Exoplanetary Spin-Orbit Alignment: Results from the Ensemble of Rossiter-McLaughlin Observations

Abstract

One possible diagnostic of planet formation, orbital migration, and tidal evolution is the angle psi between a planet's orbital axis and the spin axis of its parent star. In general, psi cannot be measured, but for transiting planets one can measure the angle lambda between the sky projections of the two axes via the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect. Here, we show how to combine measurements of lambda in different systems to derive statistical constraints on psi. We apply the method to 11 published measurements of lambda, using two different single-parameter distributions to describe the ensemble. First, assuming a Rayleigh distribution (or more precisely, a Fisher distribution on a sphere), we find that the peak value is less than 22 degrees with 95% confidence. Second, assuming a fraction f of the orbits have random orientations relative to the stars, and the remaining fraction (1-f) are perfectly aligned, we find f<0.36 with 95% confidence. This latter model fits the data better than the Rayleigh distribution, mainly because the XO-3 system was found to be strongly misaligned while the other 10 systems are consistent with perfect alignment. If the XO-3 result proves robust, then our results may be interpreted as evidence for two distinct modes of planet migration.

Accepted to ApJ; 13 pages, 8 figures

References in corpus (21)

• Shrinking binary and planetary orbits by Kozai cycles with tidal friction
• Dynamical Outcomes of Planet-Planet Scattering
• Dynamical Origin of Extrasolar Planet Eccentricity Distribution
• Formation of Hot Planets by a combination of planet scattering, tidal circularization, and Kozai mechanism
• Tidal Evolution of Close-in Extra-Solar Planets
• Prospects for the Characterization and Confirmation of Transiting Exoplanets via the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect
• Misaligned spin-orbit in the XO-3 planetary system?
• Hot Jupiters in binary star systems
• The Transit Light Curve Project. V. System Parameters and Stellar Rotation Period of HD 189733
• Falling Transiting Extrasolar Giant Planets
• Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Alignment in the Exoplanetary System HD 189733
• Measurement of the Rossiter--McLaughlin Effect in the Transiting Exoplanetary System TrES-1
• Cassini States with Dissipation: Why Obliquity Tides Cannot Inflate Hot Jupiters
• The Rotation Period of the Planet-Hosting Star HD 189733
• WASP-14b: 7.3 Mj transiting planet in an eccentric orbit
• Spin-Orbit Alignment for the Eccentric Exoplanet HD 147506b
• Refined parameters and spectroscopic transit of the super-massive planet HD147506b
• A Possible Spin-Orbit Misalignment in the Transiting Eccentric Planet HD 17156b
• The Prograde Orbit of Exoplanet TrES-2b
• Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Angle of Exoplanet HAT-P-1b
• The Spin-Orbit Alignment of the HD17156 Transiting Eccentric Planetary System

Cited by in corpus (191)

• Architecture and Dynamics of Kepler's Candidate Multiple Transiting Planet Systems
• Hot Stars with Hot Jupiters Have High Obliquities
• Obliquities of Hot Jupiter host stars: Evidence for tidal interactions and primordial misalignments
• Origins of Hot Jupiters
• Spin-orbit angle measurements for six southern transiting planets; New insights into the dynamical origins of hot Jupiters
• Secular Chaos and the Production of Hot Jupiters
• Stellar Spin-Orbit Misalignment in a Multiplanet System
• Homogeneous studies of transiting extrasolar planets. III. Additional planets and stellar models
• On the Formation of Hot Jupiters in Stellar Binaries
• Evidence of Possible Spin-Orbit Misalignment Along the Line of Sight in Transiting Exoplanet Systems
• About 30% of Sun-like Stars Have Kepler-like Planetary Systems: A Study of their Intrinsic Architecture
• Multiple-Planet Scattering and the Origin of Hot Jupiters
• The Exoplanet Orbit Database II: Updates to exoplanets.org
