On the Stellar Populations of Galaxies at z=9-11: The Growth of Metals and Stellar Mass at Early Times

Abstract

We present a detailed stellar population analysis of 11 bright ($H<26.6$) galaxies at $z=9-11$ (three spectroscopically confirmed) to constrain the chemical enrichment and growth of stellar mass of early galaxies. We use the flexible Bayesian spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting code Prospector with a range of star-formation histories (SFHs), a flexible dust attenuation law and a self-consistent modeling of emission lines. This approach allows us to assess how different priors affect our results, and how well we can break degeneracies between dust attenuation, stellar ages, metallicity and emission lines using data which probe only the rest-frame ultraviolet to optical wavelengths. We measure a median observed ultraviolet spectral slope $\beta =-1.87_{-0.43}^{+0.35}$ for relatively massive star-forming galaxies ($9<\log (M_{\star }/M_{\odot })<10$), consistent with no change from $z=4$ to $z=9-10$ at these stellar masses, implying rapid enrichment. Our SED-fitting results are consistent with a star-forming main sequence with sub-linear slope ($0.7\pm 0.2$) and specific star-formation rates of $3-10{\mathrm{Gyr}}^{-1}$. However, the stellar ages and SFHs are less well constrained. Using different SFH priors, we cannot distinguish between median mass-weighted ages of $\sim 50-150$ Myr, which corresponds to 50\% formation redshifts of $z_{50}\sim 10-12$ at $z\sim 9$ and is of the order of the dynamical timescales of these systems. Importantly, the models with different SFH priors are able to fit the data equally well. We conclude that the current observational data cannot tightly constrain the mass-buildup timescales of these $z=9-11$ galaxies, with our results consistent with SFHs implying both a shallow and steep increase of the cosmic SFR density with time at $z>10$.

27 pages + Appendix; accepted by ApJ

References in corpus (68)

• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
• EAZY: A Fast, Public Photometric Redshift Code
• A Highly Consistent Framework for the Evolution of the Star-Forming "Main Sequence" from z~0-6
• UV Luminosity Functions at redshifts z~4 to z~10: 10000 Galaxies from HST Legacy Fields
• Binary Population and Spectral Synthesis Version 2.1: construction, observational verification and new results
• Stellar Population Inference with Prospector
• New Determinations of the UV Luminosity Functions from z~9 to z~2 show a remarkable consistency with halo growth and a constant star formation efficiency
• Dust Formation and Survival in Supernova Ejecta
• A dusty, normal galaxy in the epoch of reionization
• Evolution of interstellar dust and stardust in the solar neighbourhood
• Dust in the reionization era: ALMA observations of a $z$=8.38 Galaxy
• The Relation Between SFR and Stellar Mass for Galaxies at 3.5 $\le z\le$ 6.5 in CANDELS
• Introducing the THESAN project: radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the epoch of reionization
• A lack of evolution in the very bright-end of the galaxy luminosity function from z = 8-10
• Feedback-regulated star formation and escape of LyC photons from mini-haloes during reionisation
• The Evolution of the IR Luminosity Function and Dust-obscured Star Formation in the Last 13 Billion Years
• High-precision Photometric Redshifts from Spitzer/IRAC: Extreme [3.6]-[4.5] Colors Identify Galaxies in the Redshift Range z~6.6-6.9
• How Well Can We Measure the Stellar Mass of a Galaxy: The Impact of the Assumed Star Formation History Model in SED Fitting
• Fast, Slow, Early, Late: Quenching Massive Galaxies at z~0.8
• ALMA uncovers the [CII] emission and warm dust continuum in a z = 8.31 Lyman break galaxy
• The [OIII]$+$H$\beta$ Equivalent Width Distribution at z$\simeq$7: Implications for the Contribution of Galaxies to Reionization
• UV Dust Attenuation in Star-forming Galaxies: II Calibrating the A(UV) vs. L_TIR/L_UV relation
• Rapid dust production in submillimeter galaxies at z>4?
