Comment: "Electrical injection and detection of spin accumulation in silicon at 500 K with magnetic metal / silicon dioxide contacts" [Nature Commun. 2:245 doi:10.1038/ncomms125 (2011)]

Abstract

In a recent publication, we demonstrated electrical spin injection and detection in n-type silicon at temperatures up to 500K using ferromagnetic metal / SiO2 tunnel barrier contacts in a three-terminal geometry (Nature Commun. 2:245 doi:10.1038/ncomms125 (2011)). In comparing our measured spin-voltage signal with the value predicted by theory, we followed the analysis of Tran et al, (Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 036601 (2009)), and inadvertently propagated an error found therein. As they note in a recent erratum (arXiv:0810.4770v2), the correct expression for the spin resistance area product from the theory for a sample with a spin diffusion length LSD much less than the contact width or channel thickness (our experimental situation) is given by the product {gamma}^2 {rho} LSD, where {gamma} is the tunneling spin polarization, and {rho} is the resistivity of the semiconductor transport channel. With this correction, our measured spin voltages are much larger than those predicted by theory, rather than in good agreement as we stated. We emphasize that the basic conclusions of our paper are the same - the systematic decrease in electron spin lifetime with increasing electron density demonstrates spin accumulation in the Si channel rather than in interface states. We further show that the measured spin lifetimes are essentially independent of the tunnel barrier material (SiO2, Al2O3, MgO) or the magnetic metal used (Fe, CoFe, NiFe), demonstrating clear correlation of the measured spin lifetime with the character of the Si, and little correlation with the tunnel barrier / interface or magnetic metal.

Two files: 1) Authors' Comment and 2) Original Nature Commun article

References in corpus (3)

• Electrical Detection of Spin Accumulation at a Ferromagnet-Semiconductor Interface
• Semiconductors between spin-polarized source and drain
• Bias-controlled sensitivity of ferromagnet/semiconductor electrical spin detectors

Cited by in corpus (44)

• Optical spin injection and spin lifetime in Ge heterostructures
• Spin Pumping and Inverse Spin Hall Effect in Germanium
• Analysis of phonon-induced spin relaxation processes in silicon
• Efficient Spin Injection into Silicon and the Role of the Schottky Barrier
• Electrical spin injection and accumulation in CoFe/MgO/Ge contacts at room temperature
• Magnetic-Field-Modulated Resonant Tunneling in Ferromagnetic-Insulator-Nonmagnetic junctions
• Impurity-assisted tunneling magnetoresistance under weak magnetic field
• An investigation of the inverted Hanle effect in highly-doped Si
• Electric-field control of spin accumulation signals in silicon at room temperature
• Local magnetoresistance in Fe/MgO/Si lateral spin valve at room temperature
• How reliable are Hanle measurements in metals in a three-terminal geometry?
• Large spin accumulation voltages in epitaxial Mn5Ge3 contacts on Ge without oxide tunnel barrier
• Spin injection and detection in lanthanum- and niobium-doped SrTiO3 using the Hanle technique
• Electrical injection and detection of spin accumulation in Ge at room temperature
• Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy of local "spin accumulation" devices
• Observation of large spin accumulation voltages in non-degenerate Si spin devices due to spin drift effect: Experiments and theory
• The effect of spin drift on spin accumulation voltages in highly-doped Si
• Electrical and thermal spin accumulation in germanium
• Charge/Spin Supercurrent and the Fulde-Ferrell State Induced by Crystal Deformation in Weyl/Dirac Superconductors
• Room-temperature detection of spin accumulation in silicon across Schottky tunnel barriers using a MOSFET structure
• Spin heat accumulation induced by tunneling from a ferromagnet
• Dynamic detection of electron spin accumulation in ferromagnet-semiconductor devices by ferromagnetic resonance
• Suppressing spin relaxation in silicon
• Absence of nonlocal resistance in microstructures of PbTe quantum wells
• Low-field microwave absorption and magnetoresistance in iron nanostructures grown by electrodeposition on n-type lightly-doped silicon substrates
• Self-consistent model of spin accumulation magnetoresistance in ferromagnet-insulator-semiconductor tunnel junctions
• Electrical Investigation of the Oblique Hanle Effect in Ferromagnet/Oxide/Semiconductor Contacts
• Thermal Creation of Electron Spin Polarization in n-Type Silicon
• Effect of spin relaxation rate on the interfacial spin depolarization in ferromagnet/oxide/semiconductor contacts
• Study of the spin-pump-induced inverse spin-Hall effect in Bi doped n-type Si
• Effects of interface resistance asymmetry on local and non-local magnetoresistance structures
• Hot-electron effect in spin relaxation of electrically injected electrons in intrinsic Germanium
• Effect of the magnetic domain structure in the ferromagnetic contact on spin accumulation in silicon
• Thermal spin injection and accumulation in CoFe/MgO tunnel contacts to n-type Si through Seebeck spin tunneling
• Bias current dependence of the spin lifetime in insulating Al${}_{0.3}$Ga${}_{0.7}$As
• Effects of interface electric field on the magnetoresistance in spin device
• Spin Transfer from a Ferromagnet into a Semiconductor through an Oxide barrier
• Spin transport and accumulation in the persistent photoconductor Al${}_{0.3}$Ga${}_{0.7}$As
• Optimized spin-injection efficiency and spin MOSFET operation based on low-barrier ferromagnet/insulator/n-Si tunnel contact
• Observation of weak temperature dependence of spin diffusion length in highly-doped Si by using a non-local 3-terminal method
• Triggering phase-coherent spin packets by pulsed electrical spin injection across an Fe/GaAs Schottky barrier
• Spin transport in non-degenerate Si with a spin MOSFET structure at room temperature
• The perfect spin injection in silicene FS/NS junction
• Spin accumulation detection of FMR driven spin pumping in silicon-based metal-oxide-semiconductor heterostructures