Evolution from protoplanetary to debris discs: The transition disc around HD 166191
arXiv:1312.4531 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stt2435
Abstract
HD 166191 has been identified by several studies as hosting a rare and extremely bright warm debris disc with an additional outer cool disc component. However, an alternative interpretation is that the star hosts a disc that is currently in transition between a full gas disc and a largely gas-free debris disc. With the help of new optical to mid-IR spectra and Herschel imaging, we argue that the latter interpretation is supported in several ways: i) we show that HD 166191 is co-moving with the ~4 Myr-old Herbig Ae star HD 163296, suggesting that the two have the same age, ii) the disc spectrum of HD 166191 is well matched by a standard radiative transfer model of a gaseous protoplanetary disc with an inner hole, and iii) the HD 166191 mid-IR silicate feature is more consistent with similarly primordial objects. We note some potential issues with the debris disc interpretation that should be considered for such extreme objects, whose lifetime at the current brightness is mush shorter than the stellar age, or in the case of the outer component requires a mass comparable to the solid component of the Solar nebula. These aspects individually and collectively argue that HD 166191 is a 4-5 Myr old star that hosts a gaseous transition disc. Though it does not argue in favour of either scenario, we find strong evidence for 3-5 um disc variability. We place HD 166191 in context with discs at different evolutionary stages, showing that it is a potentially important object for understanding the protoplanetary to debris disc transition.
arXiv commentaccepted to MNRAS, fixed typos in abstract and axis label
References in corpus (78)
- PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
- Validation of the new Hipparcos reduction
- Herschel Space Observatory - An ESA facility for far-infrared and submillimetre astronomy
- The Spitzer Space Telescope Mission
- The Photodetector Array Camera and Spectrometer (PACS) on the Herschel Space Observatory
- Disk Frequencies and Lifetimes in Young Clusters
- The Infrared Spectrograph on the Spitzer Space Telescope
- Protoplanetary Disks and Their Evolution
- Interpreting Spectral Energy Distributions from Young Stellar Objects. II. Fitting observed SEDs using a large grid of pre-computed models
- The Infrared Telescope Facility (IRTF) Spectral Library: Cool Stars
- Resolved Images of Large Cavities in Protoplanetary Transition Disks
- The Ages of Stars
- Evidence for a developing gap in a 10 Myr old protoplanetary disk
- The XMM-Newton Serendipitous Survey. V. The Second XMM-Newton Serendipitous Source Catalogue
- Photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs II: evolutionary models and observable properties
- Photoevaporation of Circumstellar Disks due to External FUV Radiation in Stellar Aggregates
- Making other Earths: Dynamical Simulations of Terrestrial Planet Formation and Water Delivery
- Accretion in Young Stellar/Substellar Objects
- A planetary system as the origin of structure in Fomalhaut's dust belt
- Monte Carlo radiative transfer in protoplanetary disks
- Transience of hot dust around sun-like stars
- Pulkovo Compilation of Radial Velocities for 35495 Hipparcos Stars in a Common System
- Benchmark problems for continuum radiative transfer. High optical depths, anisotropic scattering, and polarisation
- The Wide Field Spectrograph (WiFeS)
- CASSIS: The Cornell Atlas of Spitzer/IRS Sources
- A catalogue of young runaway Hipparcos stars within 3kpc from the Sun
- The evolution of X-ray emission in young stars
- Spitzer IRS Spectroscopy of IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks
- Protoplanetary disc evolution and dispersal: the implications of X-ray photoevaportion
- A high-resolution spectropolarimetric survey of Herbig Ae/Be stars - I. Observations and measurements
- On Ultrasmall Silicate Grains in the Diffuse Interstellar Medium
- The Spitzer c2d Survey of Weak-line T Tauri Stars II: New Constraints on the Timescale for Planet Building
- HST/ACS Multiband Coronagraphic Imaging of the Debris Disk around Beta Pictoris
- XHIP: An Extended Hipparcos Compilation
- Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems (FEPS): Properties of Debris Dust around Solar-type Stars
- A Spitzer IRS Study of Infrared Variability in Transitional and Pre-Transitional Disks around T Tauri Stars
- Collisional Cascades in Planetesimal Disks II. Embedded Planets
- A Spitzer Census of Transitional Protoplanetary Disks with AU-Scale Inner Holes