• The coronal X-ray - age relation and its implications for the evaporation of exoplanets
• Tidal Evolution of Close-in Planets
• Giant planets orbiting metal-rich stars show signatures of planet-planet interactions
• HAT-P-7: A Retrograde or Polar Orbit, and a Third Body
• Alignment of the stellar spin with the orbits of a three-planet system
• WASP-17b: an ultra-low density planet in a probable retrograde orbit
• WASP-121 b: a hot Jupiter in a polar orbit and close to tidal disruption
• The physical properties of extrasolar planets
• Hot Jupiters from Coplanar High-eccentricity Migration
• Stellar obliquities in exoplanetary systems
• Steady-state planet migration by the Kozai-Lidov mechanism in stellar binaries
• Starspots and spin-orbit alignment in the WASP-4 exoplanetary system
• Improved Modeling of the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect for Transiting Exoplanets
• Asteroseismic determination of obliquities of the exoplanet systems Kepler-50 and Kepler-65
• The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect reloaded: Probing the 3D spin-orbit geometry, differential stellar rotation, and the spatially-resolved stellar spectrum of star-planet systems
• Low stellar obliquities in compact multiplanet systems
• WASP-8b: a retrograde transiting planet in a multiple system
• Kepler-63b: A Giant Planet in a Polar Orbit around a Young Sun-like Star
• HAT-P-12b: A Low-Density Sub-Saturn Mass Planet Transiting a Metal-Poor K Dwarf
• The Kepler Dichotomy among the M Dwarfs: Half of Systems Contain Five or More Coplanar Planets
• Photometric Amplitude Distribution of Stellar Rotation of Kepler KOIs-Indication for Spin-Orbit Alignment of Cool Stars and High Obliquity for Hot Stars
• Warm Jupiters from secular planet-planet interactions
• First Evidence of a Retrograde Orbit of Transiting Exoplanet HAT-P-7b
• Classification of magnetized star--planet interactions: bow shocks, tails, and inspiraling flows
• Heartbeat Stars, Tidally Excited Oscillations, and Resonance Locking
• Obliquities of Kepler Stars: Comparison of Single- and Multiple-Transit Systems
• Inflating and Deflating Hot Jupiters: Coupled Tidal and Thermal Evolution of Known Transiting Planets
• Magnetically Controlled Outflows from Hot Jupiters
• On the Spin-Orbit Misalignment of the XO-3 Exoplanetary System
• The retrograde orbit of the HAT-P-6b exoplanet
• Architectures of Exoplanetary Systems. I: A Clustered Forward Model for Exoplanetary Systems around Kepler's FGK Stars
• Transits and starspots in the WASP-19 planetary system
• The Turbulent Origin of Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Planetary Systems
• Calibration of Equilibrium Tide Theory for Extrasolar Planet Systems II
• The Starspots of HAT-P-11: Evidence for a Solar-like Dynamo
• On the orbit of the short-period exoplanet WASP-19b
• Observation of the full 12-hour-long transit of the exoplanet HD80606b. Warm-Spitzer photometry and SOPHIE spectroscopy
• Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Misalignment of KOI-13.01 from its Gravity-Darkened Kepler Transit Lightcurve
• Discovery and Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect of Exoplanet Kepler-8b
• Discerning Exoplanet Migration Models Using Spin-Orbit Measurements
• The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect in Exoplanet Research
• Measurements of Stellar Inclinations for Kepler Planet Candidates
• A Preponderance of Perpendicular Planets
• A paucity of proto-hot Jupiters on super-eccentric orbits
• Neptune's wild days: constraints from the eccentricity distribution of the classical Kuiper Belt
• The determination of planetary structure in tidally relaxed inclined systems
• Rossiter--McLaughlin models and their effect on estimates of stellar rotation, illustrated using six WASP systems
• The Transit Ingress and the Tilted Orbit of the Extraordinarily Eccentric Exoplanet HD 80606b
• On the tidal origin of hot Jupiter stellar obliquity trends
• Hot Jupiters and the evolution of stellar angular momentum
• Tidal Dissipation and Obliquity Evolution in Hot Jupiter Systems
• Orbital Orientations of Exoplanets: HAT-P-4b is Prograde and HAT-P-14b is Retrograde
• TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) VI: an 11 Myr giant planet transiting a very low-mass star in Lower Centaurus Crux
• HAT-P-17b,c: A Transiting, Eccentric, Hot Saturn and a Long-period, Cold Jupiter
• HAT-P-57b: A Short-Period Giant Planet Transiting A Bright Rapidly Rotating A8V Star Confirmed Via Doppler Tomography
• HAT-P-30b: A transiting hot Jupiter on a highly oblique orbit
• Origins of Hot Jupiters from the Stellar Obliquity Distribution
• Spin-orbit alignment of exoplanet systems: ensemble analysis using asteroseismology
• On the alignment of debris disks and their host stars' rotation axis -implications for spin-orbit misalignment in exoplanetary systems
• Early Excitation of Spin-Orbit Misalignments in Close-in Planetary Systems
• WASP-12b and HAT-P-8b are Members of Triple Star Systems
• Parameter estimation on gravitational waves from multiple coalescing binaries
• Uncovering Circumbinary Planetary Architectural Properties from Selection Biases
• A disk-driven resonance as the origin of high inclinations of close-in planets
• Characterization of the KOI-94 System with Transit Timing Variation Analysis: Implication for the Planet-Planet Eclipse
• Transits and starspots in the WASP-6 planetary system
• HATS-70b: A 13 Mjup brown dwarf transiting an A star
• A possible architecture of the planetary system HR 8799
• SOAP-T: A tool to study the light-curve and radial velocity of a system with a transiting planet and a rotating spotted star
• Rotation Periods, Inclinations, and Obliquities of Cool Stars Hosting Directly Imaged Substellar Companions: Spin-Orbit Misalignments are Common
• The spin-orbit angles of the transiting exoplanets WASP-1b, WASP-24b, WASP-38b and HAT-P-8b from Rossiter-McLaughlin observations
• Effects of Unseen Additional Planetary Perturbers on Compact Extrasolar Planetary Systems
• Formation of Hot Jupiters through Secular Chaos and Dynamical Tides
• Asteroseismic inference on the spin-orbit misalignment and stellar parameters of HAT-P-7
• Secular chaos and its application to Mercury, hot Jupiters, and the organization of planetary systems
• Spin-Orbit Angles of Kepler-13Ab and HAT-P-7b from Gravity-Darkened Transit Light Curves
• The Time Dependence of hot Jupiters' Orbital Inclinations
• Are Tidal Effects Responsible for Exoplanetary Spin-Orbit Alignment?
• A Prograde, Low-Inclination Orbit for the Very Hot Jupiter WASP-3b
• Spin-Orbit angle distribution and the origin of (mis)aligned hot Jupiters
• Transit Probabilities for Stars With Stellar Inclination Constraints
• The Photoeccentric Effect and Proto-Hot Jupiters II. KOI-1474.01, a candidate eccentric planet perturbed by an unseen companion
• High precision transit observations of the exoplanet WASP-13b with the RISE instrument
• On using the beaming effect to measure spin-orbit alignment in stellar binaries with Sun-like components
• The Dynamics of the Multi-planet System Orbiting Kepler-56
• Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect Measurements for WASP-16, WASP-25 and WASP-31
• The Eccentricity Distribution of Short-Period Planet Candidates Detected by Kepler in Occultation
• WASP-117b: a 10-day-period Saturn in an eccentric and misaligned orbit
• A hot Jupiter for breakfast? --- Early stellar ingestion of planets may be common
• Improved Measurement of the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect in the Exoplanetary System HD 17156
• Tau Boo b: Hunting for reflected starlight
• Accurate characterization of the stellar and orbital parameters of the exoplanetary system WASP-33 b from orbital dynamics
• DREAM II. The spin-orbit angle distribution of close-in exoplanets under the lens of tides
• Using the Inclinations of Kepler Systems to Prioritize New Titius-Bode-Based Exoplanet Predictions
• Earth-like Habitats in Planetary Systems
• Ponderings on the Possible Preponderance of Perpendicular Planets
• Time variation of Kepler transits induced by stellar spots - a way to distinguish between prograde and retrograde motion. II. Application to KOIs
• Outer-planet scattering can gently tilt an inner planetary system
• The spin-orbit angle of the transiting hot jupiter CoRoT-1b
• Confirmation of a Retrograde Orbit for Exoplanet WASP-17b
• The gravitational interaction between planets on inclined orbits and protoplanetary disks as the origin of primordial spin--orbit misalignments
• Hot Stars With Kepler Planets Have High Obliquities
• An Aligned Orbit for the Young Planet V1298 Tau b
• Too Little, Too Late: How the Tidal Evolution of Hot Jupiters affects Transit Surveys of Clusters
• The Young Substellar Companion ROXs 12 B: Near-Infrared Spectrum, System Architecture, and Spin-Orbit Misalignment
• Oscillations of Relative Inclination Angles in Compact Extrasolar Planetary Systems
• $\text{PyTranSpot}$ - A tool for multiband light curve modeling of planetary transits and stellar spots
• Transits of Known Planets Orbiting a Naked-Eye Star
• Alignment of Protostars and Circumstellar Disks During the Embedded Phase
• Star - Planet - Debris Disk Alignment in the HD 82943 system: Is planetary system coplanarity actually the norm?
• Statistical Trends in the Obliquity Distribution of Exoplanet Systems
• The spin-orbit alignment of the transiting exoplanet WASP-3b from Rossiter-McLaughlin observations
• Long Period Jovian Tilts the Orbits of Two sub-Neptunes Relative to Stellar Spin Axis in Kepler-129
• Mutual Inclination Excitation by Stellar Oblateness
• The relevance of prior inclination determination for direct imaging of Earth-like planets
• Features of Gaia DR3 Spectroscopic Binaries I. Tidal circularization of Main-Sequence Stars
• Deriving stellar inclination of slow rotators using stellar activity
• Spin-orbit alignments for Three Transiting Hot Jupiters: WASP-103b, WASP-87b, & WASP-66b
• The well-aligned orbit of WASP-84b: evidence for disc migration
• Planets on the Edge
• The spin-orbit alignment of visual binaries
• Revised Orbit and Transit Exclusion for HD 114762b
• Planet-Induced Stellar Pulsations in HAT-P-2's Eccentric System
• Polarization in exoplanetary systems caused by transits, grazing transits, and starspots
• Exterior Companions to Hot Jupiters Orbiting Cool Stars are Coplanar
• Stellar Obliquities & Planetary Alignments (SOPA) I. Spin-Orbit measurements of Three Transiting Hot Jupiters: WASP-72b, WASP-100b, & WASP-109b
• Influence of stellar structure, evolution and rotation on the tidal damping of exoplanetary spin-orbit angles
• An eccentric Brown Dwarf eclipsing an M dwarf
• THE BANANA PROJECT. VI. Close double stars are well aligned with noticeable exceptions; results from an ensemble study using apsidal motion and Rossiter-McLaughlin measurements
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. XXXI. The WASP-33 system revisited with HARPS-N
• Orbital alignment of the eccentric warm Jupiter TOI-677 b
• Evidence for Primordial Alignment: Insights from Stellar Obliquity Measurements for Compact Sub-Saturn Systems
• Probing atmospheric escape through metastable He I triplet lines in 15 exoplanets observed with SPIRou
• Automated approach to measure stellar inclinations: validation through large-scale measurements on the red giant branch
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission XXVII. CoRoT-28b, a planet orbiting an evolved star, and CoRoT-29b, a planet showing an asymmetric transit
• Modeling the Formation of the Family of the Dwarf Planet Haumea
• Forming Different Planetary Architectures . I . Formation Efficiency of Hot Jupites from High-eccentricity Mechanisms
• Leaning Sideways: VHS 1256-1257 b is a Super-Jupiter with a Uranus-like Obliquity
• Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT 'EM) Survey. II. Discovery of a Failed Hot Jupiter on a 2.7 Year, Highly Eccentric Orbit
• Can we detect the stellar differential rotation of WASP-7 through theRossiter-McLaughlin observations?
• Characterising exo-ringsystems around fast-rotating stars using the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect
• Radial velocity observations of the 2015 Mar 20 eclipse - A benchmark Rossiter-McLaughlin curve with zero free parameters
• Activity time series of old stars from late F to early K. V. Effect on exoplanet detectability with high-precision astrometry
• Bayesian hierarchical inference of asteroseismic inclination angles
• Creating retrogradely orbiting planets by prograde stellar fly-bys
• Cosmic evolution of black hole-spin and galaxy orientations: clues from the NewHorizon and Galactica simulations
• The Dynamics of Tightly-packed Planetary Systems in the Presence of an Outer Planet: case studies using Kepler-11 and Kepler-90
• Synergies between Asteroseismology and Exoplanetary Science
• Rossiter-McLaughlin detection of the 9-month period transiting exoplanet HIP41378 d
• The PFS view of TOI-677 b: A spin-orbit aligned warm Jupiter in a dynamically hot system
• Tracing the formation and migration history: molecular signatures in the atmosphere of misaligned hot Jupiter WASP-94Ab using JWST NIRSpec/G395H
• KOI-3890: A high mass-ratio asteroseismic red-giant$+$M-dwarf eclipsing binary undergoing heartbeat tidal interactions
• Gravity darkening and tidally perturbed stellar pulsation in the misaligned exoplanet system WASP-33
• Revisiting Orbital Evolution in HAT-P-2 b and Confirmation of HAT-P-2 c
• A possible misaligned orbit for the young planet AU Mic c
• Independent discovery and refined parameters of the transiting exoplanet HAT-P-14b
• Gap formation by inclined massive planets in locally isothermal three-dimensional discs
• The distribution of mutual inclinations arising from the stellar quadrupole moment
• An ESPRESSO view of HD 189733 system. Broadband transmission spectrum, differential rotation, and system architecture
• HD 83443c: A highly eccentric giant planet on a 22-year orbit
• Prospects for detecting the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect of Earth-like planets: the test case of TRAPPIST-1b and c
• The Earth transiting the Sun as seen from Jupiter's moons: detection of an inverse Rossiter-McLaughlin effect produced by the Opposition Surge of the icy Europa
• Multi-band, Multi-epoch Photometry of the Spot-crossing System TOI-3884: Refined System Geometry and Spot Properties
• Assessing the spin-orbit obliquity of low-mass planets in the breaking the chain formation model: A story of misalignment
• Discovery of a substellar companion in the TESS light curve of the $\delta$ Scuti/$\gamma$ Doradus hybrid pulsator HD 31221
• TOI-858 B b: A hot Jupiter on a polar orbit in a loose binary
• The star HIP 41378 potentially misaligned with its cohort of long-period planets
• The low density, hot Jupiter TOI-640 b is on a polar orbit
• Accretion of Rocky Planets by Hot Jupiters
• Accretion of Planetary Material onto Host Stars
• Dynamical Architectures of S-type Transiting Planets in Binaries II: A Dichotomy in Orbital Alignment of Small Planets in Close Binary Systems
• Modeling Multi-Wavelength Stellar Astrometry. II. Determining Absolute Inclinations, Gravity Darkening Coefficients, and Spot Parameters of Single Stars with SIM Lite
• CHEOPS observations confirm nodal precession in the WASP-33 system
• Early evidence for isotropic planetary obliquities in young super-Jupiter systems
• Evidence for the Late Arrival of Hot Jupiters in Systems with High Host-star Obliquities
• Orbital alignment of HD 332231 b
• Cold giant discoveries from a joint radial-velocity and astrometry framework
• A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct $e$-$\lambda$ Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes