Effects of the scatter in sunspot group tilt angles on the large-scale magnetic field at the solar surface

Abstract

The tilt angles of sunspot groups represent the poloidal field source in Babcock-Leighton-type models of the solar dynamo and are crucial for the build-up and reversals of the polar fields in Surface Flux Transport (SFT) simulations. The evolution of the polar field is a consequence of Hale's polarity rules, together with the tilt angle distribution which has a systematic component (Joy's law) and a random component (tilt-angle scatter). We determine the scatter using the observed tilt angle data and study the effects of this scatter on the evolution of the solar surface field using SFT simulations with flux input based upon the recorded sunspot groups. The tilt angle scatter is described in our simulations by a random component according to the observed distributions for different ranges of sunspot group size (total umbral area). By performing simulations with a number of different realizations of the scatter we study the effect of the tilt angle scatter on the global magnetic field, especially on the evolution of the axial dipole moment. The average axial dipole moment at the end of cycle 17 (a medium-amplitude cycle) from our simulations was 2.73G. The tilt angle scatter leads to an uncertainty of 0.78 G (standard deviation). We also considered cycle 14 (a weak cycle) and cycle 19 (a strong cycle) and show that the standard deviation of the axial dipole moment is similar for all three cycles. The uncertainty mainly results from the big sunspot groups which emerge near the equator. In the framework of Babcock-Leighton dynamo models, the tilt angle scatter therefore constitutes a significant random factor in the cycle-to-cycle amplitude variability, which strongly limits the predictability of solar activity.

arXiv comment23 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (18)

• Sunspot group tilt angles and the strength of the solar cycle
• Solar activity forecast with a dynamo model
• The Sun's Global Photospheric and Coronal Magnetic Fields: Observations and Models
• Bipolar Magnetic Regions on the Sun: Global Analysis of the SOHO/MDI Data Set
• Surface flux transport modeling for solar cycles 15--21: effects of cycle-dependent tilt angles of sunspot groups
• The Rise of Active Region Flux Tubes in the Turbulent Solar Convective Envelope
• The solar magnetic field since 1700: I. Characteristics of sunspot group emergence and reconstruction of the butterfly diagram
• The effect of activity-related meridional flow modulation on the strength of the solar polar magnetic field
• Recovering Joys Law as a Function of Solar Cycle, Hemisphere, and Longitude
• Limits to solar cycle predictability: Cross-equatorial flux plumes
• Coronal Magnetic Field Evolution from 1996 to 2012: Continuous Non-Potential Simulations
• Modeling Solar Cycles 15 to 21 Using a Flux Transport Dynamo
• Long-Term Measurements of Sunspot Magnetic Tilt Angles
• Comparing Simulations of Rising Flux Tubes Through the Solar Convection Zone with Observations of Solar Active Regions: Constraining the Dynamo Field Strength
• The solar magnetic field since 1700: II. Physical reconstruction of total, polar and open flux
• Fluctuations in the Alpha-Effect and Grand Solar Minima
• Can surface flux transport account for the weak polar field in cycle 23?
• Digitized archive of the Kodaikanal images: Representative results of solar cycle variation from sunspot area determination

Cited by in corpus (83)