• Non-parametric Star Formation History Reconstruction with Gaussian Processes I: Counting Major Episodes of Star Formation
• Condensation of dust in the ejecta of type II-P supernovae
• The Universe at z>10: Predictions for JWST from the UniverseMachine DR1
• First Light And Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) I: Environmental Dependence of High-Redshift Galaxy Evolution
• Normal, Dust-Obscured Galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization
• The Evolution of the UV Luminosity Function from z ~ 0.75 to z ~ 2.5 using HST ERS WFC3/UVIS Observations
• Stochastic modelling of star-formation histories II: star-formation variability from molecular clouds and gas inflow
• The Intrinsic Properties of SDSS Galaxies
• The GREATS H$\beta$+[OIII] Luminosity Function and Galaxy Properties at $\mathbf{z}\sim 8$: Walking the Way of JWST
• The THESAN project: properties of the intergalactic medium and its connection to Reionization-era galaxies
• The Diversity and Variability of Star Formation Histories in Models of Galaxy Evolution
• The dust production rate of AGB stars in the Magellanic Clouds
• Stochastic modeling of star-formation histories I: the scatter of the star-forming main sequence
• The shapes of galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The ALPINE-ALMA [CII] Survey: Obscured Star Formation Rate Density and Main Sequence of star-forming galaxies at z>4
• Probing Cosmic Dawn with Emission Lines: Predicting Infrared and Nebular Line Emission for ALMA and JWST
• Detailed dust modelling in the L-Galaxies semi-analytic model of galaxy formation
• High-redshift quasars host galaxies: is there a stellar mass crisis?
• First Light And Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) II: The Photometric Properties of High-Redshift Galaxies
• T-PHOT version 2.0: improved algorithms for background subtraction, local convolution, kernel registration, and new options
• Dust production scenarios in galaxies at z ~ 6-8.3
• Ultraviolet through Infrared Spectral Energy Distributions from 1000 SDSS Galaxies: Dust Attenuation
• Probing Cosmic Dawn : Ages and Star Formation Histories of Candidate $z\ge$9 Galaxies
• Warm dust in high-z galaxies: origin and implications
• Interpreting the Spitzer/IRAC Colours of 7<z<9 Galaxies: Distinguishing Between Line Emission and Starlight Using ALMA
• Early galaxy formation in warm dark matter cosmologies
• The Dynamics, Destruction, and Survival of Supernova-Formed Dust Grains
• Thermal and nonthermal dust sputtering in hydrodynamical simulations of the multiphase interstellar medium
• UV Spectral-Slopes at $z=6-9$ in the Hubble Frontier Fields: Lack of Evidence for Unusual or Pop III Stellar Populations
• Interpreting the evolution of galaxy colours from $z=8$ to $z=5$
• Probing the Bright End of the Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Luminosity Function at z = 8-10 with Hubble Pure-Parallel Imaging
• The GOGREEN survey: Post-infall environmental quenching fails to predict the observed age difference between quiescent field and cluster galaxies at z>1
• High redshift JWST predictions from IllustrisTNG: II. Galaxy line and continuum spectral indices and dust attenuation curves
• Lyman-alpha radiation hydrodynamics of galactic winds before cosmic reionization
• High redshift JWST predictions from IllustrisTNG: III. Infrared luminosity functions, obscured star formation and dust temperature of high-redshift galaxies
• The Diverse Molecular Gas Content of Massive Galaxies Undergoing Quenching at z~1
• Supernovae within Pre-existing Wind-Blown Bubbles: Dust Injection vs. Ambient Dust Destruction
• AGB dust and gas ejecta in extremely metal-poor environments
• Improving $z\sim 7-11$ Galaxy Property Estimates with JWST/NIRCam Medium-Band Photometry
• Modelling the M*-SFR relation at high redshift: untangling factors driving biases in the intrinsic scatter measurement
• RELICS: Properties of z>5.5 Galaxies Inferred from Spitzer and Hubble Imaging Including A Candidate z~6.8 Strong [OIII] Emitter
• Dust in the first galaxies
