No evidence for a significant AGN contribution to cosmic hydrogen reionization

Abstract

We reinvestigate a claimed sample of 22 X-ray detected active galactic nuclei (AGN) at redshifts z > 4, which has reignited the debate as to whether young galaxies or AGN reionized the Universe. These sources lie within the GOODS-S/CANDELS field, and we examine both the robustness of the claimed X-ray detections (within the Chandra 4Ms imaging) and perform an independent analysis of the photometric redshifts of the optical/infrared counterparts. We confirm the reality of only 15 of the 22 reported X-ray detections, and moreover find that only 12 of the 22 optical/infrared counterpart galaxies actually lie robustly at z > 4. Combining these results we find convincing evidence for only 7 X-ray AGN at z > 4 in the GOODS-S field, of which only one lies at z > 5. We recalculate the evolving far-UV (1500 Angstrom) luminosity density produced by AGN at high redshift, and find that it declines rapidly from z = 4 to z = 6, in agreement with several other recent studies of the evolving AGN luminosity function. The associated rapid decline in inferred hydrogen-ionizing emissivity contributed by AGN falls an order-of-magnitude short of the level required to maintain hydrogen ionization at z ~ 6. We conclude that all available evidence continues to favour a scenario in which young galaxies reionized the Universe, with AGN making, at most, a very minor contribution to cosmic hydrogen reionization.

arXiv commentUpdated to accepted version: 21 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (95)

• The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• CANDELS: The Cosmic Assembly Near-infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey
• CANDELS: The Cosmic Assembly Near-infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey - The Hubble Space Telescope Observations, Imaging Data Products and Mosaics
• Accurate photometric redshifts for the CFHT Legacy Survey calibrated using the VIMOS VLT Deep Survey
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey: Initial Results From Optical and Near-Infrared Imaging
• A luminous quasar at a redshift of z = 7.085
• Constraining the Evolution of the Ionizing Background and the Epoch of Reionization with z ~ 6 Quasars II: A Sample of 19 Quasars
• UV Luminosity Functions at redshifts z~4 to z~10: 10000 Galaxies from HST Legacy Fields
• Radiative transfer in a clumpy universe: IV. New synthesis models of the cosmic UV/X-ray background
• 3D-HST WFC3-selected Photometric Catalogs in the Five CANDELS/3D-HST Fields: Photometry, Photometric Redshifts and Stellar Masses
• Cosmic Reionization and Early Star-Forming Galaxies: A Joint Analysis of New Constraints from Planck and Hubble Space Telescope
• The SDSS Quasar Survey: Quasar Luminosity Function from Data Release Three
• The Evolution of the Galaxy Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Luminosity Function Over the First Two Billion Years
• The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 4 Ms Source Catalogs
• The Rest-Frame Extreme Ultraviolet Spectral Properties of QSOs
• New Constraints on Cosmic Reionization from the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field Campaign
• CANDELS Multi-wavelength Catalogs: Source Detection and Photometry in the GOODS-South Field
• Model-independent evidence in favor of an end to reionization by z~6
• The Abundance of Star-Forming Galaxies in the Redshift Range 8.5 to 12: New Results from the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field Campaign
• Reionization of the Inhomogeneous Universe
• The effect of massive binaries on stellar populations and supernova progenitors
• Keck Spectroscopy of Faint 3<z<7 Lyman Break Galaxies: - I. New constraints on cosmic reionisation from the luminosity and redshift-dependent fraction of Lyman-alpha emission
• Reionization after Planck: The Derived Growth of the Cosmic Ionizing Emissivity now matches the Growth of the Galaxy UV Luminosity Density
• A new multi-field determination of the galaxy luminosity function at z=7-9 incorporating the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field imaging
• Stellar Population Effects on the Inferred Photon Density at Reionization
• Cosmic Reionization after Planck: Could Quasars Do It All?
