Solar Cycle Variability Induced by Tilt Angle Scatter in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model

Abstract

We present results from a three-dimensional Babcock--Leighton dynamo model that is sustained by the explicit emergence and dispersal of bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs). On average, each BMR has a systematic tilt given by Joy's law. Randomness and nonlinearity in the BMR emergence of our model produce variable magnetic cycles. However, when we allow for a random scatter in the tilt angle to mimic the observed departures from Joy's law, we find more variability in the magnetic cycles. We find that the observed standard deviation in Joy's law of ${\sigma }_{\delta }=15^{\circ }$ produces a variability comparable to observed solar cycle variability of $\sim$ 32%, as quantified by the sunspot number maxima between 1755--2008. We also find that tilt angle scatter can promote grand minima and grand maxima. The time spent in grand minima for ${\sigma }_{\delta }=15^{\circ }$ is somewhat less than that inferred for the Sun from cosmogenic isotopes (about 9% compared to 17%). However, when we double the tilt scatter to ${\sigma }_{\delta }=30^{\circ }$, the simulation statistics are comparable to the Sun ($\sim$18% of the time in grand minima and $\sim 10$% in grand maxima). Though the Babcock--Leighton mechanism is the only source of poloidal field, we find that our simulations always maintain magnetic cycles even at large fluctuations in the tilt angle. We also demonstrate that tilt quenching is a viable and efficient mechanism for dynamo saturation; a suppression of the tilt by only 1-2${}^{\circ }$ is sufficient to limit the dynamo growth. Thus, any potential observational signatures of tilt quenching in the Sun may be subtle.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (53)

• Grand minima and maxima of solar activity: New observational constraints
• Predicting solar cycle 24 with a solar dynamo model
• Sunspot group tilt angles and the strength of the solar cycle
• Solar activity forecast with a dynamo model
• Full--Sphere Simulations of a Circulation--Dominated Solar Dynamo: Exploring the Parity Issue
• Exploring the Physical Basis of Solar Cycle Predictions: Flux Transport Dynamics and Persistence of Memory in Advection versus Diffusion Dominated Solar Convection Zones
• The crucial role of surface magnetic fields for the solar dynamo
• Bipolar Magnetic Regions on the Sun: Global Analysis of the SOHO/MDI Data Set
• Solar Cycle Propagation, Memory, and Prediction: Insights from a Century of Magnetic Proxies
• Meridional Circulation in Solar and Stellar Convection Zones
• A simulation of convective dynamo in the solar convective envelope: maintenance of the solar-like differential rotation and emerging flux
• Effects of the scatter in sunspot group tilt angles on the large-scale magnetic field at the solar surface
• Solar Magnetic Field Reversals and the Role of Dynamo Families
• Grand Minima and Equatorward Propagation in a Cycling Stellar Convective Dynamo
• On the role of meridional flows in flux transport dynamo models
• Is a deep one-cell meridional circulation essential for the flux transport Solar Dynamo?
• Meridional circulation in the solar convection zone: time-distance helioseismic inferences from four years of HMI/SDO observations
• A Solar Dynamo Model Driven by Mean-Field Alpha and Babcock-Leighton Sources: Fluctuations, Grand-Minima-Maxima and Hemispheric Asymmetry in Sunspot Cycles
• Magnetically controlled stellar differential rotation near the transition from solar to anti-solar profiles
• Multiple dynamo modes as a mechanism for long-term solar activity variations
• Predicting the Amplitude and Hemispheric Asymmetry of Solar Cycle 25 with Surface Flux Transport
• Limits to solar cycle predictability: Cross-equatorial flux plumes
• A 3D Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• Effects of Meridional Flow Variations on Solar Cycles 23 and 24
• Hemispheric Asymmetries of Solar Photospheric Magnetism: Radiative, Particulate, and Heliospheric Impacts
• Meridional Flow in the Solar Convection Zone II: Helioseismic Inversions of GONG Data
• Solar parity issue with flux-transport dynamo
• Does the Babcock--Leighton Mechanism Operate on the Sun?
• Turbulent Pumping of Magnetic Flux Reduces Solar Cycle Memory and thus Impacts Predictability of the Sun's Activity
• Small-Scale and Global Dynamos and the Area and Flux Distributions of Active Regions, Sunspot Groups, and Sunspots: A Multi-Database Study
• On the Amplitude of Convective Velocities in the Deep Solar Interior
• The Waldmeier effect and the flux transport solar dynamo
• Grand Minima and North-South Asymmetry of Solar Activity
• A coupled $2\times 2$D Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo model. II. Reference dynamo solutions
• Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo: the role of downward pumping and the equatorward propagation of activity
• Sunspot positions, areas, and group tilt angles for 1611-1631 from observations by Christoph Scheiner
• A possible explanation of the Maunder minimum from a flux transport dynamo model
• Re-examining Sunspot Tilt Angle to Include Anti-Hale Statistics
• Polar Network Index as a magnetic proxy for the solar cycle studies
• A coupled 2$\times$2D Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo model. I. Surface magnetic flux evolution
• Studies of grand minima in sunspot cycles from a flux transport solar dynamo model
• A theoretical study of the build-up of the Sun's polar magnetic field by using a 3D kinematic dynamo model
• A Three-Dimensional Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Model: Initial Results with Axisymmetric Flows
• Characterisation of the turbulent electromotive force and its magnetically-mediated quenching in a global EULAG-MHD simulation of solar convection
• Quenching and anisotropy of hydromagnetic turbulent transport
• The Origin of Solar Activity in the Tachocline
• The turbulent diffusion of toroidal magnetic flux as inferred from properties of the sunspot butterfly diagram
• A proposed paradigm for solar cycle dynamics mediated via turbulent pumping of magnetic flux in Babcock-Leighton type solar dynamos
• Sunspot areas and tilt angles for solar cycles 7-10
• Correlation between Decay Rate and Amplitude of Solar Cycles as Revealed from Observations and Dynamo Theory
• Is the small-scale magnetic field correlated with the dynamo cycle?
• A mechanism for the dependence of sunspot group tilt angles on cycle strength
• Statistical properties of the Bipolar Magnetic Regions

