Evidence of Possible Spin-Orbit Misalignment Along the Line of Sight in Transiting Exoplanet Systems

Abstract

Of the 26 transiting exoplanet systems with measurements of the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect, eight have now been found to be significantly spin-orbit misaligned in the plane of the sky. Unfortunately, the RM effect only measures the angle between the orbit of a transiting exoplanet and the spin of its host star projected in the plane of sky, leaving unconstrained the compliment misalignment angle between the orbit of the planet and the spin of its host star along the line of sight. I use a simple model of stellar rotation benchmarked with observational data to statistically identify ten exoplanet systems from a sample of 75 for which there is likely a significant degree of misalignment along the line of sight between the orbit of the planet and the spin of its host star. I find that HAT-P-7, HAT-P-14, HAT-P-16, HD 17156, Kepler-5, Kepler-7, TrES-4, WASP-1, WASP-12, and WASP-14 are likely spin-orbit misaligned along the line of sight. All ten systems have host stellar masses M_star in the range 1.2 M_sun <= M_star <= 1.5 M_sun, and the probability of this occurrence by chance is less than one in ten thousand. In addition, the planets in the candidate misaligned systems are preferentially massive and eccentric. The coupled distribution of misalignment from the RM effect and from this anaylsis suggests that transiting exoplanets are more likely to be spin-orbit aligned than expected given predictions for a transiting planet population produced entirely by planet-planet scattering or Kozai cycles and tidal friction. For that reason, there are likely two populations of close-in exoplanet systems: a population of aligned systems and a population of apparently misaligned systems in which the processes that lead to misalignment or to the survival of misaligned systems operate more efficiently in systems with massive stars and planets. (abridged)

16 pages, 5 figures, and 2 tables in emulateapj format; submitted to ApJ in original form 24 December 2009, resubmitted in response to referee report 1 June 2010

References in corpus (40)

• Dynamical Outcomes of Planet-Planet Scattering
• Formation of Hot Planets by a combination of planet scattering, tidal circularization, and Kozai mechanism
• Improved parameters for extrasolar transiting planets
• Toward a Deterministic Model of Planetary Formation V. Accumulation Near the Ice Line
• Migration and the formation of systems of hot super-Earths and Neptunes
• Homogeneous studies of transiting extrasolar planets. I. Light curve analyses
• Improving Stellar and Planetary Parameters of Transiting Planet Systems: The Case of TrES-2
• The Transit Light Curve Project. IX. Evidence for a Smaller Radius of the Exoplanet XO-3b
• WASP-1b and WASP-2b: Two new transiting exoplanets detected with SuperWASP and SOPHIE
• WASP-3b: a strongly-irradiated transiting gas-giant planet
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission VI. CoRoT-Exo-3b: The first secure inhabitant of the brown-dwarf desert
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission I - CoRoT-Exo-1b: a low-density short-period planet around a G0V star
• HAT-P-7b: An Extremely Hot Massive Planet Transiting a Bright Star in the Kepler Field
• HD147506b: A Super-Massive Planet in an Eccentric Orbit Transiting a Bright Star
• The Transit Light Curve Project. V. System Parameters and Stellar Rotation Period of HD 189733
• XO-2b: Transiting Hot Jupiter in a Metal-rich Common Proper Motion Binary
• XO-3b: A Massive Planet in an Eccentric Orbit Transiting an F5V Star
• A Transiting Planet of a Sun-like Star
• Improved parameters for the transiting hot Jupiters WASP-4b and WASP-5b
• HAT-P-12b: A Low-Density Sub-Saturn Mass Planet Transiting a Metal-Poor K Dwarf
• Five Intermediate-Period Planets from the N2K Sample
• HAT-P-3b: A heavy-element rich planet transiting a K dwarf star
• High accuracy transit photometry of the planet OGLE-TR-113b with a new deconvolution-based method
• HAT-P-5b: A Jupiter-like hot Jupiter Transiting a Bright Star
• WASP-14b: 7.3 Mj transiting planet in an eccentric orbit
• HAT-P-6b: A Hot Jupiter transiting a bright F star
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission IV: CoRoT-Exo-4b: A transiting planet in a 9.2 day synchronous orbit
• WASP-10b: a 3M_J, gas-giant planet transiting a late-type K star
• Detection of a transit by the planetary companion of HD 80606
