Four-of-a-kind? Comprehensive atmospheric characterisation of the HR 8799 planets with VLTI/GRAVITY

Abstract

With four companions at separations from 16 to 71 au, HR 8799 is a unique target for direct imaging, presenting an opportunity for the comparative study of exoplanets with a shared formation history. Combining new VLTI/GRAVITY observations obtained within the ExoGRAVITY program with archival data, we perform a systematic atmospheric characterisation of all four planets. We explore different levels of model flexibility to understand the temperature structure, chemistry and clouds of each planet using both petitRADTRANS atmospheric retrievals and fits to self-consistent radiative-convective equilibrium models. Using Bayesian Model Averaging to combine multiple retrievals, we find that the HR 8799 planets are highly enriched in metals, with [M/H] $\gtrsim$1, and have stellar to super-stellar C/O ratios. The C/O ratio increases with increasing separation from $0.55_{-0.10}^{+0.12}$ for d to $0.78_{-0.04}^{+0.03}$ for b, with the exception of the innermost planet which has a C/O ratio of $0.87\pm 0.03$. By retrieving a quench pressure and using a disequilibrium chemistry model we derive vertical mixing strengths compatible with predictions for high-metallicity, self-luminous atmospheres. Bayesian evidence comparisons strongly favour the presence of HCN in HR 8799 c and e, as well as CH${}_4$ in HR 8799 c, with detections at $>5\sigma$ confidence. All of the planets are cloudy, with no evidence for patchiness. The clouds of c, d and e are best fit by silicate clouds lying above a deep iron cloud layer, while the clouds of the cooler HR 8799 b are more likely composed of Na${}_2$S. With well defined atmospheric properties, future exploration of this system is well positioned to unveil further detail in these planets, extending our understanding of the composition, structure, and formation history of these siblings.

arXiv comment45 pages, 25 figures, accepted by Astronomy & Astrophysics

References in corpus (198)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
• Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799
• Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
• X-ray spectral modelling of the AGN obscuring region in the CDFS: Bayesian model selection and catalogue
• Evolutionary models for cool brown dwarfs and extrasolar giant planets. The case of HD 20945
• Evolutionary models for very-low-mass stars and brown dwarfs with dusty atmospheres
• The Limiting Effects of Dust in Brown Dwarf Model Atmospheres
• The effects of snowlines on C/O in planetary atmospheres
• Importance Nested Sampling and the MultiNest Algorithm
• Images of a fourth planet orbiting HR 8799
• Precipitating Condensation Clouds in Substellar Atmospheres
• Detection and Characterization of Exoplanets and Disks using Projections on Karhunen-Loeve Eigenimages
• The Gemini Planet Imager: First Light
• The Evolution of L and T Dwarfs in Color-Magnitude Diagrams
• ExoMol molecular line lists XXX: a complete high-accuracy line list for water
• A Temperature and Abundance Retrieval Method for Exoplanet Atmospheres
• VOSA: Virtual Observatory SED Analyzer. An application to the Collinder 69 open cluster
• First Light for GRAVITY: Phase Referencing Optical Interferometry for the Very Large Telescope Interferometer
• petitRADTRANS: a Python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval
• SPHERE: the exoplanet imager for the Very Large Telescope
• On the radiative equilibrium of irradiated planetary atmospheres
• The Interiors of Giant Planets: Models and Outstanding Questions
• On the Luminosity of Young Jupiters
• Chemical Equilibrium Abundances in Brown Dwarf and Extrasolar Giant Planet Atmospheres
• Contributions to the Nearby Stars (NStars) Project: Spectroscopy of Stars Earlier than M0 within 40 parsecs: The Northern Sample I
• ExoMol: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other atmospheres
• Atmospheric Retrieval for Super-Earths: Uniquely Constraining the Atmospheric Composition with Transmission Spectroscopy
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets
• Detection of Carbon Monoxide and Water Absorption Lines in an Exoplanet Atmosphere
• L and T Dwarf Models and the L to T Transition
• The 0.8-14.5 micron Spectra of Mid-L to Mid-T Dwarfs: Diagnostics of Effective Temperature, Grain Sedimentation, Gas Transport, and Surface Gravity
• Models of the in situ formation of detected extrasolar giant planets
• Clouds and Chemistry in the Atmosphere of Extrasolar Planet HR8799b
• Exoplanetary Atmospheres: Key Insights, Challenges and Prospects
• PynPoint: An Image Processing Package for Finding Exoplanets
• Atmospheric Parameters of Field L and T Dwarfs
• Characterization of exoplanets from their formation I: Models of combined planet formation and evolution
• ExoMol line lists III: An improved hot rotation-vibration line list for HCN and HNC
• How to Distinguish between Cloudy Mini-Neptunes and Water/Volatile-Dominated Super-Earths
• Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRSpec PRISM
• A new set of atmosphere and evolution models for cool T-Y brown dwarfs and giant exoplanets
• A Combined Subaru/VLT/MMT 1--5 Micron Study of Planets Orbiting HR 8799: Implications for Atmospheric Properties, Masses, and Formation
• Chemical consequences of the C/O ratio on hot Jupiters: Examples from WASP-12b,CoRoT-2b, XO-1b, and HD 189733b
• Bayesian model averaging: A systematic review and conceptual classification
• Masses, Radii, and Cloud Properties of the HR 8799 Planets
• ExoMol Molecular linelists -- XXXIII. The spectrum of Titanium Oxide
• The Tucana/Horologium, Columba, AB Doradus, and Argus Associations: New Members and Dusty Debris Disks
• Characterization of Dusty Debris Disks: the IRAS and Hipparcos Catalogs
• Fingering convection and cloudless models for cool brown dwarf atmospheres
• The Debris Disk Around HR 8799
• Gamma Doradus Stars: Defining a New Class of Pulsating Variables
• ExoMol molecular line lists XXXV: a rotation-vibration line list for hot ammonia
• Model atmospheres of irradiated exoplanets: The influence of stellar parameters, metallicity, and the C/O ratio
• ExoMol molecular line lists - XVI: The rotation-vibration spectrum of hot H${}_2$S
• Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph Observations of M, L, and T Dwarfs
• Methane, Carbon Monoxide, and Ammonia in Brown Dwarfs and Self-Luminous Giant Planets
• ExoMol line lists XVIII. The high temperature spectrum of VO
• ExoMol line lists -- XXXIX. Ro-vibrational molecular line list for CO${}_2$
• Retrieving scattering clouds and disequilibrium chemistry in the atmosphere of HR 8799e
• A Patchy Cloud Model for the L to T Dwarf Transition
• Near-Infrared Spectroscopy of the Extrasolar Planet HR 8799 b
• The Formation Mechanism of Gas Giants on Wide Orbits
• Strong Brightness Variations Signal Cloudy-to-Clear Transition of Brown Dwarfs
• Observing transiting planets with JWST -- Prime targets and their synthetic spectral observations
• Cloudless atmospheres for L/T dwarfs and extra-solar giant planets
• Tracing the formation history of giant planets in protoplanetary disks with Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen and Sulphur
• Simultaneous Detection of Water, Methane and Carbon Monoxide in the Atmosphere of Exoplanet HR8799b
• First light of the VLT planet finder SPHERE. III. New spectrophotometry and astrometry of the HR8799 exoplanetary system
• Five carbon- and nitrogen-bearing species in a hot giant planet's atmosphere
• ExoMol line lists VII: The rotation-vibration spectrum of phosphine up to 1500 K
• A self-consistent cloud model for brown dwarfs and young giant exoplanets: comparison with photometric and spectroscopic observations
• The JWST Early Release Science Program for Direct Observations of Exoplanetary Systems II: A 1 to 20 Micron Spectrum of the Planetary-Mass Companion VHS 1256-1257 b
• Molecular abundances and C/O ratios in chemically evolving planet-forming disk midplanes
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets I: Heavy element content and atmospheric C/O
• Model atmospheres for massive gas giants with thick clouds: Application to the HR 8799 planets and predictions for future detections
• Uniform Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of Ultracool Dwarfs I: Characterizing Benchmarks, Gl570D and HD3651B
• A hybrid line list for CH${}_4$ and hot methane continuum
• Detection and Characterization of Exoplanets using Projections on Karhunen-Loeve Eigenimages: Forward Modeling
• The ExoMolOP Database: Cross-sections and k-tables for Molecules of Interest in High-Temperature Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Tau-REx II: Retrieval of emission spectra
• Discovery of Two Nearby, Peculiar L Dwarfs from the 2MASS Proper Motion Survey: Young or Metal-Rich?
