How reliable are Hanle measurements in metals in a three-terminal geometry?

Abstract

We test the validity of Hanle measurements in three-terminal devices by using aluminum (Al) and gold (Au). The obtained Hanle and inverted Hanle-like curves show an anomalous behavior. First, we measure Hanle signals 8 orders of magnitude larger than those predicted by standard theory. Second, the temperature and voltage dependences of the signal do not match with the tunneling spin polarization of the ferromagnetic contact. Finally, the spin relaxation times obtained with this method are independent of the choice of the metallic channel. These results are not compatible with spin accumulation in the metal. Furthermore, a scaling of the Hanle signal with the interface resistance of the devices suggests that the measured signal is originated in the tunnel junction.

9 pages, 5 figures

References in corpus (9)

• Electrical Detection of Spin Accumulation at a Ferromagnet-Semiconductor Interface
• Comment: "Electrical injection and detection of spin accumulation in silicon at 500 K with magnetic metal / silicon dioxide contacts" [Nature Commun. 2:245 doi:10.1038/ncomms125 (2011)]
• Semiconductors between spin-polarized source and drain
• Crossover from spin accumulation into interface states to spin injection in the germanium conduction band
• Control of spin injection by direct current in lateral spin valves
• An investigation of the inverted Hanle effect in highly-doped Si
• Injection and detection of spin in a semiconductor by tunneling via interface states
• Temperature evolution of spin accumulation detected electrically in a nondegenerated silicon channel
• Anomalous scaling of spin accumulation in ferromagnetic tunnel devices with silicon and germanium

Cited by in corpus (15)

• An experimental demonstration of room-temperature spin transport in n-type Germanium epilayers
• Magnetic-Field-Modulated Resonant Tunneling in Ferromagnetic-Insulator-Nonmagnetic junctions
• Impurity-assisted tunneling magnetoresistance under weak magnetic field
• Large spin accumulation voltages in epitaxial Mn5Ge3 contacts on Ge without oxide tunnel barrier
• Spin Transport and Precession in Graphene measured by Nonlocal and Three-Terminal Methods
• Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy of local "spin accumulation" devices
• Spin injection into Si in three-terminal vertical and four-terminal lateral devices with Fe/Mg/MgO/Si tunnel junctions having an ultrathin Mg insertion layer
• Spin heat accumulation induced by tunneling from a ferromagnet
• Determination of spin relaxation times in heavy metals via 2nd harmonic spin injection magnetoresistance
• All-electric spin device operation using the Weyl semimetal, WTe${}_2$, at room temperature
• Self-consistent model of spin accumulation magnetoresistance in ferromagnet-insulator-semiconductor tunnel junctions
• Non-linear spin transport in a rectifying ferromagnet/semiconductor Schottky contact
• Spincaloritronic signal generation in non-degenerate Si
• Potentiometric detection of spin polarization expected at the surface of FeTe0.6Se0.4 in the effective p-wave superconducting state
• Theory of oblique-field magnetoresistance from spin centers in three-terminal spintronic devices