Intrinsic ripples in graphene
arXiv:0704.1793 · doi:10.1038/nmat2011
Abstract
The stability of two-dimensional (2D) layers and membranes is subject of a long standing theoretical debate. According to the so called Mermin-Wagner theorem, long wavelength fluctuations destroy the long-range order for 2D crystals. Similarly, 2D membranes embedded in a 3D space have a tendency to be crumpled. These dangerous fluctuations can, however, be suppressed by anharmonic coupling between bending and stretching modes making that a two-dimensional membrane can exist but should present strong height fluctuations. The discovery of graphene, the first truly 2D crystal and the recent experimental observation of ripples in freely hanging graphene makes these issues especially important. Beside the academic interest, understanding the mechanisms of stability of graphene is crucial for understanding electronic transport in this material that is attracting so much interest for its unusual Dirac spectrum and electronic properties. Here we address the nature of these height fluctuations by means of straightforward atomistic Monte Carlo simulations based on a very accurate many-body interatomic potential for carbon. We find that ripples spontaneously appear due to thermal fluctuations with a size distribution peaked around 70 Åwhich is compatible with experimental findings (50-100 Å) but not with the current understanding of stability of flexible membranes. This unexpected result seems to be due to the multiplicity of chemical bonding in carbon.
14 pages, 6 figures
References in corpus (6)
- Electric Field Effect in Atomically Thin Carbon Films
- Two Dimensional Atomic Crystals
- The structure of suspended graphene sheets
- Strong suppression of weak (anti)localization in graphene
- Electron scattering on microscopic corrugations in graphene
- Anharmonic magnetic deformation of self-assembled molecular nanocapsules
Cited by in corpus (338)
- The electronic properties of graphene
- Electronic transport in two dimensional graphene
- Monolayer honeycomb structures of group IV elements and III-V binary compounds
- Hydrogen on graphene: Electronic structure, total energy, structural distortions, and magnetism from first-principles calculations
- Macroscopic graphene membranes and their extraordinary stiffness
- Band-structure topologies of graphene: spin-orbit coupling effects from first principles
- Structure and electronic transport in graphene wrinkles
- Electronic and optical properties of strained graphene and other strained 2D materials: a review
- Reversible Basal Plane Hydrogenation of Graphene
- Electron scattering on microscopic corrugations in graphene
- Finite temperature lattice properties of graphene beyond the quasiharmonic approximation
- High-capacity hydrogen storage by metallized graphene
- Mechanical systems in the quantum regime
- Evidence of the role of contacts on the observed electron-hole asymmetry in graphene
- Subjecting a graphene monolayer to tension and compression
- Elastic Bending Modulus of Monolayer Graphene
- Phononic thermal properties of two-dimensional materials
- Intrinsic and extrinsic corrugation of monolayer graphene deposited on SiO2
- Imaging mechanical vibrations in suspended graphene sheets
- Midgap states and charge inhomogeneities in corrugated graphene
- Limits on gas impermeability of graphene
- Force and heat current formulas for many-body potentials in molecular dynamics simulation with applications to thermal conductivity calculations
- Compression Behavior of Single-layer Graphene
- Thermal and Thermoelectric Properties of Graphene
- Electronic properties of graphene: a perspective from scanning tunneling microscopy and magneto-transport
- Quantum Manifestations of Graphene Edge Stress and Edge Instability: A First-Principles Study
- The role of contact resistance in graphene field-effect devices
- The Effect of Intrinsic Crumpling on the Mechanics of Free-Standing Graphene
- Breakdown of continuum mechanics for nanometer-wavelength rippling of graphene
- Spatially resolved spectroscopy of monolayer graphene on SiO2
- Strained graphene: tight-binding and density functional calculations
- Determination of the Bending Rigidity of Graphene via Electrostatic Actuation of Buckled Membranes
- One nanometer thin carbon nanosheets with tunable conductivity and stiffness
- Melting temperature of graphene
- Water-Gated Charge Doping of Graphene Induced by Mica Substrates
- Fast diffusion of water nanodroplets on graphene
