Selection Bias in Observing the Cosmological Evolution of the Mbh-sigma and Mbh-L Relationships

Abstract

Programs to observe evolution in the Mbh-sigma or Mbh-L relations typically compare black-hole masses, Mbh, in high-redshift galaxies selected by nuclear activity to Mbh in local galaxies selected by luminosity L, or stellar velocity dispersion sigma. Because AGN luminosity is likely to depend on Mbh, selection effects are different for high-redshift and local samples, potentially producing a false signal of evolution. This bias arises because cosmic scatter in the Mbh-sigma and Mbh-L relations means that the mean log(L) or log(sigma) among galaxies that host a black hole of given Mbh, may be substantially different than the log(L) or log(sigma) obtained from inverting the Mbh-L or Mbh-sigma relations for the same nominal Mbh. The bias is particularly strong at high Mbh, where the luminosity and dispersion functions of galaxies are falling rapidly. The most massive black holes occur more often as rare outliers in galaxies of modest mass than in the even rarer high-mass galaxies, which would otherwise be the sole location of such black holes in the absence of cosmic scatter. Because of this bias, Mbh will typically appear to be too large in the distant sample for a given L or sigma. For the largest black holes and the largest plausible cosmic scatter, the bias can reach a factor of 3 in Mbh for the Mbh-sigma relation and a factor of 9 for the Mbh-L relation. Unfortunately, the actual cosmic scatter is not known well enough to correct for the bias. Measuring evolution of the Mbh and galaxy property relations requires object selection to be precisely defined and exactly the same at all redshifts.

28 pages, 6 figures, submitted to the Astrophysical Journal

References in corpus (6)

• The Black Hole Mass - Galaxy Bulge Relationship for QSOs in the SDSS DR3
• Cosmic Evolution of Black Holes and Spheroids. I: The M_BH-sigma Relation at z=0.36
• Cosmic Evolution of Black Holes and Spheroids. II: Scaling Relations at z=0.36
• On the inconsistency between the black hole mass function inferred from M_bh-sigma and M_bh-L correlation
• The BH mass of nearby QSOs: a comparison of the bulge luminosity and virial methods
• The evolution of host mass and black hole mass in QSOs from the 2dF QSO Redshift Survey

Cited by in corpus (220)

• Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• The M-sigma and M-L Relations in Galactic Bulges and Determinations of their Intrinsic Scatter
• Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
• Relations Between Central Black Hole Mass and Total Galaxy Stellar Mass in the Local Universe
• The Illustris simulation: the evolving population of black holes across cosmic time
• What Drives the Growth of Black Holes?
• Biases in Virial Black Hole Masses: An SDSS Perspective
• The stochastic gravitational-wave background from massive black hole binary systems: implications for observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Self-Consistent Models of the AGN and Black Hole Populations: Duty Cycles, Accretion Rates, and the Mean Radiative Efficiency
• Two ten-billion-solar-mass black holes at the centres of giant elliptical galaxies
• A CEERS Discovery of an Accreting Supermassive Black Hole 570 Myr after the Big Bang: Identifying a Progenitor of Massive z > 6 Quasars
• On the cosmic evolution of the scaling relations between black holes and their host galaxies: Broad Line AGN in the zCOSMOS survey
• JADES. The diverse population of infant Black Holes at 4<z<11: merging, tiny, poor, but mighty
• Eddington-limited accretion and the black hole mass function at redshift 6
• The Romulus Cosmological Simulations: A Physical Approach to the Formation, Dynamics and Accretion Models of SMBHs
