The Cosmic Core-collapse Supernova Rate does not match the Massive-Star Formation Rate

Abstract

We identify a "supernova rate problem": the measured cosmic core-collapse supernova rate is a factor of ~ 2 smaller (with significance ~ 2 sigma) than that predicted from the measured cosmic massive-star formation rate. The comparison is critical for topics from galaxy evolution and enrichment to the abundance of neutron stars and black holes. We systematically explore possible resolutions. The accuracy and precision of the star formation rate data and conversion to the supernova rate are well supported, and proposed changes would have far-reaching consequences. The dominant effect is likely that many supernovae are missed because they are either optically dim (low-luminosity) or dark, whether intrinsically or due to obscuration. We investigate supernovae too dim to have been discovered in cosmic surveys by a detailed study of all supernova discoveries in the local volume. If possible supernova impostors are included, then dim supernovae are common enough by fraction to solve the supernova rate problem. If they are not included, then the rate of dark core collapses is likely substantial. Other alternatives are that there are surprising changes in our understanding of star formation or supernova rates, including that supernovae form differently in small galaxies than in normal galaxies. These possibilities can be distinguished by upcoming supernova surveys, star formation measurements, searches for disappearing massive stars, and measurements of supernova neutrinos.

v2 (16 pages, 5 figures, 3 tables): matches published version; extended contents and discussions; figure 4 corrected, local SFR value updated; conclusions unchanged

References in corpus (43)

• UV Star Formation Rates in the Local Universe
• Neutron Star Observations: Prognosis for Equation of State Constraints
• Theory of Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Long gamma-ray bursts and core-collapse supernovae have different environments
• The death of massive stars - I. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type II-P supernovae
• Black Hole Formation in Failing Core-Collapse Supernovae
• An H-alpha Imaging Survey of Galaxies in the Local 11 Mpc Volume
• No supernovae associated with two long-duration gamma ray bursts
• Very-High-Energy Gamma Rays from a Distant Quasar: How Transparent Is the Universe?
• An enigmatic long-lasting gamma-ray burst not accompanied by a bright supernova
• The Initial-Final Mass Relation: Direct Constraints at the Low Mass End
• The UV-Optical Color Magnitude Diagram II: Physical Properties and Morphological Evolution On and Off of a Star-Forming Sequence
• The Supernova Channel of Super-AGB Stars
• The Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background
• The Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background is detectable in Super-Kamiokande
• The Evolution of Stellar Mass and the Implied Star Formation History
• A New Class of Luminous Transients and A First Census of Their Massive Stellar Progenitors
• Photometric and spectroscopic evolution of the type IIP supernova SN 2004et
• The 2008 Luminous Optical Transient in the Nearby Galaxy NGC 300
• Role of line-of-sight cosmic ray interactions in forming the spectra of distant blazars in TeV gamma rays and high-energy neutrinos
• An Intermediate Luminosity Transient in NGC300: The Eruption of a Dust-Enshrouded Massive Star
• A Massive Progenitor of the Luminous Type IIn Supernova 2010jl
• The type IIb SN 2008ax: spectral and light curve evolution
• Supernova rates from the Southern inTermediate Redshift ESO Supernova Search (STRESS)
• SN 2008S: A Cool Super-Eddington Wind in a Supernova Impostor
• On the Evolutionary History of Stars and their Fossil Mass and Light
• The carbon-rich type Ic SN 2007gr: the photospheric phase
• SN 2010jl in UGC 5189: Yet another luminous type IIn supernova in a metal-poor galaxy
• The H-alpha Luminosity Function and Star Formation Rate Volume Density at z=0.8 from the NEWFIRM H-alpha Survey
• Real-Time Detection and Rapid Multiwavelength Follow-up Observations of a Highly Subluminous Type II-P Supernova from the Palomar Transient Factory Survey
• Optical and infrared observations of the Type IIP SN2002hh from day 3 to 397
• Constraints on core-collapse supernova progenitors from correlations with H-alpha emission
• A very faint core-collapse supernova in M85
• Faint Supernovae and Supernova Impostors: Case studies of SN2002kg/NGC2403-V37 and SN 2003gm
• Strong New Constraints on the Extragalactic Background Light in the Near- to Mid-IR
• How many supernovae are we missing at high redshift?
• The first year of SN 2004dj in NGC 2403
• Extragalactic Constraints on the Initial Mass Function
• Revealing Type Ia supernova physics with cosmic rates and nuclear gamma rays
• Discovery of a very highly extinguished supernova in a luminous infrared galaxy
• The H alpha Galaxy Survey. IV. Star formation in the local Universe
• Core-collapse supernovae in low-metallicity environments and future all-sky transient surveys
• Winds and Infalling Gas in Lyman Break Galaxies

