Certainty in Heisenberg's uncertainty principle: Revisiting definitions for estimation errors and disturbance
arXiv:1308.4853 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.89.022106
Abstract
We revisit the definitions of error and disturbance recently used in error-disturbance inequalities derived by Ozawa and others by expressing them in the reduced system space. The interpretation of the definitions as mean-squared deviations relies on an implicit assumption that is generally incompatible with the Bell-Kochen-Specker-Spekkens contextuality theorems, and which results in averaging the deviations over a non-positive-semidefinite joint quasiprobability distribution. For unbiased measurements, the error admits a concrete interpretation as the dispersion in the estimation of the mean induced by the measurement ambiguity. We demonstrate how to directly measure not only this dispersion but also every observable moment with the same experimental data, and thus demonstrate that perfect distributional estimations can have nonzero error according to this measure. We conclude that the inequalities using these definitions do not capture the spirit of Heisenberg's eponymous inequality, but do indicate a qualitatively different relationship between dispersion and disturbance that is appropriate for ensembles being probed by all outcomes of an apparatus. To reconnect with the discussion of Heisenberg, we suggest alternative definitions of error and disturbance that are intrinsic to a single apparatus outcome. These definitions naturally involve the retrodictive and interdictive states for that outcome, and produce complementarity and error-disturbance inequalities that have the same form as the traditional Heisenberg relation.
arXiv comment15 pages, 8 figures, published version
References in corpus (44)
- Contextuality for preparations, transformations, and unsharp measurements
- Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle
- Universally valid reformulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle on noise and disturbance in measurement
- Quantum weak values
- Nonperturbative theory of weak pre- and post-selected measurements
- Violation of Heisenberg's Measurement-Disturbance Relationship by Weak Measurements
- Direct measurement of general quantum states using weak measurement
- Negativity and contextuality are equivalent notions of nonclassicality
- Violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality with weak measurements of photons
- Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation in spin-measurements
- Uncertainty Relations for Noise and Disturbance in Generalized Quantum Measurements
- Proof of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation
- Quantum Zeno effect by general measurements
- Experimental Violation of Two-Party Leggett-Garg Inequalities with Semi-weak Measurements
- Weak Values, Quantum Trajectories, and the Stony-Brook Cavity QED experiment
- How well can one jointly measure two incompatible observables on a given quantum state?
- Prior information: how to circumvent the standard joint-measurement uncertainty relation
- The significance of the imaginary part of the weak value
- Experimental Test of Error-Disturbance Uncertainty Relations by Weak Measurement
- Contextual Values of Observables in Quantum Measurements
- Uncertainty Relations for Joint Measurements of Noncommuting Observables
- Violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance uncertainty relation in neutron spin measurements
- Violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities in quantum measurements with variable resolution and back-action
- Measuring measurement--disturbance relationships with weak values
- Experimental test of universal complementarity relations
- Uncertainty Relation Revisited from Quantum Estimation Theory
- Bayes' theorem and quantum retrodiction
- Contextual-value approach to the generalized measurement of observables
- Nonclassical Properties of Coherent States
- Weak values are universal in von Neumann measurements
- Universal Uncertainty Principle in the Measurement Operator Formalism
- Quantum theory of preparation and measurement
- Weak measurement of photon polarization by back-action induced path interference
- Deriving tight error-trade-off relations for approximate joint measurements of incompatible quantum observables
- Characterizing Quantum Properties of a Measurement Apparatus: Insights from the Retrodictive Approach
- Perfect correlations between noncommuting observables
- Quantum instruments as a foundation for both states and observables
- Measuring Which-Path Information with Coupled Electronic Mach-Zehnder Interferometers
- Universal joint-measurement uncertainty relation for error bars
- Simultaneous minimum-uncertainty measurement of discrete-valued complementary observables
- Implementing general measurements on linear optical and solid-state qubits
- Uncertainty characteristics of generalized quantum measurements
- Disproving Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation
- Quantum Estimation Theory of Error and Disturbance in Quantum Measurement
Cited by in corpus (44)
- Soundness and completeness of quantum root-mean-square errors
- Quantum root-mean-square error and measurement uncertainty relations
- Dynamics of simultaneously measured non-commuting observables
- Weak Values are Interference Phenomena
- Quantum Theory and Determinism
- Experimental test of Heisenberg's measurement uncertainty relation based on statistical distances
- Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation for Three Canonical Observables
- Tight state-independent uncertainty relations for qubits
- Operational constraints on state-dependent formulations of quantum error-disturbance trade-off relations
- On the Role of Information Theoretic Uncertainty Relations in Quantum Theory
- Classical Field Approach to Quantum Weak Measurements
- Experimental demonstration of separating the waveparticle duality of a single photon with the quantum Cheshire cat
- State-Dependent Approach to Entropic Measurement-Disturbance Relations
- Implications and applications of the variance-based uncertainty equalities
- Steering-enhanced quantum metrology using superpositions of noisy phase shifts
- Error-Disturbance Trade-off in Sequential Quantum Measurements
- Direct evaluation of measurement uncertainties by feedback compensation of decoherence
- Improved Error-Tradeoff and Error-Disturbance Relations
- Observation of non-classical correlations in sequential measurements of photon polarization
- Complementarity Relation for Coherence and Disturbance
- Noise and Disturbance of Qubit Measurements: An Information-Theoretic Characterisation
- Focusing in Arthurs-Kelly-type Joint Measurements with Correlated Probes
- The role of system-meter entanglement in controlling the resolution and decoherence of quantum measurements
- Experimental test of error-tradeoff uncertainty relation using a continuous-variable entangled state
- On the relation between measurement outcomes and physical properties
- Entanglement witness and entropy uncertainty of open Quantum systems under Zeno effect
- Determining complementary properties using weak-measurement: uncertainty, predictability, and disturbance
- Experimental evaluation of non-classical correlations between measurement outcomes and target observable in a quantum measurement
- Dependence of measurement outcomes on the dynamics of quantum coherent interactions between the system and the meter
- Unveiling quantum steering by quantum-classical uncertainty complementarity
- Connection between Measurement Disturbance Relation and Multipartite Quantum Correlation
- From Rényi Entropy Power to Information Scan of Quantum States
- Modelling and Control of Quantum Measurement Induced Backaction in Double Quantum Dots
- Effects of the free evolution in the Arthurs-Kelly model of simultaneous measurement and in the retrodictive predictions of the Heisenberg uncertainty relations
- What does the operator algebra of quantum statistics tell us about the objective causes of observable effects?
- Error-disturbance uncertainty relations in Faraday measurements
- Quantum Uncertainty and Error-Disturbance Tradeoff
- State-Independent Error-Disturbance Tradeoff For Measurement Operators
- Experimental test of error-disturbance uncertainty relation with continuous variables
- Origin of meter fluctuations in weak measurement interactions
- Uncertainty-disturbance relations and applications
- Geometric Formulation of Universally Valid Uncertainty Relation for Error
- Incompatible observables in classical physics: A closer look at measurement in Hamiltonian mechanics
- Linear simultaneous measurements of position and momentum with minimum error-trade-off in each minimum uncertainty state