The Formation Mechanism of Gas Giants on Wide Orbits

Abstract

The recent discoveries of massive planets on ultra-wide orbits of HR 8799 (Marois et al. 2008) and Fomalhaut (Kalas et al. 2008) present a new challenge for planet formation theorists. Our goal is to figure out which of three giant planet formation mechanisms--core accretion (with or without migration), scattering from the inner disk, or gravitational instability--could be responsible for Fomalhaut b, HR 8799 b, c and d, and similar planets discovered in the future. This paper presents the results of numerical experiments comparing the long-period planet formation efficiency of each possible mechanism in model A star, G star and M star disks. First, a simple core accretion simulation shows that planet cores forming beyond 35 AU cannot reach critical mass, even under the most favorable conditions one can construct. Second, a set of N-body simulations demonstrates that planet-planet scattering does not create stable, wide-orbit systems such as HR 8799. Finally, a linear stability analysis verifies previous work showing that global spiral instabilities naturally arise in high-mass disks. We conclude that massive gas giants on stable orbits with semimajor axes greater than 35 AU form by gravitational instability in the disk. We recommend that observers examine the planet detection rate as a function of stellar age, controlling for planet dimming with time. If planet detection rate is found to be independent of stellar age, it would confirm our prediction that gravitational instability is the dominant mode of producing detectable planets on wide orbits. We also predict that the occurrence ratio of long-period to short-period gas giants should be highest for M dwarfs due to the inefficiency of core accretion and the expected small fragment mass in their disks.

Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal. 14 pages, including 3 figures and 1 table

References in corpus (38)

• Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799
• Dynamical Outcomes of Planet-Planet Scattering
• Optical Images of an Exosolar Planet 25 Light Years from Earth
• Planet formation around stars of various masses: The snow line and the frequency of giant planets
• Origins of Eccentric Extrasolar Planets: Testing the Planet-Planet Scattering Model
• The Burst Mode of Protostellar Accretion
• The properties of brown dwarfs and low-mass hydrogen-burning stars formed by disc fragmentation
• A Submillimeter View of Circumstellar Dust Disks in $\rho$ Ophiuchus
• A New Planet Around an M Dwarf: Revealing a Correlation Between Exoplanets and Stellar Mass
• The Two Modes of Gas Giant Planet Formation
• The Debris Disk Around HR 8799
• Synthetic Spectra and Colors of Young Giant Planet Atmospheres: Effects of Initial Conditions and Atmospheric Metallicity
• Variations on Debris Disks: Icy Planet Formation at 30-150 AU for 1-3 Solar Mass Main Sequence Stars
• Planets around evolved intermediate-mass stars. I. Two substellar companions in the open clusters NGC 2423 and NGC 4349
• Global Models for the Evolution of Embedded, Accreting Protostellar Disks
• The minimum mass for star formation, and the origin of binary brown dwarfs
• Can giant planets form by gravitational fragmentation of discs?
• Ice Lines, Planetesimal Composition and Solid Surface Density in the Solar Nebula
• Properties of gravitoturbulent accretion disks
• HST/NICMOS detection of HR 8799 b in 1998
• Planet-planet scattering in planetesimal disks
• Silicon and Nickel Enrichment in Planet-Host Stars: Observations and Implications for the Core-Accretion Theory of Planet Formation
• Mean motion resonances from planet-planet scattering
• Core Formation in Giant Gaseous Protoplanets
• Introducing a Hybrid Method of Radiative Transfer for Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
• Testing Disk Instability Models for Giant Planet Formation
• Global magnetohydrodynamical models of turbulence in protoplanetary disks I. A cylindrical potential on a Cartesian grid and transport of solids
• Gravitational Instabilities, Chondrule Formation, and the FU Orionis Phenomenon
• Numerical simulations of type III planetary migration: III. Outward migration of massive planets
• Long period planets from dynamical relaxation
• The Thermal Regulation of Gravitational Instabilities in Protoplanetary Disks. IV. Simulations with Envelope Irradiation
• A possible architecture of the planetary system HR 8799
• `Tail-end' Bondi-Hoyle accretion in young star clusters: Implications for disks, planets, and stars
• 3D Radiative Hydrodynamics for Disk Stability Simulations: A Proposed Testing Standard and New Results
• Solar System Analogs Around IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks
• Saturn Forms by Core Accretion in 3.4 Myr
• The Minimum Jeans Mass, Brown Dwarf Companion IMF, and Predictions for Detection of Y-type Dwarfs
• Discovering the Growth Histories of Exoplanets: The Saturn Analog HD 149026b

