Retrieval analysis of 38 WFC3 transmission spectra and resolution of the normalisation degeneracy
arXiv:1809.06894 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2550
Abstract
A comprehensive analysis of 38 previously published Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) transmission spectra is performed using a hierarchy of nested-sampling retrievals: with versus without clouds, grey versus non-grey clouds, isothermal versus non-isothermal transit chords and with water, hydrogen cyanide and/or ammonia. We revisit the "normalisation degeneracy": the relative abundances of molecules are degenerate at the order-of-magnitude level with the absolute normalisation of the transmission spectrum. Using a suite of mock retrievals, we demonstrate that the normalisation degeneracy may be partially broken using WFC3 data alone, even in the absence of optical/visible data and without appealing to the presence of patchy clouds, although lower limits to the mixing ratios may be prior-dominated depending on the measurement uncertainties. With James Webb Space Telescope-like spectral resolutions, the normalisation degeneracy may be completely broken from infrared spectra alone. We find no trend in the retrieved water abundances across nearly two orders of magnitude in exoplanet mass and a factor of 5 in retrieved temperature (about 500 to 2500 K). We further show that there is a general lack of strong Bayesian evidence to support interpretations of non-grey over grey clouds (only for WASP-69b and WASP-76b) and non-isothermal over isothermal atmospheres (no objects). 35 out of 38 WFC3 transmission spectra are well-fitted by an isothermal transit chord with grey clouds and water only, while 8 are adequately explained by flat lines. Generally, the cloud composition is unconstrained.
arXiv commentAccepted by MNRAS. 33 pages, 29 figures, 3 tables
References in corpus (84)
- emcee: The MCMC Hammer
- MultiNest: an efficient and robust Bayesian inference tool for cosmology and particle physics
- Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
- X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
- Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
- A continuum from clear to cloudy hot-Jupiter exoplanets without primordial water depletion
- Clouds in the atmosphere of the super-Earth exoplanet GJ 1214b
- A high accuracy computed water line list
- A Temperature and Abundance Retrieval Method for Exoplanet Atmospheres
- Improved parameters for extrasolar transiting planets
- The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets
- Atmospheric Retrieval for Super-Earths: Uniquely Constraining the Atmospheric Composition with Transmission Spectroscopy
- ExoMol line lists IV: The rotation-vibration spectrum of methane up to 1500 K
- Transmission Spectra as Diagnostics of Extrasolar Giant Planet Atmospheres
- HAT-P-11b: A Super-Neptune Planet Transiting a Bright K Star in the Kepler Field
- A Precise Water Abundance Measurement for the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b
- Rayleigh scattering in the transit spectrum of HD 189733b
- WASP-12b: The hottest transiting planet yet discovered
- The Transit Light Source Effect: False Spectral Features and Incorrect Densities for M-dwarf Transiting Planets
- A variationally computed line list for hot NH3
- Thermal structure of an exoplanet atmosphere from phase-resolved emission spectroscopy
- A featureless transmission spectrum for the Neptune-mass exoplanet GJ 436b
- The nature of the TRAPPIST-1 exoplanets
- A population study of gaseous exoplanets
- How to Distinguish between Cloudy Mini-Neptunes and Water/Volatile-Dominated Super-Earths
- ExoMol line lists III: An improved hot rotation-vibration line list for HCN and HNC
- H- Opacity and Water Dissociation in the Dayside Atmosphere of the Very Hot Gas Giant WASP-18 b
- HD 209458b in New Light: Evidence of Nitrogen Chemistry, Patchy Clouds and Sub-Solar Water
- Tau-REx I: A next generation retrieval code for exoplanetary atmospheres
- The Heavy Element Masses of Extrasolar Giant Planets, Revealed
- Atmospheric reconnaissance of the habitable-zone Earth-sized planets orbiting TRAPPIST-1
- Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planet Transits
- The Influence of Non-Uniform Cloud Cover on Transit Transmission Spectra
- HAT-P-26b: A Neptune-Mass Exoplanet with a Well Constrained Heavy Element Abundance