• An ALMA [CII] survey of 27 quasars at z>5.94
• The first and second data releases of the Kilo-Degree Survey
• How Mergers May Affect The Mass Scaling Relations Between Black Holes, Galaxies, and Other Gravitationally Bound Systems
• Gravitational waves from resolvable massive black hole binary systems and observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• The cosmic evolution of massive black holes in the Horizon-AGN simulation
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: its consequences and the quest for the most fundamental relation
• Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: IV. Evolution in the Scaling Relations of Spheroids
• The Lick AGN Monitoring Project: The MBH - sigma Relation For Reverberation-Mapped Active Galaxies
• Unification of the Fundamental Plane and Super-Massive Black Holes Masses
• Ongoing and co-evolving star formation in zCOSMOS galaxies hosting Active Galactic Nuclei
• The black hole mass -- stellar velocity dispersion correlation: bulges versus pseudobulges
• Discriminating Between the Physical Processes that Drive Spheroid Size Evolution
• Stellar Velocity Dispersion Measurements in High-Luminosity Quasar Hosts and Implications for the AGN Black Hole Mass Scale
• JWST CEERS & JADES Active Galaxies at z = 4-7 Violate the Local $M_{\bullet }-M_{\star }$ Relation at $>3\sigma$: Implications for Low-Mass Black Holes and Seeding Models
• The MASSIVE Survey - I. A Volume-Limited Integral-Field Spectroscopic Study of the Most Massive Early-Type Galaxies within 108 Mpc
• Journey to the M_BH -sigma relation: the fate of low mass black holes in the Universe
• Accretion-Driven Evolution of Black Holes: Eddington Ratios, Duty Cycles, and Active Galaxy Fractions
• Massive Galaxies in COSMOS: Evolution of Black hole versus bulge mass but not versus total stellar mass over the last 9 Gyrs?
• The mass relations between supermassive black holes and their host galaxies at 1<z<2 with HST-WFC3
• The LABOCA Survey of the Extended Chandra Deep Field South: Clustering of submillimetre galaxies
• Weighing the Black Holes in z~2 Submillimeter-Emitting Galaxies Hosting Active Galactic Nuclei
• Cosmic Evolution of Black Holes and Spheroids. III. The M-sigma relation in the last six billion years
• The Demographics of Broad Line Quasars in the Mass-Luminosity Plane II. Black Hole Mass and Eddington Ratio Functions
• The quasar M_bh - M_host relation through Cosmic Time II - Evidence for evolution from z=3 to the present age
• Comparing and calibrating black hole mass estimators for distant active galactic nuclei
• Black Holes in Pseudobulges and Spheroidals: A Change in the Black Hole-Bulge Scaling Relations at Low Mass
• Accretion Rate and the Physical Nature of Unobscured Active Galaxies
• Star formation rate and dynamical mass of 10^8 solar mass black hole host galaxies at redshift 6
• The Black Hole Mass-Bulge Luminosity Relationship for Active Galactic Nuclei from Reverberation Mapping and Hubble Space Telescope Imaging
• Secular evolution and a non-evolving black hole to galaxy mass ratio in the last 7 Gyr
• A snapshot on galaxy evolution occurring in the Great Wall: the role of Nurture at z=0
• NANOGrav Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Circular Orbits
• The Lick AGN Monitoring Project: Recalibrating Single-Epoch Virial Black Hole Mass Estimates
• Do the Most Massive Black Holes at $z=2$ Grow via Major Mergers?
• ALMA Observations Show Major Mergers Among the Host Galaxies of Fast-growing, High-redshift Supermassive Black Holes
• Redshift 6.4 host galaxies of 10^8 solar mass black holes: low star formation rate and dynamical mass
• No significant evolution of relations between Black hole mass and Galaxy total stellar mass up to z~2.5
• Are Radio AGN Powered by Accretion or Black Hole Spin?
