In defense of the epistemic view of quantum states: a toy theory

Abstract

We present a toy theory that is based on a simple principle: the number of questions about the physical state of a system that are answered must always be equal to the number that are unanswered in a state of maximal knowledge. A wide variety of quantum phenomena are found to have analogues within this toy theory. Such phenomena include: the noncommutativity of measurements, interference, the multiplicity of convex decompositions of a mixed state, the impossibility of discriminating nonorthogonal states, the impossibility of a universal state inverter, the distinction between bi-partite and tri-partite entanglement, the monogamy of pure entanglement, no cloning, no broadcasting, remote steering, teleportation, dense coding, mutually unbiased bases, and many others. The diversity and quality of these analogies is taken as evidence for the view that quantum states are states of incomplete knowledge rather than states of reality. A consideration of the phenomena that the toy theory fails to reproduce, notably, violations of Bell inequalities and the existence of a Kochen-Specker theorem, provides clues for how to proceed with this research program.

arXiv comment32 pages, REVTEX, based on a talk given at the Rob Clifton Memorial Conference, College Park, May 2003; v2: minor modifications throughout, updated references

References in corpus (26)

• Distributed Entanglement
• Quantum Nonlocality without Entanglement
• Hidden Variables and the Two Theorems of John Bell
• Universal state inversion and concurrence in arbitrary dimensions
• Unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible
• Unextendible Product Bases and Bound Entanglement
• Noncommuting mixed states cannot be broadcast
• Is Quantum Bit Commitment Really Possible?
• Quantum probabilities as Bayesian probabilities
• Quantum Theory From Five Reasonable Axioms
• Unknown Quantum States: The Quantum de Finetti Representation
• Quantum State Discrimination
• Quantum Mechanics as Quantum Information (and only a little more)
• Characterizing quantum theory in terms of information-theoretic constraints
• Violation of Bell's inequality: criterion for quantum communication complexity advantage
• Degrees of concealment and bindingness in quantum bit commitment protocols
• Information Tradeoff Relations for Finite-Strength Quantum Measurements
• A classical analogue of entanglement
• Quantum information: How much information in a state vector?
• Collapse Models
• How much state assignments can differ
• Disentangling Nonlocality and Teleportation
• The quantum bit commitment theorem
• Foundations of quantum theory and quantum information applications
• A note on information theoretic characterizations of physical theories
• Quantum state targeting

Cited by in corpus (374)

• Steering, Entanglement, Nonlocality, and the EPR Paradox
• On the reality of the quantum state
• Quantum Steering
• Entanglement, EPR-correlations, Bell-nonlocality, and Steering
• Probabilistic theories with purification
• Einstein, incompleteness, and the epistemic view of quantum states
• The uncertainty principle determines the non-locality of quantum mechanics
• Quantum-Bayesian Coherence: The No-Nonsense Version
• Is the quantum state real? An extended review of $\psi$-ontology theorems
• Towards a Formulation of Quantum Theory as a Causally Neutral Theory of Bayesian Inference
• Specker's Parable of the Over-protective Seer: A Road to Contextuality, Nonlocality and Complementarity (PLUS AN ERRATUM)
• Is a system's wave function in one-to-one correspondence with its elements of reality?
• Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
• QBism, the Perimeter of Quantum Bayesianism
• Kochen-Specker Contextuality
• The theory of manipulations of pure state asymmetry: basic tools and equivalence classes of states under symmetric operations
• Quantum from principles
• Introduction to the book "Quantum Theory: Informational Foundations and Foils"
• The completeness of quantum theory for predicting measurement outcomes
• Quasi-quantization: classical statistical theories with an epistemic restriction
• Quantum Picturalism
• Verification of quantum computation: An overview of existing approaches
• Are quantum states real?
• Distinct Quantum States Can Be Compatible with a Single State of Reality
• Generalized Probability Theories: What determines the structure of quantum theory?
• Reconstruction of Gaussian quantum mechanics from Liouville mechanics with an epistemic restriction
• Measurements on the reality of the wavefunction
• No $\psi$-epistemic model can fully explain the indistinguishability of quantum states
• Is a time symmetric interpretation of quantum theory possible without retrocausality?
