Make Super-Earths, Not Jupiters: Accreting Nebular Gas onto Solid Cores at 0.1 AU and Beyond

Abstract

Close-in super-Earths having radii 1--4 $R_{\oplus }$ may possess hydrogen atmospheres comprising a few percent by mass of their rocky cores. We determine the conditions under which such atmospheres can be accreted by cores from their parent circumstellar disks. Accretion from the nebula is problematic because it is too efficient: we find that 10-$M_{\oplus }$ cores embedded in solar metallicity disks tend to undergo runaway gas accretion and explode into Jupiters, irrespective of orbital location. The threat of runaway is especially dire at $\sim$0.1 AU, where solids may coagulate on timescales orders of magnitude shorter than gas clearing times; thus nascent atmospheres on close-in orbits are unlikely to be supported against collapse by planetesimal accretion. The time to runaway accretion is well approximated by the cooling time of the atmosphere's innermost convective zone, whose extent is controlled by where H${}_2$ dissociates. Insofar as the temperatures characterizing H${}_2$ dissociation are universal, timescales for core instability tend not to vary with orbital distance --- and to be alarmingly short for 10-$M_{\oplus }$ cores. Nevertheless, in the thicket of parameter space, we identify two scenarios, not mutually exclusive, that can reproduce the preponderance of percent-by-mass atmospheres for super-Earths at $\sim$0.1 AU, while still ensuring the formation of Jupiters at $\gtrsim 1$ AU. Scenario (a): planets form in disks with dust-to-gas ratios that range from $\sim$20$\times$ solar at 0.1 AU to $\sim$2$\times$ solar at 5 AU. Scenario (b): the final assembly of super-Earth cores from mergers of proto-cores --- a process that completes quickly at $\sim$0.1 AU once begun --- is delayed by gas dynamical friction until just before disk gas dissipates completely.

18 pages, 10 figures, Final proofed version, 2014 ApJ, 797, 95. Includes conceptual corrections to Section 4.2 on the amount of nebular depletion required for scenario (b)

References in corpus (12)

• Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799
• The Occurrence and Mass Distribution of Close-in Super-Earths, Neptunes, and Jupiters
• Models of the in situ formation of detected extrasolar giant planets
• On the Location of the Snow Line in a Protoplanetary Disk
• Formation of Jupiter using opacities based on detailed grain physics
• Atmospheric Mass Loss During Planet Formation: The Importance of Planetesimal Impacts
• Post-Oligarchic Evolution of Protoplanetary Embryos and the Stability of Planetary Systems
• Formation of close in Super-Earths \& Mini-Neptunes: Required Disk Masses \& Their Implications
• An Atmospheric Structure Equation for Grain Growth
• Short dissipation times of proto-planetary discs - an artifact of selection effects?
• The Transiting System GJ1214: High-Precision Defocused Transit Observations and a Search for Evidence of Transit Timing Variation
• Accretion and Evolution of ~2.5 Earth-mass Planets with Voluminous H/He Envelopes

Cited by in corpus (144)

• Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: How the radial pebble flux determines a terrestrial-planet or super-Earth growth mode
• Exoplanet Statistics and Theoretical Implications
• Hydrodynamics of Embedded Planets' First Atmospheres. II. A Rapid Recycling of Atmospheric Gas
• The Gaia-Kepler Stellar Properties Catalog. II. Planet Radius Demographics as a Function of Stellar Mass and Age
• Challenges in Planet Formation
• Four newborn planets transiting the young solar analog V1298 Tau
• Reduced gas accretion on super-Earths and ice giants
• The nature and origins of sub-Neptune size planets
• Planet formation with envelope enrichment: new insights on planetary diversity
• Hydrodynamics of embedded planets' first atmospheres - III. The role of radiation transport for super-Earth planets
• A reassessment of the in situ formation of close-in super-Earths
• Scaling K2. I. Revised Parameters for 222,088 K2 Stars and a K2 Planet Radius Valley at 1.9 $R_{\oplus }$
• Occurrence Rates of Planets Orbiting M Stars: Applying ABC to Kepler DR25, Gaia DR2, and 2MASS Data
• Conclusive evidence for a population of water-worlds around M-dwarfs remains elusive
• A pair of TESS planets spanning the radius valley around the nearby mid-M dwarf LTT 3780
• WASP-107b's density is even lower: a case study for the physics of planetary gas envelope accretion and orbital migration
• Primordial Radius Gap and Potentially Broad Core Mass Distributions of Super-Earths and Sub-Neptunes
• Constraints on Super-Earths Interiors from Stellar Abundances
• The Boundary between Gas-rich and Gas-poor Planets
• The Habitable-zone Planet Finder Reveals A High Mass and a Low Obliquity for the Young Neptune K2-25b
• TESS spots a hot Jupiter with an inner transiting Neptune
• Hydrogen dominated atmospheres on terrestrial mass planets: evidence, origin and evolution
• A deep radius valley revealed by Kepler short cadence observations
• How planets grow by pebble accretion. III. Emergence of an interior composition gradient
• A Tale of Planet Formation: From Dust to Planets
• Three Super-Earths Orbiting HD 7924
• The Occurrence Rate of Terrestrial Planets Orbiting Nearby Mid-to-late M Dwarfs from TESS Sectors 1-42
• Creating the Radius Gap without Mass Loss
• Predicted diversity in water content of terrestrial exoplanets orbiting M dwarfs
• An Overabundance of Low-density Neptune-like Planets
• Tidal Inflation Reconciles Low-Density Sub-Saturns with Core Accretion
• Evolution of the Exoplanet Size Distribution: Forming Large Super-Earths Over Billions of Years
• TOI-1452 b: SPIRou and TESS reveal a super-Earth in a temperate orbit transiting an M4 dwarf
• Most super-Earths formed by dry pebble accretion are less massive than 5 Earth masses
• One year of AU Mic with HARPS: I -- measuring the masses of the two transiting planets
• A planetary system with two transiting mini-Neptunes near the radius valley transition around the bright M dwarf TOI-776
• The maximum mass of planetary embryos formed in core-accretion models
• In situ accretion of gaseous envelopes on to planetary cores embedded in evolving protoplanetary discs
• The importance of silicate vapor in determining the structure, radii, and envelope mass fractions of sub-Neptunes
• Constraining the entropy of formation from young transiting planets
• TOI-1235 b: a keystone super-Earth for testing radius valley emergence models around early M dwarfs
• A significant mutual inclination between the planets within the $\pi$ Mensae system
• Warm Jupiters in TESS Full-Frame Images: A Catalog and Observed Eccentricity Distribution for Year 1
• The End of Runaway: How Gap Opening Limits the Final Masses of Gas Giants
• The Imprint of the Protoplanetary Disk in the Accretion of Super-Earth Envelopes
• The Magellan-TESS Survey I: Survey Description and Mid-Survey Results
• Envelopes of embedded super-Earths II. Three-dimensional isothermal simulations
• Heavy-metal Jupiters by major mergers: metallicity vs. mass for giant planets
• Moderately Eccentric Warm Jupiters from Secular Interactions with Exterior Companions
• Steady State by Recycling prevents Premature Collapse of Protoplanetary Atmospheres