• WASP-7: The brightest transiting-exoplanet system in the Southern hemisphere
• Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Angle of Exoplanet HAT-P-1b
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission III. The spectroscopic transit of CoRoT-Exo-2b with SOPHIE and HARPS
• Updated parameters for the transiting exoplanet WASP-3b using RISE, a new fast camera for the Liverpool Telescope
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission V. CoRoT-Exo-4b: Stellar and planetary parameters
• OGLE2-TR-L9: An extrasolar planet transiting a fast-rotating F3 star
• A Hubble Space Telescope transit light curve for GJ436b
• The low density transiting exoplanet WASP-15b
• On the Age of Stars Harboring Transiting Planets
• A Precise Estimate of the Radius of the Exoplanet HD 149026b from Spitzer Photometry
• The first rotation periods in Praesepe

Cited by in corpus (176)

• The Occurrence and Architecture of Exoplanetary Systems
• Obliquities of Hot Jupiter host stars: Evidence for tidal interactions and primordial misalignments
• Origins of Hot Jupiters
• Hot Jupiters from Secular Planet--Planet Interactions
• The Transiting Circumbinary Planets Kepler-34 and Kepler-35
• Internal Gravity Waves in Massive Stars: Angular Momentum Transport
• Multiple-Planet Scattering and the Origin of Hot Jupiters
• A Study of the Shortest-Period Planets Found With Kepler
• Stellar Rotation Periods of the Kepler Objects of Interest: A Dearth of Close-in Planets around Fast Rotators
• Alignment of the stellar spin with the orbits of a three-planet system
• Evolution of Spin Direction of Accreting Magnetic Protostars and Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Exoplanetary Systems
• Consequences of the Ejection and Disruption of Giant Planets
• Rotation Periods, Variability Properties and Ages for Kepler Exoplanet Candidate Host Stars
• Stellar obliquities in exoplanetary systems
• Starspots and spin-orbit alignment in the WASP-4 exoplanetary system
• The Apparently Decaying Orbit of WASP-12
• Tidal Dissipation in Planet-Hosting Stars: Damping of Spin-Orbit Misalignment and Survival of Hot Jupiters
• The Oblique Orbit of the Super-Neptune HAT-P-11b
• Low stellar obliquities in compact multiplanet systems
• Transits and Occultations of an Earth-Sized Planet in an 8.5-Hour Orbit
• Kepler-63b: A Giant Planet in a Polar Orbit around a Young Sun-like Star
• HAT-P-20b--HAT-P-23b: Four Massive Transiting Extrasolar Planets
• Friends of Hot Jupiters II: No Correspondence Between Hot-Jupiter Spin-Orbit Misalignment and the Incidence of Directly Imaged Stellar Companions
• The Transit Light Source Effect II: The Impact of Stellar Heterogeneity on Transmission Spectra of Planets Orbiting Broadly Sun-like Stars
• Photometric Amplitude Distribution of Stellar Rotation of Kepler KOIs-Indication for Spin-Orbit Alignment of Cool Stars and High Obliquity for Hot Stars
• Internal Gravity Waves Modulate the Apparent Misalignment of Exoplanets around Hot Stars
• HAT-P-26b: A Low-Density Neptune-Mass Planet Transiting a K Star
• Obliquities of Kepler Stars: Comparison of Single- and Multiple-Transit Systems
• On the Inference of a Star's Inclination Angle from its Rotation Velocity and Projected Rotation Velocity
• Discovery of a 1.6-year Magnetic Activity Cycle in the Exoplanet Host Star iota Horologii
• The retrograde orbit of the HAT-P-6b exoplanet
• Using Star Spots to Measure the Spin-orbit Alignment of Transiting Planets
• Transits and starspots in the WASP-19 planetary system
• Evidence for the Tidal Destruction of Hot Jupiters by Subgiant Stars
• Calibration of Equilibrium Tide Theory for Extrasolar Planet Systems II
• The Turbulent Origin of Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Planetary Systems
• Optical and X-ray Transients from Planet-Star Mergers
• Asteroseismic inference on rotation, gyrochronology and planetary system dynamics of 16 Cygni
• Planets Transiting Non-Eclipsing Binaries
• Debris disks as signposts of terrestrial planet formation. II Dependence of exoplanet architectures on giant planet and disk properties
• Hot Jupiters are Destroyed by Tides While Their Host Stars are on the Main Sequence
• WASP-80b has a dayside within the T-dwarf range
• Discerning Exoplanet Migration Models Using Spin-Orbit Measurements
• The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect in Exoplanet Research
