux determines a terrestrial-planet or super-Earth growth mode
• Chemical enrichment of giant planets and discs due to pebble drift
• Exoplanet Statistics and Theoretical Implications
• Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: Growth of gas giants
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets I: Heavy element content and atmospheric C/O
• The newborn planet population emerging from ring-like structures in discs
• Reduced gas accretion on super-Earths and ice giants
• Planet formation with envelope enrichment: new insights on planetary diversity
• Friends of Hot Jupiters. IV. Stellar companions beyond 50 AU might facilitate giant planet formation, but most are unlikely to cause Kozai-Lidov migration
• Trends in Atmospheric Properties of Neptune-Size Exoplanets
• A highly settled disk around Oph 163131
• Terrestrial planet formation from lost inner solar system material
• Planetesimal rings as the cause of the Solar System's planetary architecture
• Dynamical evidence for an early giant planet instability
• Planet population synthesis driven by pebble accretion in cluster environments
• Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
• An opening criterion for dust gaps in protoplanetary discs
• Rocky super-Earths or waterworlds: the interplay of planet migration, pebble accretion and disc evolution
• Formation of Giant Planet Satellites
• Influence of sub- and super-solar metallicities on the compositions of solid planetary building blocks
• Jupiter's inhomogeneous envelope
• Spiral arms in the proto-planetary disc HD100453 detected with ALMA: evidence for binary-disc interaction and a vertical temperature gradient
• Planet formation by pebble accretion in ringed disks
• Pebble-driven Planet Formation around Very Low-mass Stars and Brown Dwarfs
• The Exoplanet Radius Valley from Gas-driven Planet Migration and Breaking of Resonant Chains
• Pebble-driven planet formation for TRAPPIST-1 and other compact systems
• The Boundary between Gas-rich and Gas-poor Planets
• Breaking Degeneracies in Formation Histories by Measuring Refractory Content in Gas Giants
• The origin of the high metallicity of close-in giant exoplanets: Combined effect of the resonant and aerodynamic shepherding
• Planet formation and migration near the silicate sublimation front in protoplanetary disks
• The Habitable-zone Planet Finder Reveals A High Mass and a Low Obliquity for the Young Neptune K2-25b
• How dust fragmentation may be beneficial to planetary growth by pebble accretion
• The formation of mini-Neptunes
• A Tale of Planet Formation: From Dust to Planets
• Leaky dust traps: How fragmentation impacts dust filtering by planets
• Growth after the streaming instability: from planetesimal accretion to pebble accretion
• The consequences of planetary migration on the minor bodies of the early Solar System
• RV-detected planets around M dwarfs: Challenges for core accretion models
• Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales (MAPS). A Circumplanetary Disk Candidate in Molecular Line Emission in the AS 209 Disk
• Architectures of Compact Super-Earth Systems Shaped by Instabilities
• Evaporation of dark matter from celestial bodies
• A fading radius valley towards M-dwarfs, a persistent density valley across stellar types
• Close-in ice lines and the super-stellar C/O ratio in discs around very low-mass stars
• Jupiter's heavy-element enrichment expected from formation models
• Rapid Formation of Massive Planetary Cores in a Pressure Bump
• A Hubble PanCET Study of HAT-P-11b: A Cloudy Neptune with a Low Atmospheric Metallicity
• Dry or water world? How the water contents of inner sub-Neptunes constrain giant planet formation and the location of the water ice line
• Formation of moon systems around giant planets: Capture and ablation of planetesimals as foundation for a pebble accretion scenario
• The Galilean Satellites Formed Slowly from Pebbles
• Jupiter's formation in the vicinity of the amorphous ice snowline
• Thermal torque effects on the migration of growing low-mass planets
• Long-Period Giant Companions to Three Compact, Multiplanet Systems
• Runaway gas accretion and gap opening versus type~I migration
• Influence of planetary gas accretion on the shape and depth of gaps in protoplanetary discs
• Formation of Super-Earth Mass Planets at 125-250 AU from a Solar-type Star
• Puffed up Edges of Planet-opened Gaps in Protoplanetary Disks. I. hydrodynamic simulations
• Giants are bullies: how their growth influences systems of inner sub-Neptunes and super-Earths
• Pebble accretion at the origin of water in Europa
• Super-Earths and Earth-like Exoplanets
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets III: The formation of WASP-77A b and $\tau$ Boötis b
• Hydrodynamical turbulence in eccentric circumbinary discs and its impact on the in situ formation of circumbinary planets
• Setting the Stage: Planet formation and Volatile Delivery
• Gas flow around a planet embedded in a protoplanetary disc: the dependence on the planetary mass
• Jupiter's "Cold" Formation in the Protosolar Disk Shadow: An Explanation for the Planet's Uniformly Enriched Atmosphere
• Do the TRAPPIST-1 Planets Have Hydrogen-rich Atmospheres?
