Deflating Super-Puffs: Impact of Photochemical Hazes on the Observed Mass-Radius Relationship of Low Mass Planets
arXiv:2001.00055 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/ab6a9b
Abstract
The observed mass-radius relationship of low-mass planets informs our understanding of their composition and evolution. Recent discoveries of low mass, large radii objects ("super-puffs") have challenged theories of planet formation and atmospheric loss, as their high inferred gas masses make them vulnerable to runaway accretion and hydrodynamic escape. Here we propose that high altitude photochemical hazes could enhance the observed radii of low-mass planets and explain the nature of super-puffs. We construct model atmospheres in radiative-convective equilibrium and compute rates of atmospheric escape and haze distributions, taking into account haze coagulation, sedimentation, diffusion, and advection by an outflow wind. We develop mass-radius diagrams that include atmospheric lifetimes and haze opacity, which is enhanced by the outflow, such that young (~0.1-1 Gyr), warm (T 500 K), low mass objects ( < 4M) should experience the most apparent radius enhancement due to hazes, reaching factors of three. This reconciles the densities and ages of the most extreme super-puffs. For Kepler-51b, the inclusion of hazes reduces its inferred gas mass fraction to <10%, similar to that of planets on the large radius side of the sub-Neptune radius gap. This suggests that Kepler-51b may be evolving towards that population, and that some warm sub-Neptunes may have evolved from super-puffs. Hazes also render transmission spectra of super-puffs and sub-Neptunes featureless, consistent with recent measurements. Our hypothesis can be tested by future observations of super-puffs' transmission spectra at mid-infrared wavelengths, where we predict that the planet radius will be half of that observed in the near-infrared.
arXiv comment32 pages, 25 figures, and 2 tables. Accepted for publication in ApJ
References in corpus (118)
- The California-Kepler Survey. III. A Gap in the Radius Distribution of Small Planets
- Planet Occurrence within 0.25 AU of Solar-type Stars from Kepler
- The false positive rate of Kepler and the occurrence of planets
- Characteristics of planetary candidates observed by Kepler, II: Analysis of the first four months of data
- Planetary Radii across Five Orders of Magnitude in Mass and Stellar Insolation: Application to Transits
- A continuum from clear to cloudy hot-Jupiter exoplanets without primordial water depletion
- Clouds in the atmosphere of the super-Earth exoplanet GJ 1214b
- Evolution of the Solar Activity over Time and Effects on Planetary Atmospheres: I. High-energy Irradiances (1-1700 A)
- Precipitating Condensation Clouds in Substellar Atmospheres
- Mass-Radius Relationships for Solid Exoplanets
- Kepler planets: a tale of evaporation
- Most 1.6 Earth-Radius Planets are not Rocky
- The evaporation valley in the Kepler planets
- Atmospheric Escape from Hot Jupiters
- Understanding the Mass-Radius Relation for Sub-Neptunes: Radius as a Proxy for Composition
- The Occurrence Rate of Small Planets around Small Stars
- Probabilistic Forecasting of the Masses and Radii of Other Worlds
- Growth Model Interpretation of Planet Size Distribution
- Photodissociation and photoionisation of atoms and molecules of astrophysical interest
- An asteroseismic view of the radius valley: stripped cores, not born rocky
- The Role of Core Mass in Controlling Evaporation: the Kepler Radius Distribution and the Kepler-36 Density Dichotomy
- Core-powered mass loss and the radius distribution of small exoplanets
- Disequilibrium Carbon, Oxygen, and Nitrogen Chemistry in the Atmospheres of HD 189733b and HD 209458b
- Neglected Clouds in T and Y Dwarf Atmospheres
- Mass-Radius Relation for Rocky Planets based on PREM
- How Thermal Evolution and Mass Loss Sculpt Populations of Super-Earths and Sub-Neptunes: Application to the Kepler-11 System and Beyond
- Detection of Carbon Monoxide and Water Absorption Lines in an Exoplanet Atmosphere