Cited by in corpus (169)

• Cosmic Star Formation History
• Neutrino Physics with JUNO
• Observational constraints on the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae : the case for missing high mass stars
• A two-parameter criterion for classifying the explodability of massive stars by the neutrino-driven mechanism
• The Effect of Pair-Instability Mass Loss on Black Hole Mergers
• Fast radio bursts: the last sign of supramassive neutron stars
• Design and operation of the ATLAS Transient Science Server
• The death of massive stars - II. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type Ibc supernovae
• The search for failed supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: confirmation of a disappearing star
• The Zwicky Transient Facility Bright Transient Survey. II. A Public Statistical Sample for Exploring Supernova Demographics
• Observing the Next Galactic Supernova
• The Landscape of the Neutrino Mechanism of Core-Collapse Supernovae: Neutron Star and Black Hole Mass Functions, Explosion Energies and Nickel Yields
• A Simple Approach to the Supernova Progenitor-Explosion Connection
• On the origin of a highly-dispersed coherent radio burst
• The next-generation liquid-scintillator neutrino observatory LENA
• Delay-time distribution of core-collapse supernovae with late events resulting from binary interaction
• Rates of Superluminous Supernovae at z~0.2
• Star formation, supernovae, iron, and alpha: consistent cosmic and Galactic histories
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with The Large Binocular Telescope: First Candidates
• Extragalactic Background Light from Hierarchical Galaxy Formation: Gamma-ray Attenuation up to the Epoch of Cosmic Reionization and the First Stars
• Grand Unified Neutrino Spectrum at Earth: Sources and Spectral Components
• Abundance Profiling of Extremely Metal-Poor Stars and Supernova Properties in the Early Universe
• The Initial Masses of the Red Supergiant Progenitors to Type-II Supernovae
• What can be learned from a future supernova neutrino detection?
• How Gravitational-wave Observations Can Shape the Gamma-ray Burst Paradigm
• Core-collapse supernovae missed by optical surveys
• Luminous Red Novae: Stellar Mergers or Giant Eruptions?
• The early detection and follow-up of the highly obscured Type II supernova 2016ija/DLT16am
• Failed Supernovae Explain the Compact Remnant Mass Function
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: Constraints from 7 Years of Data
• A comparison between star formation rate diagnostics and rate of core collapse supernovae within 11 Mpc
• Supernova rates from the SUDARE VST-Omegacam search. I
• The Extended Hubble Space Telescope Supernova Survey: The Rate of Core Collapse Supernovae to z~1
• Gravitational wave signatures in black-hole-forming core collapse
• Decoding the stellar fossils of the dusty Milky Way progenitors
• Advanced LIGO Constraints on Neutron Star Mergers and R-Process Sites
• A New, Faint Population of X-ray Transients
• The red supergiant and supernova rate problems: implications for core-collapse supernova physics
• The Core Collapse Supernova Rate from the SDSS-II Supernova Survey
• New Prospects for Detecting High-Energy Neutrinos from Nearby Supernovae
• Measuring the supernova unknowns at the next-generation neutrino telescopes through the diffuse neutrino background
• Multi-Messenger Tests for Fast-Spinning Newborn Pulsars Embedded in Stripped-Envelope Supernovae
• r-process Production Sites as inferred from Eu Abundances in Dwarf Galaxies
• Pair-Instability Supernovae at the Epoch of Reionization
• Unmasking the Supernova Impostors
• A unified explanation for the supernova rate-galaxy mass dependency based on supernovae discovered in Sloan galaxy spectra
• Stellar Collapse Diversity and the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background
• Constraints on Core Collapse from the Black Hole Mass Function
• Observatory science with eXTP
• The Rate of Supernovae at Redshift 0.1-1.0 - the Stockholm VIMOS Supernova Survey IV
• Fundamental physics with the diffuse supernova background neutrinos
• Star formation and nuclear activity in luminous infrared galaxies: An infrared through radio review
• Exciting Prospects for Detecting Late-Time Neutrinos from Core-Collapse Supernovae
• The ASAS-SN Bright Supernova Catalog $-$ I. 2013$-$2014
• The SPIRITS sample of Luminous Infrared Transients: Uncovering Hidden Supernovae and Dusty Stellar Outbursts in Nearby Galaxies
• Pan-STARRS and PESSTO search for an optical counterpart to the LIGO gravitational wave source GW150914
• The Supernova Progenitor Mass Distributions of M31 and M33: Further Evidence for an Upper Mass Limit
• Gone without a bang: An archival HST survey for disappearing massive stars
• The Metallicity Dependence of the Minimum Mass for Core-Collapse Supernovae
• The Star-Forming Galaxy Contribution to the Cosmic MeV and GeV Gamma-Ray Background
• Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background from extensive core-collapse simulations of $8$-$100{\mathrm{M}}_{\odot }$ progenitors
• The ASAS-SN Bright Supernova Catalog -- III. 2016
• Diffuse supernova neutrinos: oscillation effects, stellar cooling and progenitor mass dependence
• RES-NOVA: A new neutrino observatory based on archaeological lead
• High-Energy Emission from Interacting Supernovae: New Constraints on Cosmic-Ray Acceleration in Dense Circumstellar Environments
• FBOTs and AT2018cow following electron-capture collapse of merged white dwarfs
• Dips in the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background
• How Turbulence Enables Core-Collapse Supernova Explosions
• Extending the supernova Hubble diagram to z~1.5 with the Euclid space mission
• Tomography of Massive Stars from Core Collapse to Supernova Shock Breakout
• Supernova Relic Neutrinos and the Supernova Rate Problem: Analysis of Uncertainties and Detectability of ONeMg and Failed Supernovae
• Spectrum of the Supernova Relic Neutrino Background and Metallicity Evolution of Galaxies
• Supernova Remnant Progenitor Masses in M31
• Binary population synthesis models for core-collapse gamma-ray burst progenitors
• Supernova Progenitors, Their Variability, and the Type IIP Supernova ASASSN-16fq in M66
• Are Starburst Galaxies Proton Calorimeters?
• No redshift evolution of non-repeating fast radio-burst rates
• The High Cadence Transient Survey (HiTS) - I. Survey design and supernova shock breakout constraints
• The ASAS-SN Bright Supernova Catalog -- IV. 2017
• Compact Binary Coalescences: Astrophysical Processes and Lessons Learned
• Probing secret interactions of eV-scale sterile neutrinos with the diffuse supernova neutrino background
• Retainment of r-process material in dwarf galaxies
• Discovery of Two Supernovae in the Nuclear Regions of the Luminous Infrared Galaxy IC 883
• Impact of binary interactions on the diffuse supernova neutrino background
• A physical model of mass ejection in failed supernovae
• The Host Galaxies of Rapidly Evolving Transients in the Dark Energy Survey
• LOSS's First Supernova? New Limits on the "Impostor" SN 1997bs
• Multimessenger Search for Sources of Gravitational Waves and High-Energy Neutrinos: Results for Initial LIGO-Virgo and IceCube
• Towards Probing the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background in All Flavors
• Very Low Energy Supernovae: Light Curves and Spectra of Shock Breakout
• High-redshift supernova rates measured with the gravitational telescope A1689
• Imprint of Explosion Mechanism on Supernova Relic Neutrinos
• Cosmic Magnetism in Centimeter and Meter Wavelength Radio Astronomy
• Supernovae and their host galaxies - II. The relative frequencies of supernovae types in spirals
• Effects of stellar rotation on star formation rates and comparison to core-collapse supernova rates
• A low-energy explosion yields the underluminous Type IIP SN 2020cxd
• First results from GeMS/GSAOI for project SUNBIRD: Supernovae UNmasked By Infra-Red Detection
• Stellar Binaries That Survive Supernovae
• Nucleosynthetic Constraints on the Mass of the Heaviest Supernovae
• Chemical evolution of elliptical galaxies with a variable IMF -- A publicly available code
• Probing the Structure of Jet Driven Core-Collapse Supernova and Long Gamma Ray Burst Progenitors with High Energy Neutrinos
• Flavor Triangle of the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background
• The warm-hot circumgalactic medium of the Milky Way as seen by eROSITA
• SN 2008jb: A "Lost" Core-Collapse Supernova in a Star-Forming Dwarf Galaxy at ~10 Mpc
• Massive White Dwarfs in Young Star Clusters
• An Integral Condition for Core-Collapse Supernova Explosions
• SN 2005at - A neglected type Ic supernova at 10 Mpc
• A deficit of ultraluminous X-ray sources in luminous infrared galaxies
• Core-Collapse Supernova Rate Synthesis Within 11 Mpc
• Detecting extra-galactic supernova neutrinos in the Antarctic ice
• Vetting the optical transient candidates detected by the GWAC network using convolutional neural networks
• Discovery of Variability of the Progenitor of SN 2011dh in M51 Using the Large Binocular Telescope
• Revisiting the Cosmic Star Formation History: Caution on the Uncertainties in Dust Correction and Star Formation Rate Conversion