Cited by in corpus (142)

• Images of a fourth planet orbiting HR 8799
• Rapid growth of gas-giant cores by pebble accretion
• Resolved Images of Large Cavities in Protoplanetary Transition Disks
• Forming the cores of giant planets from the radial pebble flux in protoplanetary discs
• Separating gas-giant and ice-giant planets by halting pebble accretion
• Spectral and Photometric Diagnostics of Giant Planet Formation Scenarios
• Extrasolar planet population synthesis IV. Correlations with disk metallicity, mass and lifetime
• Clouds and Chemistry in the Atmosphere of Extrasolar Planet HR8799b
• Characterization of exoplanets from their formation I: Models of combined planet formation and evolution
• The Runts of the Litter: Why planets formed through gravitational instability can only be failed binary stars
• KELT-1b: A Strongly Irradiated, Highly Inflated, Short Period, 27 Jupiter-mass Companion Transiting a mid-F Star
• A Combined Subaru/VLT/MMT 1--5 Micron Study of Planets Orbiting HR 8799: Implications for Atmospheric Properties, Masses, and Formation
• Direct Imaging of a Cold Jovian Exoplanet in Orbit around the Sun-like Star GJ 504
• Near-Infrared Spectroscopy of the Extrasolar Planet HR 8799 b
• Transitional Disks as Signposts of Young, Multiplanet Systems
• Discovery of a probable 4-5 Jupiter-mass exoplanet to HD 95086 by direct-imaging
• Planets Around Low-Mass Stars (PALMS). IV. The Outer Architecture of M Dwarf Planetary Systems
• The Gemini NICI Planet-Finding Campaign: The Frequency of Planets around Young Moving Group Stars
• The Great Escape: How Exoplanets and Smaller Bodies Desert Dying Stars
• Possible planet-forming regions on submillimetre images
• Population-Level Eccentricity Distributions of Imaged Exoplanets and Brown Dwarf Companions: Dynamical Evidence for Distinct Formation Channels
• Orbital characterization of the βPictoris b giant planet
• A Statistical Analysis of SEEDS and Other High-Contrast Exoplanet Surveys: Massive Planets or Low-Mass Brown Dwarfs?
• First Light LBT AO Images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.65 and 3.3 Microns: New Discrepancies between Young Planets and Old Brown Dwarfs
• Exoplanet albedo spectra and colors as a function of planet phase, separation, and metallicity
• Directly Imaged L-T Transition Exoplanets in the Mid-Infrared
• Formation of giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits
• Formation of Giant Planets by Disk Instability on Wide Orbits Around Protostars with Varied Masses
• Three Wide Planetary-Mass Companions to FW Tau, ROXs 12, and ROXs 42B
• Global Models of Planet Formation and Evolution
• Planet-Planet Scattering Alone Cannot Explain the Free-Floating Planet Population
• Direct imaging discovery of 12-14 Jupiter mass object orbiting a young binary system of very low-mass stars
• Clouds in the Coldest Brown Dwarfs: FIRE Spectroscopy of Ross 458C
• A survey of young, nearby, and dusty stars to understand the formation of wide-orbit giant planets
• The near-infrared spectral energy distribution of β Pictoris b
• On the origin of planets at very wide orbits from the re-capture of free floating planets
• Planets Around Low-Mass Stars (PALMS). III. A Young Dusty L Dwarf Companion at the Deuterium-Burning Limit
• A Disk Around the Planetary-Mass Companion GSC 06214-00210 b: Clues About the Formation of Gas Giants on Wide Orbits
• Discovery of a Planetary-mass Companion to a Brown Dwarf in Taurus
• Formation and survivability of giant planets on wide orbits
• WISE Y Dwarfs As Probes of the Brown Dwarf-Exoplanet Connection
• On The Possibility of Enrichment and Differentiation in Gas Giants During Birth by Disk Instability
• Synthesizing Exoplanet Demographics: A Single Population of Long-Period Planetary Companions to M Dwarfs Consistent with Microlensing, Radial Velocity, and Direct Imaging Surveys
• Thermal Infrared MMTAO Observations of the HR 8799 Planetary System
• High resolution imaging of young M-type stars of the solar neighborhood: Probing the existence of companions down to the mass of Jupiter
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of Young Planetary-Mass Companions on Wide Orbits
• A Trend Between Cold Debris Disk Temperature and Stellar Type: Implications for the Formation and Evolution of Wide-Orbit Planets