• Contextual advantage for state discrimination
• The ZX-calculus is complete for stabilizer quantum mechanics
• Quantum fluctuation theorems, contextuality and work quasi-probabilities
• Reformulating and Reconstructing Quantum Theory
• Implications of the Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph quantum no-go theorem
• Quantum theory from questions
• Entropy in general physical theories
• Maximally epistemic interpretations of the quantum state and contextuality
• General probabilistic theories: An introduction
• Phase groups and the origin of non-locality for qubits
• Interpretations of quantum theory: A map of madness
• Certifying quantum signatures in thermodynamics and metrology via contextuality of quantum linear response
• Generalized Probabilistic Theories Without the No-Restriction Hypothesis
• Bell's Theorem and Locally-Mediated Reformulations of Quantum Mechanics
• A system's wave function is uniquely determined by its underlying physical state
• Information Invariance and Quantum Probabilities
• Origin of Complex Quantum Amplitudes and Feynman's Rules
• How ψ-epistemic models fail at explaining the indistinguishability of quantum states
• A detector-based measurement theory for quantum field theory
• Quantum Theory and Determinism
• Quantum cryptography: key distribution and beyond
• The Characterization of Noncontextuality in the Framework of Generalized Probabilistic Theories
• Complementarity in classical dynamical systems
• Experimental minimum-error quantum-state discrimination in high dimensions
• Decoherence and its Role in the Modern Measurement Problem
• Entropic Dynamics
• A measure of physical reality
• Why interference phenomena do not capture the essence of quantum theory
• Contextual-value approach to the generalized measurement of observables
• $\psi$-epistemic models are exponentially bad at explaining the distinguishability of quantum states
• No-hypersignaling principle
• No Return to Classical Reality
• Introducing the Qplex: A Novel Arena for Quantum Theory
• Experimentally bounding deviations from quantum theory in the landscape of generalized probabilistic theories
• Toy Models for Retrocausality
• Operational quantum theory without predefined time
• Uniqueness of noncontextual models for stabilizer subtheories
• An Information-Geometric Reconstruction of Quantum Theory, I: The Abstract Quantum Formalism
• Contextual advantage for state-dependent cloning
• Higher-order interference in extensions of quantum theory
• No-go theorems for ψ-epistemic models based on a continuity assumption
• The Quantum Measurement Problem: State of Play
• Law without law: from observer states to physics via algorithmic information theory
• Stable Facts, Relative Facts
• Explaining the unobserved: why quantum mechanics is not only about information
• Mutually unbiased bases, orthogonal Latin squares, and hidden-variable models
• Entanglement is an inevitable feature of any non-classical theory
• From Information Geometry to Quantum Theory
• Entanglement is necessary for emergent classicality in all physical theories
• Toolbox for reconstructing quantum theory from rules on information acquisition
• Quantum States as Ordinary Information
• Nonnegative subtheories and quasiprobability representations of qubits
• Robust preparation noncontextuality inequalities in the simplest scenario
• Almost quantum theory
• Efficient Hidden-Variable Simulation of Measurements in Quantum Experiments
• The original Wigner's friend paradox within a realist toy model
• What Quantum Measurements Measure
• What is nonclassical about uncertainty relations?
• Toy quantum categories
• Deriving Grover's lower bound from simple physical principles
• A channel-based framework for steering, non-locality and beyond
• Thermodynamical cost of some interpretations of quantum theory
• Strong no-go theorem for Gaussian quantum bit commitment
• Quantum mechanics as classical statistical mechanics with an ontic extension and an epistemic restriction
• Bell's Theorem and the Causal Arrow of Time
• The computational landscape of general physical theories
• A simple proof that anomalous weak values require coherence
• Strong Complementarity and Non-locality in Categorical Quantum Mechanics
• On quantum vs. classical probability
• Time-symmetric boundary conditions and quantum foundations
• Projective measurements can probe non-classical work extraction and time-correlations
• Why Should we Interpret Quantum Mechanics?
