No Need for Extreme Stellar Masses at z~7: A Test-case Study of COS-87259

Abstract

Recent controversy regarding the existence of massive (log(M/Msun)>11) galaxies at z>6 poses a challenge for galaxy formation theories. Hence, it is of critical importance to understand the effects of SED fitting methods on stellar mass estimates of Epoch of Reionization galaxies. In this work, we perform a case study on the AGN host galaxy candidate COS-87259 with spectroscopic redshift z=6.853, that is claimed to have an extremely high stellar mass of log(M/Msun)~11.2. We test a suite of different SED fitting algorithms and stellar population models on our independently measured photometry in 17 broad bands for this source. Between five different code setups, the stellar mass estimates for COS-87259 span log(M/Msun)=10.24-11.00, whilst the reduced chi-squared values of the fits are all close to unity within dchi2=1.2, so that the quality of the SED fits is basically indistinguishable. Only when we adopt a nonparametric star formation history model within Prospector do we retrieve a stellar mass exceeding log(M/Msun)=11. Although the derived stellar masses change when using previously reported photometry for this source, the nonparametric SED-fitting method always yields the highest values. As these models are becoming increasingly popular for James Webb Space Telescope high-redshift science, we stress the absolute importance of testing various SED fitting routines particularly on apparently very massive galaxies at such high redshifts.

arXiv comment9 pages, including 2 tables and 2 figures. Published in ApJL

References in corpus (44)

• Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
• The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
• The Astropy Project: Sustaining and Growing a Community-oriented Open-source Project and the Latest Major Release (v5.0) of the Core Package
• Starburst99: Synthesis Models for Galaxies with Active Star Formation
• Correcting for the Effects of Interstellar Extinction
• Infrared Emission from Interstellar Dust. IV. The Silicate-Graphite-PAH Model in the Post-Spitzer Era
• The Cosmic Evolution Survey (COSMOS) -- Overview
• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
• EAZY: A Fast, Public Photometric Redshift Code
• Accurate photometric redshifts for the CFHT Legacy Survey calibrated using the VIMOS VLT Deep Survey
• COSMOS Photometric Redshifts with 30-bands for 2-deg2
• Measuring and Modelling the Redshift Evolution of Clustering: the Hubble Deep Field North
• UltraVISTA: a new ultra-deep near-infrared survey in COSMOS
• Stellar Population Inference with Prospector
• Deriving Physical Properties from Broadband Photometry with Prospector: Description of the Model and a Demonstration of its Accuracy Using 129 Galaxies in the Local Universe
• COSMOS2020: A panchromatic view of the Universe to $z\sim 10$ from two complementary catalogs
• Two Remarkably Luminous Galaxy Candidates at $z\approx 10-12$ Revealed by JWST
• Defining the intrinsic AGN infrared spectral energy distribution and measuring its contribution to the infrared output of composite galaxies
• A Critical Assessment of Photometric Redshift Methods: A CANDELS Investigation
• Third Data Release of the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program
• An Older, More Quiescent Universe from Panchromatic SED Fitting of the 3D-HST Survey
• On the Stellar Populations of Galaxies at z=9-11: The Growth of Metals and Stellar Mass at Early Times
• Galaxy Stellar Mass Functions from z~10 to z~6 using the Deepest Spitzer/IRAC Data: No Significant Evolution in the Stellar-to-Halo Mass Ratio of Galaxies in the First Gyr of Cosmic Time
• The [OIII]$+$H$\beta$ Equivalent Width Distribution at z$\simeq$7: Implications for the Contribution of Galaxies to Reionization
• Extreme Value Statistics of the Halo and Stellar Mass Distributions at High Redshift: are JWST Results in Tension with ΛCDM?
• The stellar mass function of the most massive galaxies at 3<=z<5 in the UKIDSS Ultra Deep Survey
• The Subaru COSMOS 20: Subaru Optical Imaging of the HST COSMOS Field with 20 Filters
• Spitzer bright, UltraVISTA faint sources in COSMOS: the contribution to the overall population of massive galaxies at z=3-7
• A first look at the SMACS0723 JWST ERO: spectroscopic redshifts, stellar masses and star-formation histories
• The Most Massive Galaxies and Black Holes Allowed by $\Lambda$CDM
• The ALMA REBELS Survey: Specific Star-Formation Rates in the Reionization Era
• On the ages of bright galaxies $\sim 500$ Myr after the Big Bang: insights into star formation activity at $z\gtrsim 15$ with JWST
• High-Redshift Galaxies from Early JWST Observations: Constraints on Dark Energy Models
• Spitzer Matching survey of the UltraVISTA ultra-deep Stripes (SMUVS): Full-mission IRAC Mosaics and Catalogs
• Stellar mass functions of galaxies at 4<z<7 from an IRAC-selected sample in COSMOS/UltraVISTA: limits on the abundance of very massive galaxies
• The Evolving Interstellar Medium of Star-Forming Galaxies, as traced by $\text{Stardust}$
• The Number Densities and Stellar Populations of Massive Galaxies at 3 < z < 6: A Diverse, Rapidly Forming Population in the Early Universe
• Radio and Far-IR Emission Associated with a Massive Star-forming Galaxy Candidate at z$\simeq$6.8: A Radio-Loud AGN in the Reionization Era?
• The Spitzer Matching Survey of the UltraVISTA Ultra-deep Stripes (SMUVS): the Evolution of Dusty and Non-Dusty Galaxies with Stellar Mass at z=2-6
• Euclid preparation. XXI. Intermediate-redshift contaminants in the search for $z>6$ galaxies within the Euclid Deep Survey
• Statistical stellar mass corrections for high-z galaxies observed with JWST broad-band filters due to template degeneracies

Cited by in corpus (5)

• EPOCHS IV: SED Modelling Assumptions and their impact on the Stellar Mass Function at 6.5 < z < 13.5 using PEARLS and public JWST observations
• Modeling the JWST high-redshift galaxies with a general formation scenario and the consistency with the $\Lambda$CDM model
• Massive Dark Matter Halos at High Redshift: Implications for Observations in the JWST Era
• JWST ERS Program Q3D: The pitfalls of virial BH mass constraints shown in a z = 3 quasar with an ultramassive host
• Exploring the properties of the obscured hyperluminous quasar COS-87259 at z=6.853