Revising the Giant Planet Mass-Metallicity Relation: Deciphering the Formation Sequence of Giant Planets

Abstract

The rate at which giant planets accumulate solids and gas is a critical component of planet formation models, yet it is extremely challenging to predict from first principles. Characterizing the heavy element (everything other than hydrogen and helium) content of giant planets provides important clues about their provenance. Using thermal evolution models with updated H-He EOS and atmospheric boundary condition that varies with envelope metallicity, we quantify the bulk heavy element content of 147 warm ($<1000$ K) giant planets with well-measured masses and radii, more than tripling the sample size studied in Thorngren et al. 2016. These measurements reveal that the population's heavy element mass follows the relation $M_{\mathrm{Z}}=M_{\mathrm{core}}+f_Z(M_{\mathrm{p}}-M_{\mathrm{core}})$, with $M_{\mathrm{core}}=14.7_{-1.6}^{+1.8}$ Earth masses (M${}_{\oplus }$), $f_Z=0.09\pm 0.01$, and an astrophysical scatter of $0.66\pm 0.08\times M_Z$. The classical core-accretion scenario ($Z_{\mathrm{p}}=1$ at 10 M${}_{\oplus }$ and $Z_{\mathrm{p}}=0.5$ at 20 M${}_{\oplus }$) is inconsistent with the population. At low planet masses ($<<150$ M${}_{\oplus }$), $M_{\mathrm{Z}}\sim M_{\mathrm{core}}$ and as a result, $Z_{\mathrm{p}}=M_{\mathrm{Z}}/M_{\mathrm{p}}$ declines linearly with $M_{\mathrm{p}}$. However, bulk metallicity does not continue to decline with planet mass and instead flattens out at $f_Z\sim 0.09$ ($\sim 7\times$ solar metallicity). When normalized by stellar metallicity, $Z_{\mathrm{p}}/Z_{\star }$ flattens out at $3.3\pm 0.5$ at high planet masses. This explicitly shows that giant planets continue to accrete material enriched in heavy elements during the gas accretion phase.

