Materials loss measurements using superconducting microwave resonators
arXiv:2006.04718 · doi:10.1063/5.0017378
Abstract
The performance of superconducting circuits for quantum computing is limited by materials losses. In particular, coherence times are typically bounded by two-level system (TLS) losses at single photon powers and millikelvin temperatures. The identification of low loss fabrication techniques, materials, and thin film dielectrics is critical to achieving scalable architectures for superconducting quantum computing. Superconducting microwave resonators provide a convenient qubit proxy for assessing performance and studying TLS loss and other mechanisms relevant to superconducting circuits such as non-equilibrium quasiparticles and magnetic flux vortices. In this review article, we provide an overview of considerations for designing accurate resonator experiments to characterize loss, including applicable types of loss, cryogenic setup, device design, and methods for extracting material and interface losses, summarizing techniques that have been evolving for over two decades. Results from measurements of a wide variety of materials and processes are also summarized. Lastly, we present recommendations for the reporting of loss data from superconducting microwave resonators to facilitate materials comparisons across the field.
arXiv commentReview Article
References in corpus (101)
- Supplementary information for "Quantum supremacy using a programmable superconducting processor"
- Circuit Quantum Electrodynamics: Coherent Coupling of a Single Photon to a Cooper Pair Box
- Cavity quantum electrodynamics for superconducting electrical circuits: an architecture for quantum computation
- Observation of high coherence in Josephson junction qubits measured in a three-dimensional circuit QED architecture
- Decoherence in Josephson Qubits from Dielectric Loss
- Coherent Josephson qubit suitable for scalable quantum integrated circuits
- Coherent quantum state storage and transfer between two phase qubits via a resonant cavity
- New material platform for superconducting transmon qubits with coherence times exceeding 0.3 milliseconds
- Controlling the spontaneous emission of a superconducting transmon qubit
- Towards understanding two-level-systems in amorphous solids -- Insights from quantum circuits
- Planar Superconducting Resonators with Internal Quality Factors above One Million
- Phase preserving amplification near the quantum limit with a Josephson Ring Modulator
- Engineering cryogenic setups for 100-qubit scale superconducting circuit systems
- A quantum memory with near-millisecond coherence in circuit QED
- Experimental evidence for a surface distribution of two-level systems in superconducting lithographed microwave resonators
- Coplanar Waveguide Resonators for Circuit Quantum Electrodynamics
- A widely tunable parametric amplifier based on a SQUID array resonator
- Surface participation and dielectric loss in superconducting qubits
- Implementing the Quantum von Neumann Architecture with Superconducting Circuits
- Efficient and robust analysis of complex scattering data under noise in microwave resonators
- Measurement of Resonant Frequency and Quality Factor of Microwave Resonators: Comparison of Methods
- 3D integrated superconducting qubits
- An analysis method for asymmetric resonator transmission applied to superconducting devices
- The high-coherence fluxonium qubit
- Microwave Dielectric Loss at Single Photon Energies and milliKelvin Temperatures
- Improved superconducting qubit coherence using titanium nitride
- Relaxation and frequency shifts induced by quasiparticles in superconducting qubits
- Loss and decoherence due to stray infrared light in superconducting quantum circuits
- Reducing intrinsic loss in superconducting resonators by surface treatment and deep etching of silicon substrates
- Measurement and Control of Quasiparticle Dynamics in a Superconducting Qubit
- Impact of ionizing radiation on superconducting qubit coherence
- Hot non-equilibrium quasiparticles in transmon qubits
- Study of loss in superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators
- Reaching 10 ms single photon lifetimes for superconducting aluminum cavities
- Nonreciprocal microwave signal processing with a Field-Programmable Josephson Amplifier
- Protecting superconducting qubits from external sources of loss and heat
- Noise Properties of Superconducting Coplanar Waveguide Microwave Resonators
- Low Loss Superconducting Titanium Nitride Coplanar Waveguide Resonators
- Three-dimensional superconducting resonators at mK with the photon lifetime up to seconds
