Interpreting the atmospheric composition of exoplanets: sensitivity to planet formation assumptions

Abstract

Constraining planet formation based on the atmospheric composition of exoplanets is a fundamental goal of the exoplanet community. Existing studies commonly try to constrain atmospheric abundances, or to analyze what abundance patterns a given description of planet formation predicts. However, there is also a pressing need to develop methodologies that investigate how to transform atmospheric compositions into planetary formation inferences. In this study we summarize the complexities and uncertainties of state-of-the-art planet formation models and how they influence planetary atmospheric compositions. We introduce a methodology that explores the effect of different formation model assumptions when interpreting atmospheric compositions. We apply this framework to the directly imaged planet HR 8799e. Based on its atmospheric composition, this planet may have migrated significantly during its formation. We show that including the chemical evolution of the protoplanetary disk leads to a reduced need for migration. Moreover, we find that pebble accretion can reproduce the planet's composition, but some of our tested setups lead to too low atmospheric metallicities, even when considering that evaporating pebbles may enrich the disk gas. We conclude that the definitive inversion from atmospheric abundances to planet formation for a given planet may be challenging, but a qualitative understanding of the effects of different formation models is possible, opening up pathways for new investigations.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ, base formation inversion code is available at: https://gitlab.com/mauricemolli/formation-inversion

References in corpus (201)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
• The effects of snowlines on C/O in planetary atmospheres
• Importance Nested Sampling and the MultiNest Algorithm
• Towards a Deterministic Model of Planetary Formation I: a Desert in the Mass and Semi Major Axis Distributions of Extra Solar Planets
• Rapid growth of gas-giant cores by pebble accretion
• A simple model for the evolution of the dust population in protoplanetary disks
• Precipitating Condensation Clouds in Substellar Atmospheres
• Models of Giant Planet formation with migration and disc evolution
• The effect of gas drag on the growth of protoplanets -- Analytical expressions for the accretion of small bodies in laminar disks
• On the width and shape of gaps in protoplanetary disks
• Dynamical Origin of Extrasolar Planet Eccentricity Distribution
• Extrasolar planet population synthesis I: Method, formation tracks and mass-distance distribution
• C/O ratio as a Dimension for Characterizing Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• Separating gas-giant and ice-giant planets by halting pebble accretion
• Neglected Clouds in T and Y Dwarf Atmospheres
• Dust and Gas in the disc of HL Tauri: Surface density, dust settling, and dust-to-gas ratio
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets
• Disk Accretion Onto High-Mass Planets
• A Precise Water Abundance Measurement for the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b
• Comparing Jupiter interior structure models to Juno gravity measurements and the role of a dilute core
• The imprint of exoplanet formation history on observable present-day spectra of hot Jupiters
• Characterizing transiting exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
• 3D mixing in hot Jupiter atmospheres. I. application to the day/night cold trap in HD 209458b
• Atomic and Molecular Opacities for Brown Dwarf and Giant Planet Atmospheres
• Exoplanetary Atmospheres: Key Insights, Challenges and Prospects
• High C/O Ratio and Weak Thermal Inversion in the Very Hot Atmosphere of Exoplanet WASP-12b
• Structure and evolution of super-Earth to super-Jupiter exoplanets: I. heavy element enrichment in the interior
• Can TiO Explain Thermal Inversions in the Upper Atmospheres of Irradiated Giant Planets?
• Transitions in the cloud composition of hot Jupiters
• Pebble isolation mass --- scaling law and implications for the formation of super-Earths and gas giants
• A Framework for Characterizing the Atmospheres of Low-Mass Low-Density Transiting Planets
• Dust Evolution and the Formation of Planetesimals
• Chemical consequences of the C/O ratio on hot Jupiters: Examples from WASP-12b,CoRoT-2b, XO-1b, and HD 189733b
• Models of Jupiter's Growth Incorporating Thermal and Hydrodynamic Constraints
• A Three-Dimensional View of Turbulence: Constraints on Turbulent Motions in the HD 163296 Protoplanetary Disk using DCO${}^{+}$
• Towards Chemical Constraints on Hot Jupiter Migration
• Masses, Radii, and Cloud Properties of the HR 8799 Planets
• Comparative Planetary Atmospheres: Models of TrES-1 and HD209458b
• Compositional imprints in density-distance-time: a rocky composition for close-in low-mass exoplanets from the location of the valley of evaporation
• A new vision on giant planet interiors: the impact of double diffusive convection
• Orbital Migration and Mass Accretion of Protoplanets in 3D Global Computations with Nested Grids
• Retrieving Temperatures and Abundances of Exoplanet Atmospheres with High-Resolution Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy
• Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: How the radial pebble flux determines a terrestrial-planet or super-Earth growth mode
• Atmospheric Chemistry in Giant Planets, Brown Dwarfs, and Low-Mass Dwarf Stars III. Iron, Magnesium, and Silicon
• The Heavy Element Masses of Extrasolar Giant Planets, Revealed
• A chemical model for the atmosphere of hot Jupiters
• Extremely Irradiated Hot Jupiters: Non-Oxide Inversions, H- Opacity, and Thermal Dissociation of Molecules
• Chemical enrichment of giant planets and discs due to pebble drift
• Model atmospheres of irradiated exoplanets: The influence of stellar parameters, metallicity, and the C/O ratio
• Aerosol Composition of Hot Giant Exoplanets Dominated by Silicates and Hydrocarbon Hazes
• Mass-Metallicity Trends in Transiting Exoplanets from Atmospheric Abundances of H${}_2$O, Na, and K
• A spectral survey of an ultra-hot Jupiter: Detection of metals in the transmission spectrum of KELT-9 b
• Transmission spectral properties of clouds for hot Jupiter exoplanets
• Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph Observations of M, L, and T Dwarfs
• A comparison of chemistry and dust cloud formation in ultracool dwarf model atmospheres
• Methane, Carbon Monoxide, and Ammonia in Brown Dwarfs and Self-Luminous Giant Planets
• Chemistry in Disks. IV. Benchmarking gas-grain chemical models with surface reactions
• Evolution of Protoplanetary Discs with Magnetically Driven Disc Winds
• The Influence of Non-Uniform Cloud Cover on Transit Transmission Spectra
• Retrieving scattering clouds and disequilibrium chemistry in the atmosphere of HR 8799e
• A Systematic Retrieval Analysis of Secondary Eclipse Spectra II: A Uniform Analysis of Eight Planets and Their C to O Ratios
• Turbulence in the TW Hya Disk
• H${}_2$O abundances and cloud properties in ten hot giant exoplanets
• Accretion of Jupiter-mass Planets in the Limit of Vanishing Viscosity
• Dust flow in gas disks in the presence of embedded planets
• Detection of Fe I in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b, and a new likelihood-based approach for Doppler-resolved spectroscopy
• Hydrodynamics of Embedded Planets' First Atmospheres. II. A Rapid Recycling of Atmospheric Gas
• Heat transport in giant (exo)planets: a new perspective
• Observing transiting planets with JWST -- Prime targets and their synthetic spectral observations
• Theoretical models of planetary system formation: mass vs semi-major axis
• Magneto-thermal Disk Wind from Protoplanetary Disks
• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). I. Bern global model of planet formation and evolution, model tests, and emerging planetary systems
• Tracing the formation history of giant planets in protoplanetary disks with Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen and Sulphur
• Chemical evolution of turbulent protoplanetary disks and the Solar nebula
• A solar C/O and sub-solar metallicity in a hot Jupiter atmosphere
• New models of Jupiter in the context of Juno and Galileo
• Atmospheric Signatures of Giant Exoplanet Formation by Pebble Accretion
• Five carbon- and nitrogen-bearing species in a hot giant planet's atmosphere
• Setting the volatile composition of (exo)planet-building material. Does chemical evolution in disk midplanes matter?
• A self-consistent cloud model for brown dwarfs and young giant exoplanets: comparison with photometric and spectroscopic observations
• Migration of massive planets in accreting disks
• Formation of planets by tidal downsizing of giant planet embryos
• Molecular abundances and C/O ratios in chemically evolving planet-forming disk midplanes
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets I: Heavy element content and atmospheric C/O
• The Complete transmission spectrum of WASP-39b with a precise water constraint
• Hot Exoplanet Atmospheres Resolved with Transit Spectroscopy (HEARTS) IV. A spectral inventory of atoms and molecules in the high-resolution transmission spectrum of WASP-121 b
• Pseudo 2D chemical model of hot Jupiter atmospheres: application to HD 209458b and HD 189733b
• High temperature condensate clouds in super-hot Jupiter atmospheres
• On the Dayside Thermal Emission of Hot Jupiters
• Retrieval analysis of 38 WFC3 transmission spectra and resolution of the normalisation degeneracy
• Planet-forming material in a protoplanetary disc: the interplay between chemical evolution and pebble drift
• Re-Evaluating WASP-12b: Strong Emission at 2.315 micron, Deeper Occultations, and an Isothermal Atmosphere
• Peering into the formation history of beta Pictoris b with VLTI/GRAVITY long baseline interferometry
• Dynamical Constraints on the HR 8799 Planets with GPI
• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). II. Planetary population of solar-like stars and overview of statistical results
• The Peculiar Atmospheric Chemistry of KELT-9b
• Sequestration of noble gases in giant planet interiors
• Gas accretion onto planetary cores: three-dimensional self-gravitating radiation hydrodynamical calculations
• Probing the extreme planetary atmosphere of WASP-12b
• CO destruction in protoplanetary disk midplanes: inside versus outside the CO snow surface
• Connecting Giant Planet Atmosphere and Interior Modeling: Constraints on Atmospheric Metal Enrichment
• A framework to combine low- and high-resolution spectroscopy for the atmospheres of transiting exoplanets
• The Intrinsic Temperature and Radiative-Convective Boundary Depth in the Atmospheres of Hot Jupiters
• Beyond Equilibrium Temperature: How the Atmosphere/Interior Connection Affects the Onset of Methane, Ammonia, and Clouds in Warm Transiting Giant Planets
• Radiation Hydrodynamical Turbulence In Protoplanetary Disks: Numerical Models and Observational Constraints
• Jupiter's composition suggests its core assembled exterior to the N2 snowline
• Jupiter's evolution with primordial composition gradients
• How much does turbulence change the pebble isolation mass for planet formation?
