Are the ultra-high-redshift galaxies at z > 10 surprising in the context of standard galaxy formation models?

Abstract

A substantial number of ultra-high redshift (8 < z < 17) galaxy candidates have been detected with JWST, posing the question: are these observational results surprising in the context of current galaxy formation models? We address this question using the well-established Santa Cruz semi-analytic models, implemented within merger trees from the new suite of cosmological N-body simulations GUREFT, which were carefully designed for ultra-high redshift studies. Using our fiducial models calibrated at z=0, we present predictions for stellar mass functions, rest-frame UV luminosity functions, and various scaling relations. We find that our (dust-free) models predict galaxy number densities at z~11 (z~13) that are an order of magnitude (a factor of ~30) lower than the observational estimates. We estimate the uncertainty in the observed number densities due to cosmic variance, and find that it leads to a fractional error of ~20-30% at z=11 (~30-80% at z=14) for a 100 sq arcmin field. We explore which processes in our models are most likely to be rate-limiting for the formation of luminous galaxies at these early epochs, considering the halo formation rate, gas cooling, star formation, and stellar feedback, and conclude that it is mainly efficient stellar-driven winds. We find that a modest boost of a factor of ~4 to the UV luminosities, which could arise from a top-heavy stellar initial mass function, would bring our current models into agreement with the observations. Adding a stochastic component to the UV luminosity can also reconcile our results with the observations.

20 pages, 16 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (82)

• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The James Webb Space Telescope
• Ultralight scalars as cosmological dark matter
• A Semi-Analytic Model for the Co-evolution of Galaxies, Black Holes, and Active Galactic Nuclei
• Binary Population and Spectral Synthesis Version 2.1: construction, observational verification and new results
• Cosmic Reionization and Early Star-Forming Galaxies: A Joint Analysis of New Constraints from Planck and Hubble Space Telescope
• Stellar Population Inference with Prospector
• A population of red candidate massive galaxies ~600 Myr after the Big Bang
• Massloss of galaxies due to a UV-background
• PRIMUS: Constraints on Star Formation Quenching and Galaxy Merging, and the Evolution of the Stellar Mass Function From z=0-1
• A Comprehensive Study on Galaxies at z~9-16 Found in the Early JWST Data: UV Luminosity Functions and Cosmic Star-Formation History at the Pre-Reionization Epoch
• CEERS Key Paper I: An Early Look into the First 500 Myr of Galaxy Formation with JWST
• The James Webb Space Telescope Mission
• Two Remarkably Luminous Galaxy Candidates at $z\approx 10-12$ Revealed by JWST
• The evolution of the galaxy UV luminosity function at redshifts z ~ 8-15 from deep JWST and ground-based near-infrared imaging
• Wave Dark Matter
• The halo mass function from the dark ages through the present day
• A Long Time Ago in a Galaxy Far, Far Away: A Candidate z ~ 12 Galaxy in Early JWST CEERS Imaging
• Early results from GLASS-JWST. III: Galaxy candidates at z$\sim$9-15
• Stress Testing $\Lambda$CDM with High-redshift Galaxy Candidates
• Efficient Formation of Massive Galaxies at Cosmic Dawn by Feedback-Free Starbursts
• Discovery and properties of ultra-high redshift galaxies ($9<z<12$) in the JWST ERO SMACS 0723 Field
• CEERS Epoch 1 NIRCam Imaging: Reduction Methods and Simulations Enabling Early JWST Science Results
• Introducing the THESAN project: radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the epoch of reionization
• On the stunning abundance of super-early, massive galaxies revealed by JWST
• Environmental Dependence of the Kennicutt-Schmidt Relation in Galaxies
• Revealing Galaxy Candidates out to $z\sim 16$ with JWST Observations of the Lensing Cluster SMACS0723
• The brightest galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
• A lack of evolution in the very bright-end of the galaxy luminosity function from z = 8-10
• On the Stellar Populations of Galaxies at z=9-11: The Growth of Metals and Stellar Mass at Early Times
• A JWST/NIRCam Study of Key Contributors to Reionization: The Star-forming and Ionizing Properties of UV-faint $z\sim 7-8$ Galaxies
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of CEERS NIRCam-selected Galaxies at $\mathbf{z}\simeq 8-10$
• A Simple Technique for Predicting High-Redshift Galaxy Evolution
• CEERS Spectroscopic Confirmation of NIRCam-Selected z > 8 Galaxy Candidates with JWST/NIRSpec: Initial Characterization of their Properties
• Evolution of the UV LF from z~15 to z~8 Using New JWST NIRCam Medium-Band Observations over the HUDF/XDF
• Essential physics of early galaxy formation
• Life beyond 30: probing the -20<M_UV<-17 luminosity function at 8<z<13 with the NIRCam parallel field of the MIRI Deep Survey
• The kiloparsec-scale star formation law at redshift 4: wide-spread, highly efficient star formation in the dust-obscured starburst galaxy GN20
• Extreme Value Statistics of the Halo and Stellar Mass Distributions at High Redshift: are JWST Results in Tension with ΛCDM?
• Non-parametric Star Formation History Reconstruction with Gaussian Processes I: Counting Major Episodes of Star Formation
• The Universe at z>10: Predictions for JWST from the UniverseMachine DR1
• Dusty Starbursts Masquerading as Ultra-high Redshift Galaxies in JWST CEERS Observations
• UV Luminosity Density Results at z>8 from the First JWST/NIRCam Fields: Limitations of Early Data Sets and the Need for Spectroscopy
• The ALMA REBELS Survey: the dust content of $z\sim 7$ Lyman Break Galaxies
• Early Results from GLASS-JWST. XIX: A High Density of Bright Galaxies at $z\approx 10$ in the Abell 2744 Region
• Astraeus I: The interplay between galaxy formation and reionization
• A Census of the Bright z=8.5-11 Universe with the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes in the CANDELS Fields
• The ultraviolet continuum slopes ($\beta$) of galaxies at $\mathbf{z}\simeq 8-16$ from JWST and ground-based near-infrared imaging
• Balancing the efficiency and stochasticity of star formation with dust extinction in z > 10 galaxies observed by JWST
• Searching for Extremely Blue UV Continuum Slopes at $z=7-11$ in JWST/NIRCam Imaging: Implications for Stellar Metallicity and Ionizing Photon Escape in Early Galaxies
• A Search for H-Dropout Lyman Break Galaxies at z~12-16
• Stochastic star formation in early galaxies: JWST implications
• The MillenniumTNG Project: The galaxy population at $z\ge 8$
• On the ages of bright galaxies $\sim 500$ Myr after the Big Bang: insights into star formation activity at $z\gtrsim 15$ with JWST
• Closing in on the sources of cosmic reionization: first results from the GLASS-JWST program
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- IV. Implications for cosmic reionization and LyC escape fraction
• H-alpha emission in local galaxies: star formation, time variability and the diffuse ionized gas
• Morphologies of Galaxies at $z\gtrsim 9$ Uncovered by JWST/NIRCam Imaging: Cosmic Size Evolution and an Identification of an Extremely Compact Bright Galaxy at $z\sim 12$
• Early results from GLASS-JWST. XI: Stellar masses and mass-to-light ratio of z>7 galaxies
• The Dependence of Theoretical Synthetic Spectra on $\alpha$-enhancement in Young, Binary Stellar Populations
• High-Redshift Galaxies from Early JWST Observations: Constraints on Dark Energy Models
• First Light And Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) V: The redshift frontier
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- VI. Simulated lightcones and galaxy clustering predictions
• Fundamental physics with the Hubble Frontier Fields: constraining Dark Matter models with the abundance of extremely faint and distant galaxies
• Probing the Bright End of the Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Luminosity Function at z = 8-10 with Hubble Pure-Parallel Imaging
• Mock Lightcones and Theory Friendly Catalogs for the CANDELS Survey
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- III. Intrinsic production efficiency of Lyman-continuum radiation
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST -- V. AGN luminosity functions and helium reionization at z = 2-7
• Photometric properties of reionization-epoch galaxies in the Simba simulations
• Using [Ne V]/[Ne III] to Understand the Nature of Extreme-Ionization Galaxies
• Cosmic variance of $z>7$ galaxies: Prediction from BlueTides
• Schrodinger's Galaxy Candidate: Puzzlingly Luminous at $z\approx 17$, or Dusty/Quenched at $z\approx 5$?
• Are the Newly-Discovered $z\sim 13$ Drop-out Sources Starburst Galaxies or Quasars?
• The Star-forming and Ionizing Properties of Dwarf z~6-9 Galaxies in JADES: Insights on Bursty Star Formation and Ionized Bubble Growth
• Galaxy Formation in the Santa Cruz semi-analytic model compared with IllustrisTNG -- I. Galaxy scaling relations, dispersions, and residuals at z=0
• CEERS: Diversity of Lyman-Alpha Emitters during the Epoch of Reionization
• The Next Generation Deep Extragalactic Exploratory Public (NGDEEP) Survey
• Bright z~9 Galaxies in Parallel: The Bright End of the Rest-UV Luminosity Function from HST Parallel Programs
• COSMOS-Web: Intrinsically Luminous z$\gtrsim$10 Galaxy Candidates Test Early Stellar Mass Assembly
• Building the First Galaxies -- Chapter 2. Starbursts Dominate The Star Formation Histories of 6 < z <12 Galaxies
• New insight on the nature of cosmic reionizers from the CEERS survey
• Characterising ultra-high-redshift dark matter halo demographics and assembly histories with the GUREFT simulations

Cited by in corpus (48)

• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Feedback-Free Starbursts at Cosmic Dawn: Observable Predictions for JWST
• EPOCHS IV: SED Modelling Assumptions and their impact on the Stellar Mass Function at 6.5 < z < 13.5 using PEARLS and public JWST observations
• Quantifying the Effects of Known Unknowns on Inferred High-redshift Galaxy Properties: Burstiness, the IMF, and Nebular Physics
• Identification of a transition from stochastic to secular star formation around $z=9$ with JWST
• The UNCOVER Survey: A First-look HST+JWST Catalog of Galaxy Redshifts and Stellar Population Properties Spanning $0.2\lesssim z\lesssim 15$
• The impact of an evolving stellar initial mass function on early galaxies and reionisation
• Seven wonders of Cosmic Dawn: JWST confirms a high abundance of galaxies and AGNs at z $\simeq$ 9-11 in the GLASS field
• ASTRODEEP-JWST: NIRCam-HST multiband photometry and redshifts for half a million sources in six extragalactic deep fields
• Elevated UV luminosity density at Cosmic Dawn explained by non-evolving, weakly mass-dependent star formation efficiency
• Transition dynamics in the ${\Lambda }_{\mathrm{s}}$CDM model: Implications for bound cosmic structures
• Redshift-dependent galaxy formation efficiency at $z=5-13$ in the FirstLight simulations
• Density modulated star formation efficiency: implications for the observed abundance of ultra-violet luminous galaxies at z>10
• DESI Dark Energy Time Evolution is Recovered by Cosmologically Coupled Black Holes
• Synergising semi-analytical models and hydrodynamical simulations to interpret JWST data from the first billion years
• On the Significance of Rare Objects at High Redshift: The Impact of Cosmic Variance
• Exploiting synergies between JWST and cosmic 21-cm observations to uncover star formation in the early Universe
• Growth of Massive Black-Holes in FFB Galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
• Modelling the star-formation activity and ionizing properties of high-redshift galaxies
• Tracing the galaxy-halo connection with galaxy clustering in COSMOS-Web from z = 0.1 to z ~ 12
• A kiloparsec-scale ordered magnetic field in a galaxy at z=5.6
• Pushing JWST to the extremes: search and scrutiny of bright galaxy candidates at z$\simeq$15-30
• ΛCDM is still not broken: empirical constraints on the star formation efficiency at z ~ 12-30
• The impact of medium-width bands on the selection, and subsequent luminosity function measurements, of high-z galaxies
• The first GLIMPSE of the faint galaxy population at Cosmic Dawn with JWST: The evolution of the ultraviolet luminosity function across z~9-15
• Exploring Cosmic Dawn with PANORAMIC I: The Bright End of the UVLF at $z\sim 9-17$
• The BoRG-$JWST$ Survey: Abundance and Mass-to-light Ratio of Luminous $z=7-9$ Galaxies from Independent Sight Lines with NIRSpec
• Discord in Concordance Cosmology and Anomalously Massive Early Galaxies
• Probing galaxy evolution from $z=0$ to $z\simeq 10$ through galaxy scaling relations in three L-Galaxies flavours
• The THESAN-ZOOM project: Star-formation efficiencies in high-redshift galaxies
• The THESAN-ZOOM project: Star formation efficiency from giant molecular clouds to galactic scale in high-redshift starbursts
• Impact of star formation models on the growth of simulated galaxies at high redshifts
• A Differentiable, End-to-End Forward Model for 21 cm Cosmology: Estimating the Foreground, Instrument, and Signal Joint Posterior
• CEERS: Forging the First Dust Grains in the Universe? A Population of Galaxies with spectroscopically-derived Extremely Low Dust Attenuation (GELDA) at 4.0<z<11.4
• Mysteries of Capotauro: investigating the puzzling nature of an extreme F356W-dropout
• Can an Anti-de Sitter Vacuum in the Dark Energy Sector Explain JWST High-Redshift Galaxy and Reionization Observations?
• Investigating cosmic strings using large-volume hydrodynamical simulations in the context of JWST's massive UV-bright galaxies
• Can Dark Stars account for the star formation efficiency excess at very high redshifts?
• Radiation-driven dusty outflows from early galaxies
• Deeper detection limits in astronomical imaging using self-supervised spatiotemporal denoising
• Stringent constraint on the CCC+TL cosmology with $H(z)$ Measurements
• The AGORA High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. X: Formation and Evolution of Galaxies at the High-redshift Frontier
• Relatively Fast and Reasonably Furious: Evidence for Increased Burstiness in Smaller Halos at Cosmic Dawn
• Dark Secrets of Baryons: Illuminating Dark Matter-Baryon Interactions with JWST
• A physically-motivated template set for high-z galaxy SED fitting
• The Cosmic Rush Hour: Rapid Formation of Bright, Massive, Disky, Star-Forming Galaxies as Signatures of Early-Universe Physics
• Power spectrum multipoles and clustering wedges during the Epoch of Reionization
• The Nature of High-Redshift Massive Quiescent Galaxies -- Searching for RUBIES-UDS-QG-z7 in FLARES