• Luminous Lyman-alpha Emitters with Very Blue UV-continuum Slopes at Redshift 5.7 <= z <= 6.6
• Reproducing the UVJ Color Distribution of Star-forming Galaxies at 0.5 < z < 2.5 with a Geometric Model of Dust Attenuation
• Degeneracies between baryons and dark matter: the challenge of constraining the nature of dark matter with JWST

Cited by in corpus (98)

• A Comprehensive Study on Galaxies at z~9-16 Found in the Early JWST Data: UV Luminosity Functions and Cosmic Star-Formation History at the Pre-Reionization Epoch
• CEERS Key Paper I: An Early Look into the First 500 Myr of Galaxy Formation with JWST
• Two Remarkably Luminous Galaxy Candidates at $z\approx 10-12$ Revealed by JWST
• A CEERS Discovery of an Accreting Supermassive Black Hole 570 Myr after the Big Bang: Identifying a Progenitor of Massive z > 6 Quasars
• A Long Time Ago in a Galaxy Far, Far Away: A Candidate z ~ 12 Galaxy in Early JWST CEERS Imaging
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• The chemical enrichment in the early Universe as probed by JWST via direct metallicity measurements at z~8
• Identification and properties of intense star-forming galaxies at redshifts z>10
• Spectroscopic confirmation of two luminous galaxies at $z\sim 14$
• The brightest galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
• A JWST/NIRCam Study of Key Contributors to Reionization: The Star-forming and Ionizing Properties of UV-faint $z\sim 7-8$ Galaxies
• JADES Imaging of GN-z11: Revealing the Morphology and Environment of a Luminous Galaxy 430 Myr After the Big Bang
• CEERS Spectroscopic Confirmation of NIRCam-Selected z > 8 Galaxy Candidates with JWST/NIRSpec: Initial Characterization of their Properties
• Evolution of the UV LF from z~15 to z~8 Using New JWST NIRCam Medium-Band Observations over the HUDF/XDF
• Extreme Value Statistics of the Halo and Stellar Mass Distributions at High Redshift: are JWST Results in Tension with ΛCDM?
• JWST NIRCam+NIRSpec: Interstellar medium and stellar populations of young galaxies with rising star formation and evolving gas reservoirs
• CEERS Key Paper V: A triality on the nature of HST-dark galaxies
• The ALMA REBELS Survey: Dust Continuum Detections at z > 6.5
• Are the ultra-high-redshift galaxies at z > 10 surprising in the context of standard galaxy formation models?
• The ultraviolet continuum slopes ($\beta$) of galaxies at $\mathbf{z}\simeq 8-16$ from JWST and ground-based near-infrared imaging
• Star formation histories of UV-luminous galaxies at $z\simeq 6.8$: implications for stellar mass assembly at early cosmic times
• A first look at the SMACS0723 JWST ERO: spectroscopic redshifts, stellar masses and star-formation histories
• The ALMA REBELS Survey: Specific Star-Formation Rates in the Reionization Era
• Feedback-Free Starbursts at Cosmic Dawn: Observable Predictions for JWST
• The MillenniumTNG Project: The galaxy population at $z\ge 8$
• Spectral Templates Optimal for Selecting Galaxies at z > 8 with JWST
• On the ages of bright galaxies $\sim 500$ Myr after the Big Bang: insights into star formation activity at $z\gtrsim 15$ with JWST
• Searching for Islands of Reionization: A Potential Ionized Bubble Powered by a Spectroscopic Overdensity at z = 8.7
• Inferring More from Less: Prospector as a Photometric Redshift Engine in the Era of JWST
• The ionising photon production efficiency at z~6 for Lyman-alpha emitters using JEMS and MUSE
• A luminous and young galaxy at z=12.33 revealed by a JWST/MIRI detection of Hα and [OIII]
• A Large Population of Faint 8<z<16 Galaxies Found in the First JWST NIRCam Observations of the NGDEEP Survey
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- VI. Simulated lightcones and galaxy clustering predictions
• EPOCHS IV: SED Modelling Assumptions and their impact on the Stellar Mass Function at 6.5 < z < 13.5 using PEARLS and public JWST observations
• Quantifying the Effects of Known Unknowns on Inferred High-redshift Galaxy Properties: Burstiness, the IMF, and Nebular Physics
• The eventful life of a luminous galaxy at z = 14: metal enrichment, feedback, and low gas fraction?