• A Critical Assessment of Photometric Redshift Methods: A CANDELS Investigation
• Eddington-limited accretion and the black hole mass function at redshift 6
• Early star-forming galaxies and the reionization of the Universe
• The Final SDSS High-Redshift Quasar Sample of 52 Quasars at z>5.7
• Spectral synthesis including massive binaries
• The Most Luminous z~9-10 Galaxy Candidates yet Found: The Luminosity Function, Cosmic Star-Formation Rate, and the First Mass Density Estimate at 500 Myr
• Faint AGNs at z>4 in the CANDELS GOODS-S field: looking for contributors to the reionization of the Universe
• Spectroscopic confirmation of z~7 LBGs: probing the earliest galaxies and the epoch of reionization
• The XMM-Newton Wide-Field Survey in the COSMOS field (XMM-COSMOS): demography and multiwavelength properties of obscured and unobscured luminous AGN
• The Discovery of a Luminous z=5.80 Quasar from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 Early Release Science data: Panchromatic Faint Object Counts for 0.2-2 microns wavelength
• Keck Spectroscopy of Faint 3<z<8 Lyman Break Galaxies:- Evidence for a Declining Fraction of Emission Line Sources In the Redshift Range 6<z<8
• Line Emitting Galaxies Beyond a Redshift of 7: An Improved Method for Estimating the Evolving Neutrality of the Intergalactic Medium
• New observations of z~7 galaxies: evidence for a patchy reionization
• The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 2 Ms Source Catalogs
• HeII Reionization and its Effect on the IGM
• Spectroscopic detection of CIV in a galaxy at z=7.045: Implications for the ionizing spectra of reionization-era galaxies
• Evolution of the Intergalactic Opacity: Implications for the Ionizing Background, Cosmic Star Formation, and Quasar Activity
• The z = 9-10 galaxy population in the Hubble Frontier Fields and CLASH surveys: The z=9 LF and further evidence for a smooth decline in UV luminosity at z >= 8
• Planck intermediate results. XLVII. Planck constraints on reionization history
• The z=5 Quasar Luminosity Function from SDSS Stripe 82
• How neutral is the intergalactic medium surrounding the redshift z=7.085 quasar ULAS J1120+0641?
• The bright end of the galaxy luminosity function at z ~ 7: before the onset of mass quenching?
• The galaxy luminosity function at z ~ 6 and evidence for rapid evolution in the bright end from z ~ 7 to 5
• The changing Lya optical depth in the range 6<z<9 from MOSFIRE spectroscopy of Y-dropouts
• The UV continua and inferred stellar populations of galaxies at z ~ 7 - 9 revealed by the Hubble Ultra Deep Field 2012 campaign
• Rapid Decline of Lyman-alpha Emission Toward the Reionization Era
• A Survey of z~6 Quasars in the SDSS Deep Stripe. II. Discovery of Six Quasars at z_{AB}>21
• Deep U band and R imaging of GOODS-South: Observations,data reduction and first results
• New redshift z ~ 9 galaxies in the Hubble Frontier Fields: Implications for early evolution of the UV luminosity density
• Faint high-redshift AGN in the Chandra Deep Field South: the evolution of the AGN luminosity function and black hole demography
• A Deep HST Search for Escaping Lyman Continuum Flux at z~1.3: Evidence for an Evolving Ionizing Emissivity
• Unveiling the nature of bright z ~ 7 galaxies with the Hubble Space Telescope
• CANDELS/GOODS-S, CDFS, ECDFS: Photometric Redshifts For Normal and for X-Ray-Detected Galaxies
• The Faint End of the Quasar Luminosity Function at z~4: Implications for Ionization of the Intergalactic Medium and Cosmic Downsizing
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey - VLT/ISAAC Near-Infrared Imaging of the GOODS-South Field
• Evolution of the Quasar Luminosity Function Over 3 < z < 5 in the COSMOS Survey Field
• A remarkably high fraction of strong Ly_alpha emitters amongst luminous redshift 6.0<z<6.5 Lyman break galaxies in the UKIDSS Ultra-Deep Survey
• The redshift evolution of escape fraction of hydrogen ionizing photons from galaxies
• The Hawk-I UDS and GOODS Survey (HUGS): Survey design and deep K-band number counts
• The galaxy UV luminosity function at z ~ 2 - 4; new results on faint-end slope and the evolution of luminosity density
• Luminosity Function from dedicated SDSS-III and MMT data of quasars in 0.7<z<4.0 selected with a new approach
• The Hard X-Ray Luminosity Function of High-Redshift ($3<z\lesssim 5$) Active Galactic Nuclei
