The Current Ability to Test Theories of Gravity with Black Hole Shadows
arXiv:1804.05812 · doi:10.1038/s41550-018-0449-5
Abstract
Our Galactic Center, Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*), is believed to harbour a supermassive black hole (BH), as suggested by observations tracking individual orbiting stars. Upcoming sub-millimetre very-long-baseline-interferometry (VLBI) images of Sgr A* carried out by the Event-Horizon-Telescope Collaboration (EHTC) are expected to provide critical evidence for the existence of this supermassive BH. We assess our present ability to use EHTC images to determine if they correspond to a Kerr BH as predicted by Einstein's theory of general relativity (GR) or to a BH in alternative theories of gravity. To this end, we perform general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamical (GRMHD) simulations and use general-relativistic radiative transfer (GRRT) calculations to generate synthetic shadow images of a magnetised accretion flow onto a Kerr BH. In addition, and for the first time, we perform GRMHD simulations and GRRT calculations for a dilaton BH, which we take as a representative solution of an alternative theory of gravity. Adopting the VLBI configuration from the 2017 EHTC campaign, we find that it could be extremely difficult to distinguish between BHs from different theories of gravity, thus highlighting that great caution is needed when interpreting BH images as tests of GR.
arXiv commentPublished in Nature Astronomy on 16.04.18 (including supplementary information); simulations at https://blackholecam.org/telling_bhs_apart/
References in corpus (35)
- The Galactic Center Massive Black Hole and Nuclear Star Cluster
- The String Dilaton and a Least Coupling Principle
- Viewing the Shadow of the Black Hole at the Galactic Center
- Event-horizon-scale structure in the supermassive black hole candidate at the Galactic Centre
- HARM: A Numerical Scheme for General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics
- A Metric for Rapidly Spinning Black Holes Suitable for Strong-Field Tests of the No-Hair Theorem
- A new method for shadow calculations: application to parameterised axisymmetric black holes
- Radiative Models of Sgr A* from GRMHD Simulations
- An Improved Distance and Mass Estimate for Sgr A* from a Multistar Orbit Analysis
- The Black Hole Accretion Code
- General parametrization of axisymmetric black holes in metric theories of gravity
- High Resolution Linear Polarimetric Imaging for the Event Horizon Telescope
- New parametrization for spherically symmetric black holes in metric theories of gravity
- Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Event Horizon Telescope Observations of Sagittarius A*
- Interferometric Measurements of Variable 340 GHz Linear Polarization in Sagittarius A*
- Evidence for Low Black Hole Spin and Physically Motivated Accretion Models from Millimeter VLBI Observations of Sagittarius A*
- BlackHoleCam: fundamental physics of the Galactic center
- A Quantitative Test of the No-Hair Theorem with Sgr A* using stars, pulsars, and the Event Horizon Telescope
- Methods for detecting flaring structures in Sagittarius A* with high frequency VLBI
- Observational appearance of inefficient accretion flows and jets in 3D GRMHD simulations: Application to Sgr~A*
- Plasma diagnostic potential of 2p4f in N -- accurate wavelengths and oscillator strengths
- The Power of Imaging: Constraining the Plasma Properties of GRMHD Simulations using EHT Observations of Sgr A*
- Millimeter Flares and VLBI Visibilities from Relativistic Simulations of Magnetized Accretion onto the Galactic Center Black Hole
- Coupled jet-disk model for Sgr A*: explaining the flat-spectrum radio core with GRMHD simulations of jets
- General relativistic radiative transfer: formulation and emission from structured tori around black holes
- Imaging the Supermassive Black Hole Shadow and Jet Base of M87 with the Event Horizon Telescope
- Modeling Seven Years of Event Horizon Telescope Observations with Radiatively Inefficient Accretion Flow Models
- Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Observations of Black Holes in the Electromagnetic Spectrum
- Probing the magnetic field structure in Sgr A* on Black Hole Horizon Scales with Polarized Radiative Transfer Simulations
- The Peculiar Pulsar Population of the Central Parsec