• Orbital misalignment of the super-Earth $\pi$ Men c with the spin of its star
• Super-Earths and Earth-like Exoplanets
• Eccentric Companions to Kepler-448b and Kepler-693b: Clues to the Formation of Warm Jupiters
• Forming Diverse Super-Earth Systems in Situ
• Gas flow around a planet embedded in a protoplanetary disc: the dependence on the planetary mass
• The Discovery of a Planetary Companion Interior to Hot Jupiter WASP-132 b
• A Featureless Infrared Transmission Spectrum for the Super-Puff Planet Kepler-79d
• The Preservation of Super Earths and the Emergence of Gas Giants after Their Progenitor Cores have Entered the Pebble Isolation Phase
• TOI-1130: A photodynamical analysis of a hot Jupiter in resonance with an inner low-mass planet
• Do the TRAPPIST-1 Planets Have Hydrogen-rich Atmospheres?
• Validation of 13 Hot and Potentially Terrestrial TESS Planets
• A pair of warm giant planets near the 2:1 mean motion resonance around the K-dwarf star TOI-2202
• A super-Earth and a mini-Neptune near the 2:1 MMR straddling the radius valley around the nearby mid-M dwarf TOI-2096
• A 1.55 R${}_{\oplus }$ habitable-zone planet hosted by TOI-715, an M4 star near the ecliptic South Pole
• Formation of secondary atmospheres on terrestrial planets by late disk accretion
• Accretion of Gas Giants Constrained by the Tidal Barrier
• Three Temperate Neptunes Orbiting Nearby Stars
• Recycling of the first atmospheres of embedded planets: Dependence on core mass and optical depth
• Global 3D Radiation Hydrodynamic Simulations of Proto-Jupiter's Convective Envelope
• Radial Gradients in Dust-to-Gas Ratio Lead to Preferred Region for Giant Planet Formation
• ALMA observations require slower Core Accretion runaway growth
• Ohmic Dissipation in Mini-Neptunes
• TESS spots a mini-neptune interior to a hot saturn in the TOI-2000 system
• Retention of Long-Period Gas Giant Planets: Type II Migration Revisited
• Atmospheric Recyling of Volatiles by Pebble-Accreting Planets
• Exoplanet Volatile Carbon Content as a Natural Pathway for Haze Formation
• Unified simulations of planetary formation and atmospheric evolution: Effects of pebble accretion, giant impacts, and stellar irradiations on super-Earth formation
• In situ formation of hot Jupiters with companion super-Earths
• The "Breaking The Chains" migration model for super-Earths formation: the effect of collisional fragmentation
• Detectability of biosignatures on LHS 1140 b
• The Endgame of Gas Giant Formation: Accretion Luminosity and Contraction Post-Runaway
• TOI 540 b: A Planet Smaller than Earth Orbiting a Nearby Rapidly Rotating Low-mass Star
• Bridging the Planet Radius Valley: Stellar Clustering as a Key Driver for Turning Sub-Neptunes into Super-Earths
• Exterior Companions to Hot Jupiters Orbiting Cool Stars are Coplanar
• Where are the Water Worlds?: Self-Consistent Models of Water-Rich Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Chains of Planets in Mean Motion Resonances Arising from Oligarchic Growth
• Sequential giant planet formation initiated by disc substructure
• The metal-poor atmosphere of a Neptune/Sub-Neptune planet progenitor
• Revising the Giant Planet Mass-Metallicity Relation: Deciphering the Formation Sequence of Giant Planets
• Three planets transiting the evolved star EPIC 249893012: a hot 8.8-M${}_{\oplus }$ super-Earth and two warm 14.7 and 10.2-M${}_{\oplus }$ sub-Neptunes
• TESS discovery of a sub-Neptune orbiting a mid-M dwarf TOI-2136
• Unified simulations of planetary formation and atmospheric evolution II: Rapid disk clearing by photoevaporation yields low-mass super-Earth atmospheres
• Kepler-1656b's Extreme Eccentricity: Signature of a Gentle Giant
• Characterisation of 92 Southern TESS Candidate Planet Hosts and a New Photometric [Fe/H] Relation for Cool Dwarfs
• Close-in Super-Earths: The first and the last stages of planet formation in an MRI-accreting disc
• Tidal Heating of Young Super-Earth Atmospheres
• Precise mass determination for the keystone sub-Neptune planet transiting the mid-type M dwarf G 9-40
• TOI-1075 b: A Dense, Massive, Ultra-Short Period Hot Super-Earth Straddling the Radius Gap
• Dust Accumulation near the Magnetospheric Truncation of Protoplanetary Discs around T Tauri Stars
