Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself

Abstract

Quantum theory provides an extremely accurate description of fundamental processes in physics. It thus seems likely that the theory is applicable beyond the, mostly microscopic, domain in which it has been tested experimentally. Here we propose a Gedankenexperiment to investigate the question whether quantum theory can, in principle, have universal validity. The idea is that, if the answer was yes, it must be possible to employ quantum theory to model complex systems that include agents who are themselves using quantum theory. Analysing the experiment under this presumption, we find that one agent, upon observing a particular measurement outcome, must conclude that another agent has predicted the opposite outcome with certainty. The agents' conclusions, although all derived within quantum theory, are thus inconsistent. This indicates that quantum theory cannot be extrapolated to complex systems, at least not in a straightforward manner.

11 + 8 pages, 4 figures; substantially rewritten, including change of title; close to published version

References in corpus (6)

• A derivation of quantum theory from physical requirements
• No extension of quantum theory can have improved predictive power
• On Spontaneous Wave Function Collapse and Quantum Field Theory
• Contexts, Systems and Modalities: a new ontology for quantum mechanics
• Relative States and the Environment: Einselection, Envariance, Quantum Darwinism, and the Existential Interpretation
• Why Bohmian Mechanics? one and two-time position measurements, Bell inequalities, philosophy and physics

Cited by in corpus (130)