- WASP-121 b: a hot Jupiter in a polar orbit and close to tidal disruption
- Hubble Space Telescope Near-IR Transmission Spectroscopy of the Super-Earth HD 97658b
- HELIOS-K: An Ultrafast, Open-source Opacity Calculator for Radiative Transfer
- ExoCross: a general program for generating spectra from molecular line lists
- An HST Optical to Near-IR Transmission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter WASP-19b: Detection of Atmospheric Water and Likely Absence of TiO
- WASP-43b: The closest-orbiting hot Jupiter
- The Complete transmission spectrum of WASP-39b with a precise water constraint
- Seven transiting hot-Jupiters from WASP-South, Euler and TRAPPIST: WASP-47b, WASP-55b, WASP-61b, WASP-62b, WASP-63b, WASP-66b & WASP-67b
- HAT-P-32b and HAT-P-33b: Two Highly Inflated Hot Jupiters Transiting High-Jitter Stars
- An absolute sodium abundance for a cloud-free 'hot Saturn' exoplanet
- Exoplanet Transit Spectroscopy Using WFC3: WASP-12 b, WASP-17 b, and WASP-19 b
- H2O abundances in the atmospheres of three hot Jupiters
- HELIOS-Retrieval: An Open-source, Nested Sampling Atmospheric Retrieval Code, Application to the HR 8799 Exoplanets and Inferred Constraints for Planet Formation
- HAT-P-12b: A Low-Density Sub-Saturn Mass Planet Transiting a Metal-Poor K Dwarf
- Constraining Exoplanet Mass from Transmission Spectroscopy
- Three sub-Jupiter-mass planets: WASP-69b & WASP-84b transit active K dwarfs and WASP-70Ab transits the evolved primary of a G4+K3 binary
- The theory of transmission spectra revisited: a semi-analytical method for interpreting WFC3 data and an unresolved challenge
- HAT-P-26b: A Low-Density Neptune-Mass Planet Transiting a K Star
- Transiting hot Jupiters from WASP-South, Euler and TRAPPIST: WASP-95b to WASP-101b
- HAT-P-39b--HAT-P-41b: Three Highly Inflated Transiting Hot Jupiters
- Three irradiated and bloated hot Jupiters: WASP-76b, WASP-82b & WASP-90b
- WASP-52b, WASP-58b, WASP-59b, and WASP-60b: four new transiting close-in giant planets
- Transits and starspots in the WASP-19 planetary system
- Stellar Diameters and Temperatures VI. High angular resolution measurements of the transiting exoplanet host stars HD 189733 and HD 209458 and implications for models of cool dwarfs
- Vibrational transition moments of CH from first principles
- Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of the Directly Imaged Exoplanet HR 8799b
- WASP-80b has a dayside within the T-dwarf range
- The GJ 436 System: Directly Determined Astrophysical Parameters of an M-Dwarf and Implications for the Transiting Hot Neptune
- A HST/WFC3 Thermal Emission Spectrum of the Hot Jupiter HAT-P-7b
- The Transit Light Curve project. XIV. Confirmation of Anomalous Radii for the Exoplanets TrES-4b, HAT-P-3b, and WASP-12b
- A Cloudiness Index for Transiting Exoplanets Based on the Sodium and Potassium Lines: Tentative Evidence for Hotter Atmospheres Being Less Cloudy at Visible Wavelengths
- Statistical Analysis of Hubble/WFC3 Transit Spectroscopy of Extrasolar Planets
- A Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum for the Warm Saturn HAT-P-12b
- Disentangling degenerate solutions from primary transit and secondary eclipse spectroscopy of exoplanets
- Stellar parameters for TRAPPIST-1
- HAT-P-17b,c: A Transiting, Eccentric, Hot Saturn and a Long-period, Cold Jupiter
- A Characteristic Transmission Spectrum dominated by HO applies to the majority of HST/WFC3 exoplanet observations
- WASP-29b: A Saturn-sized transiting exoplanet
- Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Angle of Exoplanet HAT-P-1b
- Warm Ice Giant GJ 3470b. II Revised Planetary and Stellar Parameters from Optical to Near-infrared Transit Photometry
- The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. III: The retrograde orbit of HAT-P-18b
- Transit confirmation and improved stellar and planet parameters for the super-Earth HD 97658 b and its host star
- GJ 1214b revised. Improved trigonometric parallax, stellar parameters, orbital solution, and bulk properties for the super-Earth GJ 1214b
- High-precision photometry by telescope defocussing. IV. Confirmation of the huge radius of WASP-17b
- HAT-P-38b: A Saturn-Mass Planet Transiting a Late G Star
- WASP-31b: a low-density planet transiting a metal-poor, late-F-type dwarf star
- Possible Bright Starspots on TRAPPIST-1
- Laboratory spectra of hot molecules: data needs for hot super-Earth exoplanets