• The Entropic Dynamics approach to Quantum Mechanics
• Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Steering and Quantum Steering Ellipsoids: Optimal Two-Qubit States and Projective Measurements
• Bridging the gap between general probabilistic theories and the device-independent framework for nonlocality and contextuality
• The Meaning of the Wave Function: In Search of the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics
• Experimental certification of contextuality, coherence and dimension in a programmable universal photonic processor
• Accessible fragments of generalized probabilistic theories, cone equivalence, and applications to witnessing nonclassicality
• Von Neumann Was Not a Quantum Bayesian
• QBism: Quantum Theory as a Hero's Handbook
• Quantum-Bayesian Coherence
• Quantum instruments as a foundation for both states and observables
• Limited preparation contextuality in quantum theory and its relation to the Cirel'son bound
• Contextuality of general probabilistic theories
• What is quantum in quantum randomness?
• Efficient classical simulation of the Deutsch-Jozsa and Simon's algorithms
• Antidistinguishability of Pure Quantum States
• Classical theories with entanglement
• Epistemic view of quantum states and communication complexity of quantum channels
• Contextual Subspace Variational Quantum Eigensolver
• Direct Measurement of the Two-dimensional Spatial Quantum Wavefunction via Strong Measurements
• Further extensions of Clifford circuits and their classical simulation complexities
• Q-functions as models of physical reality
• Supermeasured: Violating Bell-Statistical Independence without violating physical statistical independence
• Quantum cube: A toy model of a qubit
• Logical Pre- and Post-Selection paradoxes, measurement-disturbance and contextuality
• State space dimensionality in short memory hidden variable theories
• Big Toy Models: Representing Physical Systems As Chu Spaces
• Logical pre- and post-selection paradoxes are proofs of contextuality
• Could wavefunctions simultaneously represent knowledge and reality?
• SIC-POVMs and Compatibility among Quantum States
• Memory cost of temporal correlations
• Entropic Dynamics: an Inference Approach to Quantum Theory, Time and Measurement
• A structure theorem for generalized-noncontextual ontological models
• A general framework for phase and interference
• Oracles and query lower bounds in generalised probabilistic theories
• Quantum discord is Bohr's notion of non-mechanical disturbance introduced in his answer to EPR
• Coherence and contextuality in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer
• Stabilizer notation for Spekkens' toy theory
• A toy model for quantum mechanics
• Classicality without local discriminability: decoupling entanglement and complementarity
• Consistency of the Shannon entropy in quantum experiments
• Information-theoretic constraints on correlations with indefinite causal order
• Experimental Demonstration that No Tripartite-Nonlocal Causal Theory Explains Nature's Correlations
• Logical independence and quantum randomness
• Classical Simulation of Noncontextual Pauli Hamiltonians
• Trading drift and fluctuations in entropic dynamics: quantum dynamics as an emergent universality class
• Entropic Dynamics: Reconstructing Quantum Field Theory in Curved Space-time
• Sequences of projective measurements in generalized probabilistic models
• Inequalities witnessing coherence, nonlocality, and contextuality
• Contextuality and The Single-Qubit Stabilizer Formalism
• Probing quantumness with joint continuous measurements of non-commuting qubit observables
• Some Consequences of the Thermodynamic Cost of System Identification
• Noncontextuality Inequalities from Antidistinguishability
• An effect-theoretic reconstruction of quantum theory
• Degradation of a quantum directional reference frame as a random walk
• Conditions for the compatibility of channels in general probabilistic theory and their connection to steering and Bell nonlocality
• Quantum Protocols within Spekkens' Toy Model
• Quantum Simulation Logic, Oracles, and the Quantum Advantage
• State-injection schemes of quantum computation in Spekkens' toy theory
• Computational tameness of classical non-causal models
• Communication complexity and the reality of the wave-function
• Quantifying continuous-variable realism
• A linear program for testing nonclassicality and an open-source implementation
• Interferometric computation beyond quantum theory
• A mathematical framework for operational fine tunings
• Contextual Subspace Variational Quantum Eigensolver Calculation of the Dissociation Curve of Molecular Nitrogen on a Superconducting Quantum Computer
