Stability and Occurrence Rate Constraints on the Planetary Sculpting Hypothesis for "Transitional" Disks
arXiv:1605.02074 · doi:10.3847/0004-637X/825/1/77
Abstract
Transitional disks, protoplanetary disks with deep and wide central gaps, may be the result of planetary sculpting. By comparing numerical planet-opening-gap models with observed gaps, we find systems of 3-6 giant planets are needed in order to open gaps with the observed depths and widths. We explore the dynamical stability of such multi-planet systems using N-body simulations that incorporate prescriptions for gas effects. We find they can be stable over a typical disk lifetime, with the help of eccentricity damping from the residual gap gas that facilitates planets locking into mean motion resonances. However, in order to account for the occurrence rate of transitional disks, the planet sculpting scenario demands gap-opening-friendly disk conditions, in particular, a disk viscosity . In addition, the demography of giant planets at AU separations, poorly constrained by current data, has to largely follow occurrence rates extrapolated outward from radial velocity surveys, not the lower occurrence rates extrapolated inward from direct imaging surveys. Even with the most optimistic occurrence rates, transitional disks cannot be a common phase that most gas disks experience at the end of their life, as popularly assumed, simply because there are not enough planets to open these gaps. Finally, as consequences of demanding almost all giant planets at large separations participate in transitional disk sculpting, the majority of such planets must form early and end up in a chain of mean motion resonances at the end of disk lifetime.
arXiv commentApJ in press
References in corpus (136)
- Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799
- First Results from High Angular Resolution ALMA Observations Toward the HL Tau Region
- Planet Occurrence within 0.25 AU of Solar-type Stars from Kepler
- Images of a fourth planet orbiting HR 8799
- Dynamical Outcomes of Planet-Planet Scattering
- A giant planet imaged in the disk of the young star Beta Pictoris
- The Keck Planet Search: Detectability and the Minimum Mass and Orbital Period Distribution of Extrasolar Planets
- The Mass Dependence Between Protoplanetary Disks and their Stellar Hosts
- Giant Planet Occurrence in the Stellar Mass-Metallicity Plane
- Dust coagulation in protoplanetary disks: a rapid depletion of small grains
- Resolved Images of Large Cavities in Protoplanetary Transition Disks
- The Occurrence and Mass Distribution of Close-in Super-Earths, Neptunes, and Jupiters
- On the width and shape of gaps in protoplanetary disks
- A Major Asymmetric Dust Trap in a Transition Disk
- Dynamical Origin of Extrasolar Planet Eccentricity Distribution
- Evidence for a developing gap in a 10 Myr old protoplanetary disk
- Discovery and spectroscopy of the young Jovian planet 51 Eri b with the Gemini Planet Imager
- Photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs II: evolutionary models and observable properties
- Observations of IC348: The Disk Population at 2-3 Million Years
- Ring shaped dust accumulation in transition disks
- Can giant planets form by direct gravitational instability?
- The Disk Population of the Taurus Star-Forming Region
- Dust Filtration by Planet-Induced Gap Edges: Implications for Transitional Disks
- Discovery of Small-Scale Spiral Structures in the Disk of SAO 206462 (HD 135344B): Implications for the Physical State of the Disk from Spiral Density Wave Theory
- Observations of gas flows inside a protoplanetary gap
- Rossby Wave Instability of Thin Accretion Disks -- II. Detailed Linear Theory
- On the orbital evolution and growth of protoplanets embedded in a gaseous disc
- Dynamics of the giant planets of the solar system in the gaseous proto-planetary disk and relationship to the current orbital architecture
- Planet Formation by Coagulation: A Focus on Uranus and Neptune
- On the theory of disc photoevaporation
- Planetary Torques as the Viscosity of Protoplanetary Disks
- LkCa 15: A Young Exoplanet Caught at Formation?
