Any consistent coupling between classical gravity and quantum matter is fundamentally irreversible

Abstract

When gravity is sourced by a quantum system, there is tension between its role as the mediator of a fundamental interaction, which is expected to acquire nonclassical features, and its role in determining the properties of spacetime, which is inherently classical. Fundamentally, this tension should result in breaking one of the fundamental principles of quantum theory or general relativity, but it is usually hard to assess which one without resorting to a specific model. Here, we answer this question in a theory-independent way using General Probabilistic Theories (GPTs). We consider the interactions of the gravitational field with a single matter system, and derive a no-go theorem showing that when gravity is classical at least one of the following assumptions needs to be violated: (i) Matter degrees of freedom are described by fully non-classical degrees of freedom; (ii) Interactions between matter degrees of freedom and the gravitational field are reversible; (iii) Matter degrees of freedom back-react on the gravitational field. We argue that this implies that theories of classical gravity and quantum matter must be fundamentally irreversible, as is the case in the recent model of Oppenheim et al. Conversely if we require that the interaction between quantum matter and the gravitational field is reversible, then the gravitational field must be non-classical.

arXiv comment7 pages main text; 22 pages in total (many diagrams)

References in corpus (46)

• No Signalling and Quantum Key Distribution
• A Spin Entanglement Witness for Quantum Gravity
• Reference frames, superselection rules, and quantum information
• Gravitationally-induced entanglement between two massive particles is sufficient evidence of quantum effects in gravity
• Quantum correlations with no causal order
• Quantum computations without definite causal structure
• Probabilistic theories with purification
• How Quantum Mechanics can consistently describe the use of itself
• Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself
• Quantum Superposition of Massive Objects and the Quantization of Gravity
• A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner's friend paradox
• The Schrödinger-Newton equation and its foundations
• On the possibility of laboratory evidence for quantum superposition of geometries
• Locality & Entanglement in Table-Top Testing of the Quantum Nature of Linearized Gravity
• Observable quantum entanglement due to gravity
• Gravitationally Mediated Entanglement: Newtonian Field vs. Gravitons
• Generalized Probability Theories: What determines the structure of quantum theory?
• Linear dynamics of quantum-classical hybrids
• Hybrid classical-quantum dynamics
• Impediments to mixing classical and quantum dynamics
• Royal Road to Coupling Classical and Quantum Dynamics
• Non-Gaussianity as a signature of a quantum theory of gravity
• Coupling Classical and Quantum Variables using Continuous Quantum Measurement Theory
• Using an atom interferometer to infer gravitational entanglement generation
• Probing a Gravitational Cat State
• Witnessing the non-classical nature of gravity in the presence of unknown interactions
• On two recent proposals for witnessing nonclassical gravity
• A no-go theorem on the nature of the gravitational field beyond quantum theory
• Inconsistency of quantum--classical dynamics, and what it implies
• Quantum Superposition of Two Gravitational Cat States
• Information Content of the Gravitational Field of a Quantum Superposition
• Witnessing non-classicality beyond quantum theory
• Black Holes Decohere Quantum Superpositions
• When can gravity path-entangle two spatially superposed masses?
• Gravity entanglement, quantum reference systems, degrees of freedom
• On the Significance of Interferometric Revivals for the Fundamental Description of Gravity
• Reconstructing quantum theory from diagrammatic postulates
• Determinism without causality
• Experimental localisation of quantum entanglement through monitored classical mediator
• Testing the nonclassicality of spacetime: what can we learn from Bell-Bose et al.-Marletto-Vedral experiments?
• Quantum-classical interactions and measurement: a consistent description using statistical ensembles on configuration space
• Leaks: quantum, classical, intermediate, and more
• No-free-information principle in general probabilistic theories
• Two Roads to Classicality
• Multi-agent paradoxes beyond quantum theory
• Information and disturbance in operational probabilistic theories

Cited by in corpus (14)

• The classical-quantum limit
• Imprints of screened dark energy on nonlocal quantum correlations
• Quasinormal Modes and Greybody Factors of Charged Symmergent Black Hole
• Entanglement in Markovian hybrid classical-quantum theories of gravity
• On the quantum mechanics of entropic forces
• Can gravity mediate the transmission of quantum information?
• Restoring the second law to classical-quantum dynamics
• Doubly Quantum Mechanics
• Emergence of phantom cold dark matter from spacetime diffusion
• The thermodynamics of readout devices and semiclassical gravity
• When does entanglement through gravity imply gravitons?
• Diffusion Minimization via Optimal Smearing in Collapse and Hybrid Classical-Quantum Gravitational Models
• LIV-Decoherence on Gravitational Cat States
• Beyond Entanglement: Diagnosing quantum mediator dynamics in gravitationally mediated experiments