The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are not redundant
arXiv:2307.06191 · doi:10.22331/q-2025-05-20-1749
Abstract
Masanes, Galley and Müller [1] argue that the measurement postulates of non-relativistic quantum mechanics follow from the structural postulates together with an assumption they call the "possibility of state estimation". Their argument also relies on what they term a "theory-independent characterization of measurements for single and multipartite systems". We refute their conclusion, giving explicit examples of non-quantum measurement and state update rules that satisfy all their assumptions. We also show that their "possibility of state estimation" assumption is neither necessary nor sufficient to ensure a sensible notion of state estimation within a theory whose states are described by the quantum formalism. We further show their purportedly "theory-independent" characterization assumes several properties of quantum measurements that exclude plausible alternative types of measurement. We illustrate all these points with specific alternative measurement postulates and post-measurement state update rules. We conclude that, contrary to some folklore, quantum mechanics is by no means an island in theory-space. It can consistently be extended by rules for obtaining information about quantum states other than via POVMs. Whether such rules are realised in nature, for example in linking quantum theory and gravity, is an empirical question that cannot be resolved by theoretical analysis alone.
arXiv commentAccepted version. One typo corrected and short postscript discussion added. v3 is identical to v2 but with Creative Commons licence
References in corpus (29)
- A Spin Entanglement Witness for Quantum Gravity
- Gravitationally-induced entanglement between two massive particles is sufficient evidence of quantum effects in gravity
- Optimal Quantum Cloning Machines
- Optimal Cloning of Pure States
- How Quantum Mechanics can consistently describe the use of itself
- Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself
- Optimal universal quantum cloning and state estimation
- A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner's friend paradox
- Optimal Cloning of Pure States, Judging Single Clones
- Asymmetric quantum cloning machines in any dimension
- A no-go theorem for observer-independent facts
- Quantum Gravity Witness via Entanglement of Masses: Casimir Screening
- Quantum information distributors: Quantum network for symmetric and asymmetric cloning in arbitrary dimension and continuous limit
- Why Eppley and Hannah's Experiment Isn't
- Measurement Analysis and Quantum Gravity
- Non-Gaussianity as a signature of a quantum theory of gravity
- Using an atom interferometer to infer gravitational entanglement generation
- Nonlinearity without Superluminality
- The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are operationally redundant
- Simple Refutation of the Eppley-Hannah argument
- Renyi-entropic bounds on quantum communication
- A "thoughtful" Local Friendliness no-go theorem: a prospective experiment with new assumptions to suit
- Testing the nonclassicality of spacetime: what can we learn from Bell-Bose et al.-Marletto-Vedral experiments?
- Beable-Guided Quantum Theories: Generalising Quantum Probability Laws
- Tests of Quantum Gravity near Measurement Events
- Quantum State Readout, Collapses, Probes and Signals
- Response to "The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are not redundant"
- Mixture equivalence principles and post-quantum theories of gravity
- Masanes-Galley-Müller and the State-Update Postulate