• The First Planets: the Critical Metallicity for Planet Formation
• Exploring the conditions required to form giant planets via gravitational instability in massive protoplanetary discs
• High Contrast Imaging with an Arbitrary Aperture: Active Correction of Aperture Discontinuities
• Migration of Gas Giant Planets in Gravitationally Unstable Disks
• Experimental Design for the Gemini Planet Imager
• Observational Constraints on Companions inside of 10 AU in the HR 8799 Planetary System
• The Heavy Element Composition of Disk Instability Planets Can Range From Sub- to Super-Nebular
• The Habitable-zone Planet Finder Reveals A High Mass and a Low Obliquity for the Young Neptune K2-25b
• Locating the planetesimals belts in the multiple-planet systems HD 128311, HD 202206, HD 82943 and HR 8799
• The SEEDS High Contrast Imaging Survey of Exoplanets around Young Stellar Objects
• Hubble Space Telescope Observations of the HD 202628 Debris Disk
• Architectures of Planetary Systems and Implications for their Formation
• Metallicity of the Massive Protoplanets Around HR 8799 If Formed by Gravitational Instability
• Interactions Between Moderate- and Long-Period Giant Planets: Scattering Experiments for Systems in Isolation and with Stellar Flybys
• High Contrast Imaging of the Close Environment of HD 142527 -
• Discovery of Seven Companions to Intermediate Mass Stars with Extreme Mass Ratios in the Scorpius-Centaurus Association
• The Young Suns Exoplanet Survey: Detection of a wide orbit planetary mass companion to a solar-type Sco-Cen member
• Interaction Cross Sections and Survival Rates for Proposed Solar System Member Planet Nine
• Turbulent Disks are Never Stable: Fragmentation and Turbulence-Promoted Planet Formation
• A Pan-STARRS + UKIDSS Search for Young, Wide Planetary-Mass Companions in Upper Scorpius
• Characterization of the gaseous companion κ Andromedae b: New Keck and LBTI high-contrast observations
• MASSIVE: A Bayesian analysis of giant planet populations around low-mass stars
• Four-of-a-kind? Comprehensive atmospheric characterisation of the HR 8799 planets with VLTI/GRAVITY
• A Spitzer IRS Study of Debris Disks Around Planet-Host Stars
• Estimates of the Planet Yield from Ground-Based High-Contrast Imaging Observations as a Function of Stellar Mass
• MESS (Multi-purpose Exoplanet Simulation System): A Monte Carlo tool for the statistical analysis and prediction of exoplanets search results
• Embedded protostellar disks around (sub-)solar stars. II. Disk masses, sizes, densities, temperatures and the planet formation perspective
• Exoplanets Beyond the Solar Neighbourhood: Galactic Tidal Perturbations
• A Semi-Analytical Description for the Formation and Gravitational Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks
• The fragmentation of protostellar discs: the Hill criterion for spiral arms
• Searching for Scatterers: High-Contrast Imaging of Young Stars Hosting Wide-Separation Planetary-Mass Companions
• Giant Planet Formation by Disk Instability: A Comparison Simulation With An Improved Radiative Scheme
• Resolving structure of the disk around HD100546 at 7 mm with ATCA
• The Diversity of Planetary Systems Architectures: Contrasting Theory with Observations
• Discovery of a directly imaged planet to the young solar analog YSES 2
• The Ultra Cool Brown Dwarf Companion of WD 0806-661: Age, Mass, and Formation Mechanism
• The HARPS search for southern extrasolar planets XXI. Three new giant planets orbiting the metal-poor stars HD5388, HD181720, and HD190984
• The Scattered Disc of HR 8799
• Stability and Occurrence Rate Constraints on the Planetary Sculpting Hypothesis for "Transitional" Disks
• Deep infrared imaging of close companions to austral A- and F-type stars
• Retrieving C and O Abundance of HR 8799 c by Combining High- and Low-Resolution Data
• Metallicity effect and planet mass function in pebble-based planet formation models
• MARVELS-1b: A Short-Period, Brown Dwarf Desert Candidate from the SDSS-III MARVELS Planet Search
• Giant Planet Formation by Disk Instability in Low Mass Disks?
• A Hot Gap Around Jupiter's Orbit in the Solar Nebula
• Planets in the Early Universe