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Reverberation Mapping Project: No Evidence for Evolution in the M-sigma Relation to z~1
• Cosmic Evolution of Black Holes and Spheroids. IV. The BH Mass - Spheroid Luminosity Relation
• The Demographics of Broad-Line Quasars in the Mass-Luminosity Plane. I. Testing FWHM-Based Virial Black Hole Masses
• The black hole - bulge mass relation of Active Galactic Nuclei in the Extended Chandra Deep Field - South Survey
• On the evolution of the intrinsic scatter in black hole versus galaxy mass relations
• The hierarchical assembly of galaxies and black holes in the first billion years: predictions for the era of gravitational wave astronomy
• Black Hole-Galaxy Correlations without Self-Regulation
• The VLA-COSMOS Perspective on the IR-Radio Relation. I. New Constraints on Selection Biases and the Non-Evolution of the IR/Radio Properties of Star Forming and AGN Galaxies at Intermediate and High Redshift
• The Influence of Dark Matter Halos on Dynamical Estimates of Black Hole Mass: Ten New Measurements for High-sigma Early-Type Galaxies
• The cosmic growth of the active black hole population at 1<z<2 in zCOSMOS, VVDS and SDSS
• The Demography of Super-Massive Black Holes: Growing Monsters at the Heart of Galaxies
• The X-shooter/ALMA Sample of Quasars in the Epoch of Reionization. II. Black Hole Masses, Eddington Ratios, and the Formation of the First Quasars
• Linking black-hole growth with host galaxies: The accretion-stellar mass relation and its cosmic evolution
• On the radiative efficiencies, Eddington ratios, and duty cycles of luminous high-redshift quasars
• EIGER V. Characterizing the Host Galaxies of Luminous Quasars at $z\gtrsim 6$
• A Simple Model for Quasar Demographics
• Subaru High-z Exploration of Low-Luminosity Quasars (SHELLQs) VIII. A less biased view of the early co-evolution of black holes and host galaxies
• The evolution of Black Hole scaling relations in galaxy mergers
• Redshift Evolution in Black Hole-Bulge Relations: Testing CIV-based Black Hole Masses
• A wide dispersion in star formation rate and dynamical mass of 10^8 solar mass black hole host galaxies at redshift 6
• First discoveries of z~6 quasars with the Kilo Degree Survey and VISTA Kilo-Degree Infrared Galaxy survey
• The Most Massive Galaxies and Black Holes Allowed by $\Lambda$CDM
• The ALMA view of the high-redshift relation between supermassive black holes and their host galaxies
• Black Holes in the Early Universe
• High-redshift quasars host galaxies: is there a stellar mass crisis?
• The M_BH - M_star relation for X-ray obscured, red QSOs at 1.2< z <2.6
• Observational constraints on the specific accretion-rate distribution of X-ray selected AGN
• A Quintet of Black Hole Mass Determinations
• Torque-Limited Growth of Massive Black Holes in Galaxies Across Cosmic Time
• Selection effects in the black hole-bulge relation and its evolution
• Black-Hole Growth is Mainly Linked to Host-Galaxy Stellar Mass rather than Star Formation Rate
• The Evolution of the M_BH-sigma relation Inferred from the Age Distribution of Local Early-Type Galaxies and AGN Evolution
• Accounting for selection effects in the BH-bulge relations: No evidence for cosmological evolution
• Black Hole -- Galaxy Correlations in Simba
• Is there an upper limit to black hole masses?
• Subaru High-z Exploration of Low-Luminosity Quasars (SHELLQs). XIII. Large-scale Feedback and Star Formation in a Low-Luminosity Quasar at z = 7.07 on the Local Black Hole to Host Mass Relation
• Probing Massive Black Hole Binary Populations with LISA
• Evolution in the Black Hole - Galaxy Scaling Relations and the Duty Cycle of Nuclear Activity in Star-Forming Galaxies
• Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays and Neutrinos from Tidal Disruptions by Massive Black Holes
• On the geometry of broad emission region in quasars
• The Impact of the Uncertainty in Single-Epoch Virial Black Hole Mass Estimates on the Observed Evolution of the Black Hole - Bulge Scaling Relations
• On the formation of the first quasars
• A 5x10^9 Solar Mass Black Hole in NGC 1277 from Adaptive Optics Spectroscopy
• Blazars in the early Universe
• Trinity I: Self-Consistently Modeling the Dark Matter Halo-Galaxy-Supermassive Black Hole Connection from $z=0-10$
• Subaru High-z Exploration of Low-Luminosity Quasars (SHELLQs) III. Star formation properties of the host galaxies at $z\gtrsim 6$ studied with ALMA
• High-redshift quasars and their host galaxies I: kinematical and dynamical properties and their tracers
• Assessing the redshift evolution of massive black holes and their hosts
• Quasar Black Hole Mass Estimates in the Era of Time Domain Astronomy
• Upper Limits on the Masses of 105 Supermassive Black Holes from Hubble Space Telescope/Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph Archival Data
• Evident black hole-bulge coevolution in the distant universe
• The Millennium Galaxy Catalogue: The $M_{bh}$--$L_{spheroid}$ derived supermassive black hole mass function
• Mass Functions of Supermassive Black Holes Across Cosmic Time
• Towards an understanding of the evolution of the scaling relations for supermassive black holes
• Toward precise constraints on growth of massive black holes
• Host Galaxies of Luminous Type 2 Quasars at z ~ 0.5
• The growth of supermassive black holes in pseudo-bulges, classical bulges and elliptical galaxies
• Scaling relations between black holes and their host galaxies: comparing theoretical and observational measurements, and the impact of selection effects
• Cosmic Evolution of Black Holes and Spheroids. V. The Relation Between Black Hole Mass and Host Galaxy Luminosity for a Sample of 79 Active Galaxies
• No Evidence for Evolution in the Far-Infrared-Radio Correlation out to z ~ 2 in the eCDFS
• AGN evolution from a galaxy evolution viewpoint
• The host galaxies and black-hole:galaxy mass ratios of luminous quasars at z~4
• Gravitational waves and pulsar timing: stochastic background, individual sources and parameter estimation
• The MASSIVE Survey - III. Molecular gas and a broken Tully-Fisher relation in the most massive early-type galaxies
• The Redshift Evolution of the $M_{\bullet }-M_{\star }$ Relation for JWST's Supermassive Black Holes at $z>4$
• The non-linear infrared-radio correlation of low-z galaxies: implications for redshift evolution, a new radio SFR recipe, and how to minimize selection bias
• PRIMUS: An observationally motivated model to connect the evolution of the AGN and galaxy populations out to z~1
• The Chandra Deep Fields: Lifting the Veil on Distant Active Galactic Nuclei and X-Ray Emitting Galaxies
• Inferences on the Relations Between Central Black Hole Mass and Total Galaxy Stellar Mass in the high-redshift Universe
• AMUSE-Field I: Nuclear X-ray Properties of Local Field and Group Spheroids across the Stellar Mass Scale
• The redshift evolution of major merger triggering of luminous AGN: a slight enhancement at z$\sim$2
• Massive Star-Forming Host Galaxies of Quasars on Sloan Digital Sky Survey Stripe 82
• The Growth of Black Holes: Insights From Obscured Active Galaxies
• The supermassive black hole mass - Sérsic index relations for bulges and elliptical galaxies
• UNCOVER: 404 Error -- Models Not Found for the Triply Imaged Little Red Dot A2744-QSO1
• The Building Up of the Black Hole Mass - Stellar Mass Relation
• Nuclear Black Hole Formation in Clumpy Galaxies at High Redshift
• No evidence of obscured, accreting black holes in most z=6 star-forming galaxies