- Pseudomagnetic fields and ballistic transport in a suspended graphene sheet
- Scaling Properties of Flexible Membranes from Atomistic Simulations: Application to Graphene
- Tearing Graphene Sheets From Adhesive Substrates Produces Tapered Nanoribbons
- Effects of Mismatch Strain and Substrate Surface Corrugation on Morphology of Supported Monolayer Graphene
- Disorder and Electronic Transport in Graphene
- Strain superlattices and macroscale suspension of Graphene induced by corrugated substrates
- Melting of graphene: from two to one dimension
- Probing charge scattering mechanisms in suspended graphene by varying its dielectric environment
- Atomistic simulations of structural and thermodynamic properties of bilayer graphene
- Graphene via large N I: Renormalization
- Formation and control of wrinkles in graphene by the wedging transfer method
- Creating One-dimensional Nanoscale Periodic Ripples in a Continuous Mosaic Graphene Monolayer
- Scaling behavior and strain dependence of in-plane elastic properties of graphene
- First-principles study of graphene edge properties and flake shapes
- Anisotropic Ripple Deformation in Phosphorene
- Midgap states in corrugated graphene: Ab-initio calculations and effective field theory
- Bending modes, anharmonic effects and thermal expansion coefficient in single layer and multilayer graphene
- Thermal properties of fluorinated graphene
- Suppression of anharmonicities in crystalline membranes by external strain
- Spectro-microscopy of single and multi-layer graphene supported by a weakly interacting substrate
- Phonons of graphene and graphitic materials derived from the empirical potential LCBOPII
- Graphene as a Prototype Crystalline Membrane
- Diffusive Charge Transport in Graphene on SiO2
- Thermomechanical properties of a single hexagonal boron nitride sheet
- Auxetic Nanomaterials: Recent Progress and Future Development
- Proton transport through nanoscale corrugations in two-dimensional crystals
- Substrate-regulated morphology of graphene
- Formation of atomic nanoclusters on graphene sheets
- Graphene nano ribbons subjected to axial stress
- Structure of twisted and buckled bilayer graphene
- Electron density distribution and screening in rippled graphene sheets
- Response of thermalized ribbons to pulling and bending
- Unusual ultralow frequency fluctuations in freestanding graphene
- Dislocations and torsion in graphene and related systems
- Tuning the ferro- to para-electric transition temperature and dipole orientation of group-IV monochalcogenide monolayers
- Nonlinear Damping in Graphene Resonators
- Hierarchy of Graphene Wrinkles Induced by Thermal Strain Engineering
- Self-Consistent Screening Approximation for Flexible Membranes: Application to Graphene
- Electron-induced rippling in graphene
- Large-scale Graphitic Thin Films Synthesized on Ni and Transferred to Insulators: Structural and Electronic Properties
- Graphene on Ru(0001): A corrugated and chiral structure
- Phonon mediated tunneling into graphene
- Hidden area and mechanical nonlinearities in freestanding graphene
- Dynamics of 2D Material Membranes
- Gauge fields, ripples and wrinkles in graphene layers
- Rippling of Graphene
- Dislocations in graphene
- sp-Electron Magnetic Clusters with a Large Spin in Graphene
- Weyl-Gauge Symmetry of Graphene
- Curved Magnetism in CrI
- Periodic ripples in suspended graphene
- Elastic constants of graphene: Comparison of empirical potentials and DFT calculations
- Structure, stability and defects of single layer h-BN in comparison to graphene
- Large Electronic Anisotropy and Enhanced Chemical Activity of Highly Rippled Phosphorene
- Pinning of a two-dimensional membrane on top of a patterned substrate: the case of graphene
- Thermal fluctuations of free standing graphene
- Surface acoustic wave propagation in monolayer graphene
- Dangling bonds and magnetism of grain boundaries in graphene
- Graphene adhesion on mica: Role of surface morphology
- Zero-energy states in corrugated bilayer graphene
- Conductivity of suspended graphene at the Dirac point
- Tuning electronic properties of corrugated graphene: confinement, curvature and band gap opening
- Interplay between Raman shift and thermal expansion in graphene: temperature-dependent measurements and analysis of substrate corrections
- State-of-the-art models for the phase diagram of carbon and diamond nucleation
- Strain gauge fields for rippled graphene membranes under central mechanical load: an approach beyond first-order continuum elasticity