- Event-Horizon-Telescope Evidence for Alignment of the Black Hole in the Center of the Milky Way with the Inner Stellar Disk
- Global GRMHD Simulations of Black Hole Accretion Flows: a Convergence Study
- On the stability of thick accretion disks around black holes
- Imaging an Event Horizon: Mitigation of Source Variability of Sagittarius A*
- Simulations of recoiling black holes: adaptive mesh refinement and radiative transfer
Cited by in corpus (190)
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole
- First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. V. Physical Origin of the Asymmetric Ring
- First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
- Shadow of a black hole surrounded by dark matter
- Constraints on black-hole charges with the 2017 EHT observations of M87*
- Rotating black holes in Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity and its shadow
- Gravitational deflection of light and shadow cast by rotating Kalb-Ramond black holes
- Shadow and Deflection Angle of Rotating Black Holes in Perfect Fluid Dark Matter with a Cosmological Constant
- Black Hole Parameter Estimation from Its Shadow
- Shadow cast and Deflection angle of Kerr-Newman-Kasuya spacetime
- Parameter estimation of hairy Kerr black holes from its shadow and constraints from M87*
- Observing the Inner Shadow of a Black Hole: A Direct View of the Event Horizon
- Black Hole Surrounded by a Dark Matter Halo in the M87 Galactic Center and its Identification with Shadow Images
- How to tell an accreting boson star from a black hole
- Concerns regarding the use of black hole shadows as standard rulers
- Probing a nonlinear electrodynamics black hole with thin accretion disk, shadow and deflection angle with M87* and Sgr A* from EHT
- Black hole mimicker hiding in the shadow: Optical properties of the -metric
- Image of Kerr-Melvin black hole with thin accretion disk
- Photon Ring and Observational Appearance of a Hairy Black Hole
- Rotating Black Hole Shadow in Perfect Fluid Dark Matter
- Tests of Loop Quantum Gravity from the Event Horizon Telescope Results of Sgr A
- Asymptotic safety casts its shadow
- Constrained transport and adaptive mesh refinement in the Black Hole Accretion Code
- No-Hair Theorem in the Wake of Event Horizon Telescope
- Photon Spheres and Spherical Accretion Image of a Hairy Black Hole
- Plasmoid formation in global GRMHD simulations and AGN flares
- Modelling the Sgr A* Black Hole Immersed in a Dark Matter Spike
- Astrophysical Wormholes
- Testing Rotating Regular Metrics with EHT Results of Sgr A*
- Photon rings of spherically symmetric black holes and robust tests of non-Kerr metrics
- Testing Generalized Einstein-Cartan-Kibble-Sciama Gravity using Weak Deflection Angle and Shadow Cast
- Einstein-Æther Gravity in the light of Event Horizon Telescope Observations of M87*
- Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet black holes: Analytical approximation for the metric and applications to calculations of shadows
- State-of-the-art energetic and morphological modelling of the launching site of the M87 jet
- Shadow of a black hole at cosmological distance
- Observational signature of near-extremal Kerr-like black holes in a modified gravity theory at the Event Horizon Telescope
- Parameters estimation and strong gravitational lensing of nonsingular Kerr-Sen black holes
- Simulations of imaging the event horizon of Sagittarius A* from space
- Black Hole Shadow as a Test of General Relativity: Quadratic Gravity
- Chaotic shadow of a non-Kerr rotating compact object with quadrupole mass moment
- The Black Hole Explorer: Motivation and Vision
- Scalar field effects on the orbit of S2 star
- Observational signatures of wormholes with thin accretion disks
- Photon ring structure of rotating regular black holes and no-horizon spacetimes
- Investigating shadow images and rings of the charged Horndeski black hole illuminated by various thin accretions
- Black hole shadow as a standard ruler in cosmology
- Analytical study of higher-order ring images of accretion disk around black hole
- Rings and images of Horndeski hairy black hole illuminated by various thin accretions
- The shadow and photon sphere of the charged black hole in Rastall gravity
- Comparison of the ion-to-electron temperature ratio prescription: GRMHD simulations with electron thermodynamics
- Magnetic reconnection and plasmoid formation in three-dimensional accretion flows around black holes
- Gravitational lensing for a boosted Kerr black hole in the presence of plasma
- TeraHertz Exploration and Zooming-in for Astrophysics (THEZA): ESA Voyage 2050 White Paper
- A Parametric model for the shapes of black-hole shadows in non-Kerr spacetimes
- Fuzzball Shadows: Emergent Horizons from Microstructure
- Investigating Loop Quantum Gravity with EHT Observational Effects of Rotating Black holes
- Motion of Particles and Gravitational Lensing Around (2+1)-dimensional BTZ black holes in Gauss-Bonnet Gravity
- Shadow Images of a Rotating Dyonic Black Hole with a Global Monopole Surrounded by Perfect Fluid
- Distinguishing gravitational and emission physics in black-hole imaging: spherical symmetry
- Testing the Schwarzschild metric in a strong field region with the Event Horizon Telescope
- Shadow and Photon Sphere of Black Hole in Clouds of Strings and Quintessence
- Testing black hole mimickers with the Event Horizon Telescope image of Sagittarius A
- Images from disk and spherical accretions of hairy Schwarzschild black holes
- Study of Gravastars in Rastall Gravity
- Investigating effects of dark matter on photon orbits and black hole shadows
- Modified gravity revealed along geodesic tracks
- Rotating black holes without symmetry and their shadow images
- General-relativistic hydrodynamics of non-perfect fluids: 3+1 conservative formulation and application to viscous black-hole accretion
- Accurate mapping of spherically symmetric black holes in a parameterised framework
- Black Hole Images as Tests of General Relativity: Effects of Plasma Physics
- Observational predictions of LQG motivated polymerized black holes and constraints from Sgr A* and M87*
- Separating Astrophysics and Geometry in Black Hole Images
- Rotating dirty black hole and its shadow
- First analytical calculation of black hole shadow in McVittie metric
- Stable and self consistent charged gravastar model within the framework of gravity
- Circular Orbits Structure and Thin Accretion Disks around Kerr Black Holes with Scalar Hair
- Bayesian Metric Reconstruction with Gravitational Wave Observations
- RAPTOR II: Polarized radiative transfer in curved spacetime
- Black Hole Glimmer Signatures of Mass, Spin, and Inclination
- Silhouettes of invisible black holes
- Estimating the cosmological constant from shadows of Kerr--de Sitter black holes
- Two-moment scheme for general-relativistic radiation hydrodynamics: a systematic description and new applications
- GRMHD Simulations and Modeling for Jet Formation and Acceleration Region in AGNs
- Images of hairy Reissner-Nordström black hole illuminated by static accretions
- Shadows, rings and optical appearance of a magnetically charged regular black hole illuminated by various accretion disks
- Observational constraints on Yukawa cosmology and connection with black hole shadows
- Probing the Black Hole Metric. I. Black Hole Shadows and Binary Black-Hole Inspirals
- Study of charged gravastar model in gravity
- Nonlinearly charged black holes: Shadow and Thin-accretion disk
- Temperature properties in magnetised and radiatively cooled two-temperature accretion flows onto a black hole
- Using space-VLBI to probe gravity around Sgr A*
- Superradiance in Kerr-like black holes
- Deep Horizon; a machine learning network that recovers accreting black hole parameters
- Observational Appearances of Magnetically Charged Black Holes in Born-Infeld Electrodynamics
- The Galactic Center as a laboratory for theories of gravity and dark matter
- Visibility of Black Hole Shadows in Low-luminosity AGN
- Black hole parameter estimation with synthetic Very Long Baseline Interferometry data from the ground and from space
- Modelling the polarised emission from black holes on event horizon-scales
- Using evolutionary algorithms to model relativistic jets: Application to NGC 1052
- Scalar charge of black holes in Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton theory
- Constraints on Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity from X-ray reflection spectroscopy
- Magnetized discs and photon rings around Yukawa-like black holes
- Probing spacetime and accretion model for the Galactic Center: Comparison of Kerr and dilaton black hole shadows
- Scalar Fields and Parametrized Spherically Symmetric Black Holes: Can one hear the shape of space-time?
- Shadow of regular black hole in scalar-tensor-vector gravity theory
- Possibility of Identifying Matter around Rotating Black Hole with Black Hole Shadow
- The effect of scalar hair on the charged black hole with the images from accretions disk
- Dark matter signatures of black holes with Yukawa potential
- Numerical black hole initial data and shadows in dynamical Chern-Simons gravity
- Signatures of Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity from the observed jet power and the radiative efficiency
- X-ray reflection spectroscopy with Kaluza-Klein black holes
- Harvesting energy driven by Comisso-Asenjo process from Kerr-MOG black holes
- Stable Charged Gravastar model in Cylindrically Symmetric Space-time
- Implications of axionic hair on shadow of M87*
- Constraining the Generalized Uncertainty Principle with the light twisted by rotating black holes and M87*
- Ergosphere, photon region structure, and the shadow of a rotating charged Weyl black hole
- Accretion Flow Morphology in Numerical Simulations of Black Holes from the ngEHT Model Library: The Impact of Radiation Physics
- Static spherically symmetric configurations with N non-linear scalar fields: global and asymptotic properties
- An extension of Gmunu: General-relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics based on staggered-meshed constrained transport with elliptic cleaning
- Retrograde Polish Doughnuts around Boson Stars
- Kerr-Newman Black Holes in Weyl-Cartan Theory: Shadows and EHT constraints
- Observing the Shadows of Stellar-Mass Black Holes with Binary Companions
- Qualifying ringdown and shadow of black holes under general parametrized metrics with photon orbits
- Charged Particle Production Rate from Cosmic Censorship in Dilaton Black Hole Spacetimes
- Gravitational lensing around Kehagias-Sfetsos compact objects surrounded by plasma
- Charged gravastar model in Rastall theory of gravity
- Black Hole Shadow with Soft Hair
- Toward General-Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics Simulations in Stationary Non-Vacuum Spacetimes
- Gravitational atoms in the braneworld scenario
- Imaging ultra-compact objects with radiatively inefficient accretion flows
- Charged Black Holes with Yukawa Potential
- Observability of the innermost stable circular orbit in a near-extremal Kerr black hole
- An Event Horizon Imager (EHI) Mission Concept Utilizing Medium Earth Orbit Sub-mm Interferometry
- Testing space-time geometries and theories of gravity at the Galactic Center with pulsar's time delay
- The propagation delay in the timing of a pulsar orbiting a supermassive black hole
- Magnetized accretion disks around Kerr black holes with scalar hair -- Nonconstant angular momentum disks
- The future ability to test theories of gravity with black-hole shadows
- A hybrid approach to long-term binary neutron-star simulations
- Constraining the KRZ deformation parameters I: limits from supermassive black hole X-ray data
- Parameter estimation of Kerr-Bertotti-Robinson black holes using their shadows
- Shadows and parameter estimation of rotating quantum corrected black holes and constraints from EHT observation of M87* and Sgr A*
- Impacts of nonthermal emission on the images of a black hole shadow and extended jets in two-temperature GRMHD simulations
- Shadows aspect of rotating black holes in the Einstein-AdS SU(N)-nonlinear sigma model
- A Critical Assessment of Black Hole Solutions With a Linear Term in Their Redshift Function
- Black hole in a generalized Chaplygin-Jacobi dark fluid: shadow and light deflection angle
- Effect of quintessence dark energy on the shadow of Hayward black holes with spherical accretion
- Measuring Black Hole Light Echoes with Very Long Baseline Interferometry