• Observational constraints on the co-evolution of supermassive black holes and galaxies
• Prospects for measuring supermassive black hole masses with future extremely large telescopes
• A Preferential Growth Channel for Supermassive Black Holes in Elliptical Galaxies at z<2
• The Formation of Galaxies Hosting z~6 Quasars
• Black Hole Demography: From scaling relations to models
• Synchronized Co-evolution between Supermassive Black Holes and Galaxies Over the Last Seven Billion Years as Revealed by the Hyper Suprime-Cam
• The black holes of radio galaxies during the "Quasar Era": Masses, accretion rates, and evolutionary stage
• A universal relation between the properties of supermassive black holes, galaxies, and dark matter halos
• Type 2 AGN host galaxies in the Chandra-COSMOS Legacy Survey: No Evidence of AGN-driven Quenching
• H0LiCOW VII. Cosmic evolution of the correlation between black hole mass and host galaxy luminosity
• The mass assembly of high-redshift black holes
• BlueTides simulation: establishing black hole-galaxy relations at high-redshift
• The Black Hole Mass - Stellar Velocity Dispersion Relationship for Quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7
• Evidence for Rapidly Rotating Black Holes in FR I Radio Galaxies
• Limits to Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Emission From Far-Infrared-Luminous z~6 Quasar Hosts
• H0LiCOW VI. Testing the fidelity of lensed quasar host galaxy reconstruction
• A Black Hole Mass Determination for the Compact Galaxy Mrk 1216
• A Gravitational Redshift Measurement of the White Dwarf Mass-Radius Relation
• Effects of Inclination on Measuring Velocity Dispersion and Implications for Black Holes
• A Herschel Study of 24 micron-Selected AGNs and Their Host Galaxies
• AGN evolution from galaxy evolution viewpoint - II
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Reverberation Mapping Project: The M_BH-Host Relations at 0.2<z<0.6 from Reverberation Mapping and Hubble Space Telescope Imaging
• The M_BH-M_star relation of obscured AGNs at high redshift
• Dwarf AGNs from Variability for the Origins of Seeds (DAVOS): Intermediate-mass black hole demographics from optical synoptic surveys
• The host galaxies of z=7 quasars: predictions from the BlueTides simulation
• Constraints on black hole duty cycles and the black hole-halo relation from SDSS quasar clustering
• Constraining the quasar population with the broad-line width distribution
• Probing the M-sigma Relation in the Non-Local Universe Using Red QSOs
• AMUSE-Field II. Nucleation of early-type galaxies in the field vs. cluster environment
• Stronger Constraints on the Evolution of the $M_{\mathrm{BH}}-{\sigma }_{\ast }$ Relation up to $z\sim 0.6$
• Prior-Informed AGN-Host Spectral Decomposition Using PyQSOFit
• No evidence for a significant evolution of $M_{\bullet }$-$M_{\ast }$ relation in massive galaxies up to z$\sim$4
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Reverberation Mapping Project: Quasar Host Galaxies at $z<0.8$ from Image Decomposition
• Downsizing of supermassive black holes from the SDSS quasar survey
• On the cosmological evolution of the black hole - host galaxy relation in quasars
• Black holes as the source of dark energy: a stringent test with high-redshift JWST AGNs
• High-redshift quasars and their host galaxies II: multiphase gas and stellar kinematics
• Empirical Constraints on the Evolution of the Relationship between Black Hole and Galaxy Mass: Scatter Matters
• Host Galaxies of z=4 Quasars
• On the Connection between Supermassive Black Hole and Galaxy Growth in the Reionization Epoch
• Multimessenger study of merging massive black holes in the OBELISK simulation: gravitational waves, electromagnetic counterparts, and their link to galaxy and black hole populations
• The UV--mid-IR Spectral Energy Distribution of a z=1.7 Quasar Host Galaxy
• M_BH - sigma relation in SDSS flat-spectrum radio quasars
• The miniJPAS survey: AGN & host galaxy co-evolution of X-ray selected sources
• Constraining Star Formation and AGN in z~2 Massive Galaxies using High Resolution MERLIN Radio Observations
• TRINITY II: The Luminosity-dependent Bias of the Supermassive Black Hole Mass--Galaxy Mass Relation for Bright Quasars at $z=6$
• Black Hole - Bulge Relationship of Post-Starburst Quasars at z \sim 0.3
• Resolving Disks & Mergers in $z\sim 2$ Heavily Reddened Quasars and their Companion Galaxies with ALMA
• The preferentially magnified active nucleus in IRAS F10214+4724 - III. VLBI observations of the radio core
• JWST ERS Program Q3D: The pitfalls of virial BH mass constraints shown in a z = 3 quasar with an ultramassive host
• In Search of the Largest Velocity Dispersion Galaxies
• Dark-ages reionization and galaxy formation simulation -- XVIII. The high-redshift evolution of black holes and their host galaxies
• X-ray properties of radio-selected star forming galaxies in the Chandra-COSMOS survey
• Massive Quiescent Galaxies at z>3 in The Millennium Simulation Populated by A Semi-analytic Galaxy Formation Model
• On the complementarity of pulsar timing and space laser interferometry for the individual detection of supermassive black hole binaries
• Testing the fidelity of simulations of black hole - galaxy co-evolution at z ~ 1.5 with observations
• The Impact of Black Hole Scaling Relation Assumptions on the Mass Density of Black Holes
• Concordance between observations and simulations in the evolution of the mass relation between supermassive black holes and their host galaxies
• The MASSIVE survey -- XIX. Molecular gas measurements of the supermassive black hole masses in the elliptical galaxies NGC 1684 and NGC 0997
• A Spatially-Resolved Survey of Distant Quasar Host Galaxies: II. Photoionization and Kinematics of the ISM
• The ALPINE-CRISTAL-JWST Survey: Revealing Less Massive Black Holes in High-Redshift Galaxies
• The U.S. Naval Observatory VLBI Spectroscopic Catalog
• Near-Infrared Spectroscopy of Quasars at z~3 and Estimates of Their Supermassive Black Hole Masses
• Infrared fine-structure lines at high redshift
• Evolution of black hole and galaxy growth in a semi-numerical galaxy formation model
• Inquiring into the nature of the Abell 2667 Brightest Cluster Galaxy: physical properties from MUSE
• Strong gravitational lensing by AGNs as a probe of the quasar-host relations in the distant Universe
• Mass-dependent evolution of the relation between supermassive black hole mass and host spheroid mass since z ~ 1
• Stellar and Black Hole Mass Densities as Empirical Tracers of Co-evolution Show Lock-step Growth since $z\sim 3$
• The Co-Evolution of Galaxies and Black Holes: Current Status and Future Prospects
• Inferring Mbh-Mbulge Evolution from the Gravitational Wave Background
• A new approach to constraining properties of AGN host galaxies by combining image and SED decomposition: testing upon the MBH-M* relation
• The Diversity of Environments Around Luminous Quasars at Redshift $z\sim 6$
• A STIS Atlas of CaII Triplet Absorption Line Kinematics in Galactic Nuclei
• Robust AGN and host-galaxy decomposition in optical spectral fitting
• X-ray stacking reveals average SMBH accretion properties of star-forming galaxies and their cosmic evolution over 4 <~ z <~ 7
• Variability as a new discovery channel for Intermediate-Mass Black Holes in the Time Domain Era
• On the signature of black holes on the quenched stellar mass function
• The implications of overmassive black holes at $z>5$ for quasar and black hole growth
• Past, present and Future of the Scaling Relations of Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei
• It is Feasible to Directly Measure Black Hole Masses in the First Galaxies
• Euclid: Discovery of 31 new quasars at $6.6<z<7.8$
• A stellar dynamical mass measurement of an inactive black hole at redshift 2
• Scaling Relations Between Low-mass Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies
• Black Hole-Galaxy Correlations in Cluster Zoomed-in Simulations: GIZMO-SIMBA and TNG-Cluster
• Gravitational Wave Measurement of the $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$-$M_{\mathrm{bulge}}$ Intrinsic Scatter at High Redshift
• Off-center black hole seed formation? Implications for high and low redshift massive black holes
• Quiescent Host Galaxies of Extended Quasars Revealed by Spectrophotometric Decomposition