- On the structure and topography of free-standing chemically modified graphene
- Frequency tuning, nonlinearities and mode coupling in circular graphene resonators
- Wrinkled few-layer graphene as highly efficient load bearer
- Unexpected catalytic activity of nanorippled graphene
- Revivals of quantum wave-packets in graphene
- Pseudo-magnetic field in curved graphene
- Thermal rippling behavior of graphane
- Anisotropy of the Stone-Wales Defect and Warping of Graphene Nano-ribbons: A First-principles Analysis
- Mechanical Tuning of Thermal Transport in a Molecular Junction
- Snap-through instability of graphene on substrates
- Thermal mirror buckling in freestanding graphene locally controlled by scanning tunneling microscopy
- Graphene's morphology and electronic properties from discrete differential geometry
- Defect-Dependent Corrugation in Graphene
- Density dependent electrical conductivity in suspended graphene: Approaching the Dirac point in transport
- Theory of anharmonic phonons in 2D crystals
- Ab-initio calculation of the effect of stress on the chemical activity of graphene
- Lattice thermal properties of Graphane: thermal contraction, roughness and heat capacity
- Strain-engineering of graphene's electronic structure beyond continuum elasticity
- Evanescent wave transport and shot noise in graphene: ballistic regime and effect of disorder
- Low Energy Electron Point Projection Microscopy of Suspended Graphene, the Ultimate "Microscope Slide"
- Quantum Hall plateau transition in graphene with spatially correlated random hopping
- Rippling, buckling and melting of single- and multi-layer MoS
- Instability of two dimensional graphene: Breaking sp2 bonds with soft X-rays
- Anomalous insulator metal transition in boron nitride-graphene hybrid atomic layers
- Periodized discrete elasticity models for defects in graphene
- Curvature-induced spin-orbit coupling and spin relaxation in a chemically clean single-layer graphene
- Dark-field transmission electron microscopy and the Debye-Waller factor of graphene
- Ripple edge engineering of graphene nanoribbons
- Rippling and crumpling in disordered free-standing graphene
- Altering the reactivity of pristine, N- and P-doped graphene by strain engineering: a DFT view on energy related aspects
- The effect of rippling on the mechanical properties of graphene
- Mosaic pattern formation in exfoliated graphene by mechanical deformation
- Thermodynamics of quantum crystalline membranes
- Heat transfer between weakly coupled systems: Graphene on a-SiO2
- Quantum effects in graphene monolayers: Path-integral simulations
- Correlation between Charge Inhomogeneities and Structure in Graphene and Other Electronic Crystalline Membranes
- Fluctuation-induced current from freestanding graphene: toward nanoscale energy harvesting
- Covalent functionalization of strained graphene
- Proton and molecular permeation through the basal plane of monolayer graphene oxide
- Interfacial interactions between local defects in amorphous SiO and supported graphene
- Statistical mechanics of thin spherical shells
- Feature-Rich Electronic Properties in Graphene Ripples
- Creating Magnetic Fields in excess of 1000 T by Misoriented Stacking in a Graphene Bilayer
- High Precision Fourier Monte Carlo Simulation of Crystalline Membranes
- Nonlocal effective average action approach to crystalline phantom membranes
- Princess and the Pea at the nanoscale: Wrinkling and delamination of graphene on nanoparticles
- Mobility enhancement in graphene by in situ reduction of random strain fluctuations
- Flexuron, a self-trapped state of electron in crystalline membranes
- Acoustic phonons and spin relaxation in graphene nanoribbons
- Topologically confined states at corrugations of gated bilayer graphene
- Direct Probing Stacking Order and Electronic Spectrum of Rhombohedral Trilayer Graphene with Scanning Tunneling Microscopy
- Interface-Confined Doubly Anisotropic Oxidation of Two-Dimensional MoS2
- Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction and magnetic skyrmions induced by curvature
- Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and Spectroscopy of Graphene on Insulating Substrates
- Thermomechanical properties of graphene: valence force field model approach
- Quantum and classical ripples in graphene
- Transition from ballistic to diffusive behavior of graphene ribbons in the presence of warping and charged impurities
- Bilayer graphene Origami: curvature-induced p-n junctions