• On the relative Contribution of high-redshift Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei to Reionization
• The X-ray luminosity function of Active Galactic Nuclei in the redshift interval z=3-5
• The Lyman Continuum escape fraction of faint galaxies at z~3.3 in the CANDELS/GOODS-North, EGS, and COSMOS fields with LBC
• The brighter galaxies reionised the Universe
• The Population of High Redshift AGNs in the Chandra COSMOS survey
• Evolution in the Escape Fraction of Ionizing Photons and the Decline in Strong Lya Emission from z>6 Galaxies
• A systematic search for very massive galaxies at z > 4
• The imprint of inhomogeneous HeII reionization on the HI and HeII Ly-alpha forest
• The deepest X-ray view of high-redshift galaxies: constraints on low-rate black-hole accretion
• Constraining the UV emissivity of AGN throughout cosmic time via X-ray surveys
• High-Redshift QSOs in the SWIRE Survey and the z~3 QSO Luminosity Function
• The systematic search for $z\gtrsim 5$ active galactic nuclei in the $Chandra$ Deep Field South
• Dark-ages Reionization and Galaxy Formation Simulation - X. The small contribution of quasars to reionization
• No evidence for Population III stars or a Direct Collapse Black Hole in the z = 6.6 Lyman-$\alpha$ emitter 'CR7'
• On the Evolution of the Cosmic Ionizing Background
• The 5 - 10 keV AGN luminosity function at 0.01<z<4.0
• Quasar UV luminosity function evolution up to z=8
• Local Group Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxies in the Reionization Era
• Observations of the Lyman series forest towards the redshift 7.1 quasar ULAS J1120+0641
• Inhomogeneous Helium Reionization and the Equation of State of the Intergalactic Medium
• Chandra counterparts of CANDELS GOODS-S sources
• Winds of change: reionization by starburst galaxies
• Constraints on QSO emissivity using H I and He II Lyman alpha forest
• AGNs as main contributors to the UV ionizing emissivity at high redshifts: predictions from a Lambda-CDM model with linked AGN/galaxy evolution
• Searching for candidates of Lyman continuum sources - revisiting the SSA22 field

Cited by in corpus (116)

• The Universe is Reionizing at z~7: Bayesian Inference of the IGM Neutral Fraction Using Ly$\alpha$ Emission from Galaxies
• Conditions for Reionizing the Universe with A Low Galaxy Ionizing Photon Escape Fraction
• The Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function at z = 0-7
• Low-redshift Lyman continuum leaking galaxies with high [OIII]/[OII] ratios
• The SPHINX Cosmological Simulations of the First Billion Years: the Impact of Binary Stars on Reionization
• Inferences on the Timeline of Reionization at z~8 From the KMOS Lens-Amplified Spectroscopic Survey
• Evolution of the AGN UV luminosity function from redshift 7.5
• Introducing the THESAN project: radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the epoch of reionization
• Galaxy Formation and Reionization: Key Unknowns and Expected Breakthroughs by the James Webb Space Telescope
• Subaru High-z Exploration of Low-Luminosity Quasars (SHELLQs). V. Quasar Luminosity Function and Contribution to Cosmic Reionization at z = 6
• Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
• Great Optically Luminous Dropout Research Using Subaru HSC (GOLDRUSH). I. UV Luminosity Functions at $z\sim 4-7$ Derived with the Half-Million Dropouts on the 100 deg${}^2$ Sky
• High-redshift AGN in the Chandra Deep Fields: the obscured fraction and space density of the sub-$L_{\ast }$ population
• Revealing reionization with the thermal history of the intergalactic medium: new constraints from the Lyman-$\alpha$ flux power spectrum
• SILVERRUSH. V. Census of Lya, [OIII]5007, Ha, and [CII]158um Line Emission with ~1000 LAEs at z=4.9-7.0 Revealed with Subaru/HSC
• Reionization and galaxy inference from the high-redshift Lyα forest
• The hierarchical assembly of galaxies and black holes in the first billion years: predictions for the era of gravitational wave astronomy
• An uncontaminated measurement of the escaping Lyman continuum at $z\sim 3$
• The Quasar Luminosity Function at Redshift 4 with Hyper Suprime-Cam Wide Survey
• The low-end of the black hole mass function at cosmic dawn
• The Faint End of the z=5 Quasar Luminosity Function from the CFHTLS
• The Obelisk simulation: galaxies contribute more than AGN to HI reionization of protoclusters
