Breaking the Curve with CANDELS: A Bayesian Approach to Reveal the Non-Universality of the Dust-Attenuation Law at High Redshift

Abstract

Dust attenuation affects nearly all observational aspects of galaxy evolution, yet very little is known about the form of the dust-attenuation law in the distant Universe. Here, we model the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of galaxies at z = 1.5--3 from CANDELS with rest-frame UV to near-IR imaging under different assumptions about the dust law, and compare the amount of inferred attenuated light with the observed infrared (IR) luminosities. Some individual galaxies show strong Bayesian evidence in preference of one dust law over another, and this preference agrees with their observed location on the plane of infrared excess (IRX, $L_{\text{TIR}}/L_{\text{UV}}$) and UV slope ($\beta$). We generalize the shape of the dust law with an empirical model, $A_{\lambda ,\delta }=E(B-V)k_{\lambda }(\lambda /{\lambda }_V{)}^{\delta }$ where $k_{\lambda }$ is the dust law of Calzetti et al. (2000), and show that there exists a correlation between the color excess $E(B-V)$ and tilt $\delta$ with $\delta =(0.62\pm 0.05)\log (E(B-V))$+ $(0.26\pm 0.02)$. Galaxies with high color excess have a shallower, starburst-like law, and those with low color excess have a steeper, SMC-like law. Surprisingly, the galaxies in our sample show no correlation between the shape of the dust law and stellar mass, star-formation rate, or $\beta$. The change in the dust law with color excess is consistent with a model where attenuation is caused by by scattering, a mixed star-dust geometry, and/or trends with stellar population age, metallicity, and dust grain size. This rest-frame UV-to-near-IR method shows potential to constrain the dust law at even higher ($z>3$) redshifts.

arXiv comment20 pages, 18 figures, resubmitted to ApJ

References in corpus (119)

• Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
• Star Formation in Galaxies Along the Hubble Sequence
• The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• CANDELS: The Cosmic Assembly Near-infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey
• CANDELS: The Cosmic Assembly Near-infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey - The Hubble Space Telescope Observations, Imaging Data Products and Mosaics
• EAZY: A Fast, Public Photometric Redshift Code
• A Simple Model for the Absorption of Starlight by Dust in Galaxies
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey: Initial Results From Optical and Near-Infrared Imaging
• A Quantitative Comparison of SMC, LMC, and Milky Way UV to NIR Extinction Curves
• From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling III: model calibration, comparison, and evaluation
• Dust Absorption And The Ultraviolet Luminosity Density At z \approx 3 As Calibrated By Local Starburst Galaxies
• GOODS-Herschel: an infrared main sequence for star-forming galaxies
• Detection of quiescent galaxies in a bicolor sequence from z=0-2
• The Hubble Ultra Deep Field
• The Infrared Spectral Energy Distribution of Normal Star-Forming Galaxies: Calibration at Far-Infrared and Submillimeter Wavelengths
• The Dust Opacity of Star-Forming Galaxies
• Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift
• Galaxy Structure and Mode of Star Formation in the SFR-Mass Plane from z ~ 2.5 to z ~ 0.1
• Infrared Emission from Interstellar Dust. I. Stochastic Heating of Small Grains
• Scattering by Interstellar Dust Grains: Optical and Ultraviolet
• Identifying Luminous AGN in Deep Surveys: Revised IRAC Selection Criteria
• Strong Nebular Line Ratios in the Spectra of z~2-3 Star-forming Galaxies: First Results from KBSS-MOSFIRE
• Dust-Corrected Star Formation Rates of Galaxies. I. Combinations of H-alpha and Infrared Tracers
• Determining Star Formation Rates for Infrared Galaxies
• The Stellar Populations and Evolution of Lyman Break Galaxies
• The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 4 Ms Source Catalogs
• Dust Formation in Primordial Type II Supernovae