• Ordered linear spaces and categories as frameworks for information-processing characterizations of quantum and classical theory
• Multi-agent paradoxes beyond quantum theory
• Contextuality with vanishing coherence and maximal robustness to dephasing
• All is Psi
• Spekkens' toy model in all dimensions and its relationship with stabilizer quantum mechanics
• A locally deterministic, detector-based model of quantum measurement
• On defining the Hamiltonian beyond quantum theory
• Unit Quaternions and the Bloch Sphere
• Non-locality of non-Abelian anyons
• Information Content of Systems as a Physical Principle
• Counterfactual restrictions and Bell's theorem
• Epistemic Horizons and the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics
• A review and reformulation of macroscopic realism: resolving its deficiencies using the framework of generalized probabilistic theories
• General Probabilistic Theories with a Gleason-type Theorem
• Maximum information gain in weak or continuous measurements of qudits: complementarity is not enough
• Experimental refutation of a class of ψ-epistemic models
• The equivalence of local-realistic and no-signalling theories
• Quantum mechanics is a calculus for estimation under epistemic restriction
• Measurement contextuality is implied by macroscopic realism
• Unitary Partitioning and the Contextual Subspace Variational Quantum Eigensolver
• The principle of information symmetry constrains the state-space in any physical theory
• Epistemically restricted phase space representation, weak momentum value, and reconstruction of quantum wave function
• Advantage of Quantum Theory Over Non-classical Models of Communication
• Depicting qudit quantum mechanics and mutually unbiased qudit theories
• Contextuality, Fine-Tuning, and Teleological Explanation
• Classical systems can be contextual too: Analogue of the Mermin-Peres square
• Which features of quantum physics are not fundamentally quantum but are due to indeterminism?
• A complete graphical calculus for Spekkens' toy bit theory
• Cellular automata in operational probabilistic theories
• $\psi$-epistemic interpretations of quantum theory have a measurement problem
• Observers of quantum systems cannot agree to disagree
• A Graphical Calculus for Lagrangian Relations
• Quantum theory as a critical regime of language dynamics
• Compressing the hidden variable space of a qubit
• A $\psi$-Ontology Result without the Cartesian Product Assumption
• How Real are Quantum States in $\psi$-ontic Models?
• Nonlinear Schrödinger equations and generalized Heisenberg uncertainty principle violating the principle of estimation independence
• Categorical Operational Physics
• Quantum Theory as Symmetry Broken by Vitality
• Probabilistic Theories and Reconstructions of Quantum Theory (Les Houches 2019 lecture notes)
• A single-world consistent interpretation of quantum mechanics from fundamental time and length uncertainties
• Nonzero Classical Discord
• Information-theoretic foundations of thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
• Towards optimal experimental tests on the reality of the quantum state
• Complementarity and Entanglement in Quantum Information Theory
• Exponential communication gap between weak and strong classical simulations of quantum communication
• Measurement incompatibility is strictly stronger than disturbance
• Classical analogue of quantum superdense coding and communication advantage of a single quantum system
• Efficient contextual ontological model of $n$-qubit stabilizer quantum mechanics
• Ideas Abandoned en Route to QBism
• Contextuality in anomalous heat flow
• Pseudo standard entanglement structure cannot be distinguished from standard entanglement structure
• Classical realization of the quantum Deutsch algorithm
• The Wave-Particle Duality in a Quantum Heat Engine
• Compositional resource theories of coherence
• Characterization of measurement uncertainties using the correlations between local outcomes obtained from maximally entangled pairs
• Epistemic-Pragmatist Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics: A Comparative Assessment
• Experimental Tests of Invariant Set Theory
• Efficient classical computation of expectation values in a class of quantum circuits with an epistemically restricted phase space representation
• Information Causality, the Tsirelson Bound, and the 'Being-Thus' of Things
• Epistemic Horizons From Deterministic Laws: Lessons From a Nomic Toy Theory
• From reasonable postulates to generalised Hamiltonian systems
• Data-Driven Inference, Reconstruction, and Observational Completeness of Quantum Devices
• An argument for psi-ontology in terms of protective measurements
• A classical formulation of quantum theory?
• Is the SIC Outcome There When Nobody Looks?