- Density functional theory analysis of flexural modes, elastic constants, and corrugations in strained graphene
- Tearing of Free-Standing Graphene
- Anisotropic intrinsic spin relaxation in graphene due to flexural distortions
- Buckled circular monolayer graphene: a graphene nano-bowl
- Thermal Excitations of Warped Membranes
- Thermal crumpling of perforated two-dimensional sheets
- Graphene Ripples as a Realization of a Two-Dimensional Ising Model: A Scanning Tunneling Microscope Study
- Transverse intrinsic localized modes in monatomic chain and in graphene
- Collective excitations in a large-d model for graphene
- Theory of the spontaneous buckling of doped graphene
- Entropic Effects of Thermal Rippling on van der Waals Interactions between Monolayer Graphene and a Rigid Substrate
- Theoretical analysis of a dual-probe scanning tunneling microscope setup on graphene
- Elastic properties of graphene flakes: boundary effects and lattice vibrations
- Scanning Tunneling Microscopy currents on locally disordered graphene
- Effects of thermal rippling on the frictional properties of free-standing graphene
- Delineating the role of ripples on thermal expansion of honeycomb materials:graphene, 2D-h-BN and monolayer(ML)-MoS2
- Theory of Graphene Chiral Quasiparticle LDOS maps
- Thermal properties of graphene from path-integral simulations
- Theory of Coulomb Drag in Spatially Inhomogeneous Materials
- Quantitative Chemistry and the Discrete Geometry of Conformal Atom-Thin Crystals
- Formation of wrinkles on graphene induced by nanoparticles: atomic force microscopy study
- The Ground State of Graphene and Graphene Disordered by Vacancies
- Gap opening in topological-defect lattices in graphene
- Enhancing the Adhesion of Graphene to Polymer Substrates by Controlled Defect Formation
- Electron Spin Relaxation in Graphene Nanoribbon Quantum Dots
- Strong long-range relaxations of structural defects in graphene simulated using a new semi-empirical potential
- Snap-through transition of graphene membranes for memcapacitor applications: A combined study using MD, DFT and elasticity theory
- Two dimensional Dirac fermions in the presence of long-range correlated disorder
- Kinetic Friction of Structurally Superlubric 2D Material Interfaces
- Controlling the nanoscale rippling of graphene with SiO2 nanoparticles
- Effect of disorder on the ground-state properties of graphene
- Optical conductivity of curved graphene
- Tuneable molecular doping of corrugated graphene
- Minimal conductivity of rippled graphene with topological disorder
- Dual-probe spectroscopic fingerprints of defects in graphene
- Thermodynamic properties of graphene bilayers
- Adhesion mechanics of graphene on textured substrates
- Manipulation of graphene's dynamic ripples by local harmonic out-of-plane excitation
- Irreversibility in response to forces acting on graphene sheets
- Semiclassics for matrix Hamiltonians: The Gutzwiller trace formula and applications to the graphene-type systems
- Model of ripples in graphene
- Critical radius and temperature for buckling in graphene
- Graphene as a Mechanically Active, Deformable Two-Dimensional Surfactant
- Deflection of suspended graphene by a transverse electric field
- Rippling Instabilities in Suspended Nanoribbons
- Graphene morphology regulated by nanowires patterned in parallel on a substrate surface
- Ab Initio Generalized Langevin Equation
- Atomistic potential for graphene and other sp carbon systems
- Conformal Invariance of Graphene Sheets
- Quasiparticle properties of graphene in the presence of disorder
- Anharmonicity of the acoustic modes of graphene
- Molecular Modelling Combined with Advanced Chemistry for the Rational Design of Efficient Graphene Dispersing Agents
- Thermal properties of graphene under tensile stress
- Ripples in a graphene membrane coupled to Glauber spins
- Ultra-High Mechanical Flexibility of 2D Silicon Telluride
- Electric field-controlled rippling of graphene
- Topological and Quantum Stability of Low-Dimensional Crystalline Lattices with Multiple Nonequivalent Sublattices
- Electron and phonon transport in twisted graphene nanoribbons
- Three-dimensional surface topography of graphene by divergent beam electron diffraction
- Thermal stiffening of clamped elastic ribbons
- Evolution of Complexity in Out-of-Equilibrium Systems by Time-Resolved or Space-Resolved Synchrotron Radiation Techniques
- Ripples in hexagonal lattices of atoms coupled to Glauber spins
