A Review of Basic Energy Reconstruction Techniques in Liquid Xenon and Argon Detectors for Dark Matter and Neutrino Physics Using NEST

Abstract

Detectors based upon the noble elements, especially liquid xenon as well as liquid argon, as both single- and dual-phase types, require reconstruction of the energies of interacting particles, both in the field of direct detection of dark matter (Weakly Interacting Massive Particles or WIMPs, axions, etc.) and in neutrino physics. Experimentalists, as well as theorists who reanalyze/reinterpret experimental data, have used a few different techniques over the past few decades. In this paper, we review techniques based on solely the primary scintillation channel, the ionization or secondary channel available at non-zero drift electric fields, and combined techniques that include a simple linear combination and weighted averages, with a brief discussion of the applications of profile likelihood, maximum likelihood, and machine learning. Comparing results for electron recoils (beta and gamma interactions) and nuclear recoils (primarily from neutrons) from the Noble Element Simulation Technique (NEST) simulation to available data, we confirm that combining all available information generates higher-precision means, lower widths (energy resolution), and more symmetric shapes (approximately Gaussian) especially at keV-scale energies, with the symmetry even greater when thresholding is addressed. Near thresholds, bias from upward fluctuations matters. For MeV-GeV scales, if only one channel is utilized, an ionization-only-based energy scale outperforms scintillation; channel combination remains beneficial. We discuss here what major collaborations use.

42 Pages, 2 Tables, 11 Figures, 13 Equations

References in corpus (62)

• Results from a search for dark matter in the complete LUX exposure
• Dark Matter Results From 54-Ton-Day Exposure of PandaX-II Experiment
• Observation of Coherent Elastic Neutrino-Nucleus Scattering
• Excess Electronic Recoil Events in XENON1T
• First Dark Matter Results from the XENON100 Experiment
• Search for Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay in ${}^{136}$Xe with EXO-200
• Limit on Neutrinoless ββ Decay of Xe-136 from the First Phase of KamLAND-Zen and Comparison with the Positive Claim in Ge-76
• The Large Underground Xenon (LUX) Experiment
• First Results from the DarkSide-50 Dark Matter Experiment at Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso
• Superconducting Nanowire Single-Photon Detectors for Quantum Information
• Liquid noble gas detectors for low energy particle physics
• Projected WIMP Sensitivity of the XENONnT Dark Matter Experiment
• The Astrophysical Uncertainties Of Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
• Results from the First Science Run of the ZEPLIN-III Dark Matter Search Experiment
• Simultaneous Measurement of Ionization and Scintillation from Nuclear Recoils in Liquid Xenon as Target for a Dark Matter Experiment
• Systematic study of trace radioactive impurities in candidate construction materials for EXO-200
• XENON100 Dark Matter Results from a Combination of 477 Live Days
• Measurement of Scintillation and Ionization Yield and Scintillation Pulse Shape from Nuclear Recoils in Liquid Argon
• Limits on Majoron-emitting double-beta decays of Xe-136 in the KamLAND-Zen experiment
• A Model of Nuclear Recoil Scintillation Efficiency in Noble Liquids
• Radiogenic and Muon-Induced Backgrounds in the LUX Dark Matter Detector
• Exploring New Physics with O(keV) Electron Recoils in Direct Detection Experiments
• XENON1T Dark Matter Data Analysis: Signal & Background Models, and Statistical Inference
• Nuclear recoil energy scale in liquid xenon with application to the direct detection of dark matter
• Investigation of background electron emission in the LUX detector
• Technical Results from the Surface Run of the LUX Dark Matter Experiment
• Low-energy (0.7-74 keV) nuclear recoil calibration of the LUX dark matter experiment using D-D neutron scattering kinematics
• Characterization of the Hamamatsu VUV4 MPPCs for nEXO
• Signal yields, energy resolution, and recombination fluctuations in liquid xenon
• Ultra-Low Energy Calibration of LUX Detector using ${}^{127}$Xe Electron Capture
• Atomic limits in the search for galactic dark matter
• Discrimination of electronic recoils from nuclear recoils in two-phase xenon time projection chambers
• A coherent understanding of low-energy nuclear recoils in liquid xenon
• Simulations of Events for the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Dark Matter Experiment
• Search for bosonic superweakly interacting massive dark matter particles with the XMASS-I detector
• Electron extraction efficiency study for dual-phase xenon dark matter experiments
• Projected sensitivity of the LUX-ZEPLIN experiment to the $0\nu \beta \beta$ decay of ${}^{136}$Xe
• Calibration of a two-phase xenon time projection chamber with a ${}^{37}$Ar source
• ${}^{83\text{m}}$Kr calibration of the 2013 LUX dark matter search
• A Convolutional Neural Network for Multiple Particle Identification in the MicroBooNE Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber
• COHERENT Collaboration data release from the first detection of coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering on argon
• The Liquid Argon In A Testbeam (LArIAT) Experiment
• Characterisation of NEXT-DEMO using xenon K${}_{\alpha }$ X-rays
• Search for Bosonic Super-WIMP Interactions with the XENON100 Experiment
• Study of the ionization efficiency for nuclear recoils in pure crystals
• 3D Modeling of Electric Fields in the LUX Detector
• Investigating the XENON1T Low-Energy Electronic Recoil Excess Using NEST
• Proposed low-energy absolute calibration of nuclear recoils in a dual-phase noble element TPC using D-D neutron scattering kinematics
• Determination of responses of liquid xenon to low energy electron and nuclear recoils using the PandaX-II detector
• Reflectivity and PDE of VUV4 Hamamatsu SiPMs in Liquid Xenon
• Improved Measurements of the \b{eta}-Decay Response of Liquid Xenon with the LUX Detector
• The Electronics, Trigger and Data Acquisition System for the Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber of the DarkSide-50 Search for Dark Matter
• Discovery of underground argon with low level of radioactive 39Ar and possible applications to WIMP dark matter detectors
• Lowering the low-energy threshold of xenon detectors
• Study of nuclear recoils in liquid argon with monoenergetic neutrons
• Improved Modeling of $\beta$ Electronic Recoils in Liquid Xenon Using LUX Calibration Data
• Krypton and radon background in the PandaX-I dark matter experiment
• Liquid argon scintillation response to electronic recoils between $2.8$--$1275\mathrm{keV}$ in a high light yield single-phase detector
• A New Analysis Method for WIMP searches with Dual-Phase Liquid Xe TPCs
• Properties for liquid argon scintillation for dark matter searches
• On the Upper Limit of Separability
• Revised performance parameters of the ZEPLIN-III dark matter experiment

Cited by in corpus (31)

• Dark Matter Search Results from the PandaX-4T Commissioning Run
• Search for New Physics in Electronic Recoil Data from XENONnT
• Applications and Techniques for Fast Machine Learning in Science
• A Search for Light Fermionic Dark Matter Absorption on Electrons in PandaX-4T
• A search for new physics in low-energy electron recoils from the first LZ exposure
• Background Determination for the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) Dark Matter Experiment
• Sensitivity projections for a dual-phase argon TPC optimized for light dark matter searches through the ionization channel
• Detecting Beyond the Standard Model Interactions of Solar Neutrinos in Low-Threshold Dark Matter Detectors
• First search for the absorption of fermionic dark matter with the PandaX-4T experiment
• Xenon-Doped Liquid Argon TPCs as a Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay Platform
• A Review of NEST Models for Liquid Xenon and Exhaustive Comparison to Other Approaches
• Large Low Background kTon-Scale Liquid Argon Time Projection Chambers
• Neutrino Backgrounds in Future Liquid Noble Element Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
• Low-energy Calibration of XENON1T with an Internal ${}^{37}$Ar Source
• Development of a novel, windowless, amorphous selenium based photodetector for use in liquid noble detectors
• Measurement of ambient radon progeny decay rates and energy spectra in liquid argon using the MicroBooNE detector
• Search for light dark matter from atmosphere in PandaX-4T
• Search for Cosmic-ray Boosted Sub-MeV Dark-Matter-Electron Scattering in PandaX-4T
• Two-neutrino double electron capture of ${}^{124}$Xe in the first LUX-ZEPLIN exposure
• Self-compensating Light Calorimetry with Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber for GeV Neutrino Physics
• Detection and Calibration of Low-Energy Nuclear Recoils for Dark Matter and Neutrino Scattering Experiments
• Isospin-violating dark matter at liquid noble detectors: new constraints, future projections, and an exploration of target complementarity
• Measurements and models of enhanced recombination following inner-shell vacancies in liquid xenon
• Model for bubble nucleation efficiency of low-energy nuclear recoils in bubble chambers for dark matter detection
• The Fast Stochastic Matching Pursuit for Neutrino and Dark Matter Experiments
• Nuclear recoil response of liquid xenon and its impact on solar 8B neutrino and dark matter searches
• Snowmass Instrumentation Frontier IF08 Topical Group Report: Noble Element Detectors
• Identification and reconstruction of low-energy electrons in the ProtoDUNE-SP detector
• A measurement of the mean electronic excitation energy of liquid xenon
• Search for New Physics via Low-Energy Electron Recoils with a 4.2 Tonne\times Year Exposure from the LZ Experiment
• Light yield and field dependence measurement in PandaX-II dual-phase xenon detector