• Rapid Formation of Jupiter and Wide-Orbit Exoplanets in Disks with Pressure Bumps
• Fly-by encounters between two planetary systems II: Exploring the interactions of diverse planetary system architectures
• Chemical fingerprints of hot Jupiter planet formation
• Moderate-Resolution $K$-Band Spectroscopy of Substellar Companion $\kappa$ Andromedae b
• The Orbital Eccentricities of Directly Imaged Companions Using Observable-Based Priors: Implications for Population-level Distributions
• High Contrast Imaging with Spitzer : Constraining the Frequency of Giant Planets out to 1000 AU separations
• Spatially resolved submm imaging of the HR 8799 debris disk
• Chemical analysis of early-type stars with planets
• Dynamics and habitability in circumstellar planetary systems of known binary stars
• Classification of the Circumstellar Disk Evolution During the Main Accretion Phase
• The Properties of Prestellar Discs in Isolated and Multiple Prestellar Systems
• A Rotation Rate for the Planetary-Mass Companion DH Tau b
• Pebble accretion in class 0/I YSOs as a possible pathway for early planet formation
• A companion on the planet/brown dwarf mass boundary on a wide orbit discovered by gravitational microlensing
• Conditions for Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Disks
• The ESO SupJup Survey IV. Unveiling the carbon isotope ratio of GQ Lup B and its host star
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars. XI. Two brown dwarfs in 6:1 mean motion resonance around the K giant star $\nu$ Ophiuchi
• Detection of Low Mass-ratio Stellar Binary Systems
• Diagnosing Circumstellar Debris Disks
• Migration of accreting planets in radiative discs from dynamical torques
• First Comparative Exoplanetology Within a Transiting Multi-planet System: Comparing the atmospheres of V1298 Tau b and c
• Restrictions on the Growth of Gas Giant Cores via Pebble Accretion
• Multiple Populations of Extrasolar Gas Giants
• Gas-Assisted Growth of Protoplanets in a Turbulent Medium
• The formation of giant planets in wide orbits by photoevaporation-synchronised migration
• High signal-to-noise spectral characterization of the planetary-mass object HD 106906 b
• H-alpha Variability in PTFO8-8695 and the Possible Direct Detection of Emission from a 2 Million Year Old Evaporating Hot Jupiter
• The Demographics of Wide-Separation Planets
• Orbital migration of giant planets induced by gravitationally unstable gaps: the effect of planet mass
• The post-main-sequence fate of the HR 8799 planetary system
• Constraints on planet formation via gravitational instability across cosmic time
• On the Origin of Banded Structure in Dusty Protoplanetary Discs: HL Tau and TW Hya
• An imaged 15Mjup companion within a hierarchical quadruple system
• A High-Resolution Spectroscopic Survey of Directly Imaged Companion Hosts: I. Determination of diagnostic stellar abundances for planet formation and composition
• Unveiling wide-orbit companions to K-type stars in Sco-Cen with Gaia EDR3
• Millimeter Dust Emission and Planetary Dynamics in the HD 106906 System
• Constraint on the giant planet production by core accretion
• Direct detection and spectral characterization of outer exoplanets with the SPICA coronagraph instrument (SCI)
• WIde Separation Planets In Time (WISPIT): Two directly imaged exoplanets around the Sun-like stellar binary WISPIT 1
• Gap formation in a self-gravitating disk and the associated migration of the embedded giant planet
• Searching for Wide Companions and Identifying Circum(sub)stellar Disks through PSF-Fitting of Spitzer/IRAC Archival Images
• Accretion of aerodynamically large pebbles
• A High-Resolution Spectroscopic Survey of Directly Imaged Companion Hosts: II. Diversity in C/O Ratios among Host Stars
• How planet-planet scattering can create high-inclination as well as long-period orbits
• The formation of planets by disc fragmentation
• The Outcome of the Protoplanetary Disk of Very Massive Stars
• A planetary-mass candidate imaged in the Young Suns Exoplanet Survey
• A Multi-Planet System's Sole Super-Puff: Exploring Allowable Physical Parameters for the Cold Super-Puff HIP 41378 f
• JWST-TST High Contrast: First Direct Spectroscopy of GJ 504 b reveals Clouds and Possible Metal Enrichment