Are Tidal Effects Responsible for Exoplanetary Spin-Orbit Alignment?
arXiv:1511.05570 · doi:10.3847/0004-637X/818/1/5
Abstract
The obliquities of planet-hosting stars are clues about the formation of planetary systems. Previous observations led to the hypothesis that for close-in giant planets, spin-orbit alignment is enforced by tidal interactions. Here, we examine two problems with this hypothesis. First, Mazeh and coworkers recently used a new technique -- based on the amplitude of starspot-induced photometric variability -- to conclude that spin-orbit alignment is common even for relatively long-period planets, which would not be expected if tides were responsible. We re-examine the data and find a statistically significant correlation between photometric variability and planetary orbital period that is qualitatively consistent with tidal interactions. However it is still difficult to explain quantitatively, as it would require tides to be effective for periods as long as tens of days. Second, Rogers and Lin argued against a particular theory for tidal re-alignment by showing that initially retrograde systems would fail to be re-aligned, in contradiction with the observed prevalence of prograde systems. We investigate a simple model that overcomes this problem by taking into account the dissipation of inertial waves and the equilibrium tide, as well as magnetic braking. We identify a region of parameter space where re-alignment can be achieved, but it only works for close-in giant planets, and requires some fine tuning. Thus, while we find both problems to be more nuanced than they first appeared, the tidal model still has serious shortcomings.
arXiv comment12 pages, 9 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ
References in corpus (52)
- Shrinking binary and planetary orbits by Kozai cycles with tidal friction
- Dynamical Outcomes of Planet-Planet Scattering
- The Occurrence and Architecture of Exoplanetary Systems
- The NASA Exoplanet Archive: Data and Tools for Exoplanet Research
- Hot Stars with Hot Jupiters Have High Obliquities
- Rotation Periods of 34,030 Kepler Main-Sequence Stars: The Full Autocorrelation Sample
- Obliquities of Hot Jupiter host stars: Evidence for tidal interactions and primordial misalignments
- Hot Jupiters from Secular Planet--Planet Interactions
- Formation of Hot Planets by a combination of planet scattering, tidal circularization, and Kozai mechanism
- Revised Stellar Properties of Kepler Targets for the Quarter 1-16 Transit Detection Run
- Spin-orbit angle measurements for six southern transiting planets; New insights into the dynamical origins of hot Jupiters
- Tidal dissipation in stars and giant planets
- Secular Chaos and the Production of Hot Jupiters
- Tidal dissipation in rotating solar-type stars
- Chaotic star formation and the alignment of stellar rotation with disc and planetary orbital axes
- Stellar Spin-Orbit Misalignment in a Multiplanet System
- On the Formation of Hot Jupiters in Stellar Binaries
- Exoplanetary Spin-Orbit Alignment: Results from the Ensemble of Rossiter-McLaughlin Observations
- Evidence of Possible Spin-Orbit Misalignment Along the Line of Sight in Transiting Exoplanet Systems
- Internal Gravity Waves in Massive Stars: Angular Momentum Transport
- Stellar Rotation Periods of the Kepler Objects of Interest: A Dearth of Close-in Planets around Fast Rotators
- Misaligned spin-orbit in the XO-3 planetary system?
- Evolution of Spin Direction of Accreting Magnetic Protostars and Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Exoplanetary Systems
- Eccentricity growth and orbit flip in coplanar hierarchical three body systems
- Calibrating Gyrochronology using Kepler Asteroseismic targets
- Tidal Dissipation in Planet-Hosting Stars: Damping of Spin-Orbit Misalignment and Survival of Hot Jupiters
- Tides in rotating barotropic fluid bodies: the contribution of inertial waves and the role of internal structure
- Photometric Amplitude Distribution of Stellar Rotation of Kepler KOIs-Indication for Spin-Orbit Alignment of Cool Stars and High Obliquity for Hot Stars
- First Evidence of a Retrograde Orbit of Transiting Exoplanet HAT-P-7b
- Empirical evidence for tidal evolution in transiting planetary systems
- Internal Gravity Waves Modulate the Apparent Misalignment of Exoplanets around Hot Stars
- Obliquities of Kepler Stars: Comparison of Single- and Multiple-Transit Systems
- A natural formation scenario for misaligned and short-period eccentric extrasolar planets
- The retrograde orbit of the HAT-P-6b exoplanet
- On the Spin-Orbit Misalignment of the XO-3 Exoplanetary System
- The Turbulent Origin of Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Planetary Systems
- Scattering outcomes of close-in planets: constraints on planet migration
- Nonlinear evolution of tidally forced inertial waves in rotating fluid bodies
- Evolution of Spin Direction of Accreting Magnetic Protostars and Spin-Orbit Misalignment in Exoplanetary Systems: II. Warped Discs
- Wave attractors and the asymptotic dissipation rate of tidal disturbances
- On the tidal origin of hot Jupiter stellar obliquity trends
- Cross Sections for Planetary Systems Interacting with Passing Stars and Binaries
- Tidal Dissipation and Obliquity Evolution in Hot Jupiter Systems
- Early Excitation of Spin-Orbit Misalignments in Close-in Planetary Systems
- Why is there a Dearth of Close-In Planets around Fast-Rotating stars?
- Tidal evolution of the spin-orbit angle in exoplanetary systems
- Magnetic Origins of the Stellar Mass-Obliquity Correlation in Planetary Systems
- On the relationship between the size and surface coverage of starspots on magnetically active low-mass stars
- On the Tidal Dissipation of Obliquity
- The Dynamics of the Multi-planet System Orbiting Kepler-56
- A hot Jupiter for breakfast? --- Early stellar ingestion of planets may be common
- Further Observations of the Tilted Planet XO-3: A New Determination of Spin-Orbit Misalignment, and Limits on Differential Rotation
Cited by in corpus (42)
- Origins of Hot Jupiters
- Stellar obliquities in exoplanetary systems
- The Planet Nine Hypothesis
- Empirical Tidal Dissipation in Exoplanet Hosts From Tidal Spin-Up
- Spin-orbit Misalignment as a Driver of the Kepler Dichotomy
- Uncovering Circumbinary Planetary Architectural Properties from Selection Biases
- The Kepler Dichotomy in Planetary Disks: Linking Kepler Observables to Simulations of Late-Stage Planet Formation
- The Oblique Orbit of WASP-107b from K2 Photometry
- Effects of Unseen Additional Planetary Perturbers on Compact Extrasolar Planetary Systems
- Planet Formation in Disks with Inclined Binary Companions: Can Primordial Spin-Orbit Misalignment be Produced?
- TOI-677 b: A Warm Jupiter (P=11.2d) on an eccentric orbit transiting a late F-type star
- WASP-167b/KELT-13b: Joint discovery of a hot Jupiter transiting a rapidly-rotating F1V star
- Stellar ages, masses and radii from asteroseismic modeling are robust to systematic errors in spectroscopy
- Tidal interactions in spin-orbit misaligned systems
- Nonlinear tides in a homogeneous rotating planet or star: global simulations of the elliptical instability
- Effects of Disk Warping on the Inclination Evolution of Star-Disk-Binary Systems
- Warm Jupiters in TESS Full-Frame Images: A Catalog and Observed Eccentricity Distribution for Year 1
- Obliquities of Exoplanet Host Stars: 19 New and Updated Measurements, and Trends in the Sample of 205 Measurements
- A Multi-Planet System Transiting the = 9 Rapidly Rotating F-Star HD 106315
- A warm Jupiter transiting an M dwarf: A TESS single transit event confirmed with the Habitable-zone Planet Finder
- The gravitational interaction between planets on inclined orbits and protoplanetary disks as the origin of primordial spin--orbit misalignments
- Tidal erasure of stellar obliquities constrains the timing of hot Jupiter formation
- Spin-Orbit Misalignments of Three Jovian Planets via Doppler Tomography
- On turbulence driven by axial precession and tidal evolution of the spin-orbit angle of close-in giant planets
- EPIC247098361b: a transiting warm Saturn on an eccentric days orbit around a star
- Statistical Trends in the Obliquity Distribution of Exoplanet Systems
- Zodiacal Exoplanets in Time. XI. The Orbit and Radiation Environment of the Young M Dwarf-Hosted Planet K2-25b
- On a Possible Solution to the Tidal Realignment Problem for Hot Jupiters
- Evidence for Primordial Alignment: Insights from Stellar Obliquity Measurements for Compact Sub-Saturn Systems
- Two warm, low-density sub-Jovian planets orbiting bright stars in K2 campaigns 13 and 14
- The resilience of Kepler systems to stellar obliquity
- A Secular Resonant Origin for the Loneliness of Hot Jupiters
- Prospects from TESS and Gaia to constrain the flatness of planetary systems
- Three low-mass companions around aged stars discovered by TESS
- EPIC 246851721 b: A Tropical Jupiter Transiting a Rapidly Rotating Star in a Well-Aligned Orbit
- Significant mutual inclinations between the stellar spin and the orbits of both planets in the HAT-P-11 system
- Characterization of seven transiting systems including four warm Jupiters from SOPHIE and TESS
- A highly mutually-inclined, compact warm-Jupiter system KOI-984 ?
- Revisiting the Full Sets of Orbital Parameters for the XO-3 System: No evidence for Temporal Variation of the Spin-Orbit Angle
- Obliquities of Exoplanet Host Stars from Precise Distances and Stellar Angular Diameters
- A Homogeneous Catalog of Rossiter-McLaughlin Systems: Distinct - Trends in Three Gas-Giant Mass Regimes
- Evidence for the Late Arrival of Hot Jupiters in Systems with High Host-star Obliquities