- Characterizing transiting exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
- Titan's Atmosphere and Climate
- 3D mixing in hot Jupiter atmospheres. I. application to the day/night cold trap in HD 209458b
- Gaseous Mean Opacities for Giant Planet and Ultracool Dwarf Atmospheres over a Range of Metallicities and Temperatures
- Planetary population synthesis coupled with atmospheric escape: a statistical view of evaporation
- A featureless transmission spectrum for the Neptune-mass exoplanet GJ 436b
- Atmospheres of protoplanetary cores: critical mass for nucleated instability
- Transmission Spectra of Three-Dimensional Hot Jupiter Model Atmospheres
- Chemical consequences of the C/O ratio on hot Jupiters: Examples from WASP-12b,CoRoT-2b, XO-1b, and HD 189733b
- Atmospheric Escape and the Evolution of Close-in Exoplanets
- Breeding Super-Earths and Birthing Super-Puffs in Transitional Disks
- Water Vapour Absorption in the Clear Atmosphere of an exo-Neptune
- Formation and Structure of Low Density Exo-Neptunes
- Characterization of exoplanets from their formation II: The planetary mass-radius relationship
- Solar System Abundances of the Elements
- Thermal Emission and Albedo Spectra of Super Earths with Flat Transmission Spectra
- A Plateau in the Planet Population Below Twice the Size of Earth
- Composition and fate of short-period super-Earths: The case of CoRoT-7b
- A Sub-Neptune Exoplanet with a Low-Metallicity Methane-Depleted Atmosphere and Mie-Scattering Clouds
- Atmospheric reconnaissance of the habitable-zone Earth-sized planets orbiting TRAPPIST-1
- A New Window into Escaping Exoplanet Atmospheres: 10830 Å Line of Helium
- Atmospheres of low-mass planets: the "boil-off"
- Evolutionary Analysis of Gaseous Sub-Neptune-Mass Planets with MESA
- The Mass of Kepler-93b and The Composition of Terrestrial Planets
- A resonant chain of four transiting, sub-Neptune planets
- Theory of Extrasolar Giant Planet Transits
- Quantitatively Assessing the Role of Clouds in the Transmission Spectrum of GJ 1214b
- VULCAN: an Open-Source, Validated Chemical Kinetics Python Code for Exoplanetary Atmospheres
- Tidal Locking of Habitable Exoplanets
- In-situ Accretion of Hydrogen-Rich Atmospheres on Short-Period Super-Earths: Implications for the Kepler-11 Planets
- On the Minimum Core Mass for Giant Planet Formation at Wide Separations
- HAT-P-26b: A Neptune-Mass Exoplanet with a Well Constrained Heavy Element Abundance
- Hubble Space Telescope Near-IR Transmission Spectroscopy of the Super-Earth HD 97658b
- Very Low-Density Planets around Kepler-51 Revealed with Transit Timing Variations and an Anomaly Similar to a Planet-Planet Eclipse Event
- Simultaneous Detection of Water, Methane and Carbon Monoxide in the Atmosphere of Exoplanet HR8799b
- A Neptune-sized transiting planet closely orbiting a 5-10-million-year-old star
- Zodiacal Exoplanets in Time (ZEIT) III: A short-period planet orbiting a pre-main-sequence star in the Upper Scorpius OB Association
- Photochemistry in Terrestrial Exoplanet Atmospheres III: Photochemistry and Thermochemistry in Thick Atmospheres on Super Earths and Mini Neptunes
- The Formation of Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes with Giant Impacts
- Born Dry in the Photo-Evaporation Desert: Kepler's Ultra-Short-Period Planets Formed Water-Poor
- TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME): A planet in the 45 Myr Tucana-Horologium association
- On the Indirect Detection of Sodium in the Atmosphere of the Planetary Companion to HD 209458
- Four newborn planets transiting the young solar analog V1298 Tau
- Quantifying and Predicting the Presence of Clouds in Exoplanet Atmospheres
- Trends in Atmospheric Properties of Neptune-Size Exoplanets
- Haze Production in the Atmospheres of super-Earths and mini-Neptunes: Insights from the Lab
- Chemical Kinetics on Extrasolar Planets
- 3D modeling of GJ1214b's atmosphere: vertical mixing driven by an anti-Hadley circulation
- Formation of Silicate and Titanium Clouds on Hot Jupiters
- High Temperature Photochemistry in the Atmosphere of HD189733b