- The Runts of the Litter: Why planets formed through gravitational instability can only be failed binary stars
- Mapping the Shores of the Brown Dwarf Desert II: Multiple Star Formation in Taurus-Auriga
- Observational Signatures of Planets in Protoplanetary Disks I: Gaps Opened by Single and Multiple Young Planets in Disks
- Accreting Protoplanets in the LkCa 15 Transition Disk
- Weak Turbulence in the HD 163296 Protoplanetary Disk Revealed by ALMA CO Observations
- On the Diversity of the Taurus Transitional Disks: UX Tau A & Lk Ca 15
- Transitional and Pre-Transitional disks: Gap Opening by Multiple Planets?
- On planet formation in HL Tau
- Direct Imaging of a Cold Jovian Exoplanet in Orbit around the Sun-like Star GJ 504
- Spiral Arms in the Asymmetrically Illuminated Disk of MWC 758 and Constraints on Giant Planets
- Multiple-Planet Scattering and the Origin of Hot Jupiters
- Spectro-astrometric imaging of molecular gas within protoplanetary disk gaps
- Large-Scale Asymmetries in the Transitional Disks of SAO 206462 and SR 21
- Structures in the protoplanetary disk of HD142527 seen in polarized scattered light
- Resolved gas cavities in transitional disks inferred from CO isotopologues with ALMA
- Giant planets orbiting metal-rich stars show signatures of planet-planet interactions
- Observational Signatures of Planets in Protoplanetary Disks II: Spiral Arms Observed in Scattered Light Imaging Can be Induced by Planets
- How Empty are Disk Gaps Opened by Giant Planets?
- Transitional Disks as Signposts of Young, Multiplanet Systems
- Discovery of a probable 4-5 Jupiter-mass exoplanet to HD 95086 by direct-imaging
- Effect of Ambipolar Diffusion on the Non-linear Evolution of Magnetorotational Instability in Weakly Ionized Disks
- A young protoplanet candidate embedded in the circumstellar disk of HD100546
- Retired A Stars and Their Companions. III. Comparing the Mass-Period Distributions of Planets Around A-Type Stars and Sun-Like Stars
- Mass Estimates of a Giant Planet in a Protoplanetary Disk from the Gap Structures
- The Formation Mechanism of Gas Giants on Wide Orbits
- Resonant Repulsion of Kepler Planet Pairs
- Hall-effect Controlled Gas Dynamics in Protoplanetary Disks: II. Full 3D Simulations toward the Outer Disk
- Magnetorotational Instability Driven Accretion in Protoplanetary Disks
- Nonlinear propagation of planet-generated tidal waves
- Post-Oligarchic Evolution of Protoplanetary Embryos and the Stability of Planetary Systems
- A Likely Close-In Low-Mass Stellar Companion to the Transitional Disk Star HD 142527
- Gap Opening by Extremely Low Mass Planets in a Viscous Disk
- Small vs large dust grains in transitional disks: do different cavity sizes indicate a planet?
- The Migration of Gap-Opening Planets is not Locked to Viscous Disk Evolution
- Migration of massive planets in accreting disks
- A Spitzer Census of Transitional Protoplanetary Disks with AU-Scale Inner Holes
- Discovery of a Companion Candidate in the HD169142 Transition Disk and the Possibility of Multiple Planet Formation
- Gas density drops inside dust cavities of transitional disks around young stars observed with ALMA
- On disc driven inward migration of resonantly coupled planets with application to the system around GJ876
- Polarimetric Imaging of Large Cavity Structures in the Pre-transitional Protoplanetary Disk around PDS 70: Observations of the disk
- The TRENDS High-Contrast Imaging Survey. IV. The Occurrence Rate of Giant Planets around M-Dwarfs
- Standing on the shoulders of giants: Trojan Earths and vortex trapping in low mass self-gravitating protoplanetary disks of gas and solids
- Particle Concentration At Planet Induced Gap Edges and Vortices: I. Inviscid 3-D Hydro Disks
- Stability of the directly imaged multiplanet system HR 8799: resonance and masses
- A Statistical Analysis of SEEDS and Other High-Contrast Exoplanet Surveys: Massive Planets or Low-Mass Brown Dwarfs?
- Steady state of dust distributions in disk vortices: Observational predictions and applications to transitional disks
- Local Enhancement of Surface Density in the Protoplanetary Ring Surrounding HD 142527
- An azimuthal asymmetry in the LkHa 330 disk
- Inside-Out Evacuation of Transitional Protoplanetary Disks by the Magneto-Rotational Instability
- Gas structure inside dust cavities of transition disks: Oph IRS 48 observed by ALMA
- Surface Layer Accretion in Conventional and Transitional Disks Driven by Far-Ultraviolet Ionization
- Turbulence In the Outer Regions of Protoplanetary Disks. I. Weak Accretion with No Vertical Magnetic Flux
- A companion candidate in the gap of the T Cha transitional disk
- Discovery of H-alpha Emission from the Close Companion Inside the Gap of Transitional Disk HD142527
- Can grain growth explain transition disks?
- Secular dynamics of the three body problem: application to the upsilon Andromedae planetary system
- Dust Trapping by Vortices in Transitional Disks: Evidence for Non-ideal MHD Effects in Protoplanetary Disks
- The missing cavities in the SEEDS polarized scattered light images of transitional protoplanetary disks: a generic disk model
- Type I Planet Migration in Nearly Laminar Disks
- Modeling Dust Emission of HL Tau Disk Based on Planet-Disk Interactions
- The frequency of snowline-region planets from four-years of OGLE-MOA-Wise second-generation microlensing
- Long range outward migration of giant planets, with application to Fomalhaut b
- Imaging diagnostics for transitional discs
- Subaru Imaging of Asymmetric Features in a Transitional Disk in Upper Scorpius
- Eccentric Jupiters via Disk-Planet Interactions
- The interplay between X-ray photoevaporation and planet formation
- Surface Layer Accretion in Transitional and Conventional Disks: From Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons to Planets
- Density Waves Excited by Low-Mass Planets in Protoplanetary Disks II: High-Resolution Simulations of the Nonlinear Regime
- A limit on eccentricity growth from global 3-D simulations of disc-planet interactions
- CO gas inside the protoplanetary disk cavity in HD 142527: disk structure from ALMA
- Scattered light images of spiral arms in marginally gravitationally unstable discs with an embedded planet
- The Formation of Ice Giants in a Packed Oligarchy: Instability and Aftermath
- The Nature of Transition Circumstellar Disks III. Perseus, Taurus, and Auriga
- Planet gaps in the dust layer of 3D protoplanetary disks: I. Hydrodynamical simulations of T Tauri disks
- Low mass planets in protoplanetary disks with net vertical magnetic fields: the Planetary Wake and Gap Opening
- NIR Spectroscopy of the HAeBe Star HD 100546: III. Further Evidence of an Orbiting Companion?
- Near-Infrared Imaging Polarimetry of HD142527
- The Structure of Pre-transitional Protoplanetary Disks. II. Azimuthal Asymmetries, Different Radial Distributions of Large and Small Dust Grains in PDS~70
- Two populations of transition discs?