• Effects of a fully 3D atmospheric structure on exoplanet transmission spectra: retrieval biases due to day-night temperature gradients
• C/O and Snowline Locations in Protoplanetary Disks: The Effect of Radial Drift and Viscous Gas Accretion
• Hydrodynamics of embedded planets' first atmospheres - III. The role of radiation transport for super-Earth planets
• The Impact of Non-Uniform Thermal Structure on the Interpretation of Exoplanet Emission Spectra
• The 13O-rich atmosphere of a young accreting super-Jupiter
• Formation of Silicate and Titanium Clouds on Hot Jupiters
• Uniform Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs II: Properties of 11 T-dwarfs
• Deciphering the Atmospheric Composition of WASP-12b: A Comprehensive Analysis of its Dayside Emission
• Why is it so Cold in Here?: Explaining the Cold Temperatures Retrieved from Transmission Spectra of Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Where is the Water? Jupiter-like C/H ratio but strong H${}_2$O depletion found on $\tau$ Boötis b using SPIRou
• Unlocking CO Depletion in Protoplanetary Disks I. The Warm Molecular Layer
• Composition of Early Planetary Atmospheres I: Connecting Disk Astrochemistry to the Formation of Planetary Atmospheres
• The fuzziness of giant planets' cores
• Numerical simulations of surface convection in a late M-dwarf
• The Origin of Planetary System Architectures. I. Multiple Planet Traps in Gaseous Discs
• A Volume-Limited Sample of Ultracool Dwarfs. I. Construction, Space Density, and a Gap in the L/T Transition
• A New Window into Planet Formation and Migration: Refractory-to-Volatile Elemental Ratios in Ultra-hot Jupiters
• How cores grow by pebble accretion I. Direct core growth
• A photochemical model for the carbon-rich planet WASP-12b
• Gas and dust structures in protoplanetary disks hosting multiple planets
• From planetesimals to planets: volatile molecules
• Observations of Disequilibrium CO Chemistry in the Coldest Brown Dwarfs
• Understanding and Mitigating Biases when Studying Inhomogeneous Emission Spectra with JWST
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets II: Volatiles and refractories in atmospheres
• New Avenues for Thermal Inversions in hot Jupiters
• Influence of sub- and super-solar metallicities on the compositions of solid planetary building blocks
• Protoplanetary Disk Structure With Grain Evolution: the ANDES Model
• The Challenge of Forming a Fuzzy Core in Jupiter
• Strong biases in retrieved atmospheric composition caused by strong day-night chemical heterogeneities
• An Ultra-Hot Neptune in the Neptune desert
• Detecting isotopologues in exoplanet atmospheres using ground-based high-dispersion spectroscopy
• Toward the analysis of JWST exoplanet spectra: Identifying troublesome model parameters
• The Evolution and Internal Structure of Jupiter and Saturn with Compositional Gradients
• Revelations on Jupiter's Formation, Evolution and Interior: Challenges from Juno Results
• Evidence of Three Mechanisms Explaining the Radius Anomaly of Hot Jupiters
• Toward a new paradigm for Type II migration
• Pebble Accretion and the Diversity of Planetary Systems
• TRIDENT: A Rapid 3D Radiative Transfer Model for Exoplanet Transmission Spectra
• C/O and O/H Ratios Suggest Some Hot Jupiters Originate Beyond the Snow Line
• Convection and Mixing in Giant Planet Evolution
• How planets grow by pebble accretion. III. Emergence of an interior composition gradient
• Precise Dynamical Masses and Orbital Fits for $\beta$ Pic b and $\beta$ Pic c
• The spatial distribution of carbon dust in the early solar nebula and the carbon content of planetesimals
• Connecting planet formation and astrochemistry: Refractory carbon depletion leading to super-stellar C/O in giant planetary atmospheres
• The Implications of 3D Thermal Structure on 1D Atmospheric Retrieval
• Jupiter formed as a pebble pile around the N${}_2$ ice line
• A Library of Self-Consistent Simulated Exoplanet Atmospheres
• HyDRA-H: Simultaneous Hybrid Retrieval of Exoplanetary Emission Spectra
• Double-diffusive erosion of the core of Jupiter
• Fingerprints of giant planets in the composition of solar twins