• JWST/NIRCam Observations of Stars and HII Regions in $z\simeq 6-8$ Galaxies: Properties of Star Forming Complexes on 150 pc Scales
• JWST reveals a possible $z\sim 11$ galaxy merger in triply-lensed MACS0647$-$JD
• High Equivalent Width of Hα+[N II] Emission in z~8 Lyman-break Galaxies from IRAC 5.8μm Observations: Evidence for Efficient Lyman-continuum Photon production in the Epoch of Re-ionization
• The JWST Advanced Deep Extragalactic Survey: Discovery of an Extreme Galaxy Overdensity at $z=5.4$ with JWST/NIRCam in GOODS-S
• The assembly of dusty galaxies at $z\ge 4$: the build-up of stellar mass and its scaling relations with hints from early JWST data
• Early results from GLASS-JWST. X: Rest-frame UV-optical properties of galaxies at 7 < z < 9
• Galaxy Mergers in the Epoch of Reionization I: A JWST Study of Pair Fractions, Merger Rates, and Stellar Mass Accretion Rates at $z=4.5-11.5$
• Identification of High-Redshift Galaxy Overdensities in GOODS-N and GOODS-S
• COSMOS2025: The COSMOS-Web galaxy catalog of photometry, morphology, redshifts, and physical parameters from JWST, HST, and ground-based imaging
• A needle in a haystack? Catching Pop III stars in the Epoch of Reionization: I. Pop III star forming environments
• Early results from GLASS-JWST XVI: Discovering a bluer z~4-7 Universe through UV slopes
• Rapid Quenching of Galaxies at Cosmic Noon
• JADES: Primaeval Lyman-$\alpha$ emitting galaxies reveal early sites of reionisation out to redshift $z\sim 9$
• JADES + JEMS: A Detailed Look at the Buildup of Central Stellar Cores and Suppression of Star Formation in Galaxies at Redshifts 3 < z < 4.5
• Dust attenuation law in JWST galaxies at z = 7-8
• A strong He II $\lambda$1640 emitter with extremely blue UV spectral slope at $z=8.16$: presence of Pop III stars?
• Semi-analytic forecasts for Roman -- the beginning of a new era of deep-wide galaxy surveys
• First Light And Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) VII: The Star Formation and Metal Enrichment Histories of Galaxies in the early Universe
• Value Added Catalog of physical properties of more than 1.3 million galaxies from the DESI Survey
• Zapped then Napped? A rapidly quenched remnant leaker candidate with a steep spectroscopic ${\beta }_{UV}$ slope at z=8.5
• Early Results From GLASS-JWST. XVII: Building the First Galaxies -- Chapter 1. Star Formation Histories at 5<z < 7
• Molecular Gas Reservoirs in Massive Quiescent Galaxies at $\mathrm{z}\sim 0.7$ Linked to Late Time Star Formation
• Predicting sub-millimeter flux densities from global galaxy properties
• The dawn of disks: unveiling the turbulent ionised gas kinematics of the galaxy population at $z\sim 4-6$ with JWST/NIRCam grism spectroscopy
• Resolving Ambiguities in the Inferred Star Formation Histories of Intense [O III] Emitters in the Reionisation Era
• Stochastic Modelling of Star Formation Histories III. Constraints from Physically-Motivated Gaussian Processes
• Stellar populations and star formation histories of the most extreme [OIII] emitters at $z=1.3-3.7$
• Anatomy of an ionized bubble: NIRCam grism spectroscopy of the $z=6.6$ double-peaked Lyman-$\alpha$ emitter COLA1 and its environment
• Probing the Timescale of the 1.4 GHz Radio emissions as a Star formation tracer
• Hitting the slopes: A spectroscopic view of UV continuum slopes of galaxies reveals a reddening at z > 9.5
• ColdSIM predictions of [C II] emission in primordial galaxies
