No evidence for Population III stars or a Direct Collapse Black Hole in the z = 6.6 Lyman- emitter 'CR7'
arXiv:1609.00727 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stx839
Abstract
The z = 6.6 Lyman- emitter 'CR7' has been claimed to have a Population III-like stellar population, or alternatively, be a candidate Direct Collapse Black Hole (DCBH). In this paper we investigate the evidence for these exotic scenarios using recently available, deeper, optical, near-infrared and mid-infrared imaging. We find strong Spitzer/IRAC detections for the main component of CR7 at 3.6 and 4.5 microns, and show that it has a blue colour ([3.6] - [4.5] ). This colour cannot be reproduced by current Pop. III or pristine DCBH models. Instead, the results suggest that the [3.6] band is contaminated by the [OIII]4959,5007 emission line with an implied rest-frame equivalent width of EW_0 (H + [OIII]) Å. Furthermore, we find that new near-infrared data from the UltraVISTA survey supports a weaker He II 1640 emission line than previously measured, with EW_0 Å. For the fainter components of CR7 visible in Hubble Space Telescope imaging, we find no evidence that they are particularly red as previously claimed, and show that the derived masses and ages are considerably uncertain. In light of the likely detection of strong [OIII] emission in CR7 we discuss other more standard interpretations of the system that are consistent with the data. We find that a low-mass, narrow-line AGN can reproduce the observed features of CR7, including the lack of radio and X-ray detections. Alternatively, a young, low-metallicity (~1/200 solar) starburst, modelled including binary stellar pathways, can reproduce the inferred strength of the He II line and simultaneously the strength of the observed [OIII] emission, but only if the gas shows super-solar -element abundances (O/Fe ~ 5 O/Fe solar).
arXiv comment13 pages, 8 figures and 1 table. Updated to MNRAS accepted version
References in corpus (86)
- Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
- Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
- The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
- The Host Galaxies and Classification of Active Galactic Nuclei
- Composite Quasar Spectra From the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Rest-Frame Ultraviolet Spectra of z~3 Lyman Break Galaxies
- The Star Formation History of Field Galaxies
- The COSMOS2015 Catalog: Exploring the 1<z<6 Universe with half a million galaxies
- UltraVISTA: a new ultra-deep near-infrared survey in COSMOS
- The COSMOS Survey: Hubble Space Telescope / Advanced Camera for Surveys (HST/ACS) Observations and Data Processing
- Statistics of 207 Lya Emitters at a Redshift Near 7: Constraints on Reionization and Galaxy Formation Models
- The Spitzer Legacy Survey of the HST-ACS 2 sq. deg. COSMOS Field: survey strategy and first analysis
- The Subaru/XMM-Newton Deep Survey (SXDS). IV. Evolution of Lya Emitters from z=3.1 to 5.7 in the 1 deg^2 Field: Luminosity Functions and AGN
- The transition from Population III to normal galaxies: Ly-a and HeII 1640 emission and the ionising properties of high redshift starburst galaxies
- The effect of massive binaries on stellar populations and supernova progenitors
- The 2013 Release of Cloudy
- Reconciling the Stellar and Nebular Spectra of High Redshift Galaxies
- UV-Continuum Slopes of >4000 z~4-8 Galaxies from the HUDF/XDF, HUDF09, ERS, CANDELS-South, and CANDELS-North Fields
- Stellar Population Effects on the Inferred Photon Density at Reionization
- The Cosmic Evolution Survey (COSMOS): Subaru Observations of the HST COSMOS Field
- Candidate Type II Quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: I. Selection and Optical Properties of a Sample at 0.3<Z<0.83
- Lyman-alpha and CIII] Emission in z=7-9 Galaxies: Accelerated Reionization Around Luminous Star Forming Systems?
- Spectral and Photometric Evolution of Young Stellar Populations: the Impact of Gaseous Emission at Various Metallicities
- Modelling the nebular emission from primeval to present-day star-forming galaxies
- Evidence for PopIII-like stellar populations in the most luminous Lyman- emitters at the epoch of re-ionisation: spectroscopic confirmation
- Spectral synthesis including massive binaries
- Nuclear activity versus star formation: emission-line diagnostics at ultraviolet and optical wavelengths
- The spectral evolution of the first galaxies. I. James Webb Space Telescope detection limits and color criteria for population III galaxies
- A Comparison of Stellar and Gaseous Kinematics in the Nuclei of Active Galaxies
- Physical Conditions in a Young, Unreddened, Low Metallicity Galaxy at High Redshift
- Evidence for Ubiquitous, High-EW Nebular Emission in z~7 Galaxies: Towards a Clean Measurement of the Specific Star Formation Rate using a Sample of Bright, Magnified Galaxies
- Large Area Survey for z=7 Galaxies in SDF and GOODS-N: Implications for Galaxy Formation and Cosmic Reionization
- Line-driven winds, ionizing fluxes and UV-spectra of hot stars at extremely low metallicity. I. Very massive O-stars
- A Rapidly Star-forming Galaxy 700 Million Years After the Big Bang at z=7.51
- Spectroscopic detection of CIV in a galaxy at z=7.045: Implications for the ionizing spectra of reionization-era galaxies
- New insights into the stellar content and physical conditions of star-forming galaxies at z = 2-3 from spectral modelling
- A Spectroscopic Redshift Measurement for a Luminous Lyman Break Galaxy at z=7.730 using Keck/MOSFIRE
- The VLA-COSMOS Survey. IV. Deep Data and Joint Catalog
- Z > 7 galaxies with red Spitzer/IRAC [3.6]-[4.5] colors in the full CANDELS data set: the brightest-known galaxies at Z ~ 7-9 and a probable spectroscopic confirmation at Z=7.48
- Predicted UV properties of very metal-poor starburst galaxies
- Star Formation at From the Spitzer Large Area Survey with Hyper-Suprime-Cam (SPLASH)
- The bright end of the galaxy luminosity function at z ~ 7: before the onset of mass quenching?
- Spectroscopic detections of CIII]1909 at z~6-7: A new probe of early star forming galaxies and cosmic reionisation
- The galaxy luminosity function at z ~ 6 and evidence for rapid evolution in the bright end from z ~ 7 to 5
- An Intensely Star-Forming Galaxy at z~7 with Low Dust and Metal Content Revealed by Deep ALMA and HST Observations
- An extreme [OIII] emitter at : a low metallicity Lyman continuum source
- The UV continua and inferred stellar populations of galaxies at z ~ 7 - 9 revealed by the Hubble Ultra Deep Field 2012 campaign
- Identification of the brightest Lyα emitters at z=6.6: implications for the evolution of the luminosity function in the re-ionisation era
- Extreme Emission Line Galaxies in CANDELS: Broad-Band Selected, Star-Bursting Dwarf Galaxies at z>1
- Unveiling the nature of bright z ~ 7 galaxies with the Hubble Space Telescope
- A critical analysis of the UV-continuum slopes of high-redshift galaxies; no evidence (yet) for extreme stellar populations at z > 6
- T-PHOT: A new code for PSF-matched, prior-based, multiwavelength extragalactic deconfusion photometry
- Chandra Detection of a TypeII Quasar at z=3.288
- The effect of stellar evolution uncertainties on the rest-frame ultraviolet stellar lines of CIV and HeII in high-redshift Lyman-break galaxies
- A Coherent Study of Emission Lines from Broad-Band Photometry: Specific Star-Formation Rates and [OIII]/Hβ Ratio at 3 < z < 6
- Candidate Type II Quasars at 2 < z < 4.3 in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey III
- The evolution of the equivalent width of the Ha emission line and specific star-formation rate in star-forming galaxies at 1<z<5
- A population of high-redshift type-2 quasars-I. Selection Criteria and Optical Spectra
- Late Pop III Star Formation During the Epoch of Reionization: Results from the Renaissance Simulations
- The 8 o'clock Arc: A Serendipitous Discovery of a Strongly Lensed Lyman Break Galaxy in the SDSS DR4 Imaging Data
- Discovery of a z=6.1 Radio-Loud Quasar in the NDWFS
- Discovery of bright z ~ 7 galaxies in the UltraVISTA survey
- HeII emitters in the VIMOS VLT Deep Survey: PopIII star formation or peculiar stellar populations in galaxies at 2<z<4.6?