• Solar cycle prediction
• Prediction of the strength and timing of sunspot cycle 25 reveal decadal-scale space environmental conditions
• Magnetic Flux Transport at the Solar Surface
• An Updated Solar Cycle 25 Prediction with AFT: The Modern Minimum
• Predictability of the solar cycle over one cycle
• The cause of the weak solar cycle 24
• Solar Cycle Variability Induced by Tilt Angle Scatter in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• Solar cycle 25: another moderate cycle?
• The Effect of "Rogue" Active Regions on the Solar Cycle
• Models for the long-term variations of solar activity
• Surface Flux Transport on the Sun
• Source of a Prominent Poleward Surge During Solar Cycle 24
• Double-peaks of the solar cycle: An explanation from a dynamo model
• Understanding solar cycle variability
• Long-term modulation of solar cycles
• Improvement of solar cycle prediction: Plateau of solar axial dipole moment
• Nonlinear mechanisms that regulate the solar cycle amplitude
• Re-examining Sunspot Tilt Angle to Include Anti-Hale Statistics
• Long-term Solar Activity Studies using Microwave Imaging Observations and Prediction for Cycle 25
• A coupled 2$\times$2D Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo model. I. Surface magnetic flux evolution
• Physical Models for Solar Cycle Predictions
• A Three-Dimensional Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Model: Initial Results with Axisymmetric Flows
• A theoretical study of the build-up of the Sun's polar magnetic field by using a 3D kinematic dynamo model
• Towards an algebraic method of solar cycle prediction I. Calculating the ultimate dipole contributions of individual active regions
• Comparison of Debrecen and Mount Wilson/Kodaikanal sunspot group tilt angles and the Joy's law
• Predicting solar surface large-scale magnetic field of Cycle 24
• Recovery from Maunder-like Grand Minima in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• Reconstruction of spectral solar irradiance since 1700 from simulated magnetograms
• Modelling total solar irradiance since 1878 from simulated magnetograms
• Variable Heating and Flaring of Three Redback Millisecond Pulsar Companions
• Tilt Angle and Footpoint Separation of Small and Large Bipolar Sunspot Regions Observed with HMI
• How many active regions are necessary to predict the solar dipole moment?
• How good is the bipolar approximation of active regions for surface flux transport?
• Solar activity: intrinsic periodicities beyond 11 years
• Dynamo saturation through the latitudinal variation of bipolar magnetic regions in the Sun
• Sunspot tilt angles revisited: Dependence on the solar cycle strength
• Correlation between Decay Rate and Amplitude of Solar Cycles as Revealed from Observations and Dynamo Theory
• Latitude Distribution of Sunspots: Analysis Using Sunspot Data and A Dynamo Model
• Average motion of emerging solar active region polarities II: Joy's law
• Modelling variability of solar activity cycles
• a dynamo-based prediction of solar cycle 25
• Comparison of physics-based prediction models of solar cycle 25
• Physical link of the polar field build-up with the Waldmeier effect broadens the scope of early solar cycle prediction: Cycle 25 is likely to be slightly stronger than Cycle 24
• Solar Anti-Hale Bipolar Magnetic Regions: A Distinct Population with Systematic Properties
• Activity Complexes and A Prominent Poleward Surge During Solar Cycle 24
• Different contributions to space weather and space climate from different big solar active regions
• Towards a live homogeneous database of solar active regions based on SOHO/MDI and SDO/HMI synoptic magnetograms. I. Automatic detection and calibration
• Impact of Anomalous Active Regions on the Large-scale Magnetic Field of the Sun
• Dynamo Model for North-South Asymmetry of Solar Activity
• Exploring cycle period and parity of stellar magnetic activity with dynamo modeling
• Dynamo modelling for cycle variability and occurrence of grand minima in Sun-like stars: Rotation rate dependence
• Can the long-term hemispheric asymmetry of solar activity result from fluctuations in dynamo parameters?
• Effect of morphological asymmetry between leading and following sunspots on the prediction of solar cycle activity
• Is hemispheric asymmetry in the sunspot cycle solely governed by polar flux imbalance in the previous cycle?
• Algebraic quantification of an active region's contribution to the solar cycle
• Toward a live homogeneous database of solar active regions based on SOHO/MDI and SDO/HMI synoptic magnetograms.II.parameters for solar cycle variability
• Meridional flow in the solar polar caps revealed by magnetic field observation and simulation
• Rearrangements of Open Magnetic Flux and Formation of Polar Coronal Holes in Cycle 24
• Modeling effects of starspots on stellar magnetic cycles
• Probing the variations in the timing of the Sun's polar magnetic field reversals through observations and surface flux transport simulations
• Algebraic Quantification of the Contribution of Active Regions to the Sun's Dipole Moment: Applications to Century-scale Polar Field Estimates and Solar Cycle Forecasting
• Recent advances in the 3D kinematic Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo modeling
• The nonuniformity of poleward flux transport on the solar surface: a statistical method applied to solar cycles 21-24
• Subcritical dynamo and hysteresis in a Babcock-Leighton type kinematic dynamo model
• Decay of Activity Complexes, Formation of Unipolar Magnetic Regions and Coronal Holes in their Causal Relation
• Minimal Roles of Solar Subsurface Meridional Flow in the distributed-shear Babcock-Leighton Dynamo
• Role of sunspot latitude versus tilt in determining the polar field and amplitude of the next cycle: Cause of the weak Solar Cycle 20
• Polar cap magnetic field reversals during solar grand minima: could pores play a role?
• Inferring Quadrupolar Dynamo Mode from Sunspot Statistics
• Rogue active regions and the inherent unpredictability of the solar dynamo
• Extreme Fluctuations in the Sun's Activity over the Modern Maximum: Understanding the Enigmatic Solar Cycles 19-20
• Observation-Based Iterative Map for Solar Cycles. I. Nature of Solar Cycle Variability
• Active regions and the large-scale magnetic field of solar cycle 24
• Relationship Between the Tilt Angle of Sunspot Group and the Properties of the Next Solar Cycle
• Recovery of the Solar Cycle from Maunder-like Grand Minima Episodes: A Quantification of the Necessary Polar Flux Threshold through Solar Dynamo Simulations
• Prediction of the Solar Polar Fields in 2026: An Unusually Weak Level Across the Last Five Solar Cycles
• Solar Cycle Prediction: Challenges, Progress, and Future Perspectives
• The rush to the poles and the role of magnetic buoyancy in the solar dynamo
• Ultra-fast simulations of the solar dipole and open flux
• Long-term variability of the solar cycle in the Babcock-Leighton dynamo framework
• Active-region Modulation of Subsurface Meridional Flows and Magnetic Flux Transport on the Sun
• The Sun's polar magnetic field: datasets, proxies and theoretical issues
• Can meridional flow variations explain the observed rising/declining phase asymmetry in the solar cycle?