A massive blow for $\Lambda$CDM $-$ the high redshift, mass, and collision velocity of the interacting galaxy cluster El Gordo contradicts concordance cosmology

Abstract

El Gordo (ACT-CL J0102-4915) is an extremely massive galaxy cluster ($M_{200}\approx 3\times 10^{15}$ $M_{\odot }$) at redshift $z=0.87$ composed of two subclusters with mass ratio 3.6 merging at speed $V_{infall}\approx 2500$ km/s. Such a fast collision between individually rare massive clusters is unexpected in Lambda cold dark matter ($\Lambda$CDM) cosmology at such high $z$. However, this is required for non-cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of the merger to match its observed properties (Zhang et al. 2015). Here, we determine the probability of finding a similar object in a $\Lambda$CDM context using the Jubilee simulation box with side length $6h^{-1}$ Gpc. We search for galaxy cluster pairs that have turned around from the cosmic expansion with properties similar to El Gordo in terms of total mass, mass ratio, redshift, and collision velocity relative to virial velocity. We fit the distribution of pair total mass quite accurately, with the fits used in two methods to infer the probability of observing El Gordo in the surveyed region. The more conservative (and detailed) method involves considering the expected distribution of pairwise mass and redshift for analogue pairs with similar dimensionless parameters to El Gordo in the past lightcone of a $z=0$ observer. Detecting one pair with its mass and redshift rules out $\Lambda$CDM cosmology at $6.16\sigma$. We also use the results of Kraljic & Sarkar (2015) to show that the Bullet Cluster is in $2.78\sigma$ tension once the sky coverage of its discovery survey is accounted for. Using a ${\chi }^2$ approach, the combined tension can be estimated as $6.43\sigma$. Both collisions arise naturally in a Milgromian dynamics (MOND) cosmology with light sterile neutrinos.

arXiv comment21 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables, 4 MB. Accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society in this form

References in corpus (107)

• Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant
• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
• The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
• A direct empirical proof of the existence of dark matter
• The Rockstar Phase-Space Temporal Halo Finder and the Velocity Offsets of Cluster Cores
• The Structure of Dark Matter Haloes in Dwarf Galaxies
• The Mass Function of an X-Ray Flux-Limited Sample of Galaxy Clusters
• The MACHO Project: Microlensing Results from 5.7 Years of LMC Observations
• Direct constraints on the dark matter self-interaction cross-section from the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56
• Limits on the Macho Content of the Galactic Halo from the EROS-2 Survey of the Magellanic Clouds
• Dark matter halo concentrations in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe year 5 cosmology
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND): Observational Phenomenology and Relativistic Extensions
• Ahf: Amiga's Halo Finder
• Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
• The Radial Acceleration Relation in Rotationally Supported Galaxies
• Scalar-Tensor-Vector Gravity Theory
• The Expansion of the Universe is Faster than Expected
• Significant Excess of ElectronLike Events in the MiniBooNE Short-Baseline Neutrino Experiment
• The evolution substructure I: a new identification method
• Haloes gone MAD: The Halo-Finder Comparison Project
• Planck Early Results VIII: The all-sky Early Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster sample
• Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• One Law To Rule Them All: The Radial Acceleration Relation of Galaxies
• Pōniuā'ena: A Luminous $z=7.5$ Quasar Hosting a 1.5 Billion Solar Mass Black Hole
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics in the Milky Way
• Large Scale Structure in Bekenstein's theory of relativistic Modified Newtonian Dynamics
• A complete sample of twelve very X-ray luminous galaxy clusters at z>0.5
• The halo mass function through the cosmic ages
• Quasi-linear formulation of MOND
• The relation between velocity dispersion and mass in simulated clusters of galaxies: dependence on the tracer and the baryonic physics
• Planck 2013 results. XXVII. Doppler boosting of the CMB: Eppur si muove
• Discovery of an X-ray-Luminous Galaxy Cluster at z=1.4
• Discovery of a galaxy cluster with a violently starbursting core at z=2.506
• The dark matter crisis: falsification of the current standard model of cosmology
• A massive core for a cluster of galaxies at a redshift of 4.3
• Galaxies as simple dynamical systems: observational data disfavor dark matter and stochastic star formation
• Evidence for a ~300 Mpc Scale Under-density in the Local Galaxy Distribution
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: ACT-CL J0102-4915 "El Gordo," a Massive Merging Cluster at Redshift 0.87
• On the Proof of Dark Matter, the Law of Gravity and the Mass of Neutrinos
• An MHD Gadget for cosmological simulations
• Resolving the virial discrepancy in clusters of galaxies with modified Newtonian dynamics
• Subsonic turbulence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics and moving-mesh simulations
• IDCS J1426+3508: Discovery of a Massive, IR-Selected Galaxy Cluster at z = 1.75
• Fitting the radial acceleration relation to individual SPARC galaxies
• High Performance P3M N-body code: CUBEP3M
• Hydrostatic mass profiles in X-COP galaxy clusters
• The Bullet Cluster 1E0657-558 evidence shows Modified Gravity in the absence of Dark Matter
• THINGS about MOND
• Discovery and Cosmological Implications of SPT-CL J2106-5844, the Most Massive Known Cluster at z > 1
• Simultaneous Falsification of LCDM and Quintessence with Massive, Distant Clusters
• The progeny of a Cosmic Titan: a massive multi-component proto-supercluster in formation at z=2.45 in VUDS
• 1E0657-56: A Contender for the Hottest Known Cluster of Galaxies
• Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Study of the Galaxy Cluster XMMU J2235.3-2557 at z=1.4: A Surprisingly Massive Galaxy Cluster when the Universe is One-third of its Current Age
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Physical Properties and Purity of a Galaxy Cluster Sample Selected via the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• The KBC void and Hubble tension contradict $\Lambda$CDM on a Gpc scale $-$ Milgromian dynamics as a possible solution
• Are sterile neutrinos consistent with clusters, the CMB and MOND?
• Bullet Cluster: A Challenge to LCDM Cosmology
• Cosmology with Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND)
• Weighing "El Gordo" with a Precision Scale: Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Analysis of the Merging Galaxy Cluster ACT-CL J0102-4915 at z=0.87
• An Extremely Massive Quiescent Galaxy at $z=3.493$: Evidence of Insufficiently Rapid Quenching Mechanisms in Theoretical Models
• A Global Analysis of Dark Matter Signals from 27 Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies using 11 Years of Fermi-LAT Observations
• How Rare is the Bullet Cluster?
• Strong constraints on thermal relic dark matter from Fermi-LAT observations of the Galactic Center
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics of Large Scale Structure
• MOND simulation suggests the origin of some peculiarities in the Local Group
• Testing Gravity with wide binary stars like $\alpha$ Centauri
• Observational evidence for a local underdensity in the Universe and its effect on the measurement of the Hubble Constant
• X-ray/UV Observing Campaign on the Mrk 279 AGN Outflow: A Global Fitting Analysis of the UV Absorption
• SPT-CL J0205-5829: A z = 1.32 Evolved Massive Galaxy Cluster in the South Pole Telescope Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Survey
• Testing the MOND Paradigm of Modified Dynamics with Galaxy-Galaxy Gravitational Lensing
• The formation of cosmic structure with modified Newtonian dynamics
• Statistics of extreme objects in the Juropa Hubble Volume simulation
• The abundance of galaxy clusters in MOND: Cosmological simulations with massive neutrinos
• Discovery of the first giant double radio relic in a galaxy cluster found in the PLANCK Sunyaev-Zel'dovich cluster survey: PLCK G287.0+32.9
• Massive and old quiescent galaxies at high redshift
• The collision velocity of the bullet cluster in conventional and modified dynamics
• A highly elongated prominent lens at z=0.87: first strong lensing analysis of El Gordo
• Pairwise Velocities of Dark Matter Halos: a Test for the Lambda Cold Dark Matter Model using the Bullet Cluster
• Merger induced scatter and bias in the cluster mass - Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect scaling relation
• Equilibrium configurations of 11eV sterile neutrinos in MONDian galaxy clusters
• Constrained Simulation of the Bullet Cluster
• Cluster-Void Degeneracy Breaking: Dark Energy, Planck and the Largest Cluster & Void
• Chandra deep observation of XDCP J0044.0-2033, a massive galaxy cluster at z>1.5
• Origin of the Local Group satellite planes
• Cosmological simulations in MOND: the cluster scale halo mass function with light sterile neutrinos
• Marriage à-la-MOND: Baryonic dark matter in galaxy clusters and the cooling flow puzzle
• A Hydrodynamical Solution for the "Twin-Tailed" Colliding Galaxy Cluster "El Gordo"
• The return of the merging galaxy subclusters of El Gordo?
• The Jubilee ISW Project I: simulated ISW and weak lensing maps and initial power spectra results
• MC${}^2$: Subaru and Hubble Space Telescope Weak-Lensing Analysis of the Double Radio Relic Galaxy Cluster PLCK G287.0+32.9
• Initial Conditions for Idealised Clusters Mergers, simulating El Gordo
• Testing modified Newtonian dynamics in the Milky Way
• Simulating the galaxy cluster "El Gordo" and identifying the merger configuration
• Galaxy Cluster Bulk Flows and Collision Velocities in QUMOND
• Merging Galaxy Clusters: Offset Between the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and X-ray Peaks
• A sample of 1959 massive galaxy clusters at high redshifts
• The Star Formation History and Dynamics of the Ultra-diffuse Galaxy Dragonfly 44 in MOND and MOG
• WMAP5 and the Cluster Mass Function
• Optical & Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Observations of a New Sample of Distant Rich Galaxy Clusters in the ROSAT All Sky Survey
• How rare is the Bullet Cluster (in a $\Lambda$CDM universe)?
• The extended ROSAT-ESO Flux-Limited X-ray Galaxy Cluster Survey (REFLEX II) V. Exploring a local underdensity in the Southern Sky
• The whole picture of the large-scale structure of the CL1604 supercluster at z$\sim$0.9
• Modeling Nearly Spherical Pure-bulge Galaxies with a Stellar Mass-to-Light Ratio Gradient under the $\Lambda$CDM and MOND Paradigms: I. Methodology, Dynamical Stellar Mass, and Fundamental Mass Plane
• Precise Mass Determination of SPT-CL J2106-5844, the Most Massive Cluster at z>1
• Planck intermediate results. VI: The dynamical structure of PLCKG214.6+37.0, a Planck discovered triple system of galaxy clusters
• An Analytic Formula for the Supercluster Mass Function

Cited by in corpus (50)

• Challenges for $\Lambda$CDM: An update
• The $H_0$ Olympics: A fair ranking of proposed models
• On the Hubble constant tension in the SNe Ia Pantheon sample
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• On the evolution of the Hubble constant with the SNe Ia Pantheon Sample and Baryon Acoustic Oscillations: a feasibility study for GRB-cosmology in 2030
• From galactic bars to the Hubble tension: weighing up the astrophysical evidence for Milgromian gravity
• UNCOVERing the extended strong lensing structures of Abell 2744 with the deepest JWST imaging
• Has JWST already falsified dark-matter-driven galaxy formation?
• Fast galaxy bars continue to challenge standard cosmology
• The distribution and morphologies of Fornax Cluster dwarf galaxies suggest they lack dark matter
• JWST's PEARLS: a new lens model for ACT-CL J0102$-$4915, "EL Gordo'', and the first red supergiant star at cosmological distances discovered by JWST
• Strong constraints on the gravitational law from $Gaia$ DR3 wide binaries
• Testing the Strong Equivalence Principle. II. Relating the External Field Effect in Galaxy Rotation Curves to the Large-Scale Structure of the Universe
• A simultaneous solution to the Hubble tension and observed bulk flow within 250 $h^{-1}$ Mpc
• Head-to-Toe Measurement of El Gordo: Improved Analysis of the Galaxy Cluster ACT-CL J0102-4915 with New Wide-field Hubble Space Telescope Imaging Data
• 3D hydrodynamic simulations for the formation of the Local Group satellite planes
• The High Fraction of Thin Disk Galaxies Continues to Challenge ΛCDM Cosmology
• Barred spiral galaxies in modified gravity theories
• Do ultra compact dwarf galaxies form monolithically or as merged star cluster complexes?
• The El Gordo galaxy cluster challenges ΛCDM for any plausible collision velocity
• A MUSE view of the massive merging galaxy cluster ACT-CL J0102-4915 (El Gordo) at z = 0.87: robust strong lensing model and data release
• The redshift dependence of the inferred $H_0$ in a local void solution to the Hubble tension
• Hydrodynamical structure formation in Milgromian cosmology
• Testing the local void hypothesis using baryon acoustic oscillation measurements over the last twenty years
• An empirical measurement of the Halo Mass Function from the combination of GAMA DR4, SDSS DR12, and REFLEX II data
• Open star clusters and their asymmetrical tidal tails
• The SRG/eROSITA All-Sky Survey : Constraints on the structure growth from cluster number counts
• DS+: a method for the identification of cluster substructures
• Dark Matter Realism
• The Kennicutt-Schmidt law and the main sequence of galaxies in Newtonian and Milgromian dynamics
• On the fundamentality of the radial acceleration relation for late-type galaxy dynamics
• New evidence and analysis of cosmological-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions
• On the absence of backsplash analogues to NGC 3109 in the $\Lambda$CDM framework
• The Magellanic Clouds are very rare in the IllustrisTNG simulations
• The velocity structure of the intracluster medium during a major merger: simulated microcalorimeter observations
• What if the universe expands linearly? A local general relativity to solve the "zero active mass" problem
• Explaining JWST star formation history at $z\sim 17$ by modifying $\Lambda$CDM
• X-ray cluster cosmology
• Constraints on the Hubble and matter density parameters with and without modelling the CMB anisotropies
• A new constant behind the rotational velocity of galaxies
• High-redshift Galaxies from JWST Observations in More Realistic Dark Matter Halo Models
• Simulating realistic self-interacting dark matter models including small and large-angle scattering
• MOND-like behavior in the Dirac-Milne universe -- Flat rotation curves and mass/velocity relations in galaxies and clusters
• Evolution of globular-cluster systems of ultra-diffuse galaxies due to dynamical friction in MOND gravity
• Fast particle-mesh code for Milgromian dynamics
• Gas of thin tubes of massless scalar field as a possible model of unified dark fluid
• Phase transition in Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MONDian) self-gravitating systems
• Are disks of satellites comprised of tidal dwarf galaxies?
• Overestimated inclinations of Milgromian disc galaxies: the case of the ultradiffuse galaxy AGC 114905
• Constraints on the gravitational potential from DESI DR2 BAO and its implications for the local void scenario