- Demographics of Transition Discs in Ophiuchus and Taurus
- Density Waves Excited by Low-Mass Planets in Protoplanetary Disks I: Linear Regime
- Comparison of the dust and gas radial structure in the transition disk [PZ99] J160421.7-213028
- Disc Clearing of Young Stellar Objects: Evidence for Fast Inside-out Dispersal
- The Structure of Pre-transitional Protoplanetary Disks I: Radiative Transfer Modeling of the Disk+Cavity in the PDS 70 system
- Vortex and spiral instabilities at gap edges in three-dimensional self-gravitating disc-satellite simulations
- Dynamical Stability of Imaged Planetary Systems in Formation: Application to HL Tau
- Planet gaps in the dust layer of 3D protoplanetary disks. II. Observability with ALMA
- From mean-motion resonances to scattered planets: Producing the Solar System, eccentric exoplanets and Late Heavy Bombardments
- The Role of Tiny Grains on the Accretion Process in Protoplanetary Disks
- Shallow Cavities in Multiple-Planet Systems
- Constraining the structure of the transition disk HD 135344B (SAO 206462) by simultaneous modeling of multiwavelength gas and dust observations
- An exoplanet in orbit around tau^1 Gruis
- Ruling out Stellar Companions and Resolving the Innermost Regions of Transitional Disks with the Keck Interferometer
- Planet-disk interaction in highly inclined systems
- Fast Modes and Dusty Horseshoes in Transitional Disks
- Type III migration in a low viscosity disc
- Effects of a planetesimal debris disk on stability scenarios for the extrasolar planetary system HR 8799
- Neptune on tiptoes: dynamical histories that preserve the cold classical Kuiper belt
- Vortices as nurseries for planetesimal formation in protoplanetary discs
- Two-Dimensional Study of the Propagation of Planetary Wake and the Indication to Gap Opening in an Inviscid Protoplanetary Disk
- High-Resolution Submillimeter and Near-Infrared Studies of the Transition Disk around Sz 91
- Shedding Light on the Eccentricity Valley: Gap Heating and Eccentricity Excitation of Giant Planets in Protoplanetary Disks
- On the Ages of Planetary Systems with Mean Motion Resonances
- Linear Corotation Torques in Non-Barotropic Disks
Cited by in corpus (33)
- Origins of Hot Jupiters
- Radial migration of gap-opening planets in protoplanetary disks. I. The case of a single planet
- Multiple Disk Gaps and Rings Generated by a Single Super-Earth
- The dispersal of protoplanetary discs I: A new generation of X-ray photoevaporation models
- Dynamical Constraints on the HR 8799 Planets with GPI
- Constraining the Nature of the PDS 70 Protoplanets with VLTI/GRAVITY
- What is the Mass of a Gap-Opening Planet?
- Spiral Arms in Disks: Planets or Gravitational Instability?
- The Sizes and Depletions of the Dust and Gas Cavities in the Transitional Disk J160421.7-213028
- Wind-driven Accretion in Transitional Protostellar Disks
- The unseen planets of double belt debris disk systems
- Save the Planet, Feed the Star: How Super-Earths Survive Migration and Drive Disk Accretion
- Precise transit and radial-velocity characterization of a resonant pair: a warm Jupiter TOI-216c and eccentric warm Neptune TOI-216b
- PDS 70: A transition disk sculpted by a single planet
- Accreting Transition Discs with large cavities created by X-ray photoevaporation in C and O depleted discs
- TOI-216b and TOI-216c: Two warm, large exoplanets in or slightly wide of the 2:1 orbital resonance
- The Orbital Eccentricities of Directly Imaged Companions Using Observable-Based Priors: Implications for Population-level Distributions
- Three Pathways for Observed Resonant Chains
- The 1600 Angstrom Emission Bump in Protoplanetary Disks: A Spectral Signature of HO Dissociation
- Magnetised Winds in Transition Discs I: 2.5D Global Simulations
- The interplay between radiation pressure and the photoelectric instability in optically thin disks of gas and dust
- Chains of Planets in Mean Motion Resonances Arising from Oligarchic Growth
- Confirming the 3:2 Resonance Chain of K2-138
- Radial migration of gap-opening planets in protoplanetary disks. II. The case of a planet pair
- Observational Signatures of Circumbinary Discs I: Kinematics
- Migration jumps of planets in transition disks
- exoMMR: a New Python Package to Confirm and Characterize Mean Motion Resonances
- Nature vs. nurture: a Bayesian framework for assessing apparent correlations between planetary orbital properties and stellar ages
- Observability of Photoevaporation Signatures in the Dust Continuum Emission of Transition Discs
- UV Spectropolarimetry with Polstar: Protoplanetary Disks
- Disentangling Planets from Photoelectric Instability in Gas-Rich Optically Thin Dusty Disks
- Nature vs. Nurture: Investigating the Effects of Measurement Uncertainties in the Assessment of Potential Trends Between Planetary and Stellar Properties
- Longterm Stability of Planetary Systems formed from a Transitional Disk