Benchmark problems for continuum radiative transfer. High optical depths, anisotropic scattering, and polarisation

Abstract

Solving the continuum radiative transfer equation in high opacity media requires sophisticated numerical tools. In order to test the reliability of such tools, we present a benchmark of radiative transfer codes in a 2D disc configuration. We test the accuracy of seven independently developed radiative transfer codes by comparing the temperature structures, spectral energy distributions, scattered light images, and linear polarisation maps that each model predicts for a variety of disc opacities and viewing angles. The test cases have been chosen to be numerically challenging, with midplane optical depths up 10^6, a sharp density transition at the inner edge and complex scattering matrices. We also review recent progress in the implementation of the Monte Carlo method that allow an efficient solution to these kinds of problems and discuss the advantages and limitations of Monte Carlo codes compared to those of discrete ordinate codes. For each of the test cases, the predicted results from the radiative transfer codes are within good agreement. The results indicate that these codes can be confidently used to interpret present and future observations of protoplanetary discs.

15 pages, 10 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (10)

• Monte Carlo radiative transfer in protoplanetary disks
• Too little radiation pressure on dust in the winds of oxygen-rich AGB stars
• Probing dust grain evolution in IM Lupi's circumstellar disc. Multi-wavelength observations and modelling of the dust disc
• A Tale of Two Herbig Ae stars -MWC275 and AB Aurigae: Comprehensive Models for SED and Interferometry
• The Inner Rim of YSO Disks: Effects of dust grain evolution
• The AU Microscopii Debris Disk: Multiwavelength Imaging and Modeling
• The inner radius of T Tauri disks estimated from near-infrared interferometry: the importance of scattered light
• On the stratified dust distribution of the GG Tau circumbinary ring
• Multiwavelength studies of the gas and dust disc of IRAS 04158+2805
• Modeling Spitzer observations of VV Ser. II. an extended quantum heated nebula and a disk shadow

Cited by in corpus (219)

• Comparing the statistics of interstellar turbulence in simulations and observations: Solenoidal versus compressive turbulence forcing
• Dust and Gas in the disc of HL Tauri: Surface density, dust settling, and dust-to-gas ratio
• Consistent dust and gas models for protoplanetary disks. I. Disk shape, dust settling, opacities, and PAHs
• Kinematic evidence for an embedded protoplanet in a circumstellar disc
• The ancient heritage of water ice in the solar system
• The inner regions of protoplanetary disks
• The warm gas atmosphere of the HD 100546 disk seen by Herschel (Evidence of a gas-rich, carbon-poor atmosphere?)
• Millimeter-wave polarization of protoplanetary disks due to dust scattering
• Survival of molecular gas in cavities of transition disks (I. CO)
• HYPERION: An open-source parallelized three-dimensional dust continuum radiative transfer code
• Constraining the X-ray and Cosmic Ray Ionization Chemistry of the TW Hya Protoplanetary Disk: Evidence for a Sub-interstellar Cosmic Ray Rate
• Exclusion of Cosmic Rays in Protoplanetary Disks: Stellar and Magnetic Effects
• Direct mapping of the temperature and velocity gradients in discs. Imaging the vertical CO snow line around IM Lupi
• Unveiling the gas and dust disk structure in HD 163296 using ALMA observations
• The Coupled Physical Structure of Gas and Dust in the IM Lup Protoplanetary Disk
• Observations of edge-on protoplanetary disks with ALMA I. Results from continuum data
• Kinematic detection of a planet carving a gap in a protoplanetary disc
• Circumbinary, not transitional: On the spiral arms, cavity, shadows, fast radial flows, streamers and horseshoe in the HD142527 disc
• Three-Dimensional Dust Radiative Transfer
• Radiative transfer with POLARIS: I. Analysis of magnetic fields through synthetic dust continuum polarization measurements
• Nine localised deviations from Keplerian rotation in the DSHARP circumstellar disks: Kinematic evidence for protoplanets carving the gaps
• Identifying gaps in flaring Herbig Ae/Be disks using spatially resolved mid-infrared imaging. Are all group I disks transitional?