• The Preservation of Super Earths and the Emergence of Gas Giants after Their Progenitor Cores have Entered the Pebble Isolation Phase
• Small Planets Around Cool Dwarfs: Enhanced Formation Efficiency of Super-Earths around M dwarfs
• The effect of a strong pressure bump in the Sun's natal disk: Terrestrial planet formation via planetesimal accretion rather than pebble accretion
• TESS Reveals a Short-period Sub-Neptune Sibling (HD 86226c) to a Known Long-period Giant Planet
• Mind the gap: Distinguishing disc substructures and their impact on the inner disc composition
• Disentangling Hot Jupiters formation location from their chemical composition
• How to make giant planets via pebble accretion
• Are the observed gaps in protoplanetary discs caused by growing planets?
• Rapid Formation of Jupiter and Wide-Orbit Exoplanets in Disks with Pressure Bumps
• Pebble Accretion in Turbulent Protoplanetary Disks
• N-body simulations of planet formation via pebble accretion II. How various giant planets form
• Probing the impact of varied migration and gas accretion rates for the formation of giant planets in the pebble accretion scenario
• Inner Planetary System Gap Complexity is a Predictor of Outer Giant Planets
• Enriching inner discs and giant planets with heavy elements
• Recycling of the first atmospheres of embedded planets: Dependence on core mass and optical depth
• An Analytical Theory for the Growth from Planetesimals to Planets by Polydisperse Pebble Accretion
• Kepler-167e as a Probe of the Formation Histories of Cold Giants with Inner Super-Earths
• Composition of giant planets: the roles of pebbles and planetesimals
• Chemical mapping of temperate sub-Neptune atmospheres: Constraining the deep-interior H2O/H2 using the atmospheric CO2/CH4
• The importance of thermal torques on the migration of planets growing by pebble accretion
• How planets grow by pebble accretion IV: Envelope opacity trends from sedimenting dust and pebbles
• A pebbles accretion model with chemistry and implications for the solar system
• From Dust to Planets I: Planetesimal and Embryo Formation
• How does accretion of planet-forming disks influence stellar abundances?