• Spectral and atmospheric characterization of 51 Eridani b using VLT/SPHERE
• Atmospheric dynamics of brown dwarfs and directly imaged giant planets
• The Dependence of Brown Dwarf Radii on Atmospheric Metallicity and Clouds: Theory and Comparison with Observations
• HELIOS-Retrieval: An Open-source, Nested Sampling Atmospheric Retrieval Code, Application to the HR 8799 Exoplanets and Inferred Constraints for Planet Formation
• First Light LBT AO Images of HR 8799 bcde at 1.65 and 3.3 Microns: New Discrepancies between Young Planets and Old Brown Dwarfs
• ExoMol line lists II: The ro-vibrational spectrum of SiO
• First light of the VLT planet finder SPHERE. IV. Physical and chemical properties of the planets around HR8799
• Retrieval of atmospheric properties of cloudy L dwarfs
• New study of the line profiles of sodium perturbed by H2
• Directly Imaged L-T Transition Exoplanets in the Mid-Infrared
• ExoMol molecular line lists V: The ro-vibrational spectra of NaCl and KCl
• Peering into the formation history of beta Pictoris b with VLTI/GRAVITY long baseline interferometry
• Dynamical Constraints on the HR 8799 Planets with GPI
• Reconnaissance of the HR 8799 Exosolar System I: Near IR Spectroscopy
• Self-Consistent Model Atmospheres and the Cooling of the Solar System's Giant Planets
• HST/NICMOS detection of HR 8799 b in 1998
• MIRACLES: atmospheric characterization of directly imaged planets and substellar companions at 4-5 $\mu$m. I. Photometric analysis of $\beta$ Pic b, HIP 65426 b, PZ Tel B and HD 206893 B
• Constraining the Nature of the PDS 70 Protoplanets with VLTI/GRAVITY
• M-band Imaging of the HR 8799 Planetary System Using an Innovative LOCI-based Background Subtraction Technique
• Direct exoplanet detection and characterization using the ANDROMEDA method: Performance on VLT/NaCo data
• Spatially resolved spectroscopy of the exoplanet HR 8799 c
• Connecting Giant Planet Atmosphere and Interior Modeling: Constraints on Atmospheric Metal Enrichment
• Direct confirmation of the radial-velocity planet $\beta$ Pic c
• Clouds in the Coldest Brown Dwarfs: FIRE Spectroscopy of Ross 458C
• Characterization of exoplanets from their formation III: The statistics of planetary luminosities
• The 13O-rich atmosphere of a young accreting super-Jupiter
• Modeling the orbital motion of Sgr A*'s near-infrared flares
• Atmospheric Retrieval Analysis of the Directly Imaged Exoplanet HR 8799b
• Interpreting the photometry and spectroscopy of directly imaged planets: a new atmospheric model applied to beta Pictoris b and SPHERE observations
• Resolved Imaging of the HR 8799 Debris Disk with Herschel
• Cloud busting: enstatite and quartz clouds in the atmosphere of 2M2224-0158
• Direct evidence of a sub-stellar companion around CT Cha
• CRIRES spectroscopy and empirical line-by-line identification of FeH molecular absorption in an M dwarf
• Gemini Planet Imager Spectroscopy of the HR 8799 planets c and d
• Helios-r2 -- A new Bayesian, open-source retrieval model for brown dwarfs and exoplanet atmospheres
• The CHARA Array Angular Diameter of HR 8799 Favors Planetary Masses for Its Imaged Companions
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets II: Volatiles and refractories in atmospheres
• Chemical Diversity in Protoplanetary Disks and Its Impact on the Formation History of Giant Planets
• 1D atmospheric study of the temperate sub-Neptune K2-18b
• Keck/NIRC2 $L$'-Band Imaging of Jovian-Mass Accreting Protoplanets around PDS 70
• Toward the analysis of JWST exoplanet spectra: Identifying troublesome model parameters
• Ultracool Dwarfs Observed with the Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph. II. Emergence and Sedimentation of Silicate Clouds in L Dwarfs, and Analysis of the Full M5--T9 Field Dwarf Spectroscopic Sample
• Atmospheric circulation of brown dwarfs and directly imaged exoplanets driven by cloud radiative feedback: effects of rotation
• High-Cadence, High-Contrast Imaging for Exoplanet Mapping: Observations of the HR 8799 Planets with VLT/SPHERE Satellite Spot-Corrected Relative Photometry
• An independent analysis of the brown dwarf atmosphere monitoring (BAM) data: large-amplitude variability is rare outside the L/T transition
• The GJ 504 system revisited. Combining interferometric, radial velocity, and high contrast imaging data
• Radial Velocity Measurements of HR 8799 b and c with Medium Resolution Spectroscopy