• COSMOS-Web: A history of galaxy migrations over the stellar mass-star formation rate plane
• A simple spectroscopic technique to identify rejuvenating galaxies
• Deep Spitzer/IRAC Data for z~10 galaxies Reveal Blue Balmer Break Colors: Young Stellar Populations at ~500 Myr of Cosmic Time
• First Light And Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) XII: The consequences of star-dust geometry on galaxies in the EoR
• Behind the Spotlight: A systematic assessment of outshining using NIRCam medium-bands in the JADES Origins Field
• Detection of the 2175Å UV Bump at z>7: Evidence for Rapid Dust Evolution in a Merging Reionisation-Era Galaxy
• Exploring the Gas-Phase Metallicity Gradients of Star-forming Galaxies at Cosmic Noon
• No Need for Extreme Stellar Masses at z~7: A Test-case Study of COS-87259
• The BoRG-$JWST$ Survey: Abundance and Mass-to-light Ratio of Luminous $z=7-9$ Galaxies from Independent Sight Lines with NIRSpec
• Galaxy Mergers in the Epoch of Reionization II: Major Merger-Triggered Star Formation and AGN Activities at $z=$ 4.5-8.5
• Double Trouble: Two spectroscopically confirmed low-mass quiescent galaxies at z>5 in overdensities
• Probing Reionization-Era Galaxies with JWST UV Luminosity Functions and Large-Scale Clustering
• Strong [O III] λ5007 Compact Galaxies Identified from SDSS DR16 and Their Scaling Relations
• What is the nature of Little Red Dots and what is not, MIRI SMILES edition
• GA-NIFS: Dissecting the multiple sub-structures and probing their complex interactions in the \Lyalpha emitter galaxy CR7 at z = 6.6 with JWST/NIRSpec
• Infrared Ejecta and Cold Dust in the Young Supernova Remnant N132D
• Quenching of Galaxies at Cosmic Noon: Understanding the Effect of Environment
• Galaxy Rest-Frame UV Colors at z ~ 2-4 with HST UVCANDELS
• A unique window into the Epoch of Reionisation: A double-peaked Lyman-$\alpha$ emitter in the proximity zone of a quasar at $z\sim 6.6$
• Rapid, out of equilibrium metal enrichment indicated by a flat mass-metallicity relation at z~6 from NIRCam grism spectroscopy
• JWSTs PEARLS: NIRCam imaging and NIRISS spectroscopy of a $z=3.6$ star-forming galaxy lensed into a near-Einstein Ring by a $z=1.258$ massive elliptical galaxy
• JADES Dark Horse: demonstrating high-multiplex observations with JWST/NIRSpec dense-shutter spectroscopy in the JADES Origins Field
• Reconstructing galaxy star formation histories from COSMOS2020 photometry using simulation-based inference
• The MOSDEF Survey: A New View of a Remarkable z=1.89 Merger
• The slope and scatter of the star forming main sequence at z~5 : reconciling observations with simulations
• Testing Photometric Techniques for Measuring the Rest-Frame UV Spectral Slope Against JWST PRISM Spectroscopy
• Flexible Simulation Based Inference for Galaxy Photometric Fitting with Synthesizer
• All the Massive Galaxy Overdensities during Reionization: JWST Rest-Frame Optical Selection Reveals Young, Chemically Evolved Galaxies Embedded in Dense, Neutral Gas at z > 5
• pop-cosmos: Star formation over 12 Gyr from generative modelling of a deep infrared-selected galaxy catalogue
• Out of oxygen: Extremely metal-poor galaxy candidates identified at $2.5<z<6.5$ with deep JADES medium-band imaging
• Ciii]$\lambda 1909$ emission as an alternative to Ly$\alpha$ in the reionization era: the dependence of Ciii] and Ly$\alpha$ at $3<z<4$ from the VANDELS survey