Incompatible observables in classical physics: A closer look at measurement in Hamiltonian mechanics
arXiv:2104.02064 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.110.024124
Abstract
Quantum theory famously entails the existence of incompatible measurements; pairs of observables which cannot be simultaneously measured to arbitrary precision. Incompatibility is widely regarded to be a uniquely quantum phenomenon, linked to failure to commute of quantum operators. Even in the face of deep parallels between quantum commutators and classical Poisson brackets, no connection has been established between the Poisson algebra and any intrinsic limitations to classical measurement. Here I examine measurement in classical Hamiltonian physics as a process involving the joint evolution of an object-system and a finite-temperature measuring apparatus. Instead of the ideal measurement capable of extracting information without disturbing the system, I find a Heisenberg-like precision-disturbance relation: Measuring an observable leaves all Poisson-commuting observables undisturbed but inevitably disturbs all non-Poisson-commuting observables. In this relation the role of h-bar is played by an apparatus-specific quantity, q-bar. While not a universal constant, q-bar takes a finite positive value for any apparatus that can be built. I show that a classical version of Ozawa's model of quantum measurement, originally proposed as a means to violate the Heisenberg relation, does not violate the classical relation. Hence, incompatibility may prove to be a feature not only of quantum, but of classical physics too. This approach points the way to studying the Bayesian epistemology of classical physics, which was until now assumed to be trivial. It now seems possible that it is non-trivial and bears a resemblance to the quantum formalism. These findings may be of interest to researchers working on foundations of quantum mechanics, particularly for psi-epistemic interpretations. And there may be applications in the fields of precision measurement, nanoengineering and molecular machines.
arXiv comment22 pages, 3 figures; substantial improvements after going through peer review: improved notation; added 1 figure, modified 1 figure, removed 1 figure; added treatment of inefficient measurements; added 3 new subsections, removed 1 subsection ("On the foundations of statistical physics"); all main results remain unchanged
References in corpus (32)
- In defense of the epistemic view of quantum states: a toy theory
- A Straightforward Introduction to Continuous Quantum Measurement
- Unknown Quantum States: The Quantum de Finetti Representation
- Second Law of Thermodynamics with Discrete Quantum Feedback Control
- Minimal Energy Cost for Thermodynamic Information Processing: Measurement and Information Erasure
- Universally valid reformulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle on noise and disturbance in measurement
- Einstein, incompleteness, and the epistemic view of quantum states
- Work and information processing in a solvable model of Maxwell's demon
- Soundness and completeness of quantum root-mean-square errors
- Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation in spin-measurements
- Uncertainty Relations for Noise and Disturbance in Generalized Quantum Measurements
- Thermodynamics of a physical model implementing a Maxwell demon
- Quantum Trajectories and Quantum Measurement Theory
- Proof of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation
- Thermodynamics with continuous information flow
- Information processing and the second law of thermodynamics: an inclusive, Hamiltonian approach
- Quantum root-mean-square error and measurement uncertainty relations
- Quantum Continual Measurements and a Posteriori Collapse on CCR
- Quantum from principles
- The completeness of quantum theory for predicting measurement outcomes
- Introduction to the book "Quantum Theory: Informational Foundations and Foils"
- Quasi-quantization: classical statistical theories with an epistemic restriction
- Maxwell's Refrigerator: An Exactly Solvable Model
- Reconstruction of Gaussian quantum mechanics from Liouville mechanics with an epistemic restriction
- An autonomous and reversible Maxwell's demon
- Generalization of the Second Law for a Nonequilibrium Initial State
- Certainty in Heisenberg's uncertainty principle: Revisiting definitions for estimation errors and disturbance
- Position measuring interactions and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle
- On the energetics of information exchange
- A universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation
- An Algebraic Approach to Koopman Classical Mechanics
- Measurement theory in classical mechanics