• A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner's friend paradox
• A change of perspective: switching quantum reference frames via a perspective-neutral framework
• Experimental test of local observer-independence
• Respecting One's Fellow: QBism's Analysis of Wigner's Friend
• A quintet of quandaries: five no-go theorems for Relational Quantum Mechanics
• Switching internal times and a new perspective on the 'wave function of the universe'
• On Formalisms and Interpretations
• A no-go theorem for the persistent reality of Wigner's friend's perception
• Entanglement: Quantum or Classical?
• Relational Quantum Mechanics is about Facts, not States: A reply to Pienaar and Brukner
• Quantum reference frames for general symmetry groups
• Quantum Theory and the Limits of Objectivity
• A detector-based measurement theory for quantum field theory
• Indeterminism in Physics and Intuitionistic Mathematics
• Quantum Theory of the Classical: Einselection, Envariance, Quantum Darwinism and Extantons
• QBism and Relational Quantum Mechanics compared
• Stable Facts, Relative Facts
• Bell's Theorem Versus Local Realism in a Quaternionic Model of Physical Space
• Generalized probability rules from a timeless formulation of Wigner's friend scenarios
• The original Wigner's friend paradox within a realist toy model
• Frauchiger-Renner argument and quantum histories
• Life as the Explanation of the Measurement Problem
• Physics and Metaphysics of Wigner's Friends: Even performed pre-measurements have no results
• No-go theorem based on incomplete information of Wigner about his friend
• Inadequacy of Modal Logic in Quantum Settings
• A "thoughtful" Local Friendliness no-go theorem: a prospective experiment with new assumptions to suit
• Scientific Objectivity and its Limits
• Any consistent coupling between classical gravity and quantum matter is fundamentally irreversible
• The wavefunction as a true ensemble
• A possibilistic no-go theorem on the Wigner's friend paradox
• Switching Quantum Reference Frames for Quantum Measurement
• Quantum prescriptions are more ontologically distinct than they are operationally distinguishable
• The Measurement Problem Is a Feature, Not a Bug--Schematising the Observer and the Concept of an Open System on an Informational, or (Neo-)Bohrian, Approach
• Experimental quantum phase discrimination enhanced by controllable indistinguishability-based coherence
• Decoherence framework for Wigner's friend experiments
• Testing quantum theory with thought experiments
• Representations of epistemic uncertainty and awareness in data-driven strategies
• Unitary-Only Quantum Theory Cannot Consistently Describe the Use of Itself: On the Frauchiger-Renner Paradox
• Timelessness strictly inside the Quantum Realm
• Relative Facts of Relational Quantum Mechanics are Incompatible with Quantum Mechanics
• Quantum information in neural systems
• Wigner Friend scenarios with non-invasive weak measurements
• Multi-agent paradoxes beyond quantum theory
• Comment on Healey's "Quantum Theory and the Limits of Objectivity"
• Quantum realism: axiomatization and quantification
• The Montevideo Interpretation: How the inclusion of a Quantum Gravitational Notion of Time Solves the Measurement Problem
• Which features of quantum physics are not fundamentally quantum but are due to indeterminism?
• Quantum mechanics is a calculus for estimation under epistemic restriction
• Characterization of the non-classical relation between measurement outcomes represented by non-orthogonal quantum states
• Quantum information vs.\ epistemic logic: An analysis of the Frauchiger-Renner theorem
• Wigner's friend, Feynman's paths and material records
• Quantum erasing the memory of Wigner's friend
• Watching the Clocks: Interpreting the Page-Wootters Formalism and the Internal Quantum Reference Frame Programme
• A possible solution to the which-way problem of quantum interference
• Observers of quantum systems cannot agree to disagree
• How long does it take to implement a projective measurement?
• Relational Quantum Mechanics and the PBR Theorem: A Peaceful Coexistence
• Universal structure of objective states in all fundamental causal theories
• Quantum fluctuations, particles and entanglement: a discussion towards the solution of the quantum measurement problems
• Quantum measurements with, and yet without an Observer
• A single-world consistent interpretation of quantum mechanics from fundamental time and length uncertainties
• Towards a Quantum-Like Cognitive Architecture for Decision-Making
• Quantum mechanical rules for observed observers and the consistency of quantum theory
• Relational Quantum Mechanics, Quantum Relativism, and the Iteration of Relativity
• Dependence of measurement outcomes on the dynamics of quantum coherent interactions between the system and the meter
• Relativistic Quantum Theory
• Standard Quantum Mechanics without observers
• Epistemic-Pragmatist Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics: A Comparative Assessment
• A Physics Lab Inside Your Head: Quantum Thought Experiments as an Educational Tool
• Uncertainty limits of the information exchange between a quantum system and an external meter
• Quantitative relations between different measurement contexts
• Relational Quantum Mechanics and Contextuality
• Epistemic Horizons From Deterministic Laws: Lessons From a Nomic Toy Theory
• No relation for Wigner's friend
• Physics is organized around transformations connecting contextures in a polycontextural world
• Quantum and Classical Bayesian Agents
• The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are not redundant
• Relating Wigner's Friend Scenarios to Nonclassical Causal Compatibility, Monogamy Relations, and Fine Tuning
• Extended Wigner's friend problem and the internal consistency of standard quantum mechanics
• The Point of Primitive Ontology
• Quasiprobability distributions with weak measurements
• Wigner's friend's memory and the no-signaling principle
• Phenomenology of Holography via Quantum Coherence on Causal Horizons
• Law of Total Probability in Quantum Theory and Its Application in Wigner's Friend Scenario
• Double-trace deformation in Keldysh field theory
• Wigner's friend and the quasi-ideal clock
• Wigner and friends, a map is not the territory! Contextuality in multi-agent paradoxes
• A general quantum circuit framework for Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios: logically and causally consistent reasoning without absolute measurement events
• Unitary Interactions Do Not Yield Outcomes: Attempting to Model "Wigner's Friend"
• Algorithmic idealism: what should you believe to experience next?
• Classical information and collapse in Wigner's friend setups
• Relating complexities for the reflexive study of complex systems
• Extended Wigner's friend paradoxes do not require nonlocal correlations
• Wave-particle duality and the objectiveness of "true" and "false"
• Spacetime Paths as a Whole
• Implications of Local Friendliness violation for quantum causality
• A scalable tripartite Wigner's friend scenario
• Toys can't play: physical agents in Spekkens' theory
• The Relational Dissolution of the Quantum Measurement Problems
• Quantum contextuality of complementary photon polarizations explored by adaptive input state control
• Epistemic Boundaries and Quantum Uncertainty: What Local Observers Can (Not) Predict
• Wigner's friend scenarios: on what to condition and how to verify the predictions
• Connecting extended Wigner's friend arguments and noncontextuality
• Statistical signatures of quantum contextuality
• Wigner's friends, tunnelling times and Feynman's "only mystery of quantum mechanics"
• Demonstration of quantum correlations that are incompatible with absoluteness of measurement
• Histories without collapse
• What does it take to solve the measurement problem?
• Copenhagen interpretation can survive the upgraded Schroedinger's cat Gedankenexperiment
• The metaphysics of decoherence
• Unitary evolution and elements of reality in consecutive quantum measurements
• How the Natural Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Avoids the Recent No-go Theorem
• Quantum theories with local information flow
• Introducing the Q-based interpretation of quantum theory
• Relativity and Quantum Theory: Under the Spell of Today's Paradigms
• Experimental evidence for the physical delocalization of individual photons in an interferometer
• Multi-stage Stern-Gerlach experiment modeled (with additional appendices)
• A Quantum Gödelian Hunch
• Limits of Absoluteness of Observed Events in Timelike Scenarios: A No-Go Theorem
• The Informational Observer in Relational Quantum Mechanics
• The paradox of classical reasoning
• Quantum Superpositions of Conscious States in a Minimal Integrated Information Model
• Events in quantum mechanics are maximally non-absolute
• On the significance of Wigner's Friend in contexts beyond quantum foundations
• Relative descriptors for quantum agents
• Does Quantum Information Require Additional Structure?
• Towards violations of Local Friendliness with quantum computers
• Phenomenological quantum mechanics: I. Phenomenology of quantum observables
• Mind before matter: reversing the arrow of fundamentality
• Quantum epistemology and constructivism