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Solar cycle prediction
• Predictability of the solar cycle over one cycle
• Models for the long-term variations of solar activity
• Double-peaks of the solar cycle: An explanation from a dynamo model
• Long-term modulation of solar cycles
• Nonlinear mechanisms that regulate the solar cycle amplitude
• Magnetic field dependence of bipolar magnetic region tilts on the Sun: Indication of tilt quenching
• Physical Models for Solar Cycle Predictions
• Mean field models of flux transport dynamo and meridional circulation in the Sun and stars
• Recovery from Maunder-like Grand Minima in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• The polar precursor method for solar cycle prediction: comparison of predictors and their temporal range
• Dynamo saturation through the latitudinal variation of bipolar magnetic regions in the Sun
• Sunspot tilt angles revisited: Dependence on the solar cycle strength
• A New Formula for Predicting Solar Cycles
• Latitude Distribution of Sunspots: Analysis Using Sunspot Data and A Dynamo Model
• Average motion of emerging solar active region polarities II: Joy's law
• Physical link of the polar field build-up with the Waldmeier effect broadens the scope of early solar cycle prediction: Cycle 25 is likely to be slightly stronger than Cycle 24
• Solar-Cycle Characteristics in Kodaikanal Sunspot Area: North--South Asymmetry, Phase Distribution and Gnevyshev Gap
• Signature of the turbulent component of solar dynamo on active region scales and its association with flaring activity
• Average motion of emerging solar active region polarities I: Two phases of emergence
• A Babcock-Leighton-type Solar Dynamo Operating in the Bulk of the Convection Zone
• Connecting the large- and the small-scale magnetic fields of solar-like stars
• Is the Hemispheric Asymmetry of Monthly Sunspot Area an Irregular Process with Long-Term Memory?
• Long-Term Evolution of the Sun's magnetic field during Cycles 15--19 based on their proxies from Kodaikanal Solar Observatory
• Analysis of BMR tilt from AutoTAB catalog: Hinting towards the thin flux tube model?
• Exploring cycle period and parity of stellar magnetic activity with dynamo modeling
• Dynamo modelling for cycle variability and occurrence of grand minima in Sun-like stars: Rotation rate dependence
• Supercriticality of the dynamo limits the memory of the polar field to one cycle
• Does the mean-field alpha effect have any impact on the memory of the solar cycle?
• The need for active region disconnection in 3D kinematic dynamo simulations
• Active-Region Tilt Angles from White-Light Images and Magnetograms: The Role of Magnetic Tongues
• Dynamical coupling of a mean-field dynamo and its wind: Feedback loop over a stellar activity cycle
• Impact of rogue active regions on hemispheric asymmetry
• Recent advances in the 3D kinematic Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo modeling
• Three-dimensional non-kinematic simulation of post-emergence evolution of bipolar magnetic regions and Babcock-Leighton dynamo of the Sun
• Probing the variations in the timing of the Sun's polar magnetic field reversals through observations and surface flux transport simulations
• Causal Interaction between the subsurface rotation rate residuals and radial magnetic field in different timescales
• On the origin of long-term modulation in the Sun's magnetic activity cycle
• A Potential New Mechanism for the Butterfly Diagram of the Solar Cycle: Latitude-dependent Radial Flux Transport
• Coriolis force acting on near-surface horizontal flows during simulations of flux emergence produces a tilt angle consistent with Joy's law on the Sun
• Subcritical dynamo and hysteresis in a Babcock-Leighton type kinematic dynamo model
• Minimal Roles of Solar Subsurface Meridional Flow in the distributed-shear Babcock-Leighton Dynamo
• Role of sunspot latitude versus tilt in determining the polar field and amplitude of the next cycle: Cause of the weak Solar Cycle 20
• Hemispheric analysis of the magnetic flux in regular and irregular solar active regions
• Observation-Based Iterative Map for Solar Cycles. I. Nature of Solar Cycle Variability
• Recovery of the Solar Cycle from Maunder-like Grand Minima Episodes: A Quantification of the Necessary Polar Flux Threshold through Solar Dynamo Simulations
• Relationship Between the Tilt Angle of Sunspot Group and the Properties of the Next Solar Cycle
• Solar Cycle Prediction: Challenges, Progress, and Future Perspectives
• Constraining the outer boundary condition for the Babcock-Leighton dynamo models
• The rush to the poles and the role of magnetic buoyancy in the solar dynamo
• Dynamo Processes Constrained by Solar and Stellar Observations
• Can meridional flow variations explain the observed rising/declining phase asymmetry in the solar cycle?
• Long-term variability of the solar cycle in the Babcock-Leighton dynamo framework
• Evolution of the Sun's activity and the poleward transport of remnant magnetic flux in Cycles 21--24
• Stellar cycle variability in Mount Wilson stars and dynamo models: Rotation rate and dynamo number dependency
• The Sun's polar magnetic field: datasets, proxies and theoretical issues