- An analytical formalism accounting for clouds and other "surfaces" for exoplanet transmission spectroscopy
- Community targets for JWST's early release science program: evaluation of WASP-63b
Cited by in corpus (91)
- petitRADTRANS: a Python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval
- Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRSpec PRISM
- A Sub-Neptune Exoplanet with a Low-Metallicity Methane-Depleted Atmosphere and Mie-Scattering Clouds
- Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRISS
- A spectral survey of an ultra-hot Jupiter: Detection of metals in the transmission spectrum of KELT-9 b
- Retrieving scattering clouds and disequilibrium chemistry in the atmosphere of HR 8799e
- Identification of carbon dioxide in an exoplanet atmosphere
- Tracing the formation history of giant planets in protoplanetary disks with Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen and Sulphur
- A solar C/O and sub-solar metallicity in a hot Jupiter atmosphere
- The ExoMolOP Database: Cross-sections and k-tables for Molecules of Interest in High-Temperature Exoplanet Atmospheres
- Connecting Giant Planet Atmosphere and Interior Modeling: Constraints on Atmospheric Metal Enrichment
- Planetary evolution with atmospheric photoevaporation I. Analytical derivation and numerical study of the evaporation valley and transition from super-Earths to sub-Neptunes
- Forward modelling and retrievals with PLATON, a fast open source tool
- Hot Jupiters: Origins, Structure, Atmospheres
- Aerosols in Exoplanet Atmospheres
- The Precision of Mass Measurements Required for Robust Atmospheric Characterization of Transiting Exoplanets
- Why is it so Cold in Here?: Explaining the Cold Temperatures Retrieved from Transmission Spectra of Exoplanet Atmospheres
- A High Internal Heat Flux and Large Core in a Warm Neptune Exoplanet
- Atmospheric Regimes and Trends on Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
- On degeneracies in retrievals of exoplanetary transmission spectra
- The ARCiS framework for Exoplanet Atmospheres: Modelling Philosophy and Retrieval
- Five key exoplanet questions answered via the analysis of 25 hot Jupiter atmospheres in eclipse
- Helios-r2 -- A new Bayesian, open-source retrieval model for brown dwarfs and exoplanet atmospheres
- A comparison of exoplanet spectroscopic retrieval tools
- Wind of Change: retrieving exoplanet atmospheric winds from high-resolution spectroscopy
- ARES I: WASP-76 b, A Tale of Two HST Spectra
- Unveiling cloudy exoplanets: the influence of cloud model choices on retrieval solutions
- Aurora: A Generalised Retrieval Framework for Exoplanetary Transmission Spectra
- An Ensemble of Bayesian Neural Networks for Exoplanetary Atmospheric Retrieval
- No umbrella needed: Confronting the hypothesis of iron rain on WASP-76b with post-processed general circulation models
- The Pyrat Bay Framework for Exoplanet Atmospheric Modeling: A Population Study of Hubble/WFC3 Transmission Spectra
- High atmospheric metal enrichment for a Saturn-mass planet
- LRG-BEASTS: transmission spectroscopy and retrieval analysis of the highly-inflated Saturn-mass planet WASP-39b
- On The Compatibility of Ground-based and Space-based Data: WASP-96 b, An Example
- The Metal-Rich Atmosphere of the Neptune HAT-P-26b
- The GAPS Programme at TNG XXXVIII. Five molecules in the atmosphere of the warm giant planet WASP-69b detected at high spectral resolution
- Outstanding Challenges of Exoplanet Atmospheric Retrievals
- Interpreting High-Resolution Spectroscopy of Exoplanets Using Cross-Correlations and Supervised Machine Learning
- Implementation of disequilibrium chemistry to spectral retrieval code ARCiS and application to sixteen exoplanet transmission spectra: Indication of disequilibrium chemistry for HD 209458b and WASP-39b
- Alkaline Exospheres of Exoplanet Systems: Evaporative Transmission Spectra
- On the Application of Bayesian Leave-One-Out Cross-Validation to Exoplanet Atmospheric Analysis
- Low albedos of hot to ultra-hot Jupiters in the optical to near-infrared transition regime
- The Impact of Mixing Treatments on Cloud Modelling in 3D Simulations of Hot Jupiters
- Exoplanet atmosphere retrievals in 3D using phase curve data with ARCiS: application to WASP-43b
- ARES IV: Probing the atmospheres of the two warm small planets HD 106315 c and HD 3167 c with the HST/WFC3 camera