• Three-Dimensional Radiation Transfer in Young Stellar Objects
• The complex structure of the disk around HD100546: the inner few astronomical units
• A highly settled disk around Oph 163131
• The polarimetric imaging mode of VLT/SPHERE/IRDIS II: Characterization and correction of instrumental polarization effects
• GASPS - a Herschel survey of gas and dust in Protoplanetary Disks: Summary and Initial Statistics
• Non-negative Matrix Factorization: Robust Extraction of Extended Structures
• Probing the turbulent mixing strength in protoplanetary disks across the stellar mass range: no significant variations
• A cavity and further radial substructures in the disk around HD~97048
• Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer
• Exclusion of Cosmic Rays in Protoplanetary Disks. II. Chemical Gradients and Observational Signatures
• Consistent dust and gas models for protoplanetary disks III. Models for selected objects from the FP7 DIANA project
• Polarized disk emission from Herbig Ae/Be stars observed using Gemini Planet Imager: HD 144432, HD 150193, HD 163296, and HD 169142
• Submillimetre dust polarisation and opacity in the HD163296 protoplanetary ring system
• Keck/NIRC2 $L$'-Band Imaging of Jovian-Mass Accreting Protoplanets around PDS 70
• Constraining the structure of the planet-forming region in the disk of the Herbig Be star HD 100546
• ALMA images of discs: are all gaps carved by planets?
• The unusual protoplanetary disk around the T Tauri star ET Cha
• Non-azimuthal linear polarization in protoplanetary disks
• A Herschel Survey of Cold Dust in Disks Around Brown Dwarfs and Low-Mass Stars
• Flybys in protoplanetary discs: II. Observational signatures
• Radiation thermo-chemical models of protoplanetary discs. IV Modelling CO ro-vibrational emission from Herbig Ae discs
• Multiple Carbon monoxide Snow-lines in Disks Sculpted by Radial Drift
• On the stability of radiation-pressure-dominated cavities
• Spiral Arms and a Massive Dust Disk with non-Keplerian Kinematics: Possible Evidence for Gravitational Instability in the Disk of Elias 2-27
• The 2008 outburst of EX Lup - silicate crystals in motion
• Detection of CH+ emission from the disc around HD100546
• Radial Surface Density Profiles of Gas and Dust in the Debris Disk around 49 Ceti
• An interferometric study of the Fomalhaut inner debris disk. III. Detailed models of the exozodiacal disk and its origin
• Multiple spiral arms in the disk around intermediate-mass binary HD 34700A
• Dust masses of disks around 8 Brown Dwarfs and Very Low-Mass Stars in Upper Sco OB1 and Ophiuchus
• Benchmarking the Calculation of Stochastic Heating and Emissivity of Dust Grains in the Context of Radiative Transfer Simulations
• Spatial segregation of dust grains in transition disks. SPHERE observations of 2MASS J16083070-3828268 and RXJ1852.3-3700
• Planet gaps in the dust layer of 3D protoplanetary disks. II. Observability with ALMA
• Uncertainties in water chemistry in disks: An application to TW Hya
• The effects of disk and dust structure on observed polarimetric images of protoplanetary disks
• The accumulation and trapping of grains at planet gaps: effects of grain growth and fragmentation
• Scattered light shadows in warped protoplanetary discs
• Constraining the structure of the transition disk HD 135344B (SAO 206462) by simultaneous modeling of multiwavelength gas and dust observations
• The Herschel DIGIT Survey of Weak-line T Tauri Stars: implications for disk evolution and dissipation
• Signatures of an eccentric disc cavity: Dust and gas in IRS 48
• A family portrait of disk inner rims around Herbig Ae/Be stars: Hunting for warps, rings, self shadowing, and misalignments in the inner astronomical units
• Sculpting the disk around T Cha: an interferometric view
• A Herschel Search For Cold Dust in Brown Dwarf Disks: First Results
• Grand challenges in protoplanetary disc modelling
• Gravitational instability in a planet-forming disk
• Gas lines from the 5-Myr old optically thin disk around HD141569A. Herschel observations and modeling
• First Scattered-Light Image of the Debris Disk around HD 131835 with the Gemini Planet Imager
• Predicting the kinematic evidence of gravitational instability
• Low abundance, strong features: Window-dressing crystalline forsterite in the disk wall of HD 100546
• Gas in the protoplanetary disc of HD 169142: Herschel's view
• Investigating dust trapping in transition disks with millimeter-wave polarization
• Radiation thermo-chemical models of protoplanetary discs. III. Impact of inner rims on Spectral Energy Distributions
• An Exo-Kuiper Belt and An Extended Halo around HD 191089 in Scattered Light
• Radiation-hydrodynamical simulations of massive star formation using Monte Carlo radiative transfer II. The formation of a 25 solar-mass star
• Herschel Observations of the T Cha Transition Disk: Constraining the Outer Disk Properties
• An algorithm for Monte-Carlo time-dependent radiation transfer
• Characterization of the inner disk around HD 141569 A from Keck/NIRC2 L-band vortex coronagraphy
• The asymmetric inner disk of the Herbig Ae star HD 163296 in the eyes of VLTI/MATISSE: evidence for a vortex?
• Detecting stellar-wind bubbles through infrared arcs in HII regions
• The Failure of Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer at Medium to High Optical Depths
• TORUS-3DPDR: A self-consistent code treating three-dimensional photoionization and photodissociation regions
• New constraints on the disk characteristics and companion candidates around T Cha with VLT/SPHERE
• The Taurus Boundary of Stellar/Substellar (TBOSS) Survey II. Disk Masses from ALMA Continuum Observations
• Composite biasing in Monte Carlo radiative transfer
• ALMA study of the HD 100453 AB system and the tidal interaction of the companion with the disk
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• Are the spiral arms in the MWC 758 protoplanetary disc driven by a companion inside the cavity?
• Directly observing continuum emission from self-gravitating spiral waves
• The reliability of approximate radiation transport methods for irradiated disk studies
• A likely flyby of binary protostar Z CMa caught in action
• TRUST I: A 3D externally illuminated slab benchmark for dust radiative transfer
• Dust properties and disk structure of evolved protoplanetary disks in Cep OB2: Grain growth, settling, gas and dust mass, and inside-out evolution
• exoALMA V: Gaseous Emission Surfaces and Temperature Structures
• Modest dust settling in the IRAS04302+2247 Class I protoplanetary disk
• Multiband GPI Imaging of the HR 4796A Debris Disk
• Spatially resolved imaging of the two-component eta Crv debris disk with Herschel
• Polarization in Monte Carlo radiative transfer and dust scattering polarization signatures of spiral galaxies
• Using Data Imputation for Signal Separation in High Contrast Imaging
• Three-dimensional molecular line transfer: A simulated star-forming region
• Spatially resolved HCN J=4--3 and CS J=7--6 emission from the disk around HD 142527
• Long lived dust rings around HD169142
• Inner disk clearing around the Herbig Ae star HD\,139614: Evidence for a planet-induced gap ?
• On the rise times in FU Orionis events
• Gas inside the 97 au cavity around the transition disk Sz\,91
• A Herschel PACS survey of the dust and gas in Upper Scorpius disks
• ALMA 870 $\mu$m continuum observations of HD 100546. Evidence of a giant planet on a wide orbit
• A new hybrid radiative transfer method for massive star formation
• Planet migration, resonant locking and accretion streams in PDS70: Comparing models and data
• HST Scattered Light Imaging and Modeling of the Edge-on Protoplanetary Disk ESO-H$\alpha$ 569
• CO ro-vibrational lines in HD100546: A search for disc asymmetries and the role of fluorescence
• Evidence for a Cosmic Ray Gradient in the IM Lup Protoplanetary Disk
• Consistent dust and gas models for protoplanetary disks IV. A panchromatic view of protoplanetary disks
• Mapping the Planetary Wake in HD 163296 with Kinematics
• HD 143006: circumbinary planet or misaligned disc?
• Circumbinary and circumstellar discs around the eccentric binary IRAS 04158+2805 -- a testbed for binary-disc interaction
• New constraints on the dust surrounding HR 4796A
• Diversity in the outcome of dust radial drift in protoplanetary discs
• Spirals, shadows & precession in HD 100453 -- I. The orbit of the binary
• Rocking shadows in broken circumbinary discs
• Simulating Observations of Ices in Protoplanetary Disks
• High resolution observations of the outer disk around T Cha: the view from ALMA
• Binary-induced spiral arms inside the disc cavity of AB Aurigae
• Sustained FU Orionis-type outbursts from colliding discs in stellar flybys
• The ALMA view of MP Mus (PDS 66): a protoplanetary disk with no visible gaps down to 4 au scales
• The Taurus Boundary of Stellar/Substellar (TBOSS) Survey I: far-IR disk emission measured with Herschel
• The Anatomy of an Unusual Edge-on Protoplanetary Disk. II. Gas temperature and a warm outer region
• Shadows, gaps, and ring-like structures in protoplanetary disks
• Herschel survey of brown dwarf disks in Rho Ophiuchi
• The Herschel view of Gas in Protoplanetary Systems (GASPS). First comparisons with a large grid of models
• GW Ori: circumtriple rings and planets
• An upper limit on the mass of the circumplanetary disk for DH Tau b
• The Anatomy of an Unusual Edge-on Protoplanetary Disk I. Dust Settling in a Cold Disk
• The inner dust shell of Betelgeuse detected by polarimetric aperture-masking interferometry
• Radiative transfer on hierarchial grids
• The dynamics of inner dead-zone boundaries in protoplanetary disks
• Modelling circumstellar discs with 3D radiation hydrodynamics
• Dust growth, fragmentation and self-induced dust traps in PHANTOM
• The color dependent morphology of the post-AGB star HD161796
• The Circumstellar Disk and Asymmetric outflow of the EX Lup Outburst System
• Resolving The Moth at Millimeter Wavelengths
• Super-Earths in the TW Hya disc
• Spirals, shadows & precession in HD 100453 -- II. The hidden companion
• The surprising evolution of the shadow on the TW Hya disk
• Analysis of the arm-like structure in the outer disk of PDS 70. Spiral density wave or vortex?
• DZ Cha: a bona fide photoevaporating disc
• Disk Masses and Dust Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks Around Brown Dwarfs
• Pebble dynamics and accretion onto rocky planets. II. Radiative models
• Analysing the SEDs of protoplanetary disks with machine learning
• Is the gap in the DS Tau disc hiding a planet?
• Chemical signatures of a warped protoplanetary disc
• Radiation hydrodynamics including irradiation and adaptive mesh refinement with AZEuS. I. Methods
• The Origin of the Doppler-flip in HD 100546: a large scale spiral arm generated by an inner binary companion
• On the role of the H2 ortho:para ratio in gravitational collapse during star formation
• Evolution from protoplanetary to debris discs: The transition disc around HD 166191
• Kinematic evidence for an embedded planet in the IM Lupi disc
• A proposed new diagnostic for Herbig disc geometry: FWHM versus J of CO ro-vibrational lines
• Chemical composition of the circumstellar disk around AB Aurigae
• Rapid radiative clearing of protoplanetary discs
• Probing the eccentricity in protostellar discs -- Modeling kinematics and morphologies
• The Foggy Disks Surrounding Herbig Ae Stars: a Theoretical Study of the H2O Line Spectra
• A kinematic excess in the annular gap and gas depleted cavity in the disc around HD 169142
• Nature of the gas and dust around 51 Oph
• Magnetic activity and radial velocity filtering of young Suns: The weak-line T Tauri stars Par 1379 and Par 2244
• On the properties of discs around accreting brown dwarfs
• CAI formation in the early Solar System
• Detection of Near-Infrared Water Ice at the Surface of the (pre)Transitional Disk of AB Aur: Informing Icy Grain Abundance, Composition, and Size
• Kinematic and thermal signatures of the directly imaged protoplanet candidate around Elias 2-24
• Chemical tracers of a highly eccentric AGB-main sequence star binary
• Circumplanetary disk ices. I. Ice formation vs. viscous evolution and grain drift
• Hiding Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets
• Characteristics of small protoplanetary disc warps in kinematic observations
• Morphology of the gas-rich debris disk around HD 121617 with SPHERE observations in polarized light
• Constraining the properties of transitional disks in Chamaeleon I with Herschel
• Synthetic HI observations of a simulated spiral galaxy
• Modeling Nitrogen Fractionation in the Protoplanetary Disk around TW Hya: Model Constraints on Grain Population and Carbon-to-Oxygen Elemental Abundance Ratio
• Atomic line radiative transfer with MCFOST I. Code description and benchmarking
• Confronting Standard Models of Proto--Planetary Disks With New Mid--Infrared Sizes from the Keck Interferometer
• Bayesian fitting of Taurus brown dwarf spectral energy distributions
• The protoplanetary disc around HD 169142: circumstellar or circumbinary?
• A young gas giant and hidden substructures in a protoplanetary disk
• Revisiting equilibrium condensation and rocky planet compositions: Introducing the ECCOplanets code
• Ray-tracing 3D dust radiative transfer with DART-Ray: code upgrade and public release
• Imaging the 44 AU Kuiper Belt-analogue debris ring around HD 141569A with GPI polarimetry
• Weighing protoplanetary discs with kinematics: physical model, method and benchmark
• Bipolar molecular outflow of the very low-mass star Par-Lup3-4
• Observational Signatures of Circumbinary Discs I: Kinematics
• The complex infrared dust continuum emission of NGC1068: ground-based N- and Q-band spectroscopy and new radiative transfer models
• NaCo polarimetric observations of Sz 91 transitional disk: a remarkable case of dust filtering
• Spectroscopic and interferometric signatures of magnetospheric accretion in young stars
• Smoke on the wind: dust nucleation in archetype colliding wind pinwheel WR104
• Locating Hidden Exoplanets in ALMA Data Using Machine Learning
• The disk around the brown dwarf KPNO Tau 3
• Monte Carlo radiative transfer with explicit absorption to simulate absorption, scattering, and stimulated emission
• Narrow belt of debris around the Sco-Cen star HD 141011
• Disks, accretion and outflows of brown dwarfs
• Multiband polarimetric imaging of HD 34700 with SCExAO/CHARIS
• Review and prospects of hot exozodiacal dust research for future exo-Earth direct imaging missions
• V892 Tau: A tidally perturbed circumbinary disc in a triple stellar system
• Continuing to Hide Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets
• Asymmetries in asymptotic giant branch stars and their winds. I. From 3D RHD models to synthetic observables
• Tetrahedral grids in Monte Carlo radiative transfer
• The Nature of Class I Sources: Periodic Variables in Orion
• A near-infrared, optical and ultraviolet polarimetric and timing investigation of complex equatorial dusty structures
• exoALMA XIX: Confirmation of Non-thermal Line Broadening in the DM Tau Protoplanetary Disk
• Kinematic Evidence of an Embedded Protoplanet in HD 142666 Identified by Machine Learning
• Performance of the Gemini Planet Imager Non-Redundant Mask and spectroscopy of two close-separation binaries HR 2690 and HD 142527
• Probing dust and grain growth in the optically thick circumbinary ring of V892 Tau
• Tracing Planetary Accretion in a 3 Gyr-old Hydrogen-Rich White Dwarf: The Extremely Polluted Atmosphere of LSPM J0207+3331
• Constraining protoplanetary disc mass using the GI wiggle
• Paradigmatic examples for testing models of optical light polarization by spheroidal dust
• Searching for planet-driven dust spirals in ALMA visibilities
• Direct Imaging for the Debris Disk around $\epsilon$ Eridani with the Cool-Planet Imaging Coronagraph
• Large Dust Grains and a Possible Dust Trap in the Polar Circumbinary Disc of HD 98800B
• Benchmarking pre-main sequence stellar evolutionary tracks using disk-based dynamical stellar masses
• Investigating 2M1155-7919B: a Nearby, Young, Low-Mass Star Actively Accreting from a Nearly Edge-on, Dusty Disk
• Constraining the mass of the planet(s) sculpting a disk cavity. The intriguing case of 2MASS J16042165-2130284
• Discontinuous Galerkin finite element method for the continuum radiative transfer problem inside axis-symmetric circumstellar envelopes