Evidence of surface loss as ubiquitous limiting damping mechanism in SiN micro- and nanomechanical resonators

Abstract

Silicon nitride (SiN) micro- and nanomechanical resonators have attracted a lot of attention in various research fields due to their exceptionally high quality factors ($Q$s). Despite their popularity, the origin of the limiting loss mechanisms in these structures has remained controversial. In this paper we propose an analytical model combining acoustic radiation loss with intrinsic loss. The model accurately predicts the resulting mode-dependent $Q$s of a low-stress silicon-rich and a high-stress stoichiometric SiN membrane. The large acoustic mismatch of the low-stress membrane to the substrate seems to minimize radiation loss and $Q$s of higher modes ($n\wedge m\ge 3$) are limited by intrinsic losses. The study of these intrinsic losses in low-stress membranes with varying lengths $L$ and thicknesses $h$ reveals an inverse linear dependence of the intrinsic loss with $h$ for thin resonators independent of $L$. This finding was confirmed by comparing the intrinsic dissipation of arbitrary (membranes, strings, and cantilevers) SiN resonators extracted from literature, suggesting surface loss as ubiquitous damping mechanism in thin SiN resonators with $Q_{surf}=\beta \cdot h$ and $\beta =6\times 10^{10}\pm 4\times 10^{10}$~m${}^{-1}$. Based on the intrinsic loss the maximal achievable $Q$s and $Q\cdot f$ products for SiN membranes and strings are outlined.

References in corpus (10)

• Strong dispersive coupling of a high finesse cavity to a micromechanical membrane
• Observation of Radiation Pressure Shot Noise on a Macroscopic Object
• High quality mechanical and optical properties of commercial silicon nitride membranes
• Coupling graphene mechanical resonators to superconducting microwave cavities
• Intrinsic dissipation in nanomechanical resonators due to phonon tunneling
• Graphene optomechanics realized at microwave frequencies
• High-Q Nanomechanics via Destructive Interference of Elastic Waves
• Demonstration of suppressed phonon tunneling losses in phononic bandgap shielded membrane resonators for high-Q optomechanics
• Low-power photothermal probing of single plasmonic nanostructures with nanomechanical string resonators
• Tensile strained $I{n}_{x}G{a}_{1-x}P$ membranes for cavity optomechanics

Cited by in corpus (66)

• Ultra-coherent nanomechanical resonators via soft clamping and dissipation dilution
• Nanotube mechanical resonators with quality factors of up to 5 million
• Ultralow-Noise SiN Trampoline Resonators for Sensing and Optomechanics
• Mesoscopic physics of nanomechanical systems
• Generalized dissipation dilution in strained mechanical resonators
• Strained crystalline nanomechanical resonators with ultralow dissipation
• Spiderweb nanomechanical resonators via Bayesian optimization: inspired by nature and guided by machine learning
• Silicon nitride membrane resonators at millikelvin temperatures with quality factors exceeding $10^8$
• Magnon blockade in a PT-symmetric-like cavity magnomechanical system
• Hierarchical tensile structures with ultralow mechanical dissipation
• Near-field integration of a SiN nanobeam and a SiO${}_2$ microcavity for Heisenberg-limited displacement sensing
• Analysis of membrane phononic crystals with wide bandgaps and low-mass defects
• Nanomechanical Dissipation and Strain Engineering
• Microfabrication of large area high-stress silicon nitride membranes for optomechanical devices
• Fractal-like mechanical resonators with soft-clamped fundamental mode
• Engineering the dissipation of crystalline micromechanical resonators
• Microscopic nanomechanical dissipation in gallium arsenide resonators
• Clamp-tapering increases the quality factor of stressed nanobeams
• Nanomechanical resonators with ultra-high-$Q$ perimeter modes
• High-Strength Amorphous Silicon Carbide for Nanomechanics
• Stress control of tensile-strained In${}_{1-x}$Ga${}_x$P nanomechanical string resonators
• Photostrictive actuators based on freestanding ferroelectric membranes
• Effect of oxygen plasma on nanomechanical silicon nitride resonators
• Influence of clamp-widening on the quality factor of nanomechanical silicon nitride resonators
• Soft-clamped phononic dimers for mechanical sensing and transduction
• Integrated tuning fork nanocavity optomechanical transducers with high $f_M{Q}_M$ product and stress-engineered frequency tuning
• Modelling and observation of nonlinear damping in dissipation-diluted nanomechanical resonators
• Direct laser-written optomechanical membranes in fiber Fabry-Perot cavities
• Mechanical Spectroscopy of Parametric Amplification in a High-Q Membrane Microresonator
• Control of Recoil Losses in Nanomechanical SiN Membrane Resonators
• High-Q trampoline resonators from strained crystalline InGaP for integrated free-space optomechanics
• Optically detected spin-mechanical resonance in silicon carbide membranes
• Towards cavity-free ground state cooling of an acoustic-frequency silicon nitride membrane
• Evidence for structural damping in a high-stress silicon nitride nanobeam and its implications for quantum optomechanics
• Determining Young's modulus via the eigenmode spectrum of a nanomechanical string resonator
• Detecting Acoustic Blackbody Radiation with an Optomechanical Antenna
• Silicon-nitride nanosensors toward room temperature quantum optomechanics
• Phononically shielded photonic-crystal mirror membranes for cavity quantum optomechanics
• A soft-clamped topological waveguide for phonons
• Demonstration of Frequency Stability limited by Thermal Fluctuation Noise in Silicon Nitride Nanomechanical Resonators
• Silicon Nitride MOMS Oscillator for Room Temperature Quantum Optomechanics
• Coupling of Light and Mechanics in a Photonic Crystal Waveguide
• Tuning dissipation dilution in 2D material resonators by MEMS-induced tension
• Towards a Room-Temperature Spin-Photon Interface based on Nitrogen-Vacancy centers and Optomechanics
• Nanomechanical crystalline AlN resonators with high quality factors for quantum optoelectromechanics
• Self-calibrating gas pressure sensor with a 10-decade measurement range
• Universal length dependence of tensile stress in nanomechanical string resonators
• Low-Dissipation Nanomechanical Devices from Monocrystalline Silicon Carbide
• Optically Defined Mechanical Geometry
• On the effect of linear feedback and parametric pumping on a resonators frequency stability
• Feedback-cooling the fundamental torsional mechanical mode of a tapered optical fiber to 30 mK
• Mode-Dependent Scaling of Nonlinearity and Linear Dynamic Range in a NEMS Resonator
• Size Effects on Mechanical Properties of Micro/Nano Structures
• Edge mode engineering for optimal ultracoherent silicon nitride membranes
• Position and Mode Dependent Optical Detection Back-Action in Cantilever Beam Resonators
• Multimode optomechanical system in the quantum regime
• Thickness dependence of the mechanical properties of piezoelectric high-$Q_m$ nanomechanical resonators made from aluminium nitride
• Integration of High-Tc Superconductors with High Q Factor Oxide Mechanical Resonators
• Nano-beam clamping revisited
• Magnetic Trampoline Resonators from (La,Sr)MnO3 Single-Crystal Thin Films
• Topology optimization of high-performance optomechanical resonator
• Monolithic 4H-SiC nanomechanical resonators with high intrinsic quality factors
• Theoretical modeling of the dynamic range of an elastic nanobeam under tension with a geometric nonlinearity
• High-$Q$ membrane resonators using ultra-high-stress crystalline TiN films
• Swept-Frequency Drumhead Mechanical Resonators
• Si${}_3$N${}_4$ nanobeam optomechanical crystals