Multi-agent paradoxes beyond quantum theory
arXiv:1904.06247 · doi:10.1088/1367-2630/ab4fc4
Abstract
Which theories lead to a contradiction between simple reasoning principles and modelling observers' memories as physical systems? Frauchiger and Renner have shown that this is the case for quantum theory, with a thought experiment that leads to a multi-agent paradox. Here we generalize the conditions of the Frauchiger-Renner result so that they can be applied to arbitrary physical theories, and in particular to those expressed as generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs). We then apply them to a particular GPT, box world, and find a deterministic contradiction in the case where agents may share a PR box, which is stronger than the quantum paradox, in that it does not rely on post-selection. Obtaining an inconsistency for the framework of GPTs broadens the landscape of theories which are affected by the application of classical rules of reasoning to physical agents. In addition, we model how observers' memories may evolve in box world, in a way consistent with Barrett's criteria for allowed operations.
arXiv comment22 + 12 pages, mostly figures
References in corpus (11)
- In defense of the epistemic view of quantum states: a toy theory
- Contextuality for preparations, transformations, and unsharp measurements
- How Quantum Mechanics can consistently describe the use of itself
- Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself
- All reversible dynamics in maximally non-local theories are trivial
- Emergence of Quantum Correlations from Non-Locality Swapping
- Contextuality, Cohomology and Paradox
- Inadequacy of Modal Logic in Quantum Settings
- Logical pre- and post-selection paradoxes are proofs of contextuality
- Jamming non-local quantum correlations
- Operational locality in global theories
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Any consistent coupling between classical gravity and quantum matter is fundamentally irreversible
- Testing quantum theory with thought experiments
- Extended Wigner's friend paradoxes do not require nonlocal correlations
- Wigner and friends, a map is not the territory! Contextuality in multi-agent paradoxes
- Classical information and collapse in Wigner's friend setups
- A general quantum circuit framework for Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios: logically and causally consistent reasoning without absolute measurement events
- Toys can't play: physical agents in Spekkens' theory
- A Quantum Gödelian Hunch
- Quantum epistemology and constructivism
- On the significance of Wigner's Friend in contexts beyond quantum foundations