The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: the molecular gas content of galaxies and tensions with IllustrisTNG and the Santa Cruz SAM

Abstract

The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field (ASPECS) provides new constraints for galaxy formation models on the molecular gas properties of galaxies. We compare results from ASPECS to predictions from two cosmological galaxy formation models: the IllustrisTNG hydrodynamical simulations and the Santa Cruz semi-analytic model (SC SAM). We explore several recipes to model the H${}_2$ content of galaxies, finding them to be consistent with one another, and take into account the sensitivity limits and survey area of ASPECS. For a canonical CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor of ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CO}}=3.6{\mathrm{M}}_{\odot }/(\mathrm{K}km/s{\mathrm{pc}}^2)$ the results of our work include: (1) the H${}_2$ mass of $z>1$ galaxies predicted by the models as a function of their stellar mass is a factor of 2-3 lower than observed; (2) the models do not reproduce the number of H${}_2$-rich ($M_{H2}>3\times 10^{10}{\mathrm{M}}_{\odot }$) galaxies observed by ASPECS; (3) the H${}_2$ cosmic density evolution predicted by IllustrisTNG (the SC SAM) is in tension (only just agrees) with the observed cosmic density, even after accounting for the ASPECS selection function and field-to-field variance effects. The tension between models and observations at $z>1$ can be alleviated by adopting a CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor in the range ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CO}}=2.0-0.8{\mathrm{M}}_{\odot }/(\mathrm{K}km/s{\mathrm{pc}}^2)$. Additional work on constraining the CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor and CO excitation conditions of galaxies through observations and theory will be necessary to more robustly test the success of galaxy formation models.

arXiv commentRe-submitted to ApJ after addressing the first round of comments by the referee, other comments welcome

References in corpus (122)

• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
• Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• The Average Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos from z=0-8
• High Redshift Galaxies in the Hubble Deep Field. Color Selection and Star Formation History to z=4
• Simulating Galaxy Formation with the IllustrisTNG Model
• The Star Formation Efficiency in Nearby Galaxies: Measuring Where Gas Forms Stars Effectively
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: matter and galaxy clustering
• On the normalisation of the cosmic star formation history
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: the stellar mass content of groups and clusters of galaxies
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: the galaxy color bimodality
• A Highly Consistent Framework for the Evolution of the Star-Forming "Main Sequence" from z~0-6
• The Rockstar Phase-Space Temporal Halo Finder and the Velocity Offsets of Cluster Cores
• Physical Models of Galaxy Formation in a Cosmological Framework
• Properties of galaxies reproduced by a hydrodynamic simulation
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: A tale of two elements -- chemical evolution of magnesium and europium
• Simulating galaxy formation with black hole driven thermal and kinetic feedback
• A Semi-Analytic Model for the Co-evolution of Galaxies, Black Holes, and Active Galactic Nuclei
• The Neutral Atomic Phases of the ISM in the Galaxy
• Cool Gas in High Redshift Galaxies
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: radio haloes and magnetic fields
• The Hubble Deep Field: Observations, Data Reduction, and Galaxy Photometry
• Semi-Analytic Modelling of Galaxy Formation: The Local Universe
• Introducing the Illustris Project: the evolution of galaxy populations across cosmic time
• A model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation physics
• The First Stars
• Halos and galaxies in the standard cosmological model: results from the Bolshoi simulation
• PHIBSS: molecular gas content and scaling relations in z~1-3 normal star forming galaxies
• Very High Gas Fractions and Extended Gas Reservoirs in z=1.5 Disk Galaxies
• A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
• Galaxy formation in the Planck Cosmology - I. Matching the observed evolution of star formation rates, colours and stellar masses
• The Nature of High-Redshift Galaxies
• Gas-to-Dust mass ratios in local galaxies over a 2 dex metallicity range
• The Illustris simulation: the evolving population of black holes across cosmic time
• PHIBSS: Unified Scaling Relations of Gas Depletion Time and Molecular Gas Fractions
• The Role of Pressure in GMC Formation II: The H_2 - Pressure Relation
• UV Luminosity Functions at z~4, 5, and 6 from the HUDF and other Deep HST ACS Fields: Evolution and Star Formation History
• On the evolution of star forming galaxies
• A Universal, Local Star Formation Law in Galactic Clouds, Nearby Galaxies, High-Redshift Disks, and Starbursts
• xCOLD GASS: the complete IRAM-30m legacy survey of molecular gas for galaxy evolution studies
• The CANADA-FRANCE REDSHIFT SURVEY VI: Evolution of the galaxy luminosity function to z ~ 1
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition in Galaxies. II: HI and H_2 Column Densities
• The Star Formation Law in Atomic and Molecular Gas
• Regulation of Star Formation Rates in Multiphase Galactic Disks: a Thermal/Dynamical Equilibrium Model
• Evolution of galaxy stellar masses and star formation rates in the EAGLE simulations
• A General Model for the CO-H2 Conversion Factor in Galaxies with Applications to the Star Formation Law
• The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey: I. Survey description, data reduction and source detection
• MUFASA: Galaxy Formation Simulations With Meshless Hydrodynamics
• A physical model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation: multi-epoch validation
• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• Galaxies in LCDM with Halo Abundance Matching: luminosity-velocity relation, baryonic mass-velocity relation, velocity function and clustering
• A Comparison of Methods for Determining the Molecular Content of Model Galaxies
• Molecular Hydrogen and Global Star Formation Relations in Galaxies
• The Size Evolution of Star-forming and Quenched Galaxies in the IllustrisTNG simulation
• The star-formation activity of IllustrisTNG galaxies: main sequence, UVJ diagram, quenched fractions, and systematics
• The metallicity dependence of the CO {\rightarrow} H_2 conversion factor in z>1 star forming galaxies
• CO excitation of normal star forming galaxies out to z=1.5 as regulated by the properties of their interstellar medium
• Validation of the equilibrium model for galaxy evolution to z~3 through molecular gas and dust observations of lensed star-forming galaxies
• Shark: introducing an open source, free and flexible semi-analytic model of galaxy formation
• Cosmic evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies
• The dust content of galaxies from z = 0 to z = 9
• An Older, More Quiescent Universe from Panchromatic SED Fitting of the 3D-HST Survey
• ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: Survey Description
• Halo and Subhalo Demographics with Planck Cosmological Parameters: Bolshoi-Planck and MultiDark-Planck Simulations
• Galaxy Properties from the Ultra-violet to the Far-Infrared: Lambda-CDM models confront observations
• Environmental Dependence of the Kennicutt-Schmidt Relation in Galaxies
• The evolution of the mass-metallicity relation in IllustrisTNG
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition in Galaxies. I: An Analytic Approximation for Photodissociation Fronts in Finite Clouds
• The Role of Pressure in GMC Formation
• GAMA/G10-COSMOS/3D-HST: The 0<z<5 cosmic star-formation history, stellar- and dust-mass densities
• Star Formation in Semi-Analytic Galaxy Formation Models with Multiphase Gas
• Evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey - VLT/FORS2 Spectroscopy in the GOODS-South Field
• Cold gas properties of the Herschel Reference Survey. II. Molecular and total gas scaling relations
• The abundance, distribution, and physical nature of highly ionized oxygen OVI, OVII, and OVIII in IllustrisTNG
• Galaxy assembly, stellar feedback and metal enrichment: the view from the GAEA model
• Semi-analytic forecasts for JWST - I. UV luminosity functions at z = 4 - 10
• The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey: II. Spectroscopic redshifts and comparisons to color selections of high-redshift galaxies
• Implementing Molecular Hydrogen in Hydrodynamic Simulations of Galaxy Formation
• The Atomic-to-Molecular Transition in Galaxies. III. A New Method for Determining the Molecular Content of Primordial and Dusty Clouds
• A Universal Neutral Gas Profile for Nearby Disk Galaxies
• The Star Formation Law in Molecule-Poor Galaxies
• COLDz: Shape of the CO Luminosity Function at High Redshift and the Cold Gas History of the Universe
• ALMA spectroscopic survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: Continuum number counts, resolved 1.2-mm extragalactic background, and properties of the faintest dusty star forming galaxies
• CO Luminosity Functions For FIR and B-band Selected Galaxies and the First Estimate for Omega_{HI+H2}
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition and its Relation to the Scaling Properties of Galaxy Disks in the Local Universe
• Predictions for the CO emission of galaxies from a coupled simulation of galaxy formation and photon dominated regions
• H_2 Cooling of Primordial Gas Triggered by UV Irradiation
• Simulating the dust content of galaxies: successes and failures
• MUFASA: Galaxy star formation, gas, and metal properties across cosmic time
• ALMA spectroscopic survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: CO luminosity functions and the evolution of the cosmic density of molecular gas
• Dwarf galaxy formation with H2-regulated star formation
• Atomic and molecular gas in IllustrisTNG galaxies at low redshift
• Understanding the H2/HI Ratio in Galaxies
• Modeling the atomic-to-molecular transition in cosmological simulations of galaxy formation
• On the Origin of the Galaxy Star-Formation-Rate Sequence: Evolution and Scatter
• Atomic hydrogen in IllustrisTNG galaxies: the impact of environment parallelled with local 21-cm surveys
• The uniformity and time-invariance of the intra-cluster metal distribution in galaxy clusters from the IllustrisTNG simulations
• The CO Luminosity Density at High-z (COLDz) Survey: A Sensitive, Large Area Blind Search for Low-J CO Emission from Cold Gas in the Early Universe with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array
• Understanding the Structural Scaling Relations of Early-Type Galaxies
• A Molecular Line Scan in the Hubble Deep Field North: Constraints on the CO Luminosity Function and the Cosmic H2 Density
• H${}_2$-based star formation laws in hierarchical models of galaxy formation
• Evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies in dark matter haloes
• ALMA reveals starburst-like interstellar medium conditions in a compact star-forming galaxy at z ~ 2 using [CI] and CO
• The art of modeling CO, [CI], and [CII] in cosmological galaxy formation models
• Properties of HI discs in the Auriga cosmological simulations
• Sub-mm Emission Line Deep Fields: CO and [CII] Luminosity Functions out to z = 6
• A molecular line scan in the Hubble Deep Field North
• The Effect of Star Formation on the Redshift Evolution of Interstellar Metals, Atomic and Molecular Gas in Galaxies
• Constraining the star formation rate in the Solar neighbourhood with star clusters
• The Simulated HI Sky at low redshift
• The inferred evolution of the cold gas properties of CANDELS galaxies at 0.5 < z < 3.0
• The nature of the ISM in galaxies during the star-formation activity peak of the Universe
• Molecular hydrogen regulated star formation in cosmological SPH simulations
• A parametric study of possible solutions to the high-redshift overproduction of stars in modeled dwarf galaxies
• IQ-Collaboratory 1.1: the Star-Forming Sequence of Simulated Central Galaxies
• On the Baryonic Contents of Low Mass Galaxies
• Three regimes of CO emission in galaxy mergers