- Theoretical transmission spectra of exoplanet atmospheres with hydrocarbon haze: Effect of creation, growth, and settling of haze particles. I. Model description and first results
- The Featureless Transmission Spectra of Two Super-Puff Planets
- Spectra as Windows into Exoplanet Atmospheres
- KOI-152's Low Density Planets
- Titan solar occultation observations reveal transit spectra of a hazy world
- Bimodal Distribution of Sulfuric Acid Aerosols in the Upper Haze of Venus
- Transit Signatures of Inhomogeneous Clouds on Hot Jupiters: Insights From Microphysical Cloud Modeling
- Sedimentation Efficiency of Condensation Clouds in Substellar Atmospheres
- A photochemical model for the carbon-rich planet WASP-12b
- The propagation of Lyman-alpha in evolving protoplanetary disks
- Global-mean Vertical Tracer Mixing in Planetary Atmospheres I: Theory and Fast-rotating Planets
- Statistical Analysis of Hubble/WFC3 Transit Spectroscopy of Extrasolar Planets
- Microphysics of KCl and ZnS Clouds on GJ 1214b
- Vertical Tracer Mixing in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
- Photolytic Hazes in the Atmosphere of 51 Eri b
- New chemical scheme for studying carbon-rich exoplanet atmospheres
- Exploring atmospheres of hot mini-Neptunes and extrasolar giant planets orbiting different stars with application to HD 97658b, WASP-12b, CoRoT-2b, XO-1b and HD 189733b
- A warm Jupiter-sized planet transiting the pre-main sequence star V1298 Tau
- Constraints on the Microphysics of Pluto's Photochemical Haze from New Horizons Observations
- Tidally-Induced Radius Inflation of Sub-Neptunes
- The Roles of Tidal Evolution and Evaporative Mass Loss in the Origin of CoRoT-7 b
- A Search for Giant Planet Companions to T Tauri Stars
- Sulfur Hazes in Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres: Impacts on Reflected Light Spectra
- Identifying the "true" radius of the hot sub-Neptune CoRoT-24b by mass loss modelling
- Dusty outflows in planetary atmospheres: Understanding "super-puffs" and transmission spectra of sub-Neptunes
- Global-mean Vertical Tracer Mixing in Planetary Atmospheres II: Tidally Locked Planets
- An Independent Planet Search In The Kepler Dataset. II. An extremely low-density super-Earth mass planet around Kepler-87
- Laboratory Simulations of Haze Formation in the Atmospheres of super-Earths and mini-Neptunes: Particle Color and Size Distribution
- Aggregate Hazes in Exoplanet Atmospheres
- A possibly inflated planet around the bright, young star DS Tuc A
- Microphysical Modeling of Mineral Clouds in GJ1214 b and GJ436 b: Predicting Upper Limits on the Cloud-Top Height
- Photochemical hazes in sub-Neptunian atmospheres with focus on GJ 1214 b
- Detectable molecular features above hydrocarbon haze via transmission spectroscopy with JWST: Case studies of GJ 1214b-, GJ 436b-, HD 97658b-, and Kepler-51b-like planets
- A Hubble PanCET Study of HAT-P-11b: A Cloudy Neptune with a Low Atmospheric Metallicity
- Laboratory Investigations of Titan Haze Formation: In Situ Measurement of Gas and Particle Composition
- Photochemistry in hot H2-dominated exoplanet atmospheres
- Chemical Timescales in the Atmospheres of Highly Eccentric Exoplanets
- Shielding by Water and OH in FUV and X-ray Irradiated Protoplanetary Disks
- Evaporation of Low-Mass Planet Atmospheres: Multidimensional Hydrodynamics with Consistent Thermochemistry
- Analytic Scattering and Refraction Models for Exoplanet Transit Spectra
- Exploring A Photospheric Radius Correction to Model Secondary Eclipse Spectra for Transiting Exoplanets
Cited by in corpus (48)
- Aerosols in Exoplanet Atmospheres
- Atmospheric Regimes and Trends on Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
- TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) III: a two-planet system in the 400 Myr Ursa Major Group
- TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) VI: an 11 Myr giant planet transiting a very low-mass star in Lower Centaurus Crux
- The Hazy and Metal-Rich Atmosphere of GJ 1214 b Constrained by Near and Mid-Infrared Transmission Spectroscopy
