The Challenge of Forming a Fuzzy Core in Jupiter

Abstract

Recent structure models of Jupiter that match Juno gravity data suggest that the planet harbours an extended region in its deep interior that is enriched in heavy elements, a so-called dilute/fuzzy core. This finding raises the question of what possible formation pathways would lead to such a structure. We model Jupiter's formation and long-term evolution, starting at late-stage formation before runaway gas accretion. The formation scenarios we consider include both primordial composition gradients, as well as gradients that are built as proto-Jupiter rapidly acquires its gaseous envelope. We then follow Jupiter's evolution as it cools down and contracts, with a particular focus on the energy and material transport in the interior. We find that none of the scenarios we consider lead to a fuzzy core that is compatible with interior structure models. In all the cases, most of Jupiter's envelope becomes convective and fully mixed after at most a few million years. This is true even when we consider a case where the gas accretion leads to a cold planet, and large amounts of heavy elements are accreted. It is therefore concluded that it is very challenging to explain Jupiter's dilute core from standard formation models. We suggest that future work should consider more complex formation pathways as well as the modelling of additional physical processes that could lead to Jupiter's current-state internal structure.

arXiv comment11 pages, 9 figures, accepted for publication in A&A; grammar and typos corrected, error in Fig. 3 fixed

References in corpus (43)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Low Temperature Opacities
• The Interiors of Giant Planets: Models and Outstanding Questions
• On the Luminosity of Young Jupiters
• Line and Mean Opacities for Ultracool Dwarfs and Extrasolar Planets
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• Comparing Jupiter interior structure models to Juno gravity measurements and the role of a dilute core
• Structure and evolution of super-Earth to super-Jupiter exoplanets: I. heavy element enrichment in the interior
• Models of Jupiter's Growth Incorporating Thermal and Hydrodynamic Constraints
• A new vision on giant planet interiors: the impact of double diffusive convection
• Bulk Composition of GJ 1214b and other sub-Neptune exoplanets
• Heat transport in giant (exo)planets: a new perspective
• New models of Jupiter in the context of Juno and Galileo
• A new equation of state for dense hydrogen-helium mixtures
• Sequestration of noble gases in giant planet interiors
• Phase separation in hydrogen-helium mixtures at Mbar pressures
• Jupiter's evolution with primordial composition gradients
• The Effect of Composition on the Evolution of Giant and Intermediate-Mass Planets
• Effects of Helium Phase Separation on the Evolution of Extrasolar Giant Planets
• The fuzziness of giant planets' cores
• The Formation of Jupiter's Diluted Core by a Giant Impact
• A new model for mixing by double-diffusive convection (semi-convection). II. The transport of heat and composition through layers
• Jupiter's formation and its primordial internal structure
• The Evolution and Internal Structure of Jupiter and Saturn with Compositional Gradients
• Ab initio based equation of state of dense water for planetary and exoplanetary modeling
• The origin of the high metallicity of close-in giant exoplanets: Combined effect of the resonant and aerodynamic shepherding
• Evolution of Gas Giant Entropy During Formation by Runaway Accretion
• Convection and Mixing in Giant Planet Evolution
• Effect of Non-Adiabatic Thermal Profiles on the Inferred Compositions of Uranus and Neptune
• The Planetary Accretion Shock: I. Framework for Radiation-hydrodynamical Simulations and First Results
• Double-diffusive erosion of the core of Jupiter
• The Planetary Accretion Shock. II. Grid of Post-Shock Entropies and Radiative Shock Efficiencies for Non-Equilibrium Radiation Transport
• Bayesian Evolution Models for Jupiter with Helium Rain and Double-diffusive Convection
• Properties of hydrogen, helium, and silicon dioxide mixtures in giant planet interiors
• Coupled Thermal and Compositional Evolution of Photo Evaporating Planet Envelopes
• The Primordial Entropy of Jupiter
• Hot Start Giant Planets Form With Radiative Interiors
• The properties of heavy elements in giant planet envelopes
• The fate of planetary cores in giant and ice-giant planets

Cited by in corpus (51)

• Revelations on Jupiter's Formation, Evolution and Interior: Challenges from Juno Results
• Evidence of Three Mechanisms Explaining the Radius Anomaly of Hot Jupiters
• A new perspective on interiors of ice-rich planets: Ice-rock mixture instead of ice on top of rock
• How planets grow by pebble accretion. III. Emergence of an interior composition gradient
• Jupiter's interior from Juno: Equation-of-state uncertainties and dilute core extent
• On the mass of gas giant planets: Is Saturn a failed gas giant?
• Theoretical vs. observational uncertainties: composition of giant exoplanets
• Giant planet formation models with a self-consistent treatment of the heavy elements
• Synthetic Evolution Tracks of Giant Planets
• Formation and evolution of a protoplanetary disk: combining observations, simulations and cosmochemical constraints
• Evolution of Jupiter and Saturn with helium rain
• Study of Jupiter's Interior: Comparison of 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 Layer Models
• Towards a new era in giant exoplanet characterisation
• How planets grow by pebble accretion IV: Envelope opacity trends from sedimenting dust and pebbles
• Layer formation in a stably-stratified fluid cooled from above. Towards an analog for Jupiter and other gas giants
• Exoplanet Interior Retrievals: core masses and metallicities from atmospheric abundances
• Convective Mixing in Gas Giant Planets with Primordial Composition Gradients
• Rotation reduces convective mixing in Jupiter and other gas giants
• Ariel Planetary Interiors White Paper
• Planet Mass and Metallicity: The Exoplanets and Solar System Connection
• Super stellar abundances of alkali metals suggest significant migration for Hot Jupiters
• Evolution of Semi-convective Staircases in Rotating Flows: Consequences for Fuzzy Cores in Giant Planets
• Tidal dissipation due to the elliptical instability and turbulent viscosity in convection zones in rotating giant planets and stars
• Penetration of a cooling convective layer into a stably-stratified composition gradient: entrainment at low Prandtl number
• Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT 'EM) Survey. II. Discovery of a Failed Hot Jupiter on a 2.7 Year, Highly Eccentric Orbit
• Partially Diffusive Helium-Silica Compound in the Deep Interiors of Giant Planets
• The bulk metallicity of giant planets around M stars
• How planets form by pebble accretion V. Silicate rainout delays contraction of sub-Neptunes
• Heavy-element Accretion by Proto-Jupiter in a Massive Planetesimal Disk, Revisited
• Unraveling the origin of giant exoplanets: Observational implications of convective mixing
• The Possibility of Hydrogen-Water Demixing in Uranus, Neptune, K2-18b and TOI-270d
• 3D Simulations of Semiconvection in Spheres: Turbulent Mixing and Layer Formation
• Study of Jupiter's Interior with Quadratic Monte Carlo Simulations
• On the origin of Jupiter's fuzzy core: constraints from N-body, impact and evolution simulations
• Characterizing Jupiter's interior using machine learning reveals four key structures
• An extended low-density atmosphere around the Jupiter-sized planet WASP-193 b
• The Evolution of Jupiter and Saturn as a function of the Parameter R${}_{\rho }$
• GEMS JWST: Transmission spectroscopy of TOI-5205b reveals significant stellar contamination and a metal-poor atmosphere
• Tidally-induced migration of TESS gas giants orbiting M dwarfs
• Giant planet formation via pebble accretion across different stellar masses
• Planet Formation
• The Outcome of Collisions between Gaseous Clumps formed by Disk Instability
• Further constraints on Jupiter's primordial structure
• Structure and Melting of Fe, MgO, SiO2, and MgSiO3 in Planets: Database, Inversion, and Phase Diagram
• No dilute core produced in simulations of giant impacts on to Jupiter
• An Energy Perspective of Core Erosion in Gas Giant Planets
• Interpreting the atmospheric composition of exoplanets: sensitivity to planet formation assumptions
• Nested spheroidal figures of equilibrium III. Connection with the gravitational moments $J_{2n}$
• 3D Simulations of Convective Entrainment in Gas Giants: Rotation and Decreasing Luminosity as Barriers to Mixing
• The Evolution and Internal Structure of Neptunes and Sub-Neptunes: The importance of thermal conductivity in non-convective regions
• Possible in situ formation of Uranus and Neptune via Pebble Accretion