• Physical properties and H-ionizing-photon production rates of extreme nearby star-forming regions
• Diverse properties of Ly-alpha emission in low-redshift compact star-forming galaxies with extremely high [OIII]/[OII] ratios
• Evidence for Large-Scale Fluctuations in the Metagalactic Ionizing Background Near Redshift Six
• A tale of two sites -- I: Inferring the properties of minihalo-hosted galaxies from current observations
• Euclid preparation: V. Predicted yield of redshift 7<z<9 quasars from the wide survey
• Constraining the contribution of active galactic nuclei to reionisation
• Escape of ionizing radiation from high redshift dwarf galaxies: role of AGN feedback
• The Impact of Scatter in the Galaxy UV Luminosity to Halo Mass Relation on Ly$\alpha$ Visibility During the Epoch of Reionization
• Model-independent constraints on the hydrogen-ionizing emissivity at z>6
• Reionization in Technicolor
• Chasing the Tail of Cosmic Reionization with Dark Gap Statistics in the Ly$\alpha$ Forest over $5<z<6$
• The contribution of faint AGNs to the ionizing background at z~4
• The Role of Galaxies and AGN in Reionising the IGM - I: Keck Spectroscopy of 5 < z < 7 Galaxies in the QSO Field J1148+5251
• The Faint End of the Quasar Luminosity Function at $z\sim 5$ from the Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam Survey
• Constraining the astrophysics and cosmology from 21cm tomography using deep learning with the SKA
• (Re)Solving Reionization with Lyα: How Bright Lyα Emitters account for the $z\approx 2-8$ Cosmic Ionizing Background
• The 21cm bispectrum as a probe of non-Gaussianities due to X-ray heating
• The Epoch of IGM heating by early sources of X-rays
• The Little Engines That Could? Globular Clusters Contribute Significantly to Reionization-era Star Formation
• Lyman-$\alpha$ as a tracer of cosmic reionisation in the SPHINX radiation-hydrodynamics cosmological simulation
• The rest-frame UV luminosity function at $z\simeq 4$: a significant contribution of AGN to the bright-end of the galaxy population
• UV absorption lines and their potential for tracing the Lyman continuum escape fraction
• The VANDELS survey: a measurement of the average Lyman-continuum escape fraction of star-forming galaxies at z=3.5
• Definitive upper bound on the negligible contribution of quasars to cosmic reionization
• Peering into cosmic reionization: the Ly$\alpha$ visibility evolution from galaxies at $z$ = 4.5-8.5 with JWST
• The role of galaxies and AGN in reionising the IGM -- III : IGM-galaxy cross-correlations at z~6 from 8 quasar fields with DEIMOS and MUSE
• Large scale simulations of H and He reionization and heating driven by stars and more energetic sources
• The role of galaxies and AGN in reionizing the IGM - II: metal-tracing the faint sources of reionization at $5\lesssim z\lesssim 6$
• Two more, bright, z > 6 quasars from VST ATLAS and WISE
• Evaluating the QSO contribution to the 21-cm signal from the Cosmic Dawn
• The Evolution of the HeII-Ionizing Background at Redshifts 2.3<z<3.8 Inferred from a Statistical Sample of 24 HST/COS HeII Ly$\alpha$ Absorption Spectra
• Seeking the growth of the first black hole seeds with JWST
• Tracing Lyman-alpha and Lyman Continuum Escape in Galaxies with Mg II Emission
• The Pan-STARRS1 $\mathbf{z}>5.6$ Quasar Survey: III. The $\mathbf{z}\approx 6$ Quasar Luminosity Function
• Constraints on the End of Reionization from the Density Fields Surrounding Two Highly Opaque Quasar Sightlines
• On the AGN nature of two UV bright sources at z_spec~5.5 in the CANDELS fields: an update of the AGN space density at M1450~-22.5
• Constraints on high-J CO emission lines in $z\sim 6$ quasars
• The Infrared Medium-deep Survey. VIII. Quasar Luminosity Function at $z\sim 5$
• The Lyman continuum escape fraction and the Mean Free Path of hydrogen ionizing photons for bright z~4 QSOs from SDSS DR14
• The connection between the escape of ionizing radiation and galaxy properties at z~3 in the Keck Lyman Continuum Spectroscopic Survey
• A high space density of L* Active Galactic Nuclei at z~4 in the COSMOS field
• Observability of Low-Luminosity AGN in the Early Universe with JWST
• UNCOVERing the contribution of black holes to reionization in the JWST era
• The Goldilocks problem of the quasar contribution to reionization
• Modelling a bright z = 6 galaxy at the faint end of the AGN luminosity function