• The origin of the chemical elements in cluster cores
• Discovery of a Luminous Radio Transient 460 pc from the Central Supermassive Black Hole in Cygnus A
• The Absolute Rate of LGRB Formation
• A model of neutron-star--white-dwarf collision for fast radio bursts
• The Ultramassive White Dwarfs of the Alpha Persei Cluster
• Exploring A Cosmic-Ray Origin of the Multi-wavelength Emission in M31
• Charm decay in slow-jet supernovae as the origin of the IceCube ultra-high energy neutrino events
• The Cosmic MeV Neutrino Background as a Laboratory for Black Hole Formation
• HAWK-I infrared supernova search in starburst galaxies
• Search for transient optical counterparts to high-energy IceCube neutrinos with Pan-STARRS1
• Non-Universal Stellar Initial Mass Functions: Large Uncertainties in Star Formation Rates at $z\approx 2-4$ and Other Astrophysical Probes
• Red Supergiant Candidates for Multimessenger Monitoring of the Next Galactic Supernova
• SPIRITS 15c and SPIRITS 14buu: Two Obscured Supernovae in the Nearby Star-Forming Galaxy IC 2163
• Estimating the core compactness of massive stars with Galactic supernova neutrinos
• The Type Ia supernovae rate with Subaru/XMM-Newton Deep Survey
• CHIPS: Complete History of Interaction-Powered Supernovae
• Constraining photohadronic scenarios for the unified origin of IceCube neutrinos and ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays
• Characterising the signatures of star-forming galaxies in the extra-galactic $\gamma$-ray background
• Finding η Car Analogs in Nearby Galaxies Using Spitzer: I. Candidate Selection
• SPIRITS 16tn in NGC 3556: A heavily obscured and low-luminosity supernova at 8.8 Mpc
• The Redshift Completeness of Local Galaxy Catalogs
• Upper Limits on Very-High-Energy Gamma-ray Emission from Core-Collapse Supernovae Observed with H.E.S.S
• Diffuse neutrino background from past core-collapse supernovae
• Constraining the final fates of massive stars by oxygen and iron enrichment history in the Galaxy
• Impact of late-time neutrino emission on the diffuse supernova neutrino background
• The radial distribution of supernovae compared to star formation tracers
• iPTF Survey for Cool Transients
• Neutron stars formation and Core Collapse Supernovae
• Neutrino Backgrounds in Future Liquid Noble Element Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
• Finding $\eta$ Car Analogs in Nearby Galaxies Using Spitzer: II. Identification of An Emerging Class of Extragalactic Self-Obscured Stars
• A Force Explosion Condition for Spherically Symmetric Core-collapse Supernovae
• Probing self-interacting sterile neutrino dark matter with the diffuse supernova neutrino background
• Uncovering new white dwarf - open cluster associations using Gaia DR3
• Diffuse supernova neutrino background with up-to-date star formation rate measurements and long-term multidimensional supernova simulations
• Neutrino non-radiative decay and the diffuse supernova neutrino background
• Finding Core Collapse Supernova from the Epoch of Reionization Behind Cluster Lenses
• Diffuse neutrino supernova background as a cosmological test
• The Force Explosion Condition is Consistent with Spherically Symmetric CCSN Explosions
• Metal Enrichment in the Fermi Bubbles as a Probe of Their Origin
• The effects of rotation, metallicity and magnetic field on the islands of failed supernovae
• Weak Shock Propagation with Accretion. III. A Numerical Study On Shock Propagation & Stability
• Quantum Black Hole Seismology II: Applications to Astrophysical Black Holes
• Constraining red supergiant mass-loss prescriptions through supernova radio properties
• Search for supernova neutrinos and constraint on the galactic star formation rate with the KamLAND data
• Discovery of the Goat Horn complex: a $\sim 1000$ deg${}^2$ diffuse X-ray source connected to radio loop XII
• Origin of the diffuse 4-8 keV emission in M82
• Constraining Chaplygin models using diffuse supernova neutrino background
• Supernovae and extragalactic astronomy with laser guide star adaptive optics
• Timing coincidence search for supernova neutrinos with optical transient surveys
• Central regions of LIRGs: rings, hidden starbursts, Supernovae and star clusters
• Neutrinos from Diffuse Supernova Background
• When Do Stars Go BOOM?
• The Contribution From TeV Halos to the Isotropic Gamma-Ray Background
• The influence of rotation and metallicity on the explodability of massive stars
• New Insights into Uncertainties in the Relic Neutrino Background and Effects from the Nuclear Equation of State
• On the diversity of mixing and helium core masses of B-type dwarfs from gravity-mode asteroseismology