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. Two terrestrial planets orbiting G 264-012 and one terrestrial planet orbiting Gl 393
• Pairwise Tidal Equilibrium States and the Architecture of Extrasolar Planetary Systems
• Long live the disk: lifetimes of protoplanetary disks in hierarchical triple star systems and a possible explanation for HD 98800 B
• Three long period transiting giant planets from TESS
• Planet formation throughout the Milky Way: Planet populations in the context of Galactic chemical evolution
• Sequential giant planet formation initiated by disc substructure
• Influences of three-dimensional gas flow induced by protoplanets on pebble accretion --$\mathrm{I}$. shear regime
• Pebble accretion in class 0/I YSOs as a possible pathway for early planet formation
• The Formation of Uranus and Neptune: Fine Tuning in Core Accretion
• Key Atmospheric Signatures for Identifying the Source Reservoirs of Volatiles in Uranus and Neptune
• Unified simulations of planetary formation and atmospheric evolution II: Rapid disk clearing by photoevaporation yields low-mass super-Earth atmospheres
• Formation of giant planets with large metal masses and metal fractions via giant impacts in a rapidly dissipating disk
• Steamworlds: atmospheric structure and critical mass of planets accreting icy pebbles
• Making the Solar System
• Quantifying the Impact of the Dust Torque on the Migration of Low-mass Planets
• A Self-Consistent Model for Dust-Gas Coupling in Protoplanetary Disks
• On the multiple generations of planetary embryos
• TW Hya: an old protoplanetary disc revived by its planet
• Morphological signatures induced by dust back reaction in discs with an embedded planet
• Planetesimal formation around the snow line: I. Monte Carlo simulations of silicate dust pile-up in a turbulent disk
• Dust Accumulation near the Magnetospheric Truncation of Protoplanetary Discs around T Tauri Stars
• Promoted Mass Growth of Multiple, Distant Giant Planets through Pebble Accretion and Planet-Planet Collision
• Emergence of vortices at the edges of planet-driven gaps in protoplanetary discs
• Changing disc compositions via internal photoevaporation I: Solar-mass stars
• Influence of grain sizes and composition on the contraction rates of planetary envelopes and on planetary migration
• Dynamical Evolution of Closely Packed Multiple Planetary Systems Subject to Atmospheric Mass-Loss
• In-situ enrichment in heavy elements of hot Jupiters
• Migration of accreting planets in radiative discs from dynamical torques
• Effects of pebble accretion on the growth and composition of planetesimals in the inner Solar System
• Formation of wide-orbit giant planets in protoplanetary disks with a decreasing pebble flux
• Sublimation of refractory minerals in the gas envelopes of accreting rocky planets
• Three-dimensional transport of solids in a protoplanetary disk containing a growing giant planet
• The tidal parameters of TRAPPIST-1 b and c
• The evolution of circumstellar discs in the Galactic Centre: an application to the G-clouds
• On the suppression of giant planet formation around low-mass stars in clustered environments
• H${}_2$-H${}_2$O demixing in Uranus and Neptune: Adiabatic structure models
• Planetary core formation via multi-species pebble accretion
• The quest for Magrathea planets I: formation of second generation exoplanets around double white dwarfs
• Numerical study of coorbital thermal torques on cold or hot satellites
• Planet population synthesis: The role of stellar encounters
• Spin of protoplanets generated by pebble accretion: Influences of protoplanet-induced gas flow
• The growth of super-Earths: the importance of a self-consistent treatment of disc structures and pebble accretion
• Dust-Gas Coupling in Turbulence- and MHD Wind-Driven Protoplanetary Disks: Implications for Rocky Planet Formation
• Extreme Pebble Accretion in Ringed Protoplanetary Discs
• A low accretion efficiency of planetesimals formed at planetary gap edges
• Filling in the Gaps: Can Gravitationally Unstable Discs Form the Seeds of Gas Giant Planets?
• Architecture of planetary systems predicted from protoplanetary disks observed with ALMA I: mass of the possible planets embedded in the dust gap
• Planetesimal and planet formation in transient dust traps
• Heavy-element Accretion by Proto-Jupiter in a Massive Planetesimal Disk, Revisited
• Dust rings as a footprint of planet formation in a protoplanetary disk
• Photoevaporation of the Jovian circumplanetary disk I. Explaining the orbit of Callisto and the lack of outer regular satellites
• There is no disk mass budget problem of planet formation
• How the planetary eccentricity influences the pebble isolation mass
• Do all gaps in protoplanetary discs host planets?