- Evolution in the Escape Fraction of Ionizing Photons and the Decline in Strong Lya Emission from z>6 Galaxies
- Chemical Evolution of High-Redshift Radio Galaxies
- The Luminosity Function of Lyman alpha Emitters at Redshift z=7.7
- A sample of 6C radio sources designed to find objects at redshift > 4: II --- spectrophotometry and emission line properties
- The Brightest Ly Emitter: Pop III or Black Hole?
- A New Constraint on the Ly Fraction of UV Very Bright Galaxies at Redshift 7
- Narrow He II emission in star-forming galaxies at low metallicity. Stellar wind emission from a population of Very Massive Stars
- The ages, masses and star-formation rates of spectroscopically confirmed z~6 galaxies in CANDELS
- Physical Properties of the Narrow-Line Region of Low-Mass Active Galaxies
- Detecting Direct Collapse Black Holes: making the case for CR7
- Lyman Alpha Signatures from Direct Collapse Black Holes
- Evidence for a direct collapse black hole in the Lyman-alpha source CR7
- Exploring the nature of the Lyman- emitter CR7
- Discovery of a Radio-Selected z ~ 6 Quasar
- Searching for z~7.7 Lyman Alpha Emitters in the COSMOS Field with NEWFIRM
- Formation of Massive Population III Galaxies through Photoionization Feedback: A Possible Explanation for CR7
- The nature of the Lyman Alpha Emitter CR7: a persisting puzzle
- Deep rest-frame far-UV spectroscopy of the giant Lyman-alpha emitter 'Himiko'
- Upper limits on the mass and luminosity of Population III-dominated galaxies
- Ab Initio Cosmological Simulations of CR7 as an Active Black Hole
- Metallicity evolution of direct collapse black hole hosts: CR7 as a case study
- The discovery of a type-II quasar at z = 1.65 with integral-field spectroscopy
- Establishing an analogue population for the most distant galaxies
Cited by in corpus (57)
- Binary Population and Spectral Synthesis Version 2.1: construction, observational verification and new results
- Observations of the Lyman- Universe
- Titans of the Early Universe: The Prato Statement on the Origin of the First Supermassive Black Holes
- No evidence for a significant AGN contribution to cosmic hydrogen reionization
- ALMA uncovers the [CII] emission and warm dust continuum in a z = 8.31 Lyman break galaxy
- SILVERRUSH. III. Deep Optical and Near-Infrared Spectroscopy for Lya and UV-Nebular Lines of Bright Lya Emitters at z=6-7
- The Dawes Review 8: Measuring the Stellar Initial Mass Function
- Diagnostics for PopIII galaxies and Direct Collapse Black Holes in the early universe
- SILVERRUSH. V. Census of Lya, [OIII]5007, Ha, and [CII]158um Line Emission with ~1000 LAEs at z=4.9-7.0 Revealed with Subaru/HSC
- ALMA reveals metals yet no dust within multiple components in CR7
- JWST-JADES. Possible Population III signatures at z=10.6 in the halo of GN-z11
- Baseline Metal Enrichment from Population III Star Formation in Cosmological Volume Simulations
- On the formation of the first quasars
- Spectroscopic properties of luminous Lyman-α emitters at and comparison to the Lyman-break population
- Observational Signatures of High-Redshift Quasars and Local Relics of Black Hole Seeds
- The Persistence of Population III Star Formation
- Unique Signatures of Population III Stars in the Global 21-cm Signal
- Exploring HeII1640 emission line properties at
- On the nature and physical conditions of the luminous Lya emitter CR7 and its rest-frame UV components
- High-redshift galaxies and black holes in the eyes of JWST: a population synthesis model from infrared to X-rays
- Following the Cosmic Evolution of Pristine Gas II: The search for Pop III-Bright Galaxies
- Chasing the observational signatures of seed black holes at z > 7: candidate observability
- Chasing the observational signatures of seed black holes at z > 7: candidate statistics
- First Light: exploring the Spectra of High-Redshift Galaxies in the Renaissance Simulations
- The nature of the Lyman Alpha Emitter CR7: a persisting puzzle
- Structure and kinematics of a massive galaxy at z ~ 7
- The first supermassive black holes
- What is the Maximum Mass of a Population III Galaxy?
- Radiative effects during the assembly of direct collapse black holes
- A Magellan M2FS Spectroscopic Survey of Galaxies at 5.5<z<6.8: Program Overview and a Sample of the Brightest Lyman-alpha Emitters
- Modelling a bright z = 6 galaxy at the faint end of the AGN luminosity function
- Integral Field Spectroscopy of Green Peas (I): Disentangling disk-like, turbulence and strong outflow kinematics in SDSSJ083843.63+385350.5
- Upper limits on the mass and luminosity of Population III-dominated galaxies
- Nature and chemical abundances of a sample of Lyman- emitter objects at high redshift
- ATLAS Probe: Breakthrough Science of Galaxy Evolution, Cosmology, Milky Way, and the Solar System
- Warm dark matter constraints from high- Direct Collapse Black Holes using the JWST
- Metallicity evolution of direct collapse black hole hosts: CR7 as a case study
- The nature of CR7 revealed with MUSE: a young starburst powering extended Lyman- emission at z=6.6
- Probing the High-Redshift Universe with SPICA: Toward the Epoch of Reionization and Beyond
- Maximally Rotating Supermassive Stars at the Onset of Collapse: The Perturbative Effects of Gas Pressure, Magnetic Fields, Dark Matter and Dark Energy
- Photoionization models for extreme Ly 1216 and HeII 1640 ratios in quasar halos, and PopIII vs AGN diagnostics
- A hide-and-seek game: Looking for Population III stars during the Epoch of Reionization through the HeII1640 line
- Radio Power from a Direct-Collapse Black Hole in CR7
- Predicting the Observability of Population III Stars with ELT-HARMONI via the Helium emission line
- The interstellar medium of high-redshift galaxies: Gathering clues from C III] and [C II] lines
- Footprints of population III stars in the gravitational-wave background
- Triggering the formation of direct collapse black holes by their congeners
- The ALMA Frontier Fields survey V: ALMA Stacking of Lyman-Break Galaxies in Abell 2744, Abell 370, Abell S1063, MACSJ0416.1-2403 and MACSJ1149.5+2223
- Applications of Stellar Population Synthesis in the Distant Universe
- GA-NIFS: Dissecting the multiple sub-structures and probing their complex interactions in the \Lyalpha emitter galaxy CR7 at z = 6.6 with JWST/NIRSpec
- Low-metallicity massive single stars with rotation. III. Source of ionization and C-IV emission in I Zw 18
- What can distant galaxies teach us about massive stars?
- Growth problems of stellar black holes in early galaxies
- A Multiply-Imaged z 6.3 Lyman Alpha Emitter candidate behind Abell 2261
- Black hole formation via gas-dynamical processes
- How Black Holes Stop Their Host Galaxy from Growing Without AGN Feedback
- Mass transport in galaxy discs limits black hole growth to sub-Eddington rates