Challenging local realism with human choices

Abstract

A Bell test is a randomized trial that compares experimental observations against the philosophical worldview of local realism. A Bell test requires spatially distributed entanglement, fast and high-efficiency detection and unpredictable measurement settings. Although technology can satisfy the first two of these requirements, the use of physical devices to choose settings in a Bell test involves making assumptions about the physics that one aims to test. Bell himself noted this weakness in using physical setting choices and argued that human `free will' could be used rigorously to ensure unpredictability in Bell tests. Here we report a set of local-realism tests using human choices, which avoids assumptions about predictability in physics. We recruited about 100,000 human participants to play an online video game that incentivizes fast, sustained input of unpredictable selections and illustrates Bell-test methodology. The participants generated 97,347,490 binary choices, which were directed via a scalable web platform to 12 laboratories on five continents, where 13 experiments tested local realism using photons, single atoms, atomic ensembles, and superconducting devices. Over a 12-hour period on 30 November 2016, participants worldwide provided a sustained data flow of over 1,000 bits per second to the experiments, which used different human-generated data to choose each measurement setting. The observed correlations strongly contradict local realism and other realistic positions in bipartite and tripartite scenarios. Project outcomes include closing the `freedom-of-choice loophole' (the possibility that the setting choices are influenced by `hidden variables' to correlate with the particle properties), the utilization of video-game methods for rapid collection of human generated randomness, and the use of networking techniques for global participation in experimental science.

arXiv commentThis version includes minor changes resulting from reviewer and editorial input. Abstract shortened to fit within arXiv limits

References in corpus (27)

• Circuit Quantum Electrodynamics: Coherent Coupling of a Single Photon to a Cooper Pair Box
• Experimental loophole-free violation of a Bell inequality using entangled electron spins separated by 1.3 km
• Violation of Bell's inequality under strict Einstein locality conditions
• Significant-loophole-free test of Bell's theorem with entangled photons
• Random Numbers Certified by Bell's Theorem
• A strong loophole-free test of local realism
• Event-Ready Bell Test Using Entangled Atoms Simultaneously Closing Detection and Locality Loopholes
• The Free Will Theorem
• Violation of local realism with freedom of choice
• Certified randomness in quantum physics
• Loopholes in Bell Inequality Tests of Local Realism
• Cosmic Bell Test: Measurement Settings from Milky Way Stars
• Relaxed Bell inequalities and Kochen-Specker theorems
• How much measurement independence is needed in order to demonstrate nonlocality?
• Experimental Three-Particle Quantum Nonlocality under Strict Locality Conditions
• Generation of fresh and pure random numbers for loophole-free Bell tests
• Exploring the Quantum Speed Limit with Computer Games
• Arbitrarily small amount of measurement independence is sufficient to manifest quantum nonlocality
• Randomness in Quantum Mechanics: Philosophy, Physics and Technology
• Testing Bell's Inequality with Cosmic Photons: Closing the Setting-Independence Loophole
• Requirements for a loophole-free photonic Bell test using imperfect setting generators
• Experimental non-locality in a quantum network
• Remote optimization of an ultra-cold atoms experiment by experts and citizen scientists
• A Robust Mathematical Model for Clauser-Horne Experiments, With Implications for Rigorous Statistical Analysis
• Entanglement between a photonic time-bin qubit and a collective atomic spin excitation
• (Nearly) optimal P-values for all Bell inequalities
• Random number generation with cosmic photons

Cited by in corpus (87)