Cited by in corpus (64)

• The Evolution of the Star-forming Interstellar Medium across Cosmic Time
• The Cosmic Baryon and Metal Cycles
• Resolving small-scale cold circumgalactic gas in TNG50
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: CO luminosity functions and the molecular gas content of galaxies through cosmic history
• Automated Mining of the ALMA Archive in the COSMOS Field (A3COSMOS): II. Cold Molecular Gas Evolution out to Redshift 6
• Galaxy Cold Gas Contents in Modern Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulations
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: CO Excitation and Atomic Carbon in Star-Forming Galaxies at $z=1-3$
• FIREbox: Simulating galaxies at high dynamic range in a cosmological volume
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Multi-band constraints on line luminosity functions and the cosmic density of molecular gas
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: CO emission lines and 3 mm continuum sources
• The properties of the interstellar medium of galaxies across time as traced by the neutral atomic carbon [CI]
• Three Lyman-alpha emitting filaments converging to a massive galaxy group at z=2.91: discussing the case for cold gas infall
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: Evolution of the molecular gas in CO-selected galaxies
• The dust-continuum size of TNG50 galaxies at $z=1-5$: a comparison with the distribution of stellar light, stars, dust and H${}_2$
• Reproducing sub-millimetre galaxy number counts with cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
• VLA-ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field (VLASPECS): Total Cold Gas Masses and CO Line Ratios for z=2-3 "Main Sequence" Galaxies
• An Intensity Mapping Detection of Aggregate CO Line Emission at 3 mm
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: The nature of the faintest dusty star-forming galaxies
• Physical properties and evolution of (Sub-)millimeter selected galaxies in the galaxy formation simulation Shark
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Nature and physical properties of gas-mass selected galaxies using MUSE spectroscopy
• The Circumgalactic Medium of Milky Way-like Galaxies in the TNG50 Simulation -- I: Halo Gas Properties and the Role of SMBH Feedback
• Mock Lightcones and Theory Friendly Catalogs for the CANDELS Survey
• Plateau de Bure High-z Blue-Sequence Survey 2 (PHIBSS2): Search for Secondary Sources, CO Luminosity Functions in the Field, and the Evolution of Molecular Gas Density through Cosmic Time
• First results from SMAUG: The need for preventative stellar feedback and improved baryon cycling in semi-analytic models of galaxy formation
• The MOSDEF Survey: Implications of the Lack of Evolution in the Dust Attenuation-Mass Relation to z~2
• Multitracer cosmological line intensity mapping mock lightcone simulation
• Galaxy interactions in IllustrisTNG-100, I: The power and limitations of visual identification
• Satellites of Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with TNG50: quenched fractions, gas content, and star formation histories
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: A model to explain observed 1.1 and 0.85 millimeter dust continuum number counts
• The Circumgalactic Medium of Milky Way-like Galaxies in the TNG50 Simulation -- II: Cold, Dense Gas Clouds and High-Velocity Cloud Analogs
• The role of gas fraction and feedback in the stability and evolution of galactic discs: implications for cosmological galaxy formation models
• The cosmic abundance of cold gas in the local Universe
• [CII] line intensity mapping the epoch of reionization with the Prime-Cam on FYST
• Semi-analytic forecasts for Roman -- the beginning of a new era of deep-wide galaxy surveys
• An ALMA Spectroscopic Survey of the Brightest Submillimeter Galaxies in the SCUBA-2-COSMOS Field (AS2COSPEC): Physical Properties of z=2-5 Ultra- and Hyperluminous Infrared Galaxies
• A NOEMA molecular line scan of the Hubble Deep Field North: Improved constraints on the CO luminosity functions and cosmic density of molecular gas
• Atomic and molecular gas from the epoch of reionization down to redshift 2
• Galaxy Formation in the Santa Cruz semi-analytic model compared with IllustrisTNG -- I. Galaxy scaling relations, dispersions, and residuals at z=0
• MIGHTEE-HI: The first MeerKAT HI mass function from an untargeted interferometric survey
• The atomic-to-molecular hydrogen transition in the TNG50 simulation: Using realistic UV fields to create spatially resolved HI maps
• Cosmic metal density evolution in neutral gas: insights from observations and cosmological simulations
• IR SED and Dust Masses of Sub-solar Metallicity Galaxies at z~2.3
• Exploring the Milky Way Circumgalactic Medium in a Cosmological Context with a Semi-Analytic Model
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Constraining cumulative CO emission at $1\lesssim z\lesssim 4$ with power spectrum analysis of ASPECS LP data from 84 to 115 GHz
• Relic galaxy analogues in Illustris TNG50: the formation pathways of surviving red nuggets in a cosmological simulation
• Biases and Cosmic Variance in Molecular Gas Abundance Measurements
• On estimating the cosmic molecular gas density from CO Line Intensity Mapping observations
• Impact of H${}_2$-driven star formation and stellar feedback from low-enrichment environments on the formation of spiral galaxies
• Cosmic evolution of the H2 mass density and the epoch of molecular gas
• Extragalactic Science with the Experiment for Cryogenic Large-aperture Intensity Mapping
• ALMACAL VIII: A pilot survey for untargeted extragalactic CO emission lines in deep ALMA calibration data
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Constraining the Molecular Content at $\log (M_{\ast }/M_{\odot })\sim 9.5$ with CO stacking of MUSE detected $z\sim 1.5$ Galaxies
• The Column Densities of Molecular Gas across Cosmic Time: Bridging Observations and Simulations
• The CO universe: Modelling CO emission and H${}_2$ abundance in cosmological galaxy formation simulations
• Spritz is sparkling: simulated CO and [CII] luminosities
• ALMACAL XIII. Evolution of the CO luminosity function and the molecular gas mass density out to $z$ ~ 6
• Intertwined Formation of ${\mathrm{H}}_2$, Dust, and Stars in Cosmological Simulations
• Galaxy assembly bias and large-scale distribution: a comparison between IllustrisTNG and a semi-analytic model
• The Qz5 Survey (I): How the HI Mass Density of the Universe Evolves With Cosmic Time
• IllustrisTNG and S2COSMOS: possible conflicts in the evolution of neutral gas and dust
• Cosmological simulations predict that AGN preferentially live in gas-rich, star-forming galaxies despite effective feedback
• Kiloparsec-scale imaging of the CO(1-0)-traced cold molecular gas reservoir in a z~3.4 submillimeter galaxy
• Nature and physical properties of ALMA selected galaxies using MUSE spectroscopy
• Comparison of Cross-Correlation Methods for Line Intensity Mapping