- The GAPS Programme at TNG XXXIX -- Multiple molecular species in the atmosphere of the warm giant planet WASP-80 b unveiled at high resolution with GIANO-B
- Cloud Atlas: Hubble Space Telescope Near-Infrared Spectral Library of Brown Dwarfs, Planetary-mass companions, and hot Jupiters
- A Comprehensive Analysis of WASP-17b's Transmission Spectrum from Space-Based Observations
- Aluminium oxide in the atmosphere of hot Jupiter WASP-43b
- The GAPS Programme at TNG. XXXII. The revealing non-detection of metastable HeI in the atmosphere of the hot Jupiter WASP-80b
- An Unusual Transmission Spectrum for the Sub-Saturn KELT-11b Suggestive of a Sub-Solar Water Abundance
- How Much Information Does the Sodium Doublet Encode? Retrieval Analysis of Non-LTE Sodium Lines at Low and High Spectral Resolutions
- Phase curve pollution of exoplanet transmission spectra
- Convolutional neural networks as an alternative to Bayesian retrievals
- HST/STIS transmission spectrum of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b confirms the presence of sodium in its atmosphere
- Information content of JWST-NIRSPEC transmission spectra of warm Neptunes
- Impact of planetary mass uncertainties on exoplanet atmospheric retrievals
- How Does Thermal Scattering Shape the Infrared Spectra of Cloudy Exoplanets? A Theoretical Framework and Consequences for Atmospheric Retrievals in the JWST era
- Probing the atmosphere of WASP-69 b with low- and high-resolution transmission spectroscopy
- A Temperature Trend for Clouds and Hazes in Exoplanets Atmospheres
- The Hubble PanCET Program: A Metal-rich Atmosphere for the Inflated Hot Jupiter HAT-P-41b
- Exoplanetary Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer with Correlated-k I. Benchmarking Transit and Emission Observables
- LRG-BEASTS: Ground-based Detection of Sodium and a Steep Optical Slope in the Atmosphere of the Highly Inflated Hot-Saturn WASP-21b
- Origin and extent of the opacity challenge for atmospheric retrievals of WASP-39 b
- JWST-TST DREAMS: A Precise Water Abundance for Hot Jupiter WASP-17b from the NIRISS SOSS Transmission Spectrum
- Planet Mass and Metallicity: The Exoplanets and Solar System Connection
- Featureless transmission spectra of 12 giant exoplanets observed by GTC/OSIRIS
- JWST Transit Spectra II: Constraining Aerosol Species, Particle-size Distributions, Temperature, and Metallicity for Cloudy Exoplanets
- Evidence for stellar contamination in the transmission spectra of HAT-P-12b
- Modelling the 3D Climate of Venus with OASIS
- How do we optimally sample model grids of exoplanet spectra?
- ESPRESSO reveals blueshifted neutral iron emission lines on the dayside of WASP-76 b
- Detection of faculae in the transit and transmission spectrum of WASP-69b
- Tentative detection of titanium oxide in the atmosphere of WASP-69 b with a 4m ground-based telescope
- Probing the atmosphere of HD189733b with the Na I and K I lines
- LRG-BEASTS: Evidence for clouds in the transmission spectrum of HATS-46 b
- On physical interpretations of the reference transit radius of gas-giant exoplanets
- A Population Analysis of 20 Exoplanets Observed from the Optical to the Near-infrared Wavelengths with HST: Evidence for Widespread Stellar Contamination
- The strange case of Na I in the atmosphere of HD209458 b: Reconciling low- and high-resolution spectroscopic observations G
- ATMOSPHERIX: III- Estimating the C/O ratio and molecular dynamics at the limbs of WASP-76 b with SPIRou
- The curse of clouds
- The effect of spectroscopic binning on atmospheric retrievals
- The role of cloud particle properties on WASP-39b transmission spectrum based on JWST/NIRSpec observations
- Spitzer phase curve observations and circulation models of the inflated ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76b
- Detection of CO, CO, and HO in the atmosphere of the warm sub-Saturn HAT-P-12b
- Transverse Vector Decomposition Method for Analytical Inversion of Exoplanet Transit Spectra
- Atmospheric heat redistribution effect on Emission spectra of Hot-Jupiters
- Reliability of 1D radiative-convective photochemical-equilibrium retrievals on transit spectra of WASP-107b
- Interpreting the atmospheric composition of exoplanets: sensitivity to planet formation assumptions
- A new look into the atmospheric composition of WASP-39 b
- The effect of JWST/NIRSpec data reduction on the retrieval of WASP-39b atmospheric properties