- Steady-State Size Distributions for Collisional Populations: Analytical Solution with Size-Dependent Strength
- Terrestrial Planet Formation I. The Transition from Oligarchic Growth to Chaotic Growth
- High-Resolution Spectroscopy in Tr37: Gas Accretion Evolution in Evolved Dusty Disks
- Debris from terrestrial planet formation: the Moon-forming collision
- On the Transitional Disk Class: Linking Observations of T Tauri Stars & Physical Disk Models
- Accretion in Evolved and Transitional Disks in Cep OB2: Looking for the Origin of the Inner Holes
- An icy Kuiper-Belt around the young solar-type star HD 181327
- A New Probe of the Planet-Forming Region in T Tauri Disks
- A Far-ultraviolet Atlas of Low-resolution Hubble Space Telescope Spectra of T Tauri Stars
- The Eta Chamaeleontis Cluster: Origin in the Sco-Cen OB Association
- Rapid disappearance of a warm, dusty circumstellar disk
- Constraining the Lifetime of Circumstellar Disks in the Terrestrial Planet Zone: A Mid-IR Survey of the 30-Myr-old Tucana-Horologium Association
- The bright end of the exo-Zodi luminosity function: Disk evolution and implications for exo-Earth detectability
- The Rise and Fall of Debris Disks: MIPS Observations of h and chi Persei and the Evolution of Mid-IR Emission from Planet Formation
- Spitzer Evidence for a Late Heavy Bombardment and the Formation of Urelites in η Corvi at ~1 Gyr
- Re-examining the membership and origin of the Epsilon Cha association
- Variability of Disk Emission in Pre-Main Sequence and Related Stars. I. HD 31648 and HD 163296 - Isolated Herbig Ae Stars Driving Herbig-Haro Flows
- HD 98800: A 10-Myr-Old Transition Disk
- HATS-1b: The First Transiting Planet Discovered by the HATSouth Survey
- Circumstellar Dust Created by Terrestrial Planet Formation in HD 113766
- Evidence for Dynamical Changes in a Transitional Protoplanetary Disk with Mid-infrared Variability
- Sub-millimeter images of a dusty Kuiper belt around eta Corvi
- Gas modelling in the disc of HD 163296
- HST and Spitzer Observations of the HD 207129 Debris Ring
- The Age of the HD 15407 System and the Epoch of Final Catastrophic Mass Accretion onto Terrestrial Planets around Sun-like Stars
- Variability of the Infrared Excess of Extreme Debris Disks
- Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph survey of young stars in the Chamaeleon I star-forming region
- The T Tauri star RY Tau as a case study of the inner regions of circumstellar dust disks
- Resolving the hot dust around HD69830 and eta Corvi with MIDI and VISIR
- A Spitzer MIPS Study of 2.5-2.0 M\odot Stars in Scorpius-Centaurus
- Long-lived planetesimal discs
- C2D Spitzer-IRS spectra of disks around T Tauri stars V. Spectral decomposition
- Protostars, multiplicity, and disk evolution in the Corona Australis region: A Herschel Gould Belt Study
- Albedos of Small Jovian Trojans
- Dust properties and disk structure of evolved protoplanetary disks in Cep OB2: Grain growth, settling, gas and dust mass, and inside-out evolution
- Tycho 2 stars with infrared excess in the MSX Point Source Catalogue
- AKARI/IRC 18 Micron Survey of Warm Debris Disks
- Resolving the terrestrial planet forming regions of HD113766 and HD172555 with MIDI
- Variations of the 10 um Silicate Features in the Actively Accreting T Tauri Stars: DG Tau and XZ Tau
- The twofold debris disk around HD 113766 A - Warm and cold dust as seen with VLTI/Midi and Herschel/Pacs
Cited by in corpus (15)
- Do Two Temperature Debris Disks Have Multiple Belts?
- Five steps in the evolution from protoplanetary to debris disk
- A Comprehensive Census of Nearby Infrared Excess Stars
- The hybrid disks: a search and study to better understand evolution of disks
- Tracing planet-induced structures in circumstellar disks using molecular lines
- The transiting dust clumps in the evolved disk of the Sun-like UXor RZ Psc
- Warm Dusty Debris Disks and Distant Companion Stars: V488 Per and 2M1337
- HD 145263: Spectral Observations of Silica Debris Disk Formation via Extreme Space Weathering?
- A Star-sized Impact-Produced Dust Clump in the Terrestrial Zone of the HD 166191 System
- Faint warm debris disks around nearby bright stars explored by AKARI and IRSF
- A Herschel resolved debris disc around HD 105211
- Abundant sub-micron grains revealed in newly discovered extreme debris discs
- Discovery of carbon monoxide emission from five debris disks around young A-type stars
- Glancing through the debris disk: Photometric analysis of DE Boo with CHEOPS
- The nature of ASASSN-24fw's occultation: modelling the event as dimming by optically thick rings around a sub-stellar companion