• Determination of Three-dimensional Spin-orbit Angle with Joint Analysis of Asteroseismology, Transit Lightcurve, and the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect: Cases of HAT-P-7 and Kepler-25
• Measurements of Stellar Inclinations for Kepler Planet Candidates
• A Preponderance of Perpendicular Planets
• WASP-44b, WASP-45b and WASP-46b: three short-period, transiting extrasolar planets
• KELT-20b: A giant planet with a period of P~ 3.5 days transiting the V~ 7.6 early A star HD 185603
• Correlations between compositions and orbits established by the giant impact era of planet formation
• A Possible Tilted Orbit of the Super-Neptune HAT-P-11b
• Evolution of Spin Direction of Accreting Magnetic Protostars and Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Exoplanetary Systems: II. Warped Discs
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG XVI: Measurement of the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect of the transiting planetary systems HAT-P-3, HAT-P-12, HAT-P-22, WASP-39 and WASP-60
• Rossiter--McLaughlin models and their effect on estimates of stellar rotation, illustrated using six WASP systems
• On the tidal origin of hot Jupiter stellar obliquity trends
• Tidal Dissipation and Obliquity Evolution in Hot Jupiter Systems
• Prospects for Detection of Exoplanet Magnetic Fields Through Bow-Shock Observations During Transits
• Ultra-short-period planets from secular chaos
• Measurements of Stellar Inclinations for Kepler Planet Candidates II: Candidate Spin-Orbit Misalignments in Single and Multiple-Transiting Systems
• Orbital Orientations of Exoplanets: HAT-P-4b is Prograde and HAT-P-14b is Retrograde
• Planet-disc evolution and the formation of Kozai-Lidov planets
• Warm Spitzer Photometry of XO-4b, HAT-P-6b and HAT-P-8b
• Origins of Hot Jupiters from the Stellar Obliquity Distribution
• HAT-P-30b: A transiting hot Jupiter on a highly oblique orbit
• Spin-orbit alignment of exoplanet systems: ensemble analysis using asteroseismology
• Occurrence and Architecture of Kepler Planetary Systems as Functions of Stellar Mass and Effective Temperature
• The Banana Project. III. Spin-orbit Alignment in the Long-period Eclipsing Binary NY Cephei
• Detection of Atmospheric Escape from Four Young Mini Neptunes
• The Habitable-zone Planet Finder Reveals A High Mass and a Low Obliquity for the Young Neptune K2-25b
• Spin-orbit inclinations of the exoplanetary systems HAT-P-8, HAT-P-9, HAT-P-16 and HAT-P-23
• The Curious Case of Elemental Abundance Differences in the Dual Hot Jupiter Hosts WASP-94AB
• Gaia's potential for the discovery of circumbinary planets
• Transits and starspots in the WASP-6 planetary system
• TOI-1136 is a Young, Coplanar, Aligned Planetary System in a Pristine Resonant Chain
• MASCARA-2 b: A hot Jupiter transiting the $m_V=7.6$ A-star HD185603
• Transit Variability in Bow Shock-Hosting Planets
• Two Upper Limits on the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect, with Differing Implications: WASP-1 has a High Obliquity and WASP-2 is Indeterminate
• Evidence for Hidden Nearby Companions to Hot Jupiters
• High-resolution Transmission Spectroscopy of MASCARA-2 b with EXPRES
• A Population of Very-Hot Super-Earths in Multiple-Planet Systems Should be Uncovered by Kepler
• Tidal Dissipation in WASP-12
• The Oblique Orbit of WASP-107b from K2 Photometry
• Discrepancies between isochrone fitting and gyrochronology for exoplanet host stars?
• Rotation Periods, Inclinations, and Obliquities of Cool Stars Hosting Directly Imaged Substellar Companions: Spin-Orbit Misalignments are Common
• On the Survivability and Metamorphism of Tidally Disrupted Giant Planets: the Role of Dense Cores
• The spin-orbit angles of the transiting exoplanets WASP-1b, WASP-24b, WASP-38b and HAT-P-8b from Rossiter-McLaughlin observations
• WASP-94 A and B planets: hot-Jupiter cousins in a twin-star system
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. XIII. The orbital obliquity of three close-in massive planets hosted by dwarf K-type stars: WASP-43, HAT-P-20 and Qatar-2
• Asteroseismic inference on the spin-orbit misalignment and stellar parameters of HAT-P-7
• Escaping Helium from TOI 560.01, a Young Mini Neptune
• The Time Dependence of hot Jupiters' Orbital Inclinations
• Newly-Discovered Planets Orbiting HD~5319, HD~11506, HD~75784 and HD~10442 from the N2K Consortium
• Time variation of Kepler transits induced by stellar rotating spots - a way to distinguish between prograde and retrograde motion I. Theory
• Are Tidal Effects Responsible for Exoplanetary Spin-Orbit Alignment?
