The Search for Failed Supernovae with The Large Binocular Telescope: First Candidates

Abstract

We are monitoring 27 galaxies within 10 Mpc using the Large Binocular Telescope to search for failed supernovae (SNe), massive stars that collapse to form a black hole without a SN explosion. We present the results from the first 4 years of survey data, during which these galaxies were observed to produce 3 successful core-collapse SNe. We search for stars that have "vanished" over the course of our survey, by examining all stars showing a decrease in luminosity of $\Delta \nu L_{\nu }\ge 10^4{L}_{\odot }$ from the first to the last observation. We also search for the low luminosity, long duration transients predicted by \citet{lovegrove2013} for failed explosions of red supergiants. After analyzing the first 4 years of data in this first direct search for failed SNe, we are left with one candidate requiring further study. This candidate has an estimated mass of 18-25$M_{\odot }$, a mass range likely associated with failed SNe and, if real, implies that failed SN represent a median fraction of $f\simeq 0.30$ of core-collapses, with symmetric 90% confidence limits of $0.07\le f\le 0.62$. If follow up data eliminate this candidate, we find an upper limit on the fraction of core collapses leading to a failed SN of $f<0.40$ at 90% confidence. As the duration of the survey continues to increase, it will begin to constrain the $f\simeq$ 10-30% failure rates needed to explain the deficit of massive SN progenitors and the observed black hole mass function.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in MNRAS; 19 pages, 16 figures. For a brief video abstract of the original version of the paper, please visit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9C-PIspuKJk&list=UU0YbHd6wHHz98SUJYGAXcUA

References in corpus (77)

• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
• How Massive Single Stars End their Life
• The USNO-B Catalog
• On the normalisation of the cosmic star formation history
• K-corrections and filter transformations in the ultraviolet, optical, and near infrared
• Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars II. Optical to far-infrared isochrones with improved TP-AGB models
• The Ninth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey
• A method for optimal image subtraction
• The SBF Survey of Galaxy Distances. IV. SBF Magnitudes, Colors, and Distances
• SINGS: The SIRTF Nearby Galaxies Survey
• Progenitors of core-collapse supernovae
• Astrometric Calibration of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The death of massive stars - I. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type II-P supernovae
• Black Hole Formation in Failing Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Empirical Color Transformations Between SDSS Photometry and Other Photometric Systems
• Numerical Methods of Star Formation History Measurement and Applications to Seven Dwarf Spheroidals
• The Second-Generation Guide Star Catalog: Description and Properties
• New Grids of ATLAS9 Model Atmospheres
• Supernova 2011fe from an Exploding Carbon-Oxygen White Dwarf Star
• Progenitor-Explosion Connection and Remnant Birth Masses for Neutrino-Driven Supernovae of Iron-Core Progenitors
• A 4% Geometric Distance to the Galaxy NGC4258 from Orbital Motions in a Nuclear Gas Disk
• Homogeneous Velocity-Distance Data for Peculiar Velocity Analysis. III. The Mark III Catalog of Galaxy Peculiar Velocities
• SDSS Standard Star Catalog for Stripe 82: the Dawn of Industrial 1% Optical Photometry
• Constraints on the Progenitor System of the Type Ia Supernova SN 2011fe/PTF11kly
• A Survey About Nothing: Monitoring a Million Supergiants for Failed Supernovae
• Very Low Energy Supernovae from Neutrino Mass Loss
• Observing the Next Galactic Supernova
• The Extragalactic Distance Database: Color-Magnitude Diagrams
• Kinematics of the Local Universe XIII. 21-cm line measurements of 452 galaxies with the Nançay radiotelescope, JHK Tully-Fisher relation and preliminary maps of the peculiar velocity field
• The Landscape of the Neutrino Mechanism of Core-Collapse Supernovae: Neutron Star and Black Hole Mass Functions, Explosion Energies and Nickel Yields
• Discovery of the Dust-Enshrouded Progenitor of SN 2008S with Spitzer
• The Cosmic Core-collapse Supernova Rate does not match the Massive-Star Formation Rate
• A New Cepheid Distance to the Giant Spiral M101 Based On Image Subtraction of HST/ACS Observations
• Photometric and spectroscopic evolution of the type IIP supernova SN 2004et
• SN 2008S: an electron capture SN from a super-AGB progenitor?
• Improved Standardization of Type II-P Supernovae: Application to an Expanded Sample
• Fundamental properties of core-collapse Supernova and GRB progenitors: predicting the look of massive stars before death
• Search for Supernova Neutrino Bursts at Super-Kamiokande
• Long Gamma-Ray Transients from Collapsars
• User Manual for DUSTY
• ACS imaging of 25 galaxies in nearby groups and in the field
• Stellar Mergers Are Common
• Local galaxy flows within 5 Mpc
• Circumstellar dust as a solution to the red supergiant supernova progenitor problem
• The performance of the blue prime focus Large Binocular Camera at the Large Binocular Telescope
• Failed Supernovae Explain the Compact Remnant Mass Function
• Dusty winds: I. Self-similar solutions
• Planetary Nebulae in Face-On Spiral Galaxies. I. Planetary Nebula Photometry and Distances
• A comparison between star formation rate diagnostics and rate of core collapse supernovae within 11 Mpc
• On Absorption by Circumstellar Dust, With the Progenitor of SN2012aw as a Case Study
• The red supergiant and supernova rate problems: implications for core-collapse supernova physics
• The Massive Progenitor of the Possible Type II-Linear Supernova 2009hd in Messier 66
• A Study of Cepheids in M81 with the Large Binocular Telescope (Efficiently Calibrated with HST)
• Probing the Core-Collapse Supernova Mechanism with Gravitational Waves
• Constraints on Core Collapse from the Black Hole Mass Function
• A Late-Time View of the Progenitors of Five Type IIP Supernovae
• Taking the "Un" out of "Unnovae"
• The extra-galactic Cepheid distance scale from LMC and Galactic period-luminosity relations
• The Supernova Progenitor Mass Distributions of M31 and M33: Further Evidence for an Upper Mass Limit
• Starbursts in the Local Universe: new HST/ACS observations of the irregular galaxy NGC 4449
• Cepheids and Long Period Variables in NGC 4395
• Constraints for the Progenitor Masses of Historic Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Constraints for the Progenitor Masses of 17 Historic Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Supernova Remnant Progenitor Masses in M31
• Synoptic Sky Surveys and the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background: Removing Astrophysical Uncertainties and Revealing Invisible Supernovae
• The Black Hole Formation Probability
• An Extremely Bright Echo Associated With SN 2002hh
• Nucleosynthetic Constraints on the Mass of the Heaviest Supernovae
• The Cepheid distance to the maser-host galaxy NGC 4258: Studying systematics with the Large Binocular Telescope
• Discovery of Variability of the Progenitor of SN 2011dh in M51 Using the Large Binocular Telescope
• Attempts to reproduce the rotation profile of the red giant KIC 7341231 observed by Kepler
• LBT Discovery of a Yellow Supergiant Eclipsing Binary in the Dwarf Galaxy Holmberg IX
• Revisiting the Triangulation Method for Pointing to Supernova and Failed Supernova with Neutrinos
• Twenty Years of Galactic Observations in Searching for Bursts of Collapse Neutrinos with the Baksan Underground Scintillation Telescope
• Dust Formation By Failed Supernovae
• Finding $\eta$ Car Analogs in Nearby Galaxies Using Spitzer: II. Identification of An Emerging Class of Extragalactic Self-Obscured Stars

Cited by in corpus (116)

• The first gravitational-wave source from the isolated evolution of two 40-100 Msun stars
• The Zwicky Transient Facility: Science Objectives
• Observational constraints on the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae : the case for missing high mass stars
• The search for failed supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: confirmation of a disappearing star
• The impact of pair-instability mass loss on the binary black hole mass distribution
• Pre-supernova evolution, compact object masses and explosion properties of stripped binary stars
• What can be learned from a future supernova neutrino detection?
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: Constraints from 7 Years of Data
• Supernova rates from the SUDARE VST-Omegacam search. I
• Mass Ejection in Failed Supernovae: Variation with Stellar Progenitor
• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• Equation of State Dependent Dynamics and Multimessenger Signals from Stellar-mass Black Hole Formation
• Measuring the supernova unknowns at the next-generation neutrino telescopes through the diffuse neutrino background
• X-ray Binaries
• Formation channels of single and binary stellar-mass black holes
• LOSS Revisited - I: Unraveling correlations between supernova rates and galaxy properties, as measured in a reanalysis of the Lick Observatory Supernova Search
• Missing Red Supergiants and Carbon Burning
• Neutrino emission characteristics of black hole formation in three-dimensional simulations of stellar collapse
• Almost Gone: SN~2008S and NGC~300 2008OT-1 are Fainter than their Progenitors
• Luminous Type II Short-Plateau Supernovae 2006Y, 2006ai, and 2016egz: A Transitional Class from Stripped Massive Red Supergiants
• The Dusty Progenitor Star of the Type II Supernova 2017eaw
• The search for failed supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: a new candidate and the failed SN fraction with 11 yr of data
• Exciting Prospects for Detecting Late-Time Neutrinos from Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Gone without a bang: An archival HST survey for disappearing massive stars
• Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background from extensive core-collapse simulations of $8$-$100{\mathrm{M}}_{\odot }$ progenitors
• The Formation of Stellar Black Holes
• Effect of binary evolution on the inferred initial and final core masses of hydrogen-rich, Type~II supernova progenitors
• Characteristic Time Variability of Gravitational-Wave and Neutrino Signals from Three-dimensional Simulations of Non-Rotating and Rapidly Rotating Stellar Core-Collapse
• Whimper of a Bang: Documenting the Final Days of the Nearby Type Ia Supernova 2011fe
• Radiation-hydrodynamical modelling of underluminous type II plateau Supernovae
• The final core collapse of pulsational pair instability supernovae
• Variability of Red Supergiants in M31 from the Palomar Transient Factory
• Supernova Progenitors, Their Variability, and the Type IIP Supernova ASASSN-16fq in M66
• On The Red Supergiant Problem
• Pre-supernova evolution and final fate of stellar mergers and accretors of binary mass transfer
• The Physics of Flash (Supernova) Spectroscopy
• The LBT Satellites of Nearby Galaxies Survey (LBT-SONG): The Satellite Population of NGC 628
• Revisiting the explodability of single massive star progenitors of stripped-envelope supernovae
• The quiescent progenitors of four Type II-P/L supernovae
• It's written in the massive stars: The role of stellar physics in the formation of black holes
• LOSS's First Supernova? New Limits on the "Impostor" SN 1997bs
• Towards Probing the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background in All Flavors
• Very Low Energy Supernovae: Light Curves and Spectra of Shock Breakout
• Cosmic rays across the star-forming galaxy sequence. I: Cosmic ray pressures and calorimetry
• Mass ejection in failed supernovae: equation of state and neutrino loss dependence
• The luminous and rapidly evolving SN 2018bcc: Clues toward the origin of Type Ibn SNe from the Zwicky Transient Facility
• Flavor Triangle of the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background
• Sensitivity of future liquid argon dark matter search experiments to core-collapse supernova neutrinos
• Measurement of the core-collapse progenitor mass distribution of the Small Magellanic Cloud
• A Dark Energy Camera Search for Missing Supergiants in the LMC After the Advanced LIGO Gravitational Wave Event GW150914
• High Tide: A Systematic Search for Ellipsoidal Variables in ASAS-SN
• The Progenitor Age and Mass of the Black-Hole-Formation Candidate N6946-BH1
• Empirical Constraints on the Nucleosynthesis of Nitrogen
• Explodability criteria for the neutrino-driven supernova mechanism
• The two promising scenarios to explode core collapse supernovae
• A Search for Satellite Galaxies of Nearby Star-Forming Galaxies with Resolved Stars in LBT-SONG
• Modelling the chemical enrichment of Population III supernovae: The origin of the metals in near-pristine gas clouds
• Type II intermediate-luminosity optical transients (ILOTs)
• Precursors of Supernovae from Mass Eruption: Prospects for Early Warning of Nearby Core-collapse Supernovae
• PS15cey and PS17cke: prospective candidates from the Pan-STARRS Search for Kilonovae
• Neutrinos from Type Ia and failed core-collapse supernovae at dark matter detectors
• Intermediate Luminosity Red Transients by Black Holes Born from Erupting Massive Stars
• Our Sky now and then $-$ searches for lost stars and impossible effects as probes of advanced extra-terrestrial civilisations
• On the Progenitor of the Type Ic Supernova 2012fh
• The Cosmic MeV Neutrino Background as a Laboratory for Black Hole Formation
• On the maximum stellar rotation to form a black hole without an accompanying luminous transient
• Non-Universal Stellar Initial Mass Functions: Large Uncertainties in Star Formation Rates at $z\approx 2-4$ and Other Astrophysical Probes
• An Exceptional Dimming Event for a Massive, Cool Supergiant in M51
• Estimating the core compactness of massive stars with Galactic supernova neutrinos
• The Late Time Optical Evolution of Twelve Core-Collapse Supernovae: Detection of Normal Stellar Winds
• The Case for Strangulation in Low-Mass Hosts: DDO 113
• The 50-100pc scale parent stellar populations of type II supernovae and limitations of single star evolution models
• Red Supergiants, Yellow Hypergiants, and Post-RSG Evolution
• Luminous and Variable Stars in NGC 2403 and M81
• The Blue Supergiant Progenitor of the Supernova Imposter AT~2019krl
• Diffuse neutrino background from past core-collapse supernovae
• Constraining the final fates of massive stars by oxygen and iron enrichment history in the Galaxy
• Collective neutrino oscillations and detectabilities in failed supernovae
• The Masses of Supernova Remnant Progenitors in NGC 6946
• Nucleosynthesis signatures of neutrino-driven winds from proto-neutron stars: a perspective from chemical evolution models
• Neutrino Echos following Black Hole Formation in Core-Collapse Supernovae
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: N6946-BH1, Still No Star
• Failed supernovae as a natural explanation for the binary black hole mass distribution
• Diffuse supernova neutrino background with up-to-date star formation rate measurements and long-term multidimensional supernova simulations
• The Explosion Mechanism of Core-Collapse Supernovae and Its Observational Signatures
• Gravitational Waves from Newborn Accreting Millisecond Magnetars
• Bringing Stellar Evolution & Feedback Together: Summary of proposals from the Lorentz Center Workshop, 2022
• Radio Transients from Newborn Black Holes
• The Spin of a Newborn Black Hole: Swift J1728.9-3613
• The circumstellar matter of type II intermediate luminosity optical transients (ILOTs)
• The effects of rotation, metallicity and magnetic field on the islands of failed supernovae
• Supernovae from stellar mergers and accretors of binary mass transfer: Implications for Type IIP, 1987A-like and interacting supernovae
• Discovery of Five Candidate Analogs for $\eta$Carinae in Nearby Galaxies
• Enhanced mass-loss rate evolution of stars with $\gtrsim 18M_{\odot }$ and missing optically-observed type II core-collapse supernovae
• The Progenitor of the Vela Pulsar
• Quantum Black Hole Seismology II: Applications to Astrophysical Black Holes
• Diffuse Neutrino Background from Magnetorotational Stellar Core Collapses
• The Masses of Supernova Remnant Progenitors in M33
• A survey of extremely metal-poor gas at cosmic noon: evidence of elevated [O/Fe]
• The High Rate of the Boyajian's Star Anomaly as a Phenomenon
• Stellar Migration and Chemical Enrichment in the Milky Way Disc: A Hybrid Model
• Disappearance of a massive star in the Andromeda Galaxy due to formation of a black hole
• Progenitor constraints for core-collapse supernovae from Chandra X-ray observations
• Failed Supernova Remnants
• A rapidly fading star as a type II obscuring intermediate luminosity optical transient (ILOT) in a triple star system
• One of Everything: The Breakthrough Listen Exotica Catalog
• Triangulating Black Hole Forming Stellar Collapses through Neutrinos
• Deep Late-Time Observations of the Supernova Impostors SN 1954J and SN 1961V
• Stellar progenitors of black holes: insights from optical and infrared observations
• Stellar evolution through the Red Supergiant phase
• Red Supergiants -- The Other Side of the H-R Diagram
• A Search for Supernova Light Echoes in NGC 6946 with SITELLE
• Neutrinos from Diffuse Supernova Background
• Numerical Simulations of the Random Angular Momentum in Convection: Implications for Supergiant Collapse to Form Black Holes
• Constraining Black Hole Natal Kicks with Astrometric Microlensing
• The core starbursts of the galaxy NGC 3628: Radio very long baseline interferometry and X-ray studies