• Star Formation and Dust Attenuation Properties in Galaxies from a Statistical UV-to-FIR Analysis
• CANDELS Multi-wavelength Catalogs: Source Detection and Photometry in the GOODS-South Field
• The Abundance of Star-Forming Galaxies in the Redshift Range 8.5 to 12: New Results from the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field Campaign
• Starbursts and Star Clusters in the Ultraviolet
• The Interstellar Medium In Galaxies Seen A Billion Years After The Big Bang
• The evolution of amorphous hydrocarbons in the ISM: dust modelling from a new vantage point
• Galaxy Evolution in Cosmological Simulations with Outflows II: Metallicities and Gas Fractions
• Dust in the Early Universe: Dust Formation in the Ejecta of Population III Supernovae
• On Star Formation Rates and Star Formation Histories of Galaxies out to z ~ 3
• The Dust Attenuation Law in Distant Galaxies: Evidence for Variation with Spectral Type
• The Calibration of Monochromatic Far-Infrared Star Formation Rate Indicators
• Two bright submillimeter galaxies in a z=4.05 proto-cluster in GOODS-North, and accurate radio-infrared photometric redshifts
• What do we learn from IRAC observations of galaxies at 2 < z < 3.5?
• A Critical Assessment of Photometric Redshift Methods: A CANDELS Investigation
• Multiple Scattering in Clumpy Media. II. Galactic Environments
• Dust Obscuration and Metallicity at High Redshift: New Inferences from UV, H-alpha, and 8 Micron Observations of z~2 Star-Forming Galaxies
• Fitting the integrated Spectral Energy Distributions of Galaxies
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey. VLT/FORS2 Spectroscopy in the GOODS-South Field: Part III
• The Evolution of the Galaxy Stellar Mass Function at z= 4-8: A Steepening Low-mass-end Slope with Increasing Redshift
• Star Formation and Extinction in Redshift z~2 Galaxies: Inferences from Spitzer MIPS Observations
• Spitzer Observations of Massive Red Galaxies at High Redshift
• The Relation Between SFR and Stellar Mass for Galaxies at 3.5 $\le z\le$ 6.5 in CANDELS
• Dust attenuation in the nearby Universe: comparison between galaxies selected in the ultraviolet or in the infrared
• CANDELS: The Evolution of Galaxy Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Colors from z = 8 to 4
• The HST eXtreme Deep Field XDF: Combining all ACS and WFC3/IR Data on the HUDF Region into the Deepest Field Ever
• Evidence for Ubiquitous, High-EW Nebular Emission in z~7 Galaxies: Towards a Clean Measurement of the Specific Star Formation Rate using a Sample of Bright, Magnified Galaxies
• The Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 Early Release Science data: Panchromatic Faint Object Counts for 0.2-2 microns wavelength
• Stellar masses from the CANDELS survey: the GOODS-South and UDS fields
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey - VLT/VIMOS Spectroscopy in the GOODS-South Field: Part II
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey. VLT/VIMOS Spectroscopy in the GOODS-South Field
• Dust Formation In Early Galaxies
• Radial distribution of stars, gas and dust in SINGS galaxies. II. Derived dust properties
• Recovering galaxy stellar population properties from broad-band spectral energy distribution fitting
• The MOSDEF Survey: Excitation Properties of $z\sim 2.3$ Star-forming Galaxies
• GOODS-Herschel Measurements of the Dust Attenuation of Typical Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift: Observations of UV-Selected Galaxies at z~2
• The K20 survey. VII. The spectroscopic catalogue: spectral properties and evolution of the galaxy population
• Production of dust by massive stars at high redshift
• Direct measurements of dust attenuation in z~1.5 star-forming galaxies from 3D-HST: Implications for dust geometry and star formation rates
• GOODS-Herschel:dust attenuation properties of UV selected high redshift galaxies
• The 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field (UDF12): Observational Overview
• The DIRTY Model. I. Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer Through Dust
• How well can we really estimate the stellar masses of galaxies from broadband photometry?
• Spitzer Mid-to-Far-Infrared Flux Densities of Distant Galaxies
• Dust Attenuation in UV-selected Starbursts at High Redshift and their Local Counterparts: Implications for the Cosmic Star Formation Rate Density
• The Rising Star-Formation Histories of Distant Galaxies and Implications for Gas Accretion with Time
• Are Dusty Galaxies Blue? Insights on UV Attenuation from Dust-Selected Galaxies
• Photometric Redshift with Bayesian Priors on Physical Properties of Galaxies
• Thermal Emission from Warm Dust in the Most Distant Quasars
• Dust Extinction in High-z Galaxies with GRB Afterglow Spectroscopy - The 2175Å Feature at z=2.45
• Insights into the content and spatial distribution of dust from the integrated spectral properties of galaxies
• Lyman-alpha emission properties of simulated galaxies: interstellar medium structure and inclination effects
• The IRX-beta relation on sub-galactic scales in star-forming galaxies of the Herschel Reference Survey
• The Flux Ratio Method for Determining the Dust Attenuation of Starburst Galaxies
• The VLA Survey of the Chandra Deep Field South. V. Evolution and Luminosity Functions of sub-mJy radio sources and the issue of radio emission in radio-quiet AGN
• Colour corrections for high redshift objects due to intergalactic attenuation
• Relative merits of different types of rest-frame optical observations to constrain galaxy physical parameters
• Improving the Estimation of Star formation Rates and Stellar Population Ages of High-redshift Galaxies from Broadband Photometry
• A Near-Infrared Spectroscopic Survey of K-selected Galaxies at z~2.3: Redshifts and Implications for Broadband Photometric Studies
• Morphology and Size Differences between Local & High Redshift Luminous Infrared Galaxies
• Lyman alpha Resonant Scattering in Young Galaxies - Predictions from Cosmological Simulations
• GMASS ultradeep spectroscopy of galaxies at z ~ 2. IV. The variety of dust populations
• Dust from AGBs: relevant factors and modelling uncertainties
• Detection of PAH and Far-Infrared Emission from the Cosmic Eye: Probing the Dust and Star Formation of Lyman Break Galaxies
• The role of nuclear activity as the power source of ultraluminous infrared galaxies
• Dust-Induced Systematic Errors in UV-Derived Star Formation Rates
• Diffuse molecular gas at high redshift: Detection of CO molecules and the 2175 Å dust feature at z=1.64
• Dust Attenuation in High Redshift Galaxies -- 'Diamonds in the Sky'
• GOODS-HERSCHEL: evidence for a UV extinction bump in galaxies at z > 1
• Mid-Infrared Determination of Total Infrared Luminosity and Star Formation Rates of Local and High-Redshift Galaxies
• Genesis and evolution of dust in galaxies in the early Universe I. Modeling dust evolution in starburst galaxies
• Ultra-deep Spitzer Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy of LIRGs and ULIRGs at z ~ 1-2
• Quantifying the UV continuum slopes of galaxies to z~10 using deep Hubble and Spitzer/IRAC observations
• The Average Physical Properties and Star Formation Histories of the UV-Brightest Star-Forming Galaxies at z~3.7
• Star-Forming or Starbursting? The Ultraviolet Conundrum
• The Las Campanas Infra-red Survey. V. Keck Spectroscopy of a large sample of Extremely Red Objects
• The Quest for Dusty Star-forming Galaxies at High Redshift z>4
• Presence of dust with a UV bump in massive, star-forming galaxies at 1 < z < 2.5
• UV Opacity in Nearby Galaxies and Application to Distant Galaxies
• Deriving star formation histories from photometry using energy balance spectral energy distribution modelling
• Genesis and evolution of dust in galaxies in the early Universe II. Rapid dust evolution in quasars at z > 6
• Discovery of Lyman Break Galaxies at z~7 from the ZFOURGE Survey
• Star formation histories, extinction, and dust properties of strongly lensed z~1.5-3 star-forming galaxies from the Herschel Lensing Survey
• Evolution of grain size distribution in high-redshift dusty quasars: Integrating large amounts of dust and unusual extinction curves
• Were progenitors of local L* galaxies Lyman-alpha emitters at high redshift?
• The Dust Attenuation Curve versus Stellar Mass for Emission Line Galaxies at z ~ 2
• Measures of star formation rates from Infrared (Herschel) and UV (GALEX) emissions of galaxies in the HerMES fields
• Recovering galaxy stellar population properties from broad-band spectral energy distribution fitting II. The case with unknown redshift
• UV to IR Luminosities and Dust Attenuation Determined from ~4000 K-Selected Galaxies at 1<z<3 in the ZFOURGE Survey
• A Correlation Between Lyα Spectral Line Profile and Rest-Frame UV Morphology
• Dusty galaxies and the degeneracy between their dust distributions and the attenuation formula

Cited by in corpus (103)

• Dust Attenuation Curves in the Local Universe: Demographics and New Laws for Star-forming Galaxies and High-redshift Analogs
• Deriving Physical Properties from Broadband Photometry with Prospector: Description of the Model and a Demonstration of its Accuracy Using 129 Galaxies in the Local Universe
• GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Star Formation Rates, Stellar Masses and Dust Attenuations of 700,000 Low-redshift Galaxies
• How to measure galaxy star-formation histories I: Parametric models
• The Dust Attenuation Law in Galaxies
• An Older, More Quiescent Universe from Panchromatic SED Fitting of the 3D-HST Survey
• Star-Forming Galaxies at Cosmic Noon
• The HDUV Survey: A Revised Assessment of the Relationship between UV Slope and Dust Attenuation for High-Redshift Galaxies
• On the Stellar Populations of Galaxies at z=9-11: The Growth of Metals and Stellar Mass at Early Times
• The Star Formation Main Sequence in the Hubble Space Telescope Frontier Fields
• The Constant Average Relationship between Dust-obscured Star Formation and Stellar Mass from $z=0$ to $z=2.5$
• The evolution of star formation histories of quiescent galaxies
• The Art of Measuring Physical Parameters in Galaxies: A Critical Assessment of Spectral Energy Distribution Fitting Techniques
• Fast, Slow, Early, Late: Quenching Massive Galaxies at z~0.8
• High redshift JWST predictions from IllustrisTNG: Dust modelling and galaxy luminosity functions
• Dust attenuation, bulge formation and inside-out cessation of star-formation in Star-Forming Main Sequence galaxies at z~2
• The MOSDEF Survey: Direct Observational Constraints on the Ionizing Photon Production Efficiency, ${\xi }_{\mathrm{ion}}$, at z~2
• Dust attenuation in 2<z<3 star-forming galaxies from deep ALMA observations of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field
• A Theory for the Variation of Dust Attenuation Laws in Galaxies
• The MOSDEF Survey: the Variation of the Dust Attenuation Curve with Metallicity
• Discovery of a dark, massive, ALMA-only galaxy at z~5-6 in a tiny 3-millimeter survey
• Characterizing the UV-to-NIR shape of the dust attenuation curve of IR luminous galaxies up to z$\sim$2
• The IRX-Beta Dust Attenuation Relation in Cosmological Galaxy Formation Simulations
• Spectroscopic Measurements of the Far-Ultraviolet Dust Attenuation Curve at z~3
• Demographics of Star-forming Galaxies since $z\sim 2.5$. I. The $UVJ$ Diagram in CANDELS
• Dissecting the IRX - $\beta$ dust attenuation relation: exploring the physical origin of observed variations in galaxies
• The Nature of Massive Transition Galaxies in CANDELS, GAMA, and Cosmological Simulations
• Beyond UVJ: More Efficient Selection of Quiescent Galaxies With UV / Mid-IR Fluxes
• Radiative Transfer Model of Dust Attenuation Curves in Clumpy, Galactic Environments
• Evolution of cosmic star formation in the SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey
• Cold dust and stellar emissions in dust-rich galaxies observed with ALMA: a challenge for SED-fitting techniques
• Dust scaling relations in a cosmological simulation
• MAGPHYS+photo-z: Constraining the Physical Properties of Galaxies with Unknown Redshifts
• Fade to grey: systematic variation of the galaxy attenuation curves with galaxy properties in EAGLE
• CLEAR I: Ages and Metallicities of Quiescent Galaxies at $1.0<\mathbf{z}<1.8$ Derived from Deep Hubble Space Telescope Grism Data
• Dust attenuation and Halpha emission in a sample of galaxies observed with Herschel at $0.6<z<1.6$
• A Candidate $z\sim 10$ Galaxy Strongly Lensed into a Spatially Resolved Arc
• Quenching of star formation from a lack of inflowing gas to galaxies
• Exploring HeII$\lambda$1640 emission line properties at $z\sim 2-4$
• UVI colour gradients of 0.4<z<1.4 star-forming main sequence galaxies in CANDELS: dust extinction and star formation profiles
• High redshift JWST predictions from IllustrisTNG: II. Galaxy line and continuum spectral indices and dust attenuation curves
• The SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey: The EGS deep field - II. Morphological transformation and multi-wavelength properties of faint submillimetre galaxies
• The Strength of the 2175Å Feature in the Attenuation Curves of Galaxies at 0.1<z<3
• Characterizing Dust Attenuation in Local Star Forming Galaxies: Inclination Effects and the 2175Å Feature
• Photometric properties of reionization-epoch galaxies in the Simba simulations
• The VANDELS survey: Dust attenuation in star-forming galaxies at $\mathbf{z}=3-4$
• Revealing the dust attenuation properties on resolved scales in NGC628 with SWIFT UVOT data
• Dust attenuation evolution in $z\sim 2$-$12$ JWST galaxies
• An alternate approach to measure specific star formation rates at 2<z<7
• A Comparison of the Stellar, CO and Dust-Continuum Emission from Three, Star-Forming HUDF Galaxies at $z\sim 2$
• Dust attenuation law in JWST galaxies at z = 7-8
• Diversity of Galaxy Dust Attenuation Curves Drives the Scatter in the IRX-beta Relation
• A Comprehensive Bayesian Discrimination of the Simple Stellar Population Model, Star Formation History and Dust Attenuation Law in the Spectral Energy Distribution Modeling of Galaxies
• SCUBA-2 Ultra Deep Imaging Eao Survey (Studies) III: Multi-wavelength properties, luminosity functions and preliminary source catalog of 450-$\mu$m-selected galaxies
• Calibration of hybrid resolved star formation rate recipes based on PHANGS-MUSE H$\alpha$ and H$\beta$ maps
• Quenching and the UVJ diagram in the SIMBA cosmological simulation
• The ALPINE-ALMA [CII] survey: dust attenuation curves at z=4.4-5.5
• Early JWST imaging reveals strong optical and NIR color gradients in galaxies at $z\sim 2$ driven mostly by dust
• {\sc mirkwood:} Fast and Accurate SED Modeling Using Machine Learning
• SHARDS: Constraints on the dust attenuation law of star-forming galaxies at z~2
• Investigation of dust attenuation and star formation activity in galaxies hosting GRBs
• How Well Can We Measure Galaxy Dust Attenuation Curves? The Impact of the Assumed Star-Dust Geometry Model in SED Fitting
• The average dust attenuation curve at z~1.3 based on HST grism surveys
• Estimating dust attenuation from galactic spectra. I. methodology and tests
• MUSE stares into the shadows: the high-resolution dust attenuation curve of NGC 5626
• Galaxy inclination and the IRX-beta relation: Effects on UV star-formation rate measurements at intermediate to high redshifts
• Systematic biases in determining dust attenuation curves through galaxy SED fitting
• Unveiling the nature of 11 dusty star-forming galaxies at the peak of cosmic star formation history
• Revisiting Attenuation Curves: the Case of NGC 3351
• pop-cosmos: A comprehensive picture of the galaxy population from COSMOS data
• Evidence for Reduced Specific Star Formation Rates in the Centers of Massive Galaxies at z = 4
• G.A.S. II: Dust extinction in galaxies; Luminosity functions and InfraRed eXcess
• JWST's PEARLS: resolved study of the stellar and dust components in starburst galaxies at cosmic noon
• More is better: Strong constraints on the stellar properties of LEGA-C z ~ 1 galaxies with Prospector
• Variation of the Nebular Dust Attenuation Curve with the Properties of Local Star-forming Galaxies
• An ALMA survey of the SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey UKIDSS/UDS field: Dust attenuation in high-redshift Lyman break Galaxies
• Dust Attenuation Curves at z $\sim$ 0.8 from LEGA-C: Precise Constraints on the Slope and 2175$\mathring{A}$ Bump Strength
• The 2175 Å dust feature in star-forming galaxies at $1.3\le z\le 1.8$: the dependence on stellar mass and specific star formation rate
• Flexible Models for Galaxy Star Formation Histories Both Shift and Scramble the Optical Color-M/L Relationship
• A Variant Stellar-to-nebular Dust Attenuation Ratio on Subgalactic and Galactic Scales
• A deeper look at the dust attenuation law of star-forming galaxies at high redshift
• Evolution of the grain size distribution in Milky Way-like galaxies in post-processed IllustrisTNG simulations
• Insights on star formation histories and physical properties of $1.2\le z\lesssim 4$ Herschel-detected galaxies
• The Star-Forming Interstellar Medium of Lyman Break Galaxy Analogs
• Physical properties of strong 1 < z < 3 Balmer and Paschen lines emitters observed with JWST
• The mass-dependent UVJ diagram at cosmic noon: A challenge for galaxy evolution models and dust radiative transfer
• Decoding the IRX-β dust attenuation relation in star-forming galaxies at intermediate redshift
• Spectroscopic confirmation of a dust-obscured, metal-rich dwarf galaxy at z~5
• The SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey: The EGS deep field -- III. The evolution of faint submillimeter galaxies at $z<4$
• Using Multiple Emission Line Ratios to Constrain the Slope of the Dust Attenuation Law
• Dust Attenuation Curve for Local Subgalactic Star-forming Regions
• Empirical Dust Attenuation Model Leads to More Realistic UVJ Diagram for TNG100 Galaxies
• Detecting episodes of star formation using Bayesian model selection
• Assessing differences between local galaxy dust attenuation and point source extinction within the same environments
• Improved SED-Fitting Assumptions Result in Inside-Out Quenching at $z\sim 0.5$ and Quenching at All Radii Simultaneously at $z\sim 1$
• The viewing angle in AGN SED models, a data-driven analysis
• The Flattening of Dust Attenuation Curve to z=2.5
• The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program results: Type Ia Supernova brightness correlates with host galaxy dust
• Probing star formation and ISM properties using galaxy disk inclination II: Testing typical FUV attenuation corrections out to z$\sim$0.7
• Ultraviolet-to-far-infra-red self-consistent analysis of the stellar populations of massive starburst galaxies at intermediate redshifts
• Spatial disconnection between stellar and dust emissions: the test of the Antennae Galaxies (Arp 244)
• SE3D: Building a radiative transfer emulator to fit panchromatic resolved galaxy observations with 3D models of dust and stars
• Non-Parametric Attenuation Curves in Local Star-Forming Galaxies: Geometry Effect, Dust Evolution, and ISS