- TOI-1136 is a Young, Coplanar, Aligned Planetary System in a Pristine Resonant Chain
- Super-Rayleigh Slopes in Transmission Spectra of Exoplanets Generated by Photochemical Haze
- TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) IV: Three small planets orbiting a 120 Myr-old star in the Pisces--Eridanus stream
- Tidal Inflation Reconciles Low-Density Sub-Saturns with Core Accretion
- Evidence for the volatile-rich composition of a 1.5- planet
- LHS 1140 b is a potentially habitable water world
- Constraints on the mass and atmospheric composition and evolution of the low-density young planet DS Tuc A b
- Metastable Helium Absorptions with 3D Hydrodynamics and Self-Consistent Photochemistry II: WASP-107b, Stellar Wind, Radiation Pressure, and Shear Instability
- The TESS-Keck Survey I: A Warm Sub-Saturn-mass Planet and a Caution about Stray Light in TESS Cameras
- The First Near-Infrared Transmission Spectrum of HIP 41378 f, a Low-Mass Temperate Jovian World in a Multi-Planet System
- Optical Properties of Organic Haze Analogues in Water-rich Exoplanet Atmospheres Observable with JWST
- Cleaning our Hazy Lens: Exploring Trends in Transmission Spectra of Warm Exoplanets
- HD 191939 revisited: New and refined planet mass determinations, and a new planet in the habitable zone
- The mass-radius relation of intermediate-mass planets outlined by hydrodynamic escape and thermal evolution
- Radial Gradients in Dust-to-Gas Ratio Lead to Preferred Region for Giant Planet Formation
- V1298 Tau with TESS: Updated Ephemerides, Radii, and Period Constraints from a Second Transit of V1298 Tau e
- Sculpting the sub-Saturn Occurrence Rate via Atmospheric Mass Loss
- CKS IX: Revisiting the Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula with Precise Stellar Parameters
- A Framework for Characterizing Transmission Spectra of Exoplanets with Circumplanetary Rings
- Dynamics and Clouds in Planetary Atmospheres from Telescopic Observations
- GJ 3090 b: one of the most favourable mini-Neptune for atmospheric characterisation
- Haze Formation on Triton
- Mineral Snowflakes on Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs: Coagulation and Fragmentation of Cloud Particles with {\sc HyLandS}
- Oblique rings from migrating exomoons: A possible origin for long-period exoplanets with enlarged radii
- First Comparative Exoplanetology Within a Transiting Multi-planet System: Comparing the atmospheres of V1298 Tau b and c
- Stability and detectability of exomoons orbiting HIP 41378 f, a temperate Jovian planet with an anomalously low apparent density
- Hazy with a chance of star spots: constraining the atmosphere of the young planet, K2-33b
- Architecture Classification for Extrasolar Planetary Systems
- Evolution of steam worlds: energetic aspects
- TOI-4438 b: a transiting mini-Neptune amenable to atmospheric characterization
- A Circumplanetary Dust Ring May Explain the Extreme Spectral Slope of the 10 Myr Young Exoplanet K2-33b
- Planet Hunters TESS III: two transiting planets around the bright G dwarf HD 152843
- The multi-planet system TOI-421 -- A warm Neptune and a super puffy mini-Neptune transiting a G9 V star in a visual binary
- Transit Depth Variations Reveal TOI-216 b to be a Super-Puff
- On the stability of low-mass planets with supercritical hydrospheres
- The K2-24 planetary system revisited by CHEOPS
- A Validated Low-to-Intermediate Mass Planetary Interior Structure Model and New Mass-Radius Relations
- Discovery of a transiting hot water-world candidate orbiting Ross 176 with TESS and CARMENES
- Influence of CO versus CH on organic haze formation in atmospheres of diverse terrestrial exoplanets
- JWST unveils a high mean molecular weight atmosphere for mini-Neptune TOI-1130b: Evidence for formation beyond the water ice line
- Refining the Masses and Radii of the Star Kepler-33 and its Five Transiting Planets
- A Multi-Planet System's Sole Super-Puff: Exploring Allowable Physical Parameters for the Cold Super-Puff HIP 41378 f
- Grain Growth in Escaping Atmospheres: Implications for the Radius Inflation of Super-Puffs