• Detection and Bulk Properties of the HR 8799 Planets with High Resolution Spectroscopy
• Spectroscopy across the brown dwarf/planetary mass boundary - I. Near-infrared JHK spectra
• LBT observations of the HR 8799 planetary system: First detection of HR8799e in H band
• Atmospheric circulation of brown dwarfs and directly imaged exoplanets driven by cloud radiative feedback: global and equatorial dynamics
• Age determination of the HR8799 planetary system using asteroseismology
• Deep Thermal Infrared Imaging of HR 8799 bcde: New Atmospheric Constraints and Limits on a Fifth Planet
• PynPoint: a modular pipeline architecture for processing and analysis of high-contrast imaging data
• Thermo-compositional diabatic convection in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs and in Earth's atmosphere and oceans
• The Sonora Substellar Atmosphere Models. II. Cholla: A Grid of Cloud-free, Solar Metallicity Models in Chemical Disequilibrium for the JWST Era
• Did Fomalhaut, HR 8799, and HL Tauri Form Planets via the Gravitational Instability? Placing Limits on the Required Disk Masses
• Patchy Forsterite Clouds in the Atmospheres of Two Highly Variable Exoplanet Analogs
• The Measurement, Treatment, and Impact of Spectral Covariance and Bayesian Priors in Integral-Field Spectroscopy of Exoplanets
• The extremely red L dwarf ULAS J222711$-$004547 - dominated by dust
• GPI spectra of HR 8799 c, d, and e from 1.5 to 2.4$\mu$m with KLIP Forward Modeling
• Metallicity of the Massive Protoplanets Around HR 8799 If Formed by Gravitational Instability
• Deep exploration of the planets HR 8799 b, c, and d with moderate resolution spectroscopy
• Connecting planet formation and astrochemistry: Refractory carbon depletion leading to super-stellar C/O in giant planetary atmospheres
• A medium-resolution spectrum of the exoplanet HIP 65426 b
• The LEECH Exoplanet Imaging Survey. Further constraints on the planet architecture of the HR 8799 system
• On the Composition of Young, Directly Imaged Giant Planets
• Direct Detection and Orbit Analysis of the Exoplanets HR 8799 bcd from Archival 2005 Keck/NIRC2 Data
• The Planetary Accretion Shock: I. Framework for Radiation-hydrodynamical Simulations and First Results
• The Planetary Accretion Shock. II. Grid of Post-Shock Entropies and Radiative Shock Efficiencies for Non-Equilibrium Radiation Transport
• Assessing the C/O Ratio Formation Diagnostic: A Potential Trend with Companion Mass
• Cloudless atmospheres for young low-gravity substellar objects
• A search for a 5th planet around HR 8799 using the star-hopping RDI technique at VLT/SPHERE
• H band Image of a Planetary Companion around HR 8799 in 2002
• Characterization of the gaseous companion κ Andromedae b: New Keck and LBTI high-contrast observations
• Atmospheric retrievals with petitRADTRANS
• Empirically Determining Substellar Cloud Compositions in the era of JWST
• A detailed characterization of HR 8799's debris disk with ALMA in Band 7
• The First Dynamical Mass Measurement in the HR 8799 System
• HN Peg B: A Test of Models of the L to T Dwarf Transition
• Pre-Discovery 2007 Image of the HR 8799 Planetary System
• Peering into the Young Planetary System AB Pic. Atmosphere, Orbit, Obliquity & Second Planetary Candidate
• A deep X-ray view of the bare AGN Ark120. V. Spin determination from disc-Comptonisation efficiency method
• The Scattered Disc of HR 8799
• On the Chemical Abundance of HR 8799 and the Planet c
• Retrieving C and O Abundance of HR 8799 c by Combining High- and Low-Resolution Data
• Orbital and dynamical analysis of the system around HR 8799. New astrometric epochs from VLT/SPHERE and LBT/LUCI
• X-SHYNE: X-shooter spectra of young exoplanet analogs. I. A medium-resolution 0.65-2.5$\mu \mathrm{m}$ one-shot spectrum of VHS\,1256-1257 b
• Resolved Millimeter Observations of the HR 8799 Debris Disk
• Direct emission spectroscopy of exoplanets with the medium resolution imaging spectrometer on board JWST MIRI: I. Molecular mapping and sensitivity to instrumental effects
• A High-Contrast Search for Variability in HR 8799bc with VLT-SPHERE
• Retrieval study of cool, directly imaged exoplanet 51 Eri b
• Ultracool Dwarfs Observed with the Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph -- III. Dust Grains in Young L Dwarf Atmospheres Are Heavier
• Detecting Water In the atmosphere of HR 8799 c with L-band High Dispersion Spectroscopy Aided By Adaptive Optics
• Emission line variability of young 10-30 Mjup companions : I. The case of GQ Lup b and GSC 06214-00210 b
• Revisiting the atmosphere of the exoplanet 51 Eridani b with VLT/SPHERE
• Moderate-Resolution $K$-Band Spectroscopy of Substellar Companion $\kappa$ Andromedae b
• VLT/NACO astrometry of the HR8799 planetary system. L'-band observations of the three outer planets
• Imaging detection of the inner dust belt and the four exoplanets in the HR8799 system with JWST's MIRI coronagraph
• Enriching inner discs and giant planets with heavy elements
• Towards Robust Atmospheric Retrieval on Cloudy L Dwarfs: The Impact of Thermal and Abundance Profile Assumptions
• The planetary system host HR\,8799: On its $\lambda$ Bootis nature
• The orbital architecture and debris disks of the HR 8799 planetary system
• Atmospheric Monitoring and Precise Spectroscopy of the HR 8799 Planets with SCExAO/CHARIS
• Characterizing the Atmospheres of the HR8799 Planets with HST/WFC3
• Oxygen depletion in giant planets with different formation histories
• Deep orbital search for additional planets in the HR 8799 system
• Moderate-Resolution $K$-Band Spectroscopy of the Substellar Companion VHS 1256 b
• In-depth direct imaging and spectroscopic characterization of the young Solar System analog HD 95086
• Ultracool Dwarfs Observed with the Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph. I. An Accurate Look at the L-to-T Transition at $\sim$300 Myr from Optical through Mid-infrared Spectrophotometry
• VLTI/GRAVITY Observations and Characterization of the Brown Dwarf Companion HD 72946 B
• New constraints on the HR 8799 planetary system from mid-infrared direct imaging
• Impacts of high-contrast image processing on atmospheric retrievals
• The dynamical structure of HR 8799's inner debris disk
• The Effect of Metallicity on the Non-Equilibrium Abundance of Hydrogen Dominated Exoplanet Atmosphere
• Applying a temporal systematics model to vector Apodizing Phase Plate coronagraphic data: TRAP4vAPP

Cited by in corpus (22)

• The ESO SupJup Survey III: Confirmation of 13CO in YSES 1 b and Atmospheric Detection of YSES 1 c with CRIRES+
• Silicate clouds and a circumplanetary disk in the YSES-1 exoplanet system
• JWST-TST High Contrast: Living on the Wedge, or, NIRCam Bar Coronagraphy Reveals CO${}_2$ in the HR 8799 and 51 Eri Exoplanets' Atmospheres
• First Comparative Exoplanetology Within a Transiting Multi-planet System: Comparing the atmospheres of V1298 Tau b and c
• Atmospheric characterization of the super-Jupiter HIP 99770 b with KPIC
• The JWST Weather Report: retrieving temperature variations, auroral heating, and static cloud coverage on SIMP-0136
• ExoLyn: a golden mean approach to multi-species cloud modelling in atmospheric retrieval
• Jupiter-like uniform metal enrichment in a system of multiple giant exoplanets
• The compositions of the HR 8799 planets reflect accretion of both solids and metal-enriched gas
• Multi-modal atmospheric characterization of $\beta$ Pictoris b: Adding high-resolution continuum spectra from GRAVITY
• Flow Matching for Atmospheric Retrieval of Exoplanets: Where Reliability meets Adaptive Noise Levels
• Atmospheric abundances and bulk properties of the binary brown dwarf Gliese 229 Bab from JWST/MIRI spectroscopy
• The ExoGRAVITY survey: A K-band spectral library of giant exoplanet and brown dwarf companions
• Osiris revisited: Confirming a solar metallicity and low C/O in HD 209458b
• Distinct Rotational Evolution of Giant Planets and Brown Dwarf Companions
• The planetary-mass-limit VLT/SINFONI library: Spectral extraction and atmospheric characterization via forward modeling
• HD 143811 AB b: A Directly Imaged Planet Orbiting a Spectroscopic Binary in Sco-Cen
• Late gas released in the young Kuiper belt could have significantly contributed to the carbon enrichment of the atmospheres of Neptune and Uranus
• Direct Imaging Discovery of Giant Exoplanet $\beta$ Pictoris d: A Decade-Long Game of Hide-and-Seek
• Direct Images of CO2 Absorption in the Atmosphere of a Super-Jupiter: Enhanced Metallicity Suggestive of Formation in a Disk
• Eighteen Exoplanet Host Stars from the NPOI Data Archive
• JWST-TST High Contrast: First Direct Spectroscopy of GJ 504 b reveals Clouds and Possible Metal Enrichment