Single Fluid vs. Multifluid: Comparison between single fluid and multifluid dust models for disc planet interactions
arXiv:2209.09830 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stac2625
Abstract
Recent observations of substructures such as dust gaps and dust rings in protoplanetary discs have highlighted the importance of including dust into purely gaseous disc models. At the same time, computational difficulties arise with the standard models of simulating the dust and gas separately. These include the cost of accurately simulating the interactions between well coupled dust and gas and issues of dust concentration in areas below resolution of the gas phase. We test a single fluid approach, that incorporates the terminal velocity approximation valid for small particles, which can overcome these difficulties, through modification of FARGO3D. We compare this single fluid model with a multifluid model for a variety of planet masses. We find differences in the dust density distribution in all cases. For high-mass, gap-opening planets we find differences in the amplitude of the resulting dust rings, which we attribute to the failure of the terminal velocity approximation around shocks. For low-mass planets, both models agree everywhere except in the corotation region, where the terminal velocity approximation shows overdense dust lobes. We tentatively interpret these as dusty equivalents of thermal lobes seen in non-isothermal simulations with thermal diffusion, but more work is necessary to confirm this. At the same resolution, the computational time for the terminal velocity approximation model is significantly less than a two fluid model. We conclude that the terminal velocity approximation is a valuable tool for modelling a protoplanetary disc but that care should be taken when shocks are involved.
arXiv comment16 pages, 17 figures, 1 table
References in corpus (61)
- Streaming Instabilities in Protoplanetary Disks
- First Results from High Angular Resolution ALMA Observations Toward the HL Tau Region
- The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): I. Motivation, Sample, Calibration, and Overview
- Ringed Substructure and a Gap at 1 AU in the Nearest Protoplanetary Disk
- Gaps and Rings in an ALMA Survey of Disks in the Taurus Star-forming Region
- A comparative study of disc-planet interaction
- Particle Clumping and Planetesimal Formation Depend Strongly on Metallicity
- The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): VII. The Planet-Disk Interactions Interpretation
- Runaway migration and the formation of hot Jupiters
- Planetary Torques as the Viscosity of Protoplanetary Disks
- Halting Type I planet migration in non-isothermal disks
- On planet formation in HL Tau
- FARGO3D: A new GPU-oriented MHD code
- Planets opening dust gaps in gas disks
- Multiple Disk Gaps and Rings Generated by a Single Super-Earth
- Migration of Protoplanets in Radiative Disks
- On the wake generated by a planet in a disc
- Flybys in protoplanetary discs: I. Gas and dust dynamics
- The interaction of a giant planet with a disc with MHD turbulence II: The interaction of the planet with the disc
- Asymptotically stable numerical method for multispecies momentum transfer: gas and multifluid-dust test suite and implementation in FARGO3D
- Radiation Hydrodynamical Turbulence In Protoplanetary Disks: Numerical Models and Observational Constraints
- Dusty gas with SPH - I. Algorithm and test suite
- Dynamical corotation torques on low-mass planets
- Migration of Earth-size planets in 3D radiative discs
- On the origin of horseshoes in transitional discs
- Dusty gas with one fluid
- A comparison between grid and particle methods on the statistics of driven, supersonic, isothermal turbulence
- On linear dust-gas streaming instabilities in protoplanetary discs
- Coorbital thermal torques on low-mass protoplanets
- Rings and gaps in the disc around Elias 24 revealed by ALMA
- Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
- Dust settling and rings in the outer regions of protoplanetary discs subject to ambipolar diffusion
- A thermodynamic view of dusty protoplanetary disks
- On the accumulation of planetesimals near disc gaps created by protoplanets
- ALMA images of discs: are all gaps carved by planets?
- Flybys in protoplanetary discs: II. Observational signatures
- Migrating super-Earths in low-viscosity discs: unveiling the roles of feedback, vortices, and laminar accretion flows
- A dust and gas cavity in the disc around CQ Tau revealed by ALMA
- On the secular evolution of the ratio between gas and dust radii in protoplanetary discs
- Torques Induced by Scattered Pebble-flow in Protoplanetary Disks
- Polydisperse Streaming Instability I. Tightly coupled particles and the terminal velocity approximation
- Is the ring inside or outside the planet?: The effect of planet migration on dust rings
- Effect of dust radial drift on viscous evolution of gaseous disk
- Corotation torques experienced by planets embedded in weakly magnetized turbulent discs
- Low mass planet migration in magnetically torqued dead zones - I. Static migration torque
- Enforcing dust mass conservation in 3D simulations of tightly-coupled grains with the Phantom SPH code
- Revealing signatures of planets migrating in protoplanetary discs with ALMA multi-wavelength observations
- Planet migration, resonant locking and accretion streams in PDS70: Comparing models and data
- On dust entrainment in photoevaporative winds
- ALMA 870 m continuum observations of HD 100546. Evidence of a giant planet on a wide orbit
- HD 143006: circumbinary planet or misaligned disc?
- Dust growth, fragmentation and self-induced dust traps in PHANTOM
- Dusty disc-planet interaction with dust-free simulations
- Modeling the nonaxisymmetric structure in the HD 163296 disk with planet-disk interaction
- Dynamics of Dusty Vortices I: Extensions and limitations of the terminal velocity approximation
- Is the gap in the DS Tau disc hiding a planet?
- Conditions for justifying single-fluid approximation for charged and neutral dust fluids and a smoothed particle magnetohydrodynamics method for dust-gas mixture
- Observational signatures of eccentric Jupiters inside gas cavities in protoplanetary discs
- Multiplanet systems in inviscid discs can avoid forming resonant chains
- Migrating Low-Mass Planets in Inviscid Dusty Protoplanetary Discs
- Hiding Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets