Simple Refutation of the Eppley-Hannah argument

Abstract

In an influential paper, Eppley and Hannah argued that gravity must necessarily be quantized, by proposing a thought experiment involving classical gravitational waves interacting with quantum matter. They argue the interaction must either violate the uncertainty principle or allow superluminal signalling. The feasibility of implementing their experiment in our universe has been challenged by Mattingly, and other limitations of the argument have been noted by Huggett and Callender and by Albers et al.. However, these critiques do not directly refute the claim that coupling quantum theories with a Copenhagen collapse postulate to unentanglable classical gravitational degrees of freedom leads to contradiction. I note here that if the gravitational field interacts with matter via the local quantum state, the Eppley-Hannah argument evidently fails. This seems a plausibly natural feature of a hybrid theory, whereas the alternative considered by Eppley-Hannah is evidently inconsistent with relativity.

arXiv commentDiscussion extended; figure improved; typos fixed. Accepted version

References in corpus (6)

• Why Eppley and Hannah's Experiment Isn't
• Measurement Analysis and Quantum Gravity
• Nonlinearity without Superluminality
• Causal Quantum Theory and the Collapse Locality Loophole
• Space QUEST mission proposal: Experimentally testing decoherence due to gravity
• Causality in Time-Neutral Cosmologies

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Gravitationally induced decoherence vs space-time diffusion: testing the quantum nature of gravity
• Testing the nonclassicality of spacetime: what can we learn from Bell-Bose et al.-Marletto-Vedral experiments?
• Three little paradoxes: making sense of semiclassical gravity
• Discussions about the landscape of possibilities for treatments of cosmic inflation involving continuous spontaneous localization models
• Classical theories of gravity produce entanglement
• On the initial value problem for semiclassical gravity without and with quantum state collapses
• Tests of Quantum Gravity near Measurement Events
• On the origin of force sensitivity in tests of quantum gravity with delocalised mechanical systems
• Enlightening the CSL model landscape in inflation
• Quantum State Readout, Collapses, Probes and Signals
• The post-determined block universe
• State Swapping via Semiclassical Gravity
• Emergent universe revisited through the CSL theory
• The measurement postulates of quantum mechanics are not redundant
• Gravitational entanglement and the mass contribution of internal energy in nonrelativistic quantum systems
• Fundamental Physics, Existential Risks and Human Futures