Is the quantum state real? An extended review of $\psi$-ontology theorems

Abstract

Towards the end of 2011, Pusey, Barrett and Rudolph derived a theorem that aimed to show that the quantum state must be ontic (a state of reality) in a broad class of realist approaches to quantum theory. This result attracted a lot of attention and controversy. The aim of this review article is to review the background to the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph Theorem, to provide a clear presentation of the theorem itself, and to review related work that has appeared since the publication of the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph paper. In particular, this review: Explains what it means for the quantum state to be ontic or epistemic (a state of knowledge); Reviews arguments for and against an ontic interpretation of the quantum state as they existed prior to the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph Theorem; Explains why proving the reality of the quantum state is a very strong constraint on realist theories in that it would imply many of the known no-go theorems, such as Bell's Theorem and the need for an exponentially large ontic state space; Provides a comprehensive presentation of the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph Theorem itself, along with subsequent improvements and criticisms of its assumptions; Reviews two other arguments for the reality of the quantum state: the first due to Hardy and the second due to Colbeck and Renner, and explains why their assumptions are less compelling than those of the Pusey--Barrett--Rudolph Theorem; Reviews subsequent work aimed at ruling out stronger notions of what it means for the quantum state to be epistemic and points out open questions in this area. The overall aim is not only to provide the background needed for the novice in this area to understand the current status, but also to discuss often overlooked subtleties that should be of interest to the experts.

88 pages, 15 figures, and a lot of sleepless nights. v2 is the journal version. Reformatted in journal format, references updated, many typo corrections and other minor updates. TeX source had to be modified slightly to compile using the arXiv autocompiler, so I recommend downloading the journal version from http://quanta.ws/ojs/index.php/quanta/article/view/22

References in corpus (80)

• Polynomial-Time Algorithms for Prime Factorization and Discrete Logarithms on a Quantum Computer
• Bell nonlocality
• Relational Quantum Mechanics
• Models of Wave-function Collapse, Underlying Theories, and Experimental Tests
• On the reality of the quantum state
• Quantum Equilibrium and the Origin of Absolute Uncertainty
• Quantum Mechanical Interaction-Free Measurements
• In defense of the epistemic view of quantum states: a toy theory
• Contextuality for preparations, transformations, and unsharp measurements
• A simple test for hidden variables in spin-1 system
• Instantaneous non-local computation of low T-depth quantum circuits
• The Heisenberg Representation of Quantum Computers
• An Introduction to QBism with an Application to the Locality of Quantum Mechanics
• Einstein, incompleteness, and the epistemic view of quantum states
• Bell-Kochen-Specker theorem: A proof with 18 vectors
• Graph-Theoretic Approach to Quantum Correlations
• Is the quantum state real? An extended review of $\psi$-ontology theorems
• Towards a Formulation of Quantum Theory as a Causally Neutral Theory of Bayesian Inference
• Specker's Parable of the Over-protective Seer: A Road to Contextuality, Nonlocality and Complementarity (PLUS AN ERRATUM)
• Is a system's wave function in one-to-one correspondence with its elements of reality?
• No extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power
• QBism, the Perimeter of Quantum Bayesianism
• Are quantum states real?
• Distinct Quantum States Can Be Compatible with a Single State of Reality
• Reconstruction of Gaussian quantum mechanics from Liouville mechanics with an epistemic restriction
• Measurements on the reality of the wavefunction
• No $\psi$-epistemic model can fully explain the indistinguishability of quantum states
• Conditions for compatibility of quantum state assignments
• Implications of the Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph quantum no-go theorem
• Quantum State Separation, Unambiguous Discrimination and Exact Cloning
• Maximally epistemic interpretations of the quantum state and contextuality
• Does Time-Symmetry Imply Retrocausality? How the Quantum World Says "Maybe"
• Quantum Dynamics without the Wave Function
• How ψ-epistemic models fail at explaining the indistinguishability of quantum states
• Conclusive Exclusion of Quantum States
• (Non-)Contextuality of Physical Theories as an Axiom
• Exponential complexity and ontological theories of quantum mechanics
• Can different quantum state vectors correspond to the same physical state? An experimental test
• $\psi$-epistemic models are exponentially bad at explaining the distinguishability of quantum states
• Psi-Epistemic Theories: The Role of Symmetry
• An exercise in "anhomomorphic logic"
• No-go theorems for ψ-epistemic models based on a continuity assumption
• Ontological models and the interpretation of contextuality
• Notes on a Paulian Idea: Foundational, Historical, Anecdotal and Forward-Looking Thoughts on the Quantum
• An experimental test of all theories with predictive power beyond quantum theory
• Communication tasks with infinite quantum-classical separation
• Characteristics of Quantum-Classical Correspondence for Two Interacting Spins
• No-go theorem for the composition of quantum systems
• Epistemic view of quantum states and communication complexity of quantum channels
• The Two-State Vector Formalism of Qauntum Mechanics: an Updated Review
• How statistical are quantum states?
• Quantum-Classical Correspondence for the Equilibrium Distributions of Two Interacting Spins
• State space dimensionality in short memory hidden variable theories
• Bananaworld: Quantum Mechanics for Primates
• Stabilizer notation for Spekkens' toy theory
• Quantum Bayesianism at the Perimeter
• Generalisations of the recent Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph theorem for statistical models of quantum phenomena
• The whole is greater than the sum of the parts: on the possibility of purely statistical interpretations of quantum theory
• Ontological Models for Quantum Mechanics and the Kochen-Specker theorem
• About possible extensions of quantum theory
• Communication cost of classically simulating a quantum channel with subsequent rank-1 projective measurement
• Ontological models, preparation contextuality and nonlocality
• Annotated Interview with a QBist in the Making
• Alternative Experimental Protocol for a PBR-Like Result
• Experimental refutation of a class of ψ-epistemic models
• Quantum Chaos and Quantum-Classical Correspondence
• Necessary and sufficient optimality conditions for classical simulations of quantum communication processes
• Communication Complexity of Channels in General Probabilistic Theories
• Distinguishing initial state-vectors from each other in histories formulations and the PBR argument
• Comment on "Is a system's wave function in one-to-one correspondence with its elements of reality?" [arXiv:1111.6597]
• Detection efficiency loophole in Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph theorem
• Simpler proof of the theorem by Pusey, Barrett, and Rudolph on the reality of the quantum state
• Can quantum mechanics be considered as statistical? an analysis of the PBR theorem
• Epistemic Restrictions in Hilbert Space Quantum Mechanics
• The quantum state should be interpreted statistically
• On the 'Reality' of Observable Properties
• Should the wave-function be a part of the quantum ontological state?
• On the completeness of quantum mechanics and the interpretation of the state vector
• Topologies and Measurable Structures on the Projective Hilbert Space
• Dispelling the Quantum Spooks -- a Clue that Einstein Missed?

Cited by in corpus (160)

• Is the quantum state real? An extended review of $\psi$-ontology theorems
• Rethinking Superdeterminism
• Weak Values are Interference Phenomena
• Measurements on the reality of the wavefunction
• Is a time symmetric interpretation of quantum theory possible without retrocausality?
• Quantum fluctuation theorems, contextuality and work quasi-probabilities
• Certifying quantum signatures in thermodynamics and metrology via contextuality of quantum linear response
• Bell's Theorem and Locally-Mediated Reformulations of Quantum Mechanics
• "Space is blue and birds fly through it"
• A detector-based measurement theory for quantum field theory
• Quantum Theory and Determinism
• Can different quantum state vectors correspond to the same physical state? An experimental test
• Operational interpretation of weight-based resource quantifiers in convex quantum resource theories of states
• Why interference phenomena do not capture the essence of quantum theory
• No Return to Classical Reality
• Contextual advantage for state-dependent cloning
• Properties and Applications of the Kirkwood-Dirac Distribution
• A New Class of Retrocausal Models
• What Quantum Measurements Measure
• The view from a Wigner bubble
• The Entropic Dynamics approach to Quantum Mechanics
• The Meaning of the Wave Function: In Search of the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics
• Causation does not explain contextuality
• Antidistinguishability of Pure Quantum States
• A Quantum Paradox of Choice: More Freedom Makes Summoning a Quantum State Harder
• Quantum epistemology from subquantum ontology: quantum mechanics from theory of classical random fields
• Q-functions as models of physical reality
• Quantum and classical bounds for two-state overlaps
• Could wavefunctions simultaneously represent knowledge and reality?
• Understanding quantum mechanics: a review and synthesis in precise language
• The wavefunction as a true ensemble
• Semi-definite programming and quantum information
• Coherence and contextuality in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer
• Quantum prescriptions are more ontologically distinct than they are operationally distinguishable
• Energy Non-Conservation in Quantum Mechanics
• Reality of the quantum state: Towards a stronger ψ-ontology theorem
• Trading drift and fluctuations in entropic dynamics: quantum dynamics as an emergent universality class
• Entropic Dynamics: Reconstructing Quantum Field Theory in Curved Space-time
• Quantum States as Objective Informational Bridges
• A Stronger Theorem Against Macro-realism
• On the fundamental role of dynamics in quantum physics
• Contextuality and The Single-Qubit Stabilizer Formalism
• Communication of partial ignorance with qubits
• Noncontextuality Inequalities from Antidistinguishability
• Nonlocal quantum information transfer without superluminal signalling and communication
• Simple Communication Complexity Separation from Quantum State Antidistinguishability
• Communication complexity and the reality of the wave-function
• Timelessness strictly inside the Quantum Realm
• A mathematical framework for operational fine tunings
• Ontological models, preparation contextuality and nonlocality
• Constraints on determinism: Bell versus Conway-Kochen
• All is Psi
• Operational foundations of complementarity and uncertainty relations
• Communication tasks in operational theories
• On the optimal error exponents for classical and quantum antidistinguishability
• Lorentz-invariant, retrocausal, and deterministic hidden variables
• A Lenient Causal Arrow of Time?
• Using a resource theoretic perspective to witness and engineer quantum generalized contextuality for prepare-and-measure scenarios
• $\psi$-epistemic interpretations of quantum theory have a measurement problem
• On the reality of the quantum state once again: A no-go theorem for $\psi$-ontic models
• Tight bounds for antidistinguishability and circulant sets of pure quantum states
• Contextuality in composite systems: the role of entanglement in the Kochen-Specker theorem
• A single-world consistent interpretation of quantum mechanics from fundamental time and length uncertainties
• An impossibility theorem for Parameter Independent hidden variable theories
• A $\psi$-Ontology Result without the Cartesian Product Assumption
• How Real are Quantum States in $\psi$-ontic Models?
• Contextuality beyond the Kochen-Specker theorem
• Relational Quantum Mechanics and the PBR Theorem: A Peaceful Coexistence
• Analysis of the superdeterministic Invariant-set theory in a hidden-variable setting
• Stochastic quantum trajectories demonstrate the Quantum Zeno Effect in open spin 1/2, spin 1 and spin 3/2 systems
• How Does Nature Accomplish Spooky Action at a Distance?
• Towards optimal experimental tests on the reality of the quantum state
• How (Not) to Understand Weak Measurements of Velocities
• Corrected Bell and Noncontextuality Inequalities for Realistic Experiments
• Epistemic-Pragmatist Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics: A Comparative Assessment
• Limitations to Genuine Measurements in Ontological Models of Quantum Mechanics
• Feynman-path type simulation using stabilizer projector decomposition of unitaries
• Is the Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics $\psi$-Ontic or $\psi$-Epistemic?
• Quantum guessing games with posterior information
• Why protective measurement does not establish the reality of the quantum state
• An argument for psi-ontology in terms of protective measurements
• Local model of a qubit in the interferometric setup
• Emergent Quantum Mechanics at the Boundary of a Local Classical Lattice Model
• A Review of Unitary Quantum Premeasurement Theory An Algebraic Study of Basic Kinds of Premeasurements
• On the Colbeck-Renner Theorem
• The Operational Choi-Jamiolkowski Isomorphism
• Constraints on Macroscopic Realism Without Assuming Non-Invasive Measurability
• Protective Measurements and the Reality of the Wave Function
• Quantum bit commitment and the reality of the quantum state
• Bell Nonlocality in Classical Systems Coexisting with other System Types
• The Quantum Measurement Problem: A Review of Recent Trends
• Quantum Superpositions Cannot be Epistemic
• The Inferential Design of Entropy and its Application to Quantum Measurements
• The Non-Disjoint Ontic States of the Grassmann Ontological Model, Transformation Contextuality, and the Single Qubit Stabilizer Subtheory
• Ontological models for quantum theory as functors
• Violating the KCBS inequality with a toy mechanism
• Deciphering the Enigma of Wave-Particle Duality
• Undecidability and unpredictability: not limitations, but triumphs of science
• Completely real? A critical note on the claims by Colbeck and Renner
• The operational reality of quantum nonlocality
• The Entropic Dynamics of Spin
• Two definitions of maximally $\psi$-epistemic ontological model and preparation non-contextuality
• A quantum prediction as a collection of epistemically restricted classical predictions
• The operational framework for quantum theories is both epistemologically and ontologically neutral
• The effect of time-dilation on Bell experiments in the retrocausal Brans model
• Physical interpretation of non-normalizable harmonic oscillator states and relaxation to pilot-wave equilibrium
• Linear superposition as a core theorem of quantum empiricism
• Stochastic Mechanics Without Ad Hoc Quantization: Theory And Applications To Semiclassical Gravity
• Not-Post-Peierls compatibility under noisy channels
• The Relational Interpretation of Quantum Physics
• Reciprocal ontological models show indeterminism of the order of quantum theory
• Reality and super-reality: properties of a mathematical multiverse
• Fleeting Critical Review of the Recent Ontic Breakthrough in Quantum Mechanics
• A statistical model for quantum spin and photon number states
• Analysis of single-particle nonlocality through the prism of weak measurements
• Quantum mechanics from an epistemic state space
• Epistemic Boundaries and Quantum Uncertainty: What Local Observers Can (Not) Predict
• Is the Quantum State Real in the Hilbert Space Formulation?
• Information versus Physicality: On the Nature of the Wavefunctions of Quantum Mechanics
• Contextuality Can be Verified with Noncontextual Experiments
• Defending the Quantum Reconstruction Program
• Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders' rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics
• Reality, Causality, and Quantum Theory
• An alternative formalism for modeling spin
• Bell Nonlocality and the Reality of Quantum Wavefunction
• Efficient Computation of Generalized Noncontextual Polytopes and Quantum violation of their Facet Inequalities
• A separable, dynamically local ontological model of quantum mechanics
• Emergence of noncontextuality under quantum Darwinism
• Bohmian mechanics is not deterministic
• Failure of epistemic models to explain the antidistinguishability of quantum mixed preparations
• How contextuality and antidistinguishability are related
• Introducing the Q-based interpretation of quantum theory
• Entropic Dynamics: A hybrid-contextual theory of Quantum Mechanics
• Contextual advantages across two-state discrimination strategies
• From Joint to Single-System Psi-Onticity Without Preparation Independence
• On the Reality of the Wavefunction
• Can the ontology of Bohmian mechanics consists only in particles? The PBR theorem says no
• Decompositional equivalence: A fundamental symmetry underlying quantum theory
• Is single-particle interference spooky?
• An operational notion of classicality based on physical principles
• Spacetime geometry of spin, polarization, and wavefunction collapse
• Contextuality, Witness of Quantum Weirdness
• Partial ignorance communication tasks in quantum theory
• Preparation and Measurement in Quantum Memory Models
• Do psi-ontology theorems prove that the wave function is not epistemic?
• Entropic Dynamics: Mechanics without Mechanism
• Quantum description of reality is epistemically incomplete
• What can we learn from the conformal noninvariance of the Klein-Gordon equation?
• Quantum epistemology and constructivism
• Limits of Absoluteness of Observed Events in Timelike Scenarios: A No-Go Theorem
• Is spacetime quantum?
• On the Classification between $\psi$-Ontic and $\psi$-Epistemic Ontological Models
• Bayesianism, Conditional Probability and Laplace Law of Succession in Quantum Mechanics
• Generalised ontological models based on processes
• $\psi$-Epistemic Models, Einsteinian Intuitions, and No-Gos. A Critical Study of Recent Developments on the Quantum State
• Quantum Computation and Arrows of Time
• Reply to superdeterminists on the hidden-variable formulation of Invariant-set theory
• Towards establishing a connection between two-level quantum systems and physical spaces
• Indeterminate Probabilities and the Weak Quantum Law of Large Numbers
• Does Unitary Measurement Theory Lead to an Everettian Interpretation?