• Circumstellar dust distribution in systems with two planets in resonance
• Grain Growth in the Dust Ring with Crescent around Very Low Mass Star ZZ Tau IRS with JVLA
• Planetesimal fragmentation and giant planet formation II: dependencies with planetesimal relative velocities and compositions
• Simultaneous gas accretion onto a pair of giant planets: Impact on their final mass and on the protoplanetary disk structure
• Accreting luminous low-mass planets escape from migration traps at pressure bumps
• Radiative Nonideal MHD Simulations of Inner Protoplanetary Disks: Temperature Structures, Asymmetric Winds, and Episodic Surface Accretion
• The role of density perturbation on planet formation by pebble accretion
• Constraining giant planet formation with synthetic ALMA images of the Solar System's natal protoplanetary disk
• How external photo-evaporation changes the chemical composition of the inner disc
• Formation of multiple-planet systems in resonant chains around M dwarfs
• A primordial radius valley as a consequence of planet formation
• Super-Earth formation in systems with cold giants
• The likelihood of not detecting cavity-carving companions in transition discs -- A statistical approach
• Dust ring and gap formation by gas flow induced by low-mass planets embedded in protoplanetary disks $\mathrm{I}$. Steady-state model
• The origin of the occurrence rate profile of gas giants inside 100 days
• Dust Rings and Cavities in the Protoplanetary Disks around HD 163296 and DoAr 44
• Hidden under a warm blanket: If planets existed in protostellar disks, they would hardly produce observable substructures
• Emerging population of gap-opening planets around type-A stars -- Long-term evolution of the forming planets around HD 163296
• Thermal Processing of Solids Encountering a Young Jovian Core
• Accretion of aerodynamically large pebbles
• Changing disc compositions via internal photoevaporation II: M dwarf systems
• Diversity of disc viscosities can explain the period ratios of resonant and non-resonant systems of hot super-Earths and mini-Neptunes
• Dust ring and gap formation by gas flow induced by low-mass planets embedded in protoplanetary disks $\mathrm{II}$. Time-dependent model
• Giant planet formation via pebble accretion across different stellar masses
• The paradox of youth for ALMA planet candidates
• Increased isolation mass for pebble accreting planetary cores in pressure maxima of protoplanetary discs
• Multiple Rings and Asymmetric Structures in the Disk of SR 21
• How disc initial conditions sculpt the atmospheric composition of giant planets
• How does the chemical composition of solids influence the formation of planetesimals?
• A High-Resolution Spectroscopic Survey of Directly Imaged Companion Hosts: II. Diversity in C/O Ratios among Host Stars
• On the formation of multiple dust-trapping rings in the inner Solar system
• Constraining the formation history of the HAT-P-11 system by atmospheric abundances
• The influence of dust growth on the observational properties of circumplanetary discs
• The PAIRS project: a global formation model for planets in binaries. I. Effect of disc truncation on the growth of S-type planets
• Architecture of planetary systems predicted from protoplanetary disks observed with ALMA II: evolution outcomes and dynamical stability
• Planet Formation by Gas-Assisted Accretion of Small Solids
• Long-term evolution of the temperature structure in magnetized protoplanetary disks and its implication for the dichotomy of planetary composition
• Interpreting the atmospheric composition of exoplanets: sensitivity to planet formation assumptions
• Dust back-reaction on gas around planets modifies the cold thermal torque
• Interior dynamics of envelopes around disk-embedded planets
• How leaky? A large parameter study of leaky dust traps to quantify the transport of pebbles and ice in protoplanetary discs
• Evolution and Observable Properties of Rocky Planet Atmospheres
• Possible in situ formation of Uranus and Neptune via Pebble Accretion
• A sub-Saturn Mass-Radius Desert for Planets with Equilibrium Temperature Less than 600 K
• A break in planet occurrence near the pebble isolation mass should be observable by the Roman microlensing survey
• Shaken, not stirred: inefficient mixing of CM- and CI-like materials
• Planetesimal formation at the gas pressure bump following a migrating planet II. Effects of dust growth
• Different arrival times of CM and CI-like bodies from the outer Solar System to the asteroid belt
• The effect of late giant collisions on the atmospheres of protoplanets and the formation of cold sub-Saturns
• A multi-fluid approach for polydisperse pebble accretion: From particles to fluids, establishing the multifluid framework
• Reading between the rings: observed dust ring properties as probes of planet masses