• A High Stellar Obliquity in the WASP-7 Exoplanetary System
• Stellar Spin-Orbit Alignment for Kepler-9, a Multi-transiting Planetary system with Two Outer Planets Near 2:1 Resonance
• The Photoeccentric Effect and Proto-Hot Jupiters II. KOI-1474.01, a candidate eccentric planet perturbed by an unseen companion
• Analysis of spin-orbit alignment in the WASP-32, WASP-38, and HAT-P-27/WASP-40 systems
• On using the beaming effect to measure spin-orbit alignment in stellar binaries with Sun-like components
• MASCARA-1 b: A hot Jupiter transiting a bright $m_V=8.3$ A-star in a misaligned orbit
• Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect Measurements for WASP-16, WASP-25 and WASP-31
• WASP-20b and WASP-28b: a hot Saturn and a hot Jupiter in near-aligned orbits around solar-type stars
• Refined physical properties of the HAT-P-13 planetary system
• Discovery of XO-6b: a hot Jupiter transiting a fast rotating F5 star on an oblique orbit
• Spin orbit alignment for KELT-7b and HAT-P-56b via Doppler tomography with TRES
• Doppler tomography of transiting exoplanets: A prograde, low-inclined orbit for the hot Jupiter CoRoT-11b
• The Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect of the Transiting Exoplanet XO-4b
• Preliminary bounds of the gravitational Local Position Invariance from Solar System planetary precessions
• Obliquities of Exoplanet Host Stars: 19 New and Updated Measurements, and Trends in the Sample of 205 Measurements
• Time variation of Kepler transits induced by stellar spots - a way to distinguish between prograde and retrograde motion. II. Application to KOIs
• The Aligned Orbit of WASP-148b, the Only Known Hot Jupiter with a Nearby Warm Jupiter Companion, from NEID and HIRES
• Shock formation around planets orbiting M-dwarf stars
• KELT-21b: A Hot Jupiter Transiting the Rapidly-Rotating Metal-Poor Late-A Primary of a Likely Hierarchical Triple System
• KELT-25b and KELT-26b: A Hot Jupiter and a Substellar Companion Transiting Young A-stars Observed by TESS
• Confirmation of a Retrograde Orbit for Exoplanet WASP-17b
• Hot Stars With Kepler Planets Have High Obliquities
• The stellar obliquity, planet mass, and very low albedo of Qatar-2 from K2 Photometry
• Dynamical tides in exoplanetary systems containing Hot Jupiters: confronting theory and observations
• Stellar Obliquities in Long-period Exoplanet Systems (SOLES) I: The Spin-Orbit Alignment of K2-140 b
• The Curious Case of KOI 4: Confirming Kepler's First Exoplanet
• The misaligned orbit of the Earth-sized planet Kepler-408b
• Lucky Imaging of transiting planet host stars with LuckyCam
• Peculiar architectures for the WASP-53 and WASP-81 planet-hosting systems
• Spin-orbit measurements and refined parameters for the exoplanet systems WASP-22 and WASP-26
• The Stellar Obliquity and the Long-period planet in the HAT-P-17 Exoplanetary System
• MASCARA-4 b/bRing-1b - A retrograde hot Jupiter around the bright A3V star HD 85628
• Statistical Trends in the Obliquity Distribution of Exoplanet Systems
• Optimizing exoplanet transit searches around low-mass stars with inclination constraints
• Gravity-Darkening Analysis of Misaligned Hot Jupiter MASCARA-4 b
• NGTS-2b: An inflated hot-Jupiter transiting a bright F-dwarf
• The well-aligned orbit of WASP-84b: evidence for disc migration
• A low-eccentricity migration pathway for a 13-h-period Earth analogue in a four-planet system
• Deriving stellar inclination of slow rotators using stellar activity
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission. XVIII. CoRoT-18b: a massive hot jupiter on a prograde, nearly aligned orbit
• Kozai-Lidov cycles towards the limit of circumbinary planets
• High-resolution emission spectroscopy retrievals of MASCARA-1b with CRIRES+: Strong detections of CO, H${}_2$O and Fe emission lines and a C$/$O consistent with solar
• On a Possible Solution to the Tidal Realignment Problem for Hot Jupiters
• Confirmation of an He I evaporating atmosphere around the 650-Myr-old sub-Neptune HD235088 b (TOI-1430 b) with CARMENES
• THE BANANA PROJECT. VI. Close double stars are well aligned with noticeable exceptions; results from an ensemble study using apsidal motion and Rossiter-McLaughlin measurements
• TOI-1859b: A 64-Day Warm Jupiter on an Eccentric and Misaligned Orbit
• XO-2b: a Prograde Planet with a Negligible Eccentricity, and an Additional Radial Velocity Variation
• Two warm, low-density sub-Jovian planets orbiting bright stars in K2 campaigns 13 and 14
• HIP 33609 b: An Eccentric Brown Dwarf Transiting a V=7.3 Rapidly Rotating B-Star
• The Spin-Orbit Misalignment of TOI-1842b: The First Measurement of the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect for a Warm Sub-Saturn around a Massive Star
• HATS-13b and HATS-14b: two transiting hot Jupiters from the HATSouth survey
• Rapid rotators revisited: absolute dimensions of KOI-13
• Stellar obliquities and magnetic activities of Planet-Hosting Stars and Eclipsing Binaries based on Transit Chord Correlation
• Can we detect the stellar differential rotation of WASP-7 through theRossiter-McLaughlin observations?
• Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT 'EM) Survey. II. Discovery of a Failed Hot Jupiter on a 2.7 Year, Highly Eccentric Orbit
• KELT-18b: Puffy Planet, Hot Host, Probably Perturbed
• Bayesian hierarchical inference of asteroseismic inclination angles
• A decade of radial-velocity monitoring of Vega and new limits on the presence of planets
• The PFS view of TOI-677 b: A spin-orbit aligned warm Jupiter in a dynamically hot system
• EPIC 246851721 b: A Tropical Jupiter Transiting a Rapidly Rotating Star in a Well-Aligned Orbit
• Post-Newtonian effects on some characteristic timescales of transiting exoplanets
• XO-7 b: A transiting hot Jupiter with a massive companion on a wide orbit
• Independent discovery and refined parameters of the transiting exoplanet HAT-P-14b
• Revisiting the Architecture of the KOI-89 System
• Nature vs. nurture: a Bayesian framework for assessing apparent correlations between planetary orbital properties and stellar ages
• Assessing the spin-orbit obliquity of low-mass planets in the breaking the chain formation model: A story of misalignment
• The Aligned Orbit of a Hot Jupiter around the M Dwarf TOI-4201
• Strong NUV Refractory Absorption and Dissociated Water in the Hubble Transmission Spectrum of the Ultra Hot Jupiter KELT-20 b
• Evidence for Primordial Alignment II: Insights from Stellar Obliquity Measurements for Hot Jupiters in Compact Multiplanet Systems
• Obliquities of Exoplanet Host Stars from Precise Distances and Stellar Angular Diameters
• Planet Across Space and Time (PAST). VII. The origin and tidal evolution of hot Jupiters constrained by a broken age-frequency relation
• The low density, hot Jupiter TOI-640 b is on a polar orbit
• Stellar evolution and modelling stars
• Bifurcated Evolutionary Pathways in Multi-planet Systems Driven by Misaligned Protoplanetary Disks
• The long history of the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect and its recent applications
• TOI-1259Ab: A Warm Jupiter Orbiting a K-dwarf White-Dwarf Binary is on a Well-aligned Orbit
• The impact of faculae on the radius determination of exoplanets: The case of the M-star GJ1214
• Nature vs. Nurture: Investigating the Effects of Measurement Uncertainties in the Assessment of Potential Trends Between Planetary and Stellar Properties
• Constraints on the Obliquities of Kepler Planet-Hosting Stars
• Evidence for the Late Arrival of Hot Jupiters in Systems with High Host-star Obliquities
• The Influence of General Relativity on the Spins of Celestial Bodies in Inclined Orbits
• A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct $e$-$\lambda$ Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes