On The Red Supergiant Problem

Abstract

We examine the problem of estimating the mass range corresponding to the observed red supergiant (RSG) progenitors of Type IIP supernovae. Using Monte Carlo simulations designed to reproduce the properties of the observations, we find that the approach of Davies & Beasor (2018) significantly overestimates the maximum mass, yielding an upper limit of Mh/Msun=20.5+/-2.6 for an input population with Mh/Msun=18. Our preferred Bayesian approach does better, with Mh/Msun=18.6+/-2.1 for the same input populations, but also tends to overestimate Mh. For the actual progenitor sample and a Salpeter initial mass function we find Mh/Msun=19.01-2.04+4.04 for the Eldridge et al. (2004) mass-luminosity relation used by Smartt et al. (2009) and Davies & Beasor (2018), and Mh/Msun=21.28_-2.28+4.52 for the Sukhbold et al. (2018) mass-luminosity relation. Based on the Monte Carlo simulations, we estimate that these are overestimated by 3.3+/-0.8Mh. The red supergiant problem remains.

arXiv commentsubmitted to MNRAS

References in corpus (23)

• Progenitors of core-collapse supernovae
• Core-Collapse Supernovae from 9 to 120 Solar Masses Based on Neutrino-powered Explosions
• The death of massive stars - I. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type II-P supernovae
• Black Hole Formation in Failing Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Observational constraints on the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae : the case for missing high mass stars
• Progenitor-Explosion Connection and Remnant Birth Masses for Neutrino-Driven Supernovae of Iron-Core Progenitors
• The search for failed supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: confirmation of a disappearing star
• A Survey About Nothing: Monitoring a Million Supergiants for Failed Supernovae
• High Resolution Study of Presupernova Compactness
• The Landscape of the Neutrino Mechanism of Core-Collapse Supernovae: Neutron Star and Black Hole Mass Functions, Explosion Energies and Nickel Yields
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with The Large Binocular Telescope: First Candidates
• Fundamental properties of core-collapse Supernova and GRB progenitors: predicting the look of massive stars before death
• The Initial Masses of the Red Supergiant Progenitors to Type-II Supernovae
• Circumstellar dust as a solution to the red supergiant supernova progenitor problem
• Failed Supernovae Explain the Compact Remnant Mass Function
• The Search for Failed Supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: Constraints from 7 Years of Data
• On Absorption by Circumstellar Dust, With the Progenitor of SN2012aw as a Case Study
• The evolution of Red Supergiants to supernova in the LMC cluster NGC 2100
• A more detailed look at the Opacities for Enriched Carbon and Oxygen Mixtures
• On the Lack of X-ray Bright Type IIP Supernovae
• Constraints on Core Collapse from the Black Hole Mass Function
• Progenitor Mass Distribution for Core-Collapse Supernova Remnants in M31 and M33
• Measurement of the core-collapse progenitor mass distribution of the Small Magellanic Cloud

Cited by in corpus (26)

• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• SN2023ixf in Messier 101: A Variable Red Supergiant as the Progenitor Candidate to a Type II Supernova
• A Luminous Red Supergiant and Dusty Long-period Variable Progenitor for SN 2023ixf
• Numerical Simulations of Convective 3-Dimensional Red Supergiant Envelopes
• Luminous Type II Short-Plateau Supernovae 2006Y, 2006ai, and 2016egz: A Transitional Class from Stripped Massive Red Supergiants
• The excess of cool supergiants from contemporary stellar evolution models defies the metallicity-independent Humphreys-Davidson limit
• On `On the Red Supergiant Problem': a rebuttal, and a consensus on the upper mass cutoff for II-P progenitors
• The Time-Averaged Mass-Loss Rates of Red Supergiants As Revealed by their Luminosity Functions in M31 and M33
• A theoretical investigation of the Humphreys-Davidson limit at high and low metallicity
• Synthetic red supergiant explosion model grid for systematic characterization of Type II supernovae
• On the Red Supergiant Wind Kink. A Universal mass-loss concept for massive stars
• The impact of realistic red supergiant mass-loss on stellar evolution
• Short Term Variability of Evolved Massive Stars with TESS II: A New Class of Cool, Pulsating Supergiants
• Type II-P Supernova Progenitor Star Initial Masses and SN 2020jfo: Direct Detection, Light Curve Properties, Nebular Spectroscopy, and Local Environment
• SN 2018gj: A Short-plateau Type II Supernova with Persistent Blue-shifted H-alpha Emission
• An Exceptional Dimming Event for a Massive, Cool Supergiant in M51
• Progenitor Mass Distribution for 22 Historic Core-Collapse Supernovae
• Revisiting the progenitor of the low-luminosity type II-plateau supernova, SN 2008bk
• The landscape of binary core-collapse supernova progenitors and the late emergence of Wolf-Rayet winds
• Luminous Type II Short-Plateau SN 2023ufx: Asymmetric Explosion of a Partially-Stripped Massive Progenitor
• The effects of rotation, metallicity and magnetic field on the islands of failed supernovae
• The Progenitor of the Vela Pulsar
• Parameters of the type-IIP supernova SN 2012aw
• The Blue supergiant problem and the main-sequence width
• The Properties of Fast Yellow Pulsating Supergiants: FYPS Point the Way to Missing Red Supergiants
• Multimessenger Constraints on the Central Engine in SN 2023ixf: Neutron Star or Black Hole?