• 12-photon entanglement and scalable scattershot boson sampling with optimal entangled-photon pairs from parametric down-conversion
• Micius quantum experiments in space
• Non-Gaussian Quantum States and Where to Find Them
• Cosmic Bell Test using Random Measurement Settings from High-Redshift Quasars
• Experimentally Generated Randomness Certified by the Impossibility of Superluminal Signals
• Rethinking Superdeterminism
• Strong Quantum Nonlocality without Entanglement
• Quantum information with top quarks in QCD
• Entanglement-Based Quantum Information Technology
• Entanglement: Quantum or Classical?
• Remote optimization of an ultra-cold atoms experiment by experts and citizen scientists
• Experimental Realization of Device-Independent Quantum Randomness Expansion
• The Deep Space Quantum Link: Prospective Fundamental Physics Experiments using Long-Baseline Quantum Optics
• Scalable multiphoton quantum metrology with neither pre- nor post-selected measurements
• Bohm-Bell type experiments: Classical probability approach to (no-)signaling and applications to quantum physics and psychology
• Device-Independent Secret Sharing and a Stronger Form of Bell Nonlocality
• Entangled baryons: violation of Inequalities based on local realism assuming dependence of decays on hidden variables
• Bell correlations depth in many-body systems
• Relaxed Bell Inequalities with Arbitrary Measurement Dependence for Each Observer
• Violations of locality and free choice are equivalent resources in Bell experiments
• Optimization of device-independent witnesses of entanglement depth from two-body correlators
• Quantifying causal influences in the presence of a quantum common cause
• Semi-device-independent quantum random number generator with a broadband squeezed state of light
• Multiparty orthogonal product states with minimal genuine nonlocality
• Black hole entropy, the black hole information paradox, and time travel paradoxes from a new perspective
• Experimental nonclassicality in a causal network without assuming freedom of choice
• Contextuality-by-Default description of Bell tests: Contextuality as the rule not as an exception
• Contextuality or nonlocality; what would John Bell choose today?
• Measurement-dependence cost for Bell nonlocality: causal vs retrocausal models
• A Toy Model for Local and Deterministic Wave-function Collapse
• Genuine activation of nonlocality: From locally available to locally hidden information
• Quantum steering with vector vortex photon states with the detection loophole closed
• Genuine hidden nonlocality without entanglement: from the perspective of local discrimination
• Bell inequalities, Counterfactual Definiteness and Falsifiability
• Single-copy activation of Bell nonlocality via broadcasting of quantum states
• Quantum Nonlocality: how does Nature do it?
• Defining Quantum Games
• Superdeterministic hidden-variables models I: nonequilibrium and signalling
• The History of Quantum Games
• Real-time ghost imaging of Bell-nonlocal entanglement between a photon and a quantum memory
• Experimental tests of Multiplicative Bell Inequalities
• Beating detection loophole in nonlinear entanglement witnesses
• Authenticated teleportation with one-sided trust
• Detection loophole in measurement-device-independent entanglement witness
• Weak Gravitational Field Effects On Large-Scale Optical Interferometric Bell Tests
• Detection loophole in quantum causality and its countermeasures
• Mesoscopic and macroscopic quantum correlations in photonic, atomic and optomechanical systems
• Citizen Science to Assess Light Pollution with Mobile Phones
• Verification of Bell Nonlocality by Violating Quantum Monogamy Relations
• Tackling Loopholes in Experimental Tests of Bell's Inequality
• Entangled electron-photon pair production by channel-exchange in high-energy Compton scattering
• My discussions of quantum foundations with John Stewart Bell
• Detecting entanglement of unknown states by violating the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality
• Testing of quantum nonlocal correlations under constrained free will and imperfect detectors
• The quantum electromagnetic field in the Weyl-Wigner representation
• Spin Helicity and the Disproof of Bell's Theorem
• Experimental investigation of the relation between measurement uncertainties and non-local quantum correlations
• Misreading EPR: Variations on an Incorrect Theme
• Experimental test of measurement dependent local Bell inequality with human free will
• Continuous-Variable Entanglement Test in Driven Quantum Contacts
• Experimental Test of Leggett's Inequalities with Solid-State Spins
• Demonstration of Maxwell Demon-assistant Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Steering via Superconducting Quantum Processor
• A Family of Local Deterministic Models for Singlet Quantum State Correlations
• The violation of Bell-CHSH inequalities leads to different conclusions depending on the description used
• The quantum theory of the electromagnetic field in the Weyl-Wigner representation as a local realistic model
• Citizen Science Games on the Timeline of Quantum Games
• Why quantum correlations are shocking
• Statistical Contextual Explanation of Quantum Paradoxes
• Detection Efficiency Bounds in (Semi-)Device-Independent Scenarios
• Causal Networks and Freedom of Choice in Bell's Theorem
• Analysis of single-particle nonlocality through the prism of weak measurements
• Comment on "Experimentally adjudicating between different causal accounts of Bell-inequality violations via statistical model selection"
• Information Carried by a Single Particle in Quantum Multiple-Access Channels
• Quantum contextuality of complementary photon polarizations explored by adaptive input state control
• Standard Model of Particle Physics Violating Crypto-Nonlocal Realism
• Are Bell's conditions for local realism general enough?
• Measurement incompatibility at all remote parties do not always permit Bell nonlocality
• Measurement-device-independent nonlinear entanglement witnesses
• An Effective Way to Determine the Separability of Quantum State
• Correlating Local Quantum Reality with Causally Disconnected Choices
• Analysis of assumptions in BIG Bell Test experiments
• Violation of no-signaling on a public quantum computer
• Optimal and robust error filtration for quantum information processing
• Quantum Computation
• Structural constraint on delayed-choice quantum eraser architectures
• Comparing the cost of violating causal assumptions in Bell experiments: locality, free choice and arrow-of-time
• Demonstration that Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering requires more than one bit of faster-than-light information transmission