• On Urn Models, Non-commutativity and Operator Normal Forms
• Quantum realism and quantum surrealism
• Fully graphical treatment of the quantum algorithm for the Hidden Subgroup Problem
• Why protective measurement does not establish the reality of the quantum state
• Complete set of circuit equations for Stabilizer Quantum Mechanics
• Process tomography in general physical theories
• Quantum Mechanics Based on an Extended Least Action Principle and Information Metrics of Vacuum Fluctuations
• Quantum Darwinism and the spreading of classical information in non-classical theories
• "Without in Any Way Disturbing the System": Illuminating the Issue of Quantum Nonlocality
• Local model of a qubit in the interferometric setup
• Estimation independence as an axiom for quantum uncertainty
• Distinguishability and copiability of programs in general process theories
• Relating compatibility and divisibility of quantum channels
• Hierarchical axioms for quantum mechanics
• From the problem of Future Contingents to Peres-Mermin square experiments: An introductory review to Contextuality
• Taxonomy for Physics Beyond Quantum Mechanics
• Several foundational and information theoretic implications of Bell's theorem
• Groupoid Semantics for Thermal Computing
• Quantum bit commitment and the reality of the quantum state
• Epistemic Restrictions in Hilbert Space Quantum Mechanics
• Shannon theory beyond quantum: information content of a source
• On the origin of nonclassicality in single systems
• Quantum and classical probability as Bayes-optimal observation
• Quantum Locality, Rings a Bell?: Bell's inequality meets local reality and true determinism
• Robustness of contextuality under different types of noise as quantifiers for parity-oblivious multiplexing tasks
• A no-go theorem for theories that decohere to quantum mechanics
• Violating the KCBS inequality with a toy mechanism
• Extending Quantum Computing through Subspace, Embedding and Classical Molecular Dynamics Techniques
• Quantum Scalar Field Theory Based on the Extended Least Action Principle
• Models of Quantum Algorithms in Sets and Relations
• A classical analog for the electron spin state
• Misreading EPR: Variations on an Incorrect Theme
• Quantum Superpositions Cannot be Epistemic
• Weak versus deterministic macroscopic realism, and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen's elements of reality
• Ontological models for quantum theory as functors
• Computation in a general physical setting
• The Relational Interpretation of Quantum Physics
• `Plausibilities of plausibilities': an approach through circumstances
• Undecidability and unpredictability: not limitations, but triumphs of science
• The operational reality of quantum nonlocality
• A quantum prediction as a collection of epistemically restricted classical predictions
• On the epistemic view of quantum states
• Fleeting Critical Review of the Recent Ontic Breakthrough in Quantum Mechanics
• A consolidating review of Spekkens' toy theory
• Non-locality in theories without the no-restriction hypothesis
• Trichromatic Open Digraphs for Understanding Qubits
• Operationally independent events can influence each other in quantum theory
• Entanglement of quantum fields via classical gravity
• Linear superposition as a core theorem of quantum empiricism
• Is the local linearity of space-time inherited from the linearity of probabilities?
• Generalised Mermin-type non-locality arguments
• Algorithmic idealism: what should you believe to experience next?
• Not-Post-Peierls compatibility under noisy channels
• Algebraical Entropy and Arrow of Time
• An alternative formalism for modeling spin
• Does locality plus perfect correlation imply determinism?