• Envelopes of embedded super-Earths I. Two-dimensional simulations
• Rotation periods of TESS Objects of Interest from the Magellan-TESS Survey with multiband photometry from Evryscope and TESS
• Dynamical Evolution of Closely Packed Multiple Planetary Systems Subject to Atmospheric Mass-Loss
• Influence of grain sizes and composition on the contraction rates of planetary envelopes and on planetary migration
• Gap opening by planets in discs with magnetised winds
• Inside-Out Planet Formation. VII. Astrochemical Models of Protoplanetary Disks and Implications for Planetary Compositions
• First Comparative Exoplanetology Within a Transiting Multi-planet System: Comparing the atmospheres of V1298 Tau b and c
• Sublimation of refractory minerals in the gas envelopes of accreting rocky planets
• Super-Earths as Failed Cores in Orbital Migration Traps
• Exoplanet atmosphere evolution: emulation with neural networks
• Can Large-Scale Migration Explain the Giant Planet Occurrence Rate?
• Helium in Exoplanet Exospheres: Orbital and Stellar Influences
• Absence of extended atmospheres in low-mass star radius-gap planets GJ 9827 b, GJ 9827 d and TOI-1235 b
• TESS discovery of a super-Earth orbiting the M dwarf star TOI-1680
• The growth of super-Earths: the importance of a self-consistent treatment of disc structures and pebble accretion
• TESS and CHEOPS Discover Two Warm Sub-Neptunes Transiting the Bright K-dwarf HD 15906
• The K2-ESPRINT Project VI: K2-105 b, a Hot-Neptune around a Metal-rich G-dwarf
• Formation of Super-Earths by Tidally-Forced Turbulence
• Dynamical rearrangement of super-Earths during disk dispersal II. Assessment of the magnetospheric rebound model for planet formation scenarios
• The Dynamic Proto-atmospheres around Low-Mass Planets with Eccentric Orbits
• The McDonald Accelerating Stars Survey (MASS): Architecture of the Ancient Five-Planet Host System Kepler-444
• A sub-Neptune planet around TOI-1695 discovered and characterized with SPIRou and TESS
• Characterisation of TOI-406 as showcase of the THIRSTEE program: A 2-planet system straddling the M-dwarf density gap
• Redefining interiors and envelopes: hydrogen-silicate miscibility and its consequences for the structure and evolution of sub-Neptunes
• TOI-4336 A b: A temperate sub-Neptune ripe for atmospheric characterization in a nearby triple M-dwarf system
• NGTS-13b: A hot 4.8 Jupiter-mass planet transiting a subgiant star
• A primordial radius valley as a consequence of planet formation
• K2-79b and K2-222b: Mass measurements of two small exoplanets with periods beyond 10 days that overlap with periodic magnetic activity signals
• Coupled Thermal-Chemical Evolution Models of Sub-Neptunes Reveal Atmospheric Signatures of Their Formation Location
• Planet formation: key mechanisms and global models
• Directly Detecting the Envelopes of Low-mass Planets Embedded In Protoplanetary Discs and The Case For TW Hydrae
• Migration and Evolution of giant ExoPlanets (MEEP) II: Super-Jupiters and Lithium-rich Host Stars
• TOI-1743 b, TOI-5799 b, TOI-5799 c and TOI-6223 b: TESS discovery and validation of four super-Earth to Neptune-sized planets around M dwarfs
• The Critical Core Mass of Rotating Planets
• Exploring the habitability and interior composition of exoplanets lying within the extended habitable zone
• Evolution and Observable Properties of Rocky Planet Atmospheres
• Gas-depleted planet formation occurred in the four-planet system around the red dwarf LHS 1903
• Evidence of a gap in the envelope mass fraction of sub-Saturns
• Radio prospects of extrasolar aurorae polaris as a probe of planetary magnetism
• Ohmic dissipation during the formation of super-Earth
• JWST unveils a high mean molecular weight atmosphere for mini-Neptune TOI-1130b: Evidence for formation beyond the water ice line
• Revisiting the exoplanet radius valley with host stars from SWEET-Cat
• A Multi-Planet System's Sole Super-Puff: Exploring Allowable Physical Parameters for the Cold Super-Puff HIP 41378 f
• The effect of late giant collisions on the atmospheres of protoplanets and the formation of cold sub-Saturns
• In situ formation of super-Earth/sub-Neptune driven by the planetary rotation