How (Not) to Understand Weak Measurements of Velocities
arXiv:2309.10395 · doi:10.1016/j.shpsa.2020.12.002
Abstract
To-date, the most elaborated attempt to complete quantum mechanics by the addition of hidden variables is the de Broglie-Bohm (pilot wave) theory (dBBT). It endows particles with definite positions at all times. Their evolution is governed by a deterministic dynamics. By construction, however, the individual particle trajectories generically defy detectability in principle. Of late, this lore might seem to have been called into question in light of so-called weak measurements. Due to their characteristic weak coupling between the measurement device and the system under study, they permit the experimental probing of quantum systems without essentially disturbing them. It's natural therefore to think that weak measurements of velocity in particular offer to actually observe the particle trajectories. If true, such a claim would not only experimentally demonstrate the incompleteness of quantum mechanics: it would provide support of dBBT in its standard form, singling it out from an infinitude of empirically equivalent alternative choices for the particle dynamics. Here we examine this possibility. Our result is deflationary: weak velocity measurements constitute no new arguments, let alone empirical evidence, in favour of standard dBBT; One mustn't naïvely identify weak and actual positions. Weak velocity measurements admit of a straightforward standard quantum mechanical interpretation, independent of any commitment to particle trajectories and velocities. This is revealed by a careful reconstruction of the physical arguments on which the description of weak velocity measurements rests. It turns out that for weak velocity measurements to be reliable, one must already presuppose dBBT in its standard form: in this sense, they can provide no new argument, empirical or otherwise, for dBBT and its standard guidance equation.
arXiv commentPublished version; 33 pages, 3 figures, small technical corrections
References in corpus (24)
- Quantum Equilibrium and the Origin of Absolute Uncertainty
- Colloquium: Understanding Quantum Weak Values: Basics and Applications
- Is the quantum state real? An extended review of -ontology theorems
- On the Common Structure of Bohmian Mechanics and the Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber Theory
- Grounding Bohmian Mechanics in Weak Values and Bayesianism
- Conditional probabilities in quantum theory, and the tunneling time controversy
- Bohmian Mechanics Revisited
- Quantum Equilibrium and the Role of Operators as Observables in Quantum Theory
- Weak-Measurement Elements of Reality
- New wine in old bottles: Quantum measurement - direct, indirect, weak - with some applications
- Simple Proof for Global Existence of Bohmian Trajectories
- On the Uniqueness of Quantum Equilibrium in Bohmian Mechanics
- Quantum Mechanics as Classical Physics
- Weak values and quantum properties
- Are All Particles Identical?
- Observables and unobservables in quantum mechanics: How the no-hidden-variables theorems support the Bohmian particle ontology
- On the Weak Measurement of Velocity in Bohmian Mechanics
- Demystifying weak measurements
- Weak Measurement and its Experimental Realisation
- Detectability, Invasiveness and the Quantum Three Box Paradox
- Typicality in the foundations of statistical physics and Born's rule
- Can Bohmian Mechanics Be Made Background Independent?
- Weak Values of Momentum of the Electromagnetic Field: Average Momentum Flow Lines, Not Photon Trajectories
- The PBR theorem seen from the eyes of a Bohmian