• Grid of Pseudo-2D Chemistry Models for Tidally-Locked Exoplanets. I. The Role of Vertical and Horizontal Mixing
• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). V. Predetermination of planet types in global core accretion models
• The eccentricity distribution of giant planets and their relation to super-Earths in the pebble accretion scenario
• How planets grow by pebble accretion II: Analytical calculations on the evolution of polluted envelopes
• Dry or water world? How the water contents of inner sub-Neptunes constrain giant planet formation and the location of the water ice line
• Stellar irradiated discs and implications on migration of embedded planets III: viscosity transitions
• From cold to hot irradiated gaseous exoplanets: Fingerprints of chemical disequilibrium in atmospheric spectra
• Signatures of Nitrogen Chemistry in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• Sulfur Chemistry in the Atmospheres of Warm and Hot Jupiters
• Influence of the water content in protoplanetary discs on planet migration and formation
• Pebbles versus planetesimals: the outcomes of population synthesis models
• Exploring the formation by core accretion and the luminosity evolution of directly imaged planets: The case of HIP 65426 b
• Global 3D radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of gas accretion: The opacity dependent growth of Saturn-mass planets
• 2D Retrieval Frameworks for Hot Jupiter Phase Curves
• Gas mass tracers in protoplanetary disks: CO is still the best
• From cold to hot irradiated gaseous exoplanets: Toward an observation-based classification scheme
• UV Exoplanet Transmission Spectral Features as Probes of Metals and Rainout
• Influence of planetary gas accretion on the shape and depth of gaps in protoplanetary discs
• On the Chemical Abundance of HR 8799 and the Planet c
• Heavy-metal Jupiters by major mergers: metallicity vs. mass for giant planets
• Efficiency of Planetesimal Ablation in Giant Planetary Envelopes
• Influence of grain growth on the thermal structure of protoplanetary discs
• Dust in brown dwarfs and extra-solar planets. VII. Cloud formation in diffusive atmospheres
• On the structure and mass delivery towards circumplanetary discs
• Tidal Downsizing Model. III. Planets from sub-Earths to Brown Dwarfs: structure and metallicity preferences
• JWST Transit Spectra I: Exploring Potential Biases and Opportunities in Retrievals of Tidally-locked Hot Jupiters with Clouds and Hazes
• Searching for the origin of the Ehrenreich effect in ultra-hot Jupiters: Evidence for strong C/O gradients in the atmosphere of WASP-76b?
• Jupiter's "Cold" Formation in the Protosolar Disk Shadow: An Explanation for the Planet's Uniformly Enriched Atmosphere
• An exploration of model degeneracies with a unified phase curve retrieval analysis: The light and dark sides of WASP-43 b
• The role of planetary formation and evolution in shaping the composition of exoplanetary atmospheres
• Unlocking CO Depletion in Protoplanetary Disks II. Primordial C/H Predictions Inside the CO Snowline
• The influence of infall on the properties of protoplanetary discs
• Vertical gas accretion impacts the carbon-to-oxygen ratio of gas giant atmospheres
• Atmospheric characterization of directly imaged exoplanets with JWST/MIRI
• The water-ice line as a birthplace of planets: Implications of a species-dependent dust fragmentation threshold
• Vortex Formation and Evolution in Planet Harboring Disks under Thermal Relaxation
• Formation of giant planets with large metal masses and metal fractions via giant impacts in a rapidly dissipating disk
• Ariel Planetary Interiors White Paper
• Modeling synthetic spectra for transiting extrasolar giant planets: detectability of H${}_2$S and PH${}_3$ with JWST
• The impact of pre-main sequence stellar evolution on midplane snowline locations and C/O in planet forming discs
• Stellar abundance of binary stars: their role in determining the formation location of super-Earths and ice giants
• The Effect of the Approach to Gas Disk Gravitational Instability on the Rapid Formation of Gas Giant Planets. II. Quadrupled Spatial Resolution

Cited by in corpus (2)

• 15NH3 in the atmosphere of a cool brown dwarf
• Direct imaging of exoplanets: Legacy and prospects