- An Existence Criterion for Low-Dimensional Materials
- Interacting electrons in graphene nanoribbons in the lowest Landau level
- Direct Imaging, Three-dimensional Interaction Spectroscopy, and Friction Anisotropy of Atomic-scale Ripples on MoS
- Phonon-mediated electron pairing in graphene
- Selective Conduction of Organic Molecules via Free-Standing Graphene
- Universal behavior of crystalline membranes: crumpling transition and Poisson ratio of the flat phase
- Bending sound in graphene: origin and manifestation
- Crumpling Damaged Graphene
- Cooperative phenomenon in a rippled graphene: Chiral spin guide
- Bifurcation analysis and phase diagram of a spin-string model with buckled states
- Out-of-plane corrugations in graphene based van der Waals heterostructures
- Bending rigidity, sound propagation and ripples in flat graphene
- Shifted Landau levels in curved graphene sheets
- STM driven transition from rippled to buckled graphene in a spin-membrane model
- Defects induce phase transition from dynamic to static rippling in graphene
- From the 2D graphene honeycomb lattice to 1D nanoribbons: dimensional crossover signals in the structural thermal fluctuations
- Ripple morphology of graphitic surfaces: a comparison between few-layer graphene and HOPG
- Phonon dispersion in two-dimensional solids from atomic probability distributions
- Avoidance and Coalescence of Delamination Patterns
- Minimal graphene thickness for wear protection of diamond
- Temperature Dependent Layer Breathing Modes in Two Dimensional Materials
- Limits of stability in supported graphene nanoribbons subject to bending
- All-graphene edge contacts: Electrical resistance of graphene T-junctions
- Spontaneous tilt of single-clamped thermal elastic sheets
- Transport properties of rippled graphene
- Thermal fluctuations (eventually) unfold nanoscale origami
- Density functional theory based study of graphene and dielectric oxide interfaces
- Rippling transition from electron-induced condensation of curvature field in graphene
- Curved-space Dirac description of elastically deformed monolayer graphene is generally incorrect
- Effect of long-range structural corrugations on magnetotransport properties of phosphorene in tilted magnetic field
- X-rays writing/reading of Charge Density Waves in the CuO2 plane of a simple cuprate superconductor
- Chirality-Selective Transport of Benzene Molecules on Carbon Nanotubes
- Graphene edge structures: Folding, scrolling, tubing, rippling and twisting
- Poiseuille flow in curved spaces
- Thermal ripples in bilayer graphene
- Interplay between nanometer-scale strain variations and externally applied strain in graphene
- Anisotropic Dirac cones in monatomic hexagonal lattices
- Bending Stiffness Collapse, Buckling, Topological Bands of Freestanding Twisted Bilayer Graphene
- Acoustically driven Dirac electrons in monolayer graphene
- What spatial geometry does the (2+1)-dimensional QFT vacuum prefer?
- Graphene Cantilever Under Casimir Force
- Enhanced hydrogen-gas permeation through rippled graphene
- Boundaries Determine the Formation Energies of Lattice Defects in Two-Dimensional Buckled Materials
- Elastic properties and mechanical stability of bilayer graphene: Molecular dynamics simulations
- Theory of defect dynamics in graphene: defect groupings and their stability
- Thermo-electromechanical effects in relaxed shape graphene and bandstructures of graphene quantum dots
- Phonon-polaritons in Bose-Einstein condensates induced by Casimir-Polder interaction with graphene
- Graphene ground states
- A Perspective on Collective Properties of Atoms on 2D Materials
- Distribution of ripples in graphene membrane
- Path-integral simulation of graphene monolayers under tensile stress
- Nuclear quantum effects in graphene bilayers
- A Molecular Mechanics Study of Morphologic Interaction between Graphene and Si Nanowires on a SiO2 Substrate
- A Torsional potential for graphene derived from fitting to DFT results
- Deformation of graphene sheet: Interaction of fermions with phonons
- Nanoscale Topographical Replication of Graphene Architecture by Artificial DNA nanostructures
- Highly stable electronic properties of rippled antimonene under compressive deformation
- Time-lapsed graphene moiré superlattice on Cu(111)
- Reduced quantum electrodynamics in curved space
- Quantum effects in structural and elastic properties of graphite: Path-integral simulations
- Discontinuous evolution of the structure of stretching polycrystalline graphene
- Critical behavior in graphene: spinodal instability at room temperature
- A numerical study of the rippling instability driven by electron-phonon coupling in graphene
- Stability of Suspended Graphene under Casimir Force
- Vibrations and tunneling of strained nanoribbons at finite temperature
- Spatial mapping of the Dirac point in monolayer and bilayer graphene
- Edge mode based graphene nanomechanical resonators for high-sensitivity mass sensor
- Topological Transition of Graphene from Quantum Hall Metal to Quantum Hall Insulator at
- Folding pathways to crumpling in thermalized elastic frames
- Quantum Holonomies in Graphene Wormholes
- Quantized exciton-exciton annihilation in monolayer WS2 on SrTiO3 substrates with atomically flat terraces
- Isotopic effects in structural properties of graphene
- Thermal control of graphene morphology: a signature of its intrinsic surface tension
- Quantum interference effects in chemical vapor deposited graphene
- Rim curvature anomaly in thin conical sheets revisited
- Graphene Induced Large Shift of Surface Plasmon Resonances of Gold Films: Effective Medium Theory for Atomically Thin Materials
- Effect of out-of-plane acoustic phonons on the thermal transport properties of graphene
- Dynamics of Fluctuating Thin Sheets Under Random Forcing
- Thermally driven elastic membranes are quasi-linear across all scales
- The orientation of CO intercalated between graphene and Ru(0001)
- On corrected formula for graphene quantum conductivity
- Radiative decay effects influence the local electromagnetic response of the monolayer graphene with surface corrugations in terahertz range
- Neural network-based recognition of multiple nanobubbles in graphene
- Elastic properties of moiré lattices in epitaxial two-dimensional materials
- An analytic investigation for the edge effect on mechanical properties of graphene nanoribbons
- Purely anharmonic charge-density wave in the 2D Dirac semimetal SnP
- Koshino-Taylor effect in graphene
- Does the Round Sphere Maximize the Free Energy of (2+1)-Dimensional QFTs?
- Strain-Fluctuation-Induced Near-Quantization of Valley Hall Conductivity in Graphene Systems
- Effective models of membranes from symmetry breaking
- Tuning Gap in Corrugated Graphene with Spin Dependence
- Geometrical properties of strained and twisted moiré heterostructures
- Vibrational stability of graphene under combined shear and axial strains
- Visualization of Atomic Structures on Faceted and Nonflat Surfaces by the Difference-of-Gaussians Approach
- Apparent rippling with honeycomb symmetry and tunable periodicity observed by scanning tunneling microscopy on suspended graphene
- Universal wrinkling of freestanding atomically thin films
- Tunable Dirac points and zero-energy modes in periodic curved graphene superlattices
- First-principles derived force field for h-BN monolayer nanostructures: Applications to sheets, nanotubes and nanotori
- Thermodynamic stability and vibrational anharmonicity of black phosphorene-beyond quasi-harmonic analysis
- Intrinsic Rippling Enhances Static Non-Reciprocity in Graphene Metamaterials
- Reply to 'Comment on "Thermodynamics of quantum crystalline membranes"'
- Spontaneous charge-ordered state in Bernal-stacked bilayer graphene
- Probing divacancy defects in a zigzag graphene nanoribbon through RKKY exchange interaction
- Buckling in a rotationally invariant spin-elastic model
- Geometrically-induced localization of flexural waves on thin warped physical membranes
- Geometric control of tilt transition dynamics in single-clamped thermalized elastic sheets
- Sublattice polarization and filamentary superconductivity in strained graphene
- Impact of Nitrogen Atom Clusters and Vacancy Defects on Graphene: A Molecular Dynamics Investigation
- Quantum Buckling
- Relaxation and Its Effects on Electronic Structure in Twisted Systems: An Analytical Perspective
- Probing Temperature at Nanoscale through Thermal Vibration Characterization using Scanning Precession Electron Diffraction
- Large symmetry and hierarchical ordering transitions in sliding ferroelectrics
- Elastic Constants and Bending Rigidities from Long-Wavelength Perturbation Expansions
- Electronic states in a bilayer graphene quantum ripple
- Epitaxial two-dimensional membranes under intrinsic and extrinsic strains
- Diamond-shaped evolution of the superconducting interference pattern in NbTiN weak-link Josephson junctions
- Renormalization group approach to the elastic properties of graphene bilayers