ALMA images of discs: are all gaps carved by planets?

Abstract

Protoplanetary discs are now routinely observed and exoplanets, after the numerous indirect discoveries, are starting to be directly imaged. To better understand the planet formation process, the next step is the detection of forming planets or of signposts of young planets still in their disc, such as gaps. A spectacular example is the ALMA science verification image of HL Tau showing numerous gaps and rings in its disc. To study the observability of planet gaps, we ran 3D hydrodynamical simulations of a gas and dust disc containing a 5 M J gap-opening planet and characterised the spatial distribution of migrating, growing and fragmenting dust grains. We then computed the corresponding synthetic images for ALMA. For a value of the dust fragmentation threshold of 15 m s --1 for the collisional velocity, we identify for the first time a self-induced dust pile up in simulations taking fragmentation into account. This feature, in addition to the easily detected planet gap, causes a second apparent gap that could be mistaken for the signature of a second planet. It is therefore essential to be cautious in the interpretation of gap detections.

Accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters. 5 pages, 6 figures. MNRAS, Oxford University press, 2015, in press

References in corpus (16)

• First Results from High Angular Resolution ALMA Observations Toward the HL Tau Region
• SPLASH: An interactive visualisation tool for Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations
• Coagulation, fragmentation and radial motion of solid particles in protoplanetary disks
• Gas- and dust evolution in protoplanetary disks
• A comparative study of disc-planet interaction
• Ring shaped dust accumulation in transition disks
• Monte Carlo radiative transfer in protoplanetary disks
• Evidence of fast pebble growth near condensation fronts in the HL Tau protoplanetary disk
• Mass Estimates of a Giant Planet in a Protoplanetary Disk from the Gap Structures
• Gas density drops inside dust cavities of transitional disks around young stars observed with ALMA
• The effect of a planet on the dust distribution in a 3D protoplanetary disk
• Planet gaps in the dust layer of 3D protoplanetary disks. II. Observability with ALMA
• The accumulation and trapping of grains at planet gaps: effects of grain growth and fragmentation
• SPH simulations of grain growth in protoplanetary disks
• Tracing large-scale structures in circumstellar disks with ALMA
• Gas inside the 97 au cavity around the transition disk Sz\,91

Cited by in corpus (58)

• Sintering-induced Dust Ring Formation in Protoplanetary Disks: Application to the HL Tau Disk
• Kinematic evidence for an embedded protoplanet in a circumstellar disc
• The minimum mass of detectable planets in protoplanetary discs and the derivation of planetary masses from high resolution observations
• Kinematic detection of a planet carving a gap in a protoplanetary disc
• The newborn planet population emerging from ring-like structures in discs
• A Multi-Ringed, Modestly-Inclined Protoplanetary Disk around AA Tau
• Flybys in protoplanetary discs: I. Gas and dust dynamics
• On the formation of multiple concentric rings and gaps in protoplanetary disks
• The Ophiuchus DIsc Survey Employing ALMA (ODISEA)-III: the evolution of substructures in massive discs at 3-5 au resolution
• Modeling Dust Emission of HL Tau Disk Based on Planet-Disk Interactions
• Multiple Disk Gaps and Rings Generated by a Single Super-Earth: II. Spacings, Depths, and Number of Gaps, with Application to Real Systems
• The complex morphology of the young disk MWC 758: Spirals and dust clumps around a large cavity
• The VLA view of the HL Tau Disk - Disk Mass, Grain Evolution, and Early Planet Formation
• Rings and gaps in the disc around Elias 24 revealed by ALMA
• A cavity and further radial substructures in the disk around HD~97048
• Characterizing the variable dust permeability of planet-induced gaps
• Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
• An ALMA survey of DCN/H${}^{13}$CN and DCO${}^{+}$/H${}^{13}$CO${}^{+}$ in protoplanetary disks
• An opening criterion for dust gaps in protoplanetary discs
• Two mechanisms for dust gap opening in protoplanetary discs
• Dust-driven viscous ring-instability in protoplanetary disks
• A tunnel and a traffic jam: How transition disks maintain a detectable warm dust component despite the presence of a large planet-carved gap
• SPHERE/SHINE reveals concentric rings in the debris disk of HIP 73145
• Gas and multi-species dust dynamics in viscous protoplanetary discs: the importance of the dust back-reaction
• Multiple rings in the transitional disk of GM Aurigae revealed by VLA and ALMA
• Gas Gaps in the Protoplanetary Disk around the Young Protostar HL Tau
• Grand challenges in protoplanetary disc modelling
• Linear growth of streaming instability in pressure bumps
• Impacts of dust feedback on a dust ring induced by a planet in a protoplanetary disk
• Constraining turbulence mixing strength in transitional discs with planets using SPHERE and ALMA
• Long lived dust rings around HD169142
• The temporal requirements of directly observing self-gravitating spiral waves in protoplanetary discs with ALMA
• Planet migration, resonant locking and accretion streams in PDS70: Comparing models and data
• Evolution of porous dust grains in protoplanetary discs -- I. Growing grains
• A gas density drop in the inner 6 AU of the transition disk around the Herbig Ae star HD 139614: Further evidence for a giant planet inside the disk?
• Trapping planets in an evolving protoplanetary disk: preferred time, locations and planet mass
• Resolved observations of transition disks
• Size and density sorting of dust grains in SPH simulations of protoplanetary discs
• The diverse lives of massive protoplanets in self-gravitating discs
• The inner structure of the TW Hya Disk as revealed in scattered light
• On the Dust Signatures Induced by Eccentric Super-Earths in Protoplanetary Disks
• Properties of Density and Velocity Gaps Induced by a Planet in a Protoplanetary Disk
• The role of gap edge instabilities in setting the depth of planet gaps in protoplanetary discs
• A sub-grid model for the growth of dust particles in hydrodynamical simulations of protoplanetary disks
• DBNets: A publicly available deep learning tool to measure the masses of young planets in dusty protoplanetary discs
• ALMA constraints on assembly of Core Accretion planets
• A Machine Learning model to infer planet masses from gaps observed in protoplanetary disks
• DPNNet-2.0 Part I: Finding hidden planets from simulated images of protoplanetary disk gaps
• Termination of an inward migration of a gap-opening planet triggered by dust feedback
• Gap formation by inclined massive planets in locally isothermal three-dimensional discs
• Why Chromatic Imaging Matters
• Size and density sorting of dust grains in SPH simulations of protoplanetary disc II: Fragmentation
• Dust ring and gap formation by gas flow induced by low-mass planets embedded in protoplanetary disks $\mathrm{I}$. Steady-state model
• Dust Coagulation in the Vicinity of a Gap-Opening Jupiter-Mass Planet
• An upper limit for the growth of inner planets?
• Single Fluid vs. Multifluid: Comparison between single fluid and multifluid dust models for disc planet interactions
• Reading between the rings: observed dust ring properties as probes of planet masses
• Planet Formation Imager: Project Update