The Failure of Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer at Medium to High Optical Depths
arXiv:1805.09502 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/aac824
Abstract
Computer simulations of photon transport through an absorbing and/or scattering medium form an important research tool in astrophysics. Nearly all software codes performing such simulations for three-dimensional geometries employ the Monte Carlo radiative transfer method, including various forms of biasing to accelerate the calculations. Because of the probabilistic nature of the Monte Carlo technique, the outputs are inherently noisy, but it is often assumed that the average values provide the physically correct result. We show that this assumption is not always justified. Specifically, we study the intensity of radiation penetrating an infinite, uniform slab of material that absorbs and scatters the radiation with equal probability. The basic Monte Carlo radiative transfer method, without any biasing mechanisms, starts to break down for transverse optical depths above ~20 because so few of the simulated photon packets reach the other side of the slab. When including biasing techniques such as absorption/scattering splitting and path length stretching, the simulated photon packets do reach the other side of the slab but the biased weights do not necessarily add up to the correct solution. While the noise levels seem to be acceptable, the average values sometimes severely underestimate the correct solution. Detecting these anomalies requires the judicious application of statistical tests, similar to those used in the field of nuclear particle transport, possibly in combination with convergence tests employing consecutively larger numbers of photon packets. In any case, for transverse optical depths above ~75 the Monte Carlo methods used in our study fail to solve the one-dimensional slab problem, implying the need for approximations such as a modified random walk.
arXiv commentAccepted for publication in the ApJ; 13 pages, 6 figures
References in corpus (25)
- Infrared Emission from Interstellar Dust. I. Stochastic Heating of Small Grains
- New Interstellar Dust Models Consistent with Extinction, Emission, and Abundance Constraints
- Scattering by Interstellar Dust Grains: Optical and Ultraviolet
- The evolution of amorphous hydrocarbons in the ISM: dust modelling from a new vantage point
- Benchmark problems for continuum radiative transfer. High optical depths, anisotropic scattering, and polarisation
- Efficient 3D NLTE dust radiative transfer with SKIRT
- SKIRT: an Advanced Dust Radiative Transfer Code with a User-Friendly Architecture
- Resolving the complex structure of the dust torus in the active nucleus of the Circinus galaxy
- Radiative transfer in very optically thick circumstellar disks
- HYPERION: An open-source parallelized three-dimensional dust continuum radiative transfer code
- Three-Dimensional Dust Radiative Transfer
- The DIRTY Model. I. Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer Through Dust
- Far-infrared and dust properties of present-day galaxies in the EAGLE simulations
- The Mid-Infrared Spectra of Normal Galaxies
- Modeling Dust Emission of HL Tau Disk Based on Planet-Disk Interactions
- Monte Carlo simulations of dusty spiral galaxies: extinction and polarization properties
- A New Monte Carlo Method for Time-Dependent Neutrino Radiation Transport
- High-resolution, 3D radiative transfer modeling : I. The grand-design spiral galaxy M51
- The Herschel-ATLAS: The dust energy balance in the edge-on spiral galaxy UGC 4754
- Benchmarking the Calculation of Stochastic Heating and Emissivity of Dust Grains in the Context of Radiative Transfer Simulations
- Panchromatic radiative transfer modeling of stars and dust in the Sombrero galaxy
- Composite biasing in Monte Carlo radiative transfer
- TRUST I: A 3D externally illuminated slab benchmark for dust radiative transfer
- On the Modified Random Walk for Monte-Carlo Radiation Transfer
- Radiative transfer in disc galaxies I - A comparison of four methods to solve the transfer equation in plane-parallel geometry
Cited by in corpus (20)
- Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer
- X-ray radiative transfer in full 3D with SKIRT
- Magritte, a modern software library for 3D radiative transfer: I. Non-LTE atomic and molecular line modelling
- Self-consistent dust and non-LTE line radiative transfer with SKIRT
- Arepo-MCRT: Monte Carlo Radiation Hydrodynamics on a Moving Mesh
- Effects of Spatial Discretization in Lyman-alpha Line Radiation Transfer Simulations
- Unbiased Monte Carlo continuum radiative transfer in optically thick regions
- Polarised emission from aligned dust grains in nearby galaxies: predictions from the Auriga simulations
- A new analytical scattering phase function for interstellar dust
- Radiance Cascades: A Novel High-Resolution Formal Solution for Multidimensional Non-LTE Radiative Transfer
- The scattering order problem in Monte Carlo radiative transfer
- Investigating the ultraviolet and infrared radiation through the turbulent life of molecular clouds
- Monte Carlo radiative transfer with explicit absorption to simulate absorption, scattering, and stimulated emission
- Optical depth in polarised Monte Carlo radiative transfer
- Euclid preparation. LXVIII. Extracting physical parameters from galaxies with machine learning
- Kilonova Light-Curve Interpolation with Neural Networks
- Signatures of Massive Black Hole Merger Host Galaxies from Cosmological Simulations II: Unique Stellar Kinematics in Integral Field Unit Spectroscopy
- Monte Carlo post-processing for radiation hydro simulations of accreting planets in protoplanetary disks
- Improving Monte Carlo radiative transfer simulations: A shift of framework
- GalaxyGenius: Mock galaxy image generator for various telescopes from hydrodynamical simulations