• The Escape Fraction of Ionizing Photons During the Epoch of Reionization: observability with the Square Kilometre Array
• The Luminosity Function of bright QSOs at z~4 and implications for the cosmic ionizing background
• Lyman Continuum Escape Fraction from Low-mass Starbursts at z=1.3
• On the origin of low escape fractions of ionizing radiation from massive star-forming galaxies at high redshift
• Small-scale Intensity Mapping: Extended Halos as a Probe of the Ionizing Escape Fraction and Faint Galaxy Populations during Reionization
• IGM Transmission Bias for $z$ $\ge$ 2.9 Lyman Continuum Detected Galaxies
• The rapid transition from star-formation to AGN dominated rest-frame UV light at z ~ 4
• A tale of seven narrow spikes and a long trough: constraining the timing of the percolation of HII bubbles at the tail-end of reionization with ULAS J1120+0641
• Ionizing photon production and escape fractions during cosmic reionization in the TNG50 simulation
• An IFU investigation of possible Lyman continuum escape from Mrk 71/NGC 2366
• The Indirect Influence of Quasars on Reionization
• The Infrared Medium-deep Survey. VI. Discovery of Faint Quasars at $z\sim 5$ with a Medium-band-based Approach
• Astraeus VI: Hierarchical assembly of AGN and their large-scale effect during the Epoch of Reionization
• Lyman-alpha emitters in a cosmological volume II: the impact of the intergalactic medium
• CHORUS. I. Cosmic HydrOgen Reionization Unveiled with Subaru: Overview
• Lyman Continuum Emission Escaping from Luminous Green Pea Galaxies at z=0.5
• CDIM: Cosmic Dawn Intensity Mapper Final Report
• Astraeus III: The environment and physical properties of reionization sources
• The Infrared Medium-deep Survey. \Romannum{7}. Faint Quasars at $z\sim 5$ in the ELAIS-N1 Field
• Revisiting the Extreme Clustering of $z\approx 4$ Quasars with Large Volume Cosmological Simulations
• On the Absence of High-Redshift AGNs: Little Growth in the Supermassive Black Hole Population at High Redshifts
• Evolution of the Lyman-α emitting fraction and UV properties of lensed star-forming galaxies between 2.9 < z < 6.7
• The role of AGN jets in the reionization epoch
• Surveys of the Cosmic X-ray Background
• Searching for the connection between ionizing-photon escape and the surface density of star formation at z~3
• AGN jets versus accretion as reionization sources
• Joint Survey Processing I: Compact oddballs in the COSMOS field -- low-luminosity Quasars at z > 6?
• z ~ 2.5 - 3 Ionizers in the GOODS-N Field
• Linking UV spectral properties of MUSE Ly-alpha emitters at z>3 to Lyman continuum escape
• Maximal X-ray feedback in the pre-reionization universe
• The Infrared Medium-deep Survey. IX. Discovery of Two New $z\sim 6$ Quasars and Space Density down to $M_{1450}\sim -23.5$ mag
• Inferring the Distribution of the Ionising Photon Escape Fraction
• Massive black holes in high-redshift Lyman Break Galaxies
• The Composite Spectral Energy Distribution of Quasars is Surprisingly Universal Since Cosmic Noon
• CEMPlifying reionization
• Emission Line Galaxies in the SHARDS Hubble Frontier Fields II: Limits on Lyman-Continuum Escape Fractions of Lensed Emission Line Galaxies at Redshifts 2 < z < 3.5
• The quasar luminosity function at $z\sim 5$ via deep learning and Bayesian information criterion
• Dark matter model favoured by reionization data: 7 keV sterile neutrino vs cold dark matter
• Modelling LAEs in the Epoch of Reionization with OBELISK
• Model-independent Reconstruction of UV Luminosity Function and Reionization Epoch
• Gamma-Ray Absorption By The Cosmic Lyman Continuum From Star-forming Galaxies
• Mocking Faint Black Holes during Reionization
• Cosmic Dawn II (CoDa II): a new radiation-hydrodynamics simulation of the self-consistent coupling of galaxy formation and reionization
• Double-Peaked Ly$\alpha$ Emission during Reionization Requires Nearby Voids and a Favorable Local Ionizing Background
• The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey XIV. The evolution of the Lya emitter fraction from z=3 to z=6
• Detecting the signature of helium reionization through 3HeII 3.46cm line-intensity mapping
• The Contribution of AGN Accretion Disks to Hydrogen Reionization
• The impact of black hole feedback on the UV luminosity and stellar mass assembly of high-redshift galaxies
• BASS XXX: Distribution Functions of DR2 Eddington-ratios, Black Hole Masses, and X-ray Luminosities