Accepted for publication in ApJ, 21 pages, 14 figures

References in corpus (73)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• dynesty: A Dynamic Nested Sampling Package for Estimating Bayesian Posteriors and Evidences
• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Planetary Radii across Five Orders of Magnitude in Mass and Stellar Insolation: Application to Transits
• Rapid growth of gas-giant cores by pebble accretion
• The effect of gas drag on the growth of protoplanets -- Analytical expressions for the accretion of small bodies in laminar disks
• On the Luminosity of Young Jupiters
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets
• Forming Planetesimals in Solar and Extrasolar Nebulae
• A correlation between the heavy element content of transiting extrasolar planets and the metallicity of their parent stars
• Atmospheres of protoplanetary cores: critical mass for nucleated instability
• Planet Formation by Coagulation: A Focus on Uranus and Neptune
• Comparative Planetary Atmospheres: Models of TrES-1 and HD209458b
• Make Super-Earths, Not Jupiters: Accreting Nebular Gas onto Solid Cores at 0.1 AU and Beyond
• Hints for a Turnover at the Snow Line in the Giant Planet Occurrence Rate
• The Heavy Element Masses of Extrasolar Giant Planets, Revealed
• New indication for a dichotomy in the interior structure of Uranus and Neptune from the application of modified shape and rotation data
• On the Minimum Core Mass for Giant Planet Formation at Wide Separations
• Hydrodynamics of Embedded Planets' First Atmospheres. II. A Rapid Recycling of Atmospheric Gas
• Bayesian Analysis of Hot Jupiter Radius Anomalies: Evidence for Ohmic Dissipation?
• Fast accretion of small planetesimals by protoplanetary cores
• Tracing the formation history of giant planets in protoplanetary disks with Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen and Sulphur
• New models of Jupiter in the context of Juno and Galileo
• A new equation of state for dense hydrogen-helium mixtures
• Ab Initio Equation of State for Hydrogen-Helium Mixtures with Recalibration of the Giant-Planet Mass-Radius Relation
• How drifting and evaporating pebbles shape giant planets I: Heavy element content and atmospheric C/O
• Extreme deconvolution: Inferring complete distribution functions from noisy, heterogeneous and incomplete observations
• Jupiter's composition: sign of a (relatively) late formation in a chemically evolved protosolar disk
• Connecting Giant Planet Atmosphere and Interior Modeling: Constraints on Atmospheric Metal Enrichment
• Dust growth and evolution in protoplanetary disks
• Beyond Equilibrium Temperature: How the Atmosphere/Interior Connection Affects the Onset of Methane, Ammonia, and Clouds in Warm Transiting Giant Planets
• Hydrodynamics of embedded planets' first atmospheres - III. The role of radiation transport for super-Earth planets
• The formation of Jupiter by hybrid pebble-planetesimal accretion
• On the Origin of HD149026b
• A New Window into Planet Formation and Migration: Refractory-to-Volatile Elemental Ratios in Ultra-hot Jupiters
• Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
• Planetesimal Accretion onto Growing Proto-Gas-Giant Planets
• Re-inflated Warm Jupiters Around Red Giants
• A new equation of state for dense hydrogen-helium mixtures II: taking into account hydrogen-helium interactions
• Seeing double with K2: Testing re-inflation with two remarkably similar planets around red giant branch stars
• Ab initio based equation of state of dense water for planetary and exoplanetary modeling
• The origin of the high metallicity of close-in giant exoplanets: Combined effect of the resonant and aerodynamic shepherding
• Breaking Degeneracies in Formation Histories by Measuring Refractory Content in Gas Giants
• Planetary Core Formation with Collisional Fragmentation and Atmosphere to Form Gas Giant Planets
• The Heavy Element Composition of Disk Instability Planets Can Range From Sub- to Super-Nebular
• Leaky dust traps: How fragmentation impacts dust filtering by planets
• The Equilibrium Temperature of Planets in Elliptical Orbits
• Jupiter's interior from Juno: Equation-of-state uncertainties and dilute core extent
• Metallicity of the Massive Protoplanets Around HR 8799 If Formed by Gravitational Instability
• Infall of planetesimals onto growing giant planets: onset of runaway gas accretion and metallicity of their gas envelopes
• The Interiors of Uranus and Neptune: Current Understanding and Open Questions
• Do Metal-Rich Stars Make Metal-Rich Planets? New Insights on Giant Planet Formation from Host Star Abundances
• Capture of Solids by Growing Proto-gas Giants: Effects of Gap Formation and Supply-limited Growth
• Do close-in giant planets orbiting evolved stars prefer eccentric orbits?
• Theoretical vs. observational uncertainties: composition of giant exoplanets
• On the mass of gas giant planets: Is Saturn a failed gas giant?
• TKS X: Confirmation of TOI-1444b and a Comparative Analysis of the Ultra-short-period Planets with Hot Neptunes
• Signatures of a planet-planet impacts phase in exoplanetary systems hosting giant planets
• The Imprint of the Protoplanetary Disk in the Accretion of Super-Earth Envelopes
• Heavy-metal Jupiters by major mergers: metallicity vs. mass for giant planets
• Accounting for non-ideal mixing effects in the hydrogen-helium equation of state
• Nitrogen as a Tracer of Giant Planet Formation. I.: A Universal Deep Adiabatic Profile and Semi-analytical Predictions of Disequilibrium Ammonia Abundances in Warm Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• The Origin of Heavy Element Content Trend in Giant Planets via Core Accretion
• Enriching inner discs and giant planets with heavy elements
• Giant exoplanet composition: Why do the hydrogen-helium equation of state and interior structure matter?
• Superadiabaticity in Jupiter and giant planet interiors
• In-situ enrichment in heavy elements of hot Jupiters
• Three-dimensional transport of solids in a protoplanetary disk containing a growing giant planet
• The bulk metallicity of giant planets around M stars
• A low accretion efficiency of planetesimals formed at planetary gap edges
• Unraveling the origin of giant exoplanets: Observational implications of convective mixing
• Nonparametric Methods in Astronomy: Think, Regress, Observe -- Pick Any Three

Cited by in corpus (5)

• The compositions of the HR 8799 planets reflect accretion of both solids and metal-enriched gas
• The Impact of Irradiation on the Radius and Thermal Evolution of Transiting Brown Dwarfs
• How Internal Structure Shapes the Metallicity of Giant Exoplanets
• Direct Images of CO2 Absorption in the Atmosphere of a Super-Jupiter: Enhanced Metallicity Suggestive of Formation in a Disk
• JWST-TST High Contrast: First Direct Spectroscopy of GJ 504 b reveals Clouds and Possible Metal Enrichment