• Bell Nonlocality and the Reality of Quantum Wavefunction
• Bistable Probabilities: A Unified Framework for Studying Rationality and Irrationality in Classical and Quantum Games
• Toys can't play: physical agents in Spekkens' theory
• A statistical model for quantum spin and photon number states
• Efficient Computation of Generalized Noncontextual Polytopes and Quantum violation of their Facet Inequalities
• Quantum mechanics from an epistemic state space
• Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders' rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics
• Deterministic Underlying States are incompatible with a Counterfactual account of Lüders' rule
• Beyond the Projection Postulate and Back: Quantum Theories with Generalised State-Update Rules
• Harvesting Contextuality from the Vacuum
• The Abstract Structure of Quantum Algorithms
• QBism and the Ithaca Desiderata
• Reality, Causality, and Quantum Theory
• An epistemic interpretation and foundation of quantum theory
• Invariant Off-Diagonality: SICs as Equicoherent Quantum States
• Underlying non-Hermitian character of the Born rule in open quantum systems
• Conical Designs and Categorical Jordan Algebraic Post-Quantum Theories
• A Simplified Basis for Bell-Kochen-Specker Theorems
• On the Necessity of Entanglement for the Explanation of Quantum Speedup
• Extremal states for photon number and quadratures as gauges for nonclassicality
• How to spell out the epistemic conception of quantum states
• Quantum models of classical world
• On the Physical Explanation for Quantum Computational Speedup
• Quantum and classical structures in nondeterminstic computation
• Classical correlation alone supplies the anomaly to weak values
• Commentary on Quantum-Inspired Information Retrieval
• Time Symmetric Quantum Theory Without Retrocausality? A Reply to Tim Maudlin
• Spin Theory Based on the Extended Least Action Principle and Information Metrics: Quantization, Entanglement, and Bell Test With Time Delay
• A Theory of Inaccessible Information
• Contextuality, Witness of Quantum Weirdness
• (Modular) Effect Algebras are Equivalent to (Frobenius) Antispecial Algebras
• Decompositional equivalence: A fundamental symmetry underlying quantum theory
• Failure of epistemic models to explain the antidistinguishability of quantum mixed preparations
• Is single-particle interference spooky?
• An operational notion of classicality based on physical principles
• What does it take to solve the measurement problem?
• Introducing the Q-based interpretation of quantum theory
• Demonstration of quantum correlations that are incompatible with absoluteness of measurement
• Combinatorial Algebra for second-quantized Quantum Theory
• A hierarchy in Majorana non-abelian tests and hidden variable models
• Relating toy models of quantum computation: comprehension, complementarity and dagger mix autonomous categories
• Efficient classical simulation of the Deutsch-Jozsa algorithm
• Conspiracy in ontological models with measurement contextuality
• Phase Coordinate Uncomputation in Quantum Recursive Fourier Sampling
• Emergence of Time in a Participatory Universe
• On Relationalist Reconstructions of Quantum Theory
• Spectral Presheaves, Kochen-Specker Contextuality, and Quantale-Valued Relations
• Relationalism vs. Bayesianism
• Quantum correlations and causal structures
• A local-realistic theory for fermions
• Constraints on a Generalization of Geometric Quantum Mechanics from Neutrino and $B^0$-$\overline{B^0}$ Oscillations
• Minimal operational theories: classical theories with quantum features
• String Diagrams for Defect-Based Surface Code Computing
• Quantum theory is not only about information
• Schrödinger's pure-state steering completed
• Uncertainty-Complementarity Balance as a General Constraint on Non-locality
• Intermediate determinism in general probabilistic theories
• Local toy-model theory with ontic correlated states of composite systems
• Probe of Generic Quantum Contextuality and Nonlocal Resources for Qubits
• Contextuality: It's a Feature, not a Bug
• Fully quantum inflation: quantum marginal problem constraints in the service of causal inference
• A Functorial Construction of Quantum Subtheories
• Quantum epistemology and constructivism
• A classical groupoid model for quantum networks
• Is spacetime quantum?
• Generalised ontological models based on processes
• On the significance of Wigner's Friend in contexts beyond quantum foundations
• Uncertainty principle certifies genuine source of intrinsic randomness
• The signaling dimension in generalized probabilistic theories
• Monoidal computer I: Basic computability by string diagrams
• Conjugate Logic
• Incompatible observables in classical physics: A closer look at measurement in Hamiltonian mechanics
• Operational nonlocality
• Which entropy for general physical theories?
• Is Teleportation a (quantum) mystery?
• On Quantum Bayesianism
• In defence of non-ontic accounts of quantum states
• On the Nature of Reality
• Embodied observations from an intrinsic perspective can entail quantum dynamics
• Classical simulation of qubit by a new hardware design and its applications
• The quantum formulation derived from assumptions of epistemic processes
• The Entropic Dynamics of Relativistic Quantum Fields in Curved Space-time
• Schrödinger's equation as a consequence of the central limit theorem without prior assumption of physical laws
• Geometric Quantization and Epistemically Restricted Theories: The Continuous Case
• Limitations imposed by complementarity
• $\psi$-Epistemic Models, Einsteinian Intuitions, and No-Gos. A Critical Study of Recent Developments on the Quantum State