- Microwave response of vortices in superconducting thin films of Re and Al
- Analysis and mitigation of interface losses in trenched superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators
- Improving the Coherence Time of Superconducting Coplanar Resonators
- Determining interface dielectric losses in superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators
- A semi-empirical model for two-level system noise in superconducting microresonators
- Reducing the impact of radioactivity on quantum circuits in a deep-underground facility
- Evidence of a nonequilibrium distribution of quasiparticles in the microwave response of a superconducting aluminium resonator
- Fabrication and Characterization of Aluminum Airbridges for Superconducting Microwave Circuits
- A superconducting focal plane array for ultraviolet, optical, and near-infrared astrophysics
- Characterization and Reduction of Capacitive Loss Induced by Sub-Micron Josephson Junction Fabrication in Superconducting Qubits
- Characterization and reduction of microfabrication-induced decoherence in superconducting quantum circuits
- Understanding Quality Factor Degradation in Superconducting Niobium Cavities at Low Microwave Field Amplitudes
- Cavity Attenuators for Superconducting Qubits
- Trapping a single vortex and reducing quasiparticles in a superconducting resonator
- Quasiparticle relaxation in optically excited high-Q superconducting resonators
- Microwave attenuators for use with quantum devices below 100 mK
- Suppression of 1/f noise in solid state quantum devices by surface spin desorption
- Atomic layer deposition of titanium nitride for quantum circuits
- Reducing quantum-regime dielectric loss of silicon nitride for superconducting quantum circuits
- Losses in coplanar waveguide resonators at millikelvin temperatures
- Improving the Quality Factor of Microwave Compact Resonators by Optimizing their Geometrical Parameters
- Etch Induced Microwave Losses in Titanium Nitride Superconducting Resonators
- Bulk and surface loss in superconducting transmon qubits
- Wirebond crosstalk and cavity modes in large chip mounts for superconducting qubits
- Low-loss superconducting resonant circuits using vacuum-gap-based microwave components
- Substrate surface engineering for high-quality silicon/aluminum superconducting resonators
- Projected dipole moments of individual two-level defects extracted using circuit quantum electrodynamics
- On the properties of superconducting planar resonators at mK temperatures
- Analysis of high quality superconducting resonators: consequences for TLS properties in amorphous oxides
- Temperature Dependence of the Frequency and Noise of Superconducting Coplanar Waveguide Resonators
- High coherence superconducting microwave cavities with indium bump bonding
- Improving the performance of superconducting microwave resonators in magnetic fields
- The Quantum Socket: Three-Dimensional Wiring for Extensible Quantum Computing
- Loss mechanisms in superconducting thin film microwave resonators
- Reducing microwave loss in superconducting resonators due to trapped vortices
- Mitigation of Cosmic Ray Effect on Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detector Arrays
- Low Loss Multi-Layer Wiring for Superconducting Microwave Devices
- Fluctuations From Edge Defects in Superconducting Resonators
- Dielectric surface loss in superconducting resonators with flux-trapping holes
- Coherence in a transmon qubit with epitaxial tunnel junctions
- Non-equilibrium superconductivity in superconducting resonators
- Noise and loss of superconducting aluminium resonators at single photon energies
- High Coherence Plane Breaking Packaging for Superconducting Qubits
- Geometric Scaling of Two-Level-System Loss in Superconducting Resonators
- Phononic loss in superconducting resonators on piezoelectric substrates
- Strongly quadrature-dependent noise in superconducting micro-resonators measured at the vacuum-noise limit
- Optimization of infrared and magnetic shielding of superconducting TiN and Al coplanar microwave resonators
- Long-lived, radiation-suppressed superconducting quantum bit in a planar geometry
- Slow noise processes in superconducting resonators
- Transmission-line resonators for the study of individual two-level tunneling systems
- Identifying capacitive and inductive loss in lumped element superconducting hybrid titanium nitride/aluminum resonators
- Superconducting TiN Films Sputtered over a Large Range of Substrate DC Bias
- An analysis method for transmission measurements of superconducting resonators with applications to quantum-regime dielectric-loss measurements
- UCSB final report for the CSQ program: Review of decoherence and materials physics for superconducting qubits
- A Josephson junction defect spectrometer for measuring two-level systems
- Dielectric loss extraction for superconducting microwave resonators
- Planar Superconducting Whispering Gallery Mode Resonators
- Characterization of hidden modes in networks of superconducting qubits
- Characterization of low-temperature microwave loss of thin aluminum oxide formed by plasma oxidation
- Microwave Packaging for Superconducting Qubits
- Thin film metrology and microwave loss characterization of indium and aluminum/indium superconducting planar resonators
- Mitigating coherent leakage of superconducting qubits in a large-scale quantum socket
Cited by in corpus (93)
- Circuit Quantum Electrodynamics
- Quantum information processing with bosonic qubits in circuit QED
- Systematic Improvements in Transmon Qubit Coherence Enabled by Niobium Surface Encapsulation
- Disentangling Losses in Tantalum Superconducting Circuits
- 2023 Astrophotonics Roadmap: pathways to realizing multi-functional integrated astrophotonic instruments
- Precision measurement of the microwave dielectric loss of sapphire in the quantum regime with parts-per-billion sensitivity
- High-kinetic inductance NbN films for high-quality compact superconducting resonators
- Probing defect densities at the edges and inside Josephson junctions of superconducting qubits
- Nitrogen Plasma Passivated Niobium Resonators for Superconducting Quantum Circuits
- Superconducting resonators with voltage-controlled frequency and nonlinearity
- A gate tunable transmon qubit in planar Ge
- Towards highly efficient broadband superconducting quantum memory
- Qubit-compatible substrates with superconducting through-silicon vias
- Disentangling the sources of ionizing radiation in superconducting qubits
- The scattering coefficients of superconducting microwave resonators: I. Transfer-matrix approach
- Formation and Microwave Losses of Hydrides in Superconducting Niobium Thin Films Resulting from Fluoride Chemical Processing
- Magnetic field robust high quality factor NbTiN superconducting microwave resonators
- Fabrication and surface treatment of electron-beam evaporated niobium for low-loss coplanar waveguide resonators
- Circle fit optimization for resonator quality factor measurements: point redistribution for maximal accuracy
- Stabilizing and improving qubit coherence by engineering noise spectrum of two-level systems
- Microwave characterization of tantalum superconducting resonators on silicon substrate with niobium buffer layer
- Surface acoustic wave resonators on thin film piezoelectric substrates in the quantum regime
- Low-Loss Superconducting Resonators Fabricated from Tantalum Films Grown at Room Temperature
- Two-Level Systems in Nucleated and Non-Nucleated Epitaxial alpha-Tantalum films
- Cryogenic microwave loss in epitaxial Al/GaAs/Al trilayers for superconducting circuits
- Argon milling induced decoherence mechanisms in superconducting quantum circuits
- Tunable Capacitor For Superconducting Qubits Using an InAs/InGaAs Heterostructure
- Compact superconducting microwave resonators based on Al-AlOx-Al capacitor
- Acceptor-induced bulk dielectric loss in superconducting circuits on silicon
- Perspective: Reproducible Coherence Characterization of Superconducting Quantum Devices
- Modelling dielectric loss in superconducting resonators: Evidence for interacting atomic two-level systems at the Nb/oxide interface
- Characterization of process-related interfacial dielectric loss in aluminum-on-silicon by resonator microwave measurements, materials analysis, and imaging
- Millikelvin measurements of permittivity and loss tangent of lithium niobate
- High-quality superconducting α-Ta film sputtered on heated silicon substrate
- Fluctuation Spectroscopy of Two-Level Systems in Superconducting Resonators
- Revealing the Origin and Nature of the Buried Metal-Substrate Interface Layer in Ta/Sapphire Superconducting Films
- Towards merged-element transmons using silicon fins: the FinMET
- Thermometry Based on a Superconducting Qubit
- Annealing reduces SiN microwave-frequency dielectric loss in superconducting resonators
- Improved Parameter Targeting in 3D-Integrated Superconducting Circuits through a Polymer Spacer Process
- Nonequilibrium quasiparticle distribution in superconducting resonators: effect of pair-breaking photons
- Parametrically-controlled microwave-photonic interface for the fluxonium
- Electronic conduction and superconducting properties of CoSi films on silicon--an unconventional superconductor with technological potential
- 1/f noise in quantum nanoscience
- Observation of discrete charge states of a coherent two-level system in a superconducting qubit
- Improving magnetic-field resilience of NbTiN planar resonators using a hard-mask fabrication technique
- Characterization of the low electric field and zero-temperature two-level-system loss in hydrogenated amorphous silicon
- Loss tangent fluctuations due to two-level systems in superconducting microwave resonators
- Magnetic Field Tolerant Superconducting Spiral Resonators for Circuit QED
- Low-loss Millimeter-wave Resonators with an Improved Coupling Structure
- Ternary Metal Oxide Substrates for Superconducting Circuits
- Polymer-loaded three dimensional microwave cavities for hybrid quantum systems
- Dielectric Loss due to Charged-Defect Acoustic Phonon Emission
- The nontrivial effects of annealing on superconducting properties of Nb single crystals
- Optical Direct Write of Dolan--Niemeyer-Bridge Junctions for Transmon Qubits
- Signatures of a Spin-Active Interface and Locally Enhanced Zeeman field in a Superconductor-Chiral Material Heterostructure
- Compact inductor-capacitor resonators at sub-gigahertz frequencies
- Performance of Superconducting Resonators Suspended on SiN Membranes
- High-impedance surface acoustic wave resonators
- Stable and low loss oxide layer on α-Ta (110) film for superconducting qubits
- Measurable Improvement in Multi-Qubit Readout Using a Kinetic Inductance Traveling Wave Parametric Amplifier
- Quantum defects from single surface exhibit strong mutual interactions
- Low-loss liquid metal interconnects for superconducting quantum circuits
- Characterization of harmonic modes and parasitic resonances in multi-mode superconducting coplanar resonators
- Disentangling superconductor and dielectric microwave losses in sub-micron / interconnects using a multi-mode microstrip resonator
- Identification of soft modes in amorphous AlO via first-principles
- Growth and characterization of single crystal cubic TaN and hexagonal TaN films on c-plane Sapphire
- Niobium Air Bridges as Low-Loss Components for Superconducting Quantum Hardware
- Theory of Two-level Tunneling Systems in Superconductors
- Power and temperature dependent model for High Q superconductors
- Anomalous Loss Reduction Below Two-Level System Saturation in Aluminum Superconducting Resonators
- Low microwave loss in deposited Si and Ge thin-film dielectrics at single-photon power and low temperatures
- Quasiparticle spectroscopy in technologically-relevant niobium using London penetration depth measurements
- Low-loss Nb on Si superconducting resonators from a dual-use spintronics deposition chamber and with acid-free post-processing
- Effective reflection mode measurement for hanger-coupled microwave resonators
- Exploring van der Waals cuprate superconductors using a hybrid microwave circuit
- Epitaxial titanium nitride microwave resonators: Structural, chemical, electrical, and microwave properties
- Superconducting Ring Resonators: Modelling, Simulation, and Experimental Characterisation
- Real-time Monitoring of Neon Film Growth for Electron-on-Neon Qubits
- 1/ f noise and two-level systems in MBE-grown Al thin films
- Hydrogen and Deuterium Tunneling in Niobium
- Effect of substrate miscut angle on critical thickness, structural and electronic properties of MBE-grown NbN films on c-plane sapphire
- Equidistant resonance jumps in superconducting coplanar resonators driven by Abrikosov vortices
- Making high-quality quantum microwave devices with van der Waals superconductors
- Fabrication effects on Niobium oxidation and surface contamination in Niobium-metal bilayers using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
- Broadband and high-precision two-level system loss measurement using superconducting multi-wave resonators
- Determination of the current-phase relation of an InAs 2DEG Josephson junction with a microwave resonator
- Surface Optimization of Superconducting Aluminum Resonators for Robust Quantum Device Fabrication
- Stability of superconducting resonators: motional narrowing and the role of Landau-Zener driving of two-level defects
- Systematic Characterization of Transmon Qubit Stability with Thermal Cycling
- Enhanced Tantalum Superconducting Resonator Performance via All-Surface Organic Monolayer Passivation
- Effects of the thin-film thickness on superconducting NbTi microwave resonators for on-chip cryogenic thermometry
- A graduate laboratory experiment to set up a photon-counting detector using MKIDs