- Parametrized black holes: Scattering investigation
- Black Hole Shadow Observations with Space-Ground Interferometers
- Influence of Quantum Correction on Kerr Black Hole in Effective Loop Quantum Gravity via Shadows and EHT Results
- Analytical external spherical solutions in entangled relativity
- The impact of resistivity on the variability of black hole accretion flows
- Deep learning inference with the Event Horizon Telescope III. Zingularity results from the 2017 observations and predictions for future array expansions
- Imaging the event horizon of M87* from space on different timescales
- An exact black hole spacetime with scalar field and its shadow together with quasinormal modes
- Particle dynamics and optical appearance of charged spherically symmetric black holes in bumblebee gravity
- Deep learning inference with the Event Horizon Telescope I. Calibration improvements and a comprehensive synthetic data library
- Semi-analytic studies of accretion disk and magnetic field geometry in M87*
- Self-Gravitating Matter in Stationary and Axisymmetric Black Hole Spacetimes
- The Japanese Vision for the Black Hole Explorer Mission
- Signatures of Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity from the observed quasi-periodic oscillations in black holes
- Primary Proca Hair and the Double-Peak Optics of Black Holes
- On the Universality of Energy Extraction from Black Hole Spacetimes
- Scalar particles around a Rindler-Schwarzschild wormhole
- Observational appearance of Kaluza-Klein black holes
- Shadows of a generic class of spherically symmetric, static spacetimes
- Aberration effect on lower-order images of thin accretion disk in the astrometric approach
- Shadow of the Scalar Hairy Black Hole with Inverted Higgs Potential
- Black holes surrounded by massive vector fields in Kaluza-Klein gravity
- Shadow analysis of an approximate rotating black hole solution with weakly coupled global monopole charge
- About the (in)equivalence between holonomic versus non-holonomic theories of gravity
- GALLIFRAY -- A geometric modeling and parameter estimation framework for black hole images using bayesian techniques
- Neutral particle collisions near Gibbons-Maeda-Garfinkle-Horowitz-Strominger black holes after shadow observations
- Probing Einstein-Maxwell-Scalar Black hole via Thin Accretion Disks and Shadows with EHT Observations of M87* and Sgr A*
- Shadow Ringing of Black Holes from Photon Sphere Quasinormal Modes
- Millimeter-wave Monitoring of Active Galactic Nuclei with the Africa Millimetre Telescope
- Examining the Kerr Metric through Wave Fronts of Null Geodesics
- Exploring black holes with multiple photon spheres by interferometric signatures
- Thermodynamic analysis of a compact object in Rastall-Rainbow gravity
- Image of a quantum-corrected black hole without Cauchy horizons illuminated by a static thin accretion disk
- Signatures of the Israel Junction II: Double Photon Rings in Slowly Rotating Kerr Spacetime with Thin Shell
- Fast and accurate analytical formulas for light propagation in general static, spherically symmetric spacetimes
- Relativistic Thermal Emission from Accretion Disks in Kerr-MOG Spacetimes
- Shadows and photon spheres of static black holes embedded in a Dehnen-(1,4,5/2)-type dark matter halo with a quintessential field
- Remarks on the black hole shadows in Kerr-de Sitter space times
- PATOKA: Simulating Electromagnetic Observables of Black Hole Accretion
- Impacts of radiative cooling on the images of a black hole shadow and extended jets in two-temperature GRMHD simulations
- Visible shapes of black holes M87* and SgrA*
- Observational distinguishability of the Kerr and Kerr-Hayward metrics to EHT
- Universality of